SB XLVI: Disappointing

poker

Everyone's hero's, tell everyone's lies.
Jun 1, 2006
7,699
6,016
113
Niagara
I don't really like either team that played last night but......

I used to think Tom Coughlin was a class act. Very disappointed that with 17 seconds left, he would put an extra deep back on the field to defend the long bomb knowing it would only cost him 5 yards, and no time would be put back on the play clock... Smart move, but a very cheap way to win a Superbowl.
 
So the single strategy/play made the whole game a disappointment? Of course you know he did it on purpose.
 
No... I'm disappointed the Couch would do something that cheap in order to win.... I'm disappointed the rules are such the time would not have been put back on the clock when penalties prevent the offense from having a fair shot to move the ball and score with under 2 minutes left. Defensively, brilliant move. From a rule stand point... I think they need to look at how those kinds of penalties can used to run the clock down.
 
No... I'm disappointed the Couch would do something that cheap in order to win.... I'm disappointed the rules are such the time would not have been put back on the clock when penalties prevent the offense from having a fair shot to move the ball and score with under 2 minutes left. Defensively, brilliant move. From a rule stand point... I think they need to look at how those kinds of penalties can used to run the clock down.

Again you know the coach did it? Of course you don't. It happens often enough in other games where the players or coaahes just screw it up, especially against a no huddle offense like NE. Sorry Poker you just wrong.
 
I don't really like either team that played last night but......

I used to think Tom Coughlin was a class act. Very disappointed that with 17 seconds left, he would put an extra deep back on the field to defend the long bomb knowing it would only cost him 5 yards, and no time would be put back on the play clock... Smart move, but a very cheap way to win a Superbowl.

How do you feel about the rest of the game?

And I trust you understand the odds that it would have made any difference are very small indeed...
 
Do I know the coaching made that call.... no.

However, I do know the last 2 minutes were coached very well on both sides.... I know the Patriots wanted the ball back when NY was driving. I do believe they allowed NY to score the touch down with 58 seconds on purpose to stop the clock, get the ball back and take a shot. I know the Giants tried to stop on the one yard line to run the clock down another 40 seconds before taking a FG shot to win the game... That was all obvious, and good strategy on both sides....

I know that NY didn't stop strategizing how to run the clock down just because the Pats got the ball back with 58 seconds and one time out. They are far too good at what they do... So again.... I firmly believe the NY coaching staff knew they could take time off the clock and defend a deep td pass and only get penalized 5 yards without putting that time back on the clock. To me, that was kind of a no brainer.

Remember..... it was an extra safety on the field... defending against a long bomb... the pass was then thrown to a guy double covered at 4 yrd line... hmmmm. lets talk odds now.
 
Do I know the coaching made that call.... no.

However, I do know the last 2 minutes were coached very well on both sides.... I know the Patriots wanted the ball back when NY was driving. I do believe they allowed NY to score the touch down with 58 seconds on purpose to stop the clock, get the ball back and take a shot. I know the Giants tried to stop on the one yard line to run the clock down another 40 seconds before taking a FG shot to win the game... That was all obvious, and good strategy on both sides....

I know that NY didn't stop strategizing how to run the clock down just because the Pats got the ball back with 58 seconds and one time out. They are far too good at what they do... So again.... I firmly believe the NY coaching staff knew they could take time off the clock and defend a deep td pass and only get penalized 5 yards without putting that time back on the clock. To me, that was kind of a no brainer.

Remember..... it was an extra safety on the field... defending against a long bomb... lets talk odds now.

I guess the 'let them score the touchdown' worked well. How much time taken off the clock? I'm not sure, but 5 seconds maybe. if it was deliberate it's no more bush than taking a time clock penalty to move the filed attempt back 5 yards. i don't hear an uproar about that one or faking an injury to stop the clock.
 
clock went from 17 down to 9.... I was in the bar screaming why isn't the 8 seconds back on the clock... and guy beside me says thats the rule... they ran a play. I was dumbstruck.

As for the TD.... they had to give it up if they wanted the ball back. no time outs left and NY could was running the clock down completely to chip in a FG to win. Would have given the Pats just one play after the ensuing kickoff.
 
clock went from 17 down to 9.... I was in the bar screaming why isn't the 8 seconds back on the clock... and guy beside me says thats the rule... they ran a play. I was dumbstruck.

As for the TD.... they had to give it up if they wanted the ball back. no time outs left and NY could was running the clock down completely to chip in a FG to win. Would have given the Pats just one play after the ensuing kickoff.

Damn rules, they are always getting in the way. As for your last point, your probably right, but NE had more time on hand and yet still failed.
 
Of coarse the failed.... it was 11 guys against 12.

Don't get me wrong.... I think the Giants had a legit shot to win. No doubt at all. I would just have liked to see if Brady would have hit the pass against one on one coverage rather than having to throw into a double team. Completely bogus... I'm done my bitchin now....
 
Of coarse the failed.... it was 11 guys against 12.

Don't get me wrong.... I think the Giants had a legit shot to win. No doubt at all. I would just have liked to see if Brady would have hit the pass against one on one coverage rather than having to throw into a double team. Completely bogus... I'm done my bitchin now....

That was only for the one play. What about the rest of the last series of plays?
 
Of coarse the failed.... it was 11 guys against 12.

Don't get me wrong.... I think the Giants had a legit shot to win. No doubt at all. I would just have liked to see if Brady would have hit the pass against one on one coverage rather than having to throw into a double team. Completely bogus... I'm done my bitchin now....

The Giants had a "legit shot" to win? When I am talking about odds, what I am asking is what is the chances of a team, with no time outs, on their own 45 (or so), down by 4, scoring a touchdown to win, against 11 defenders? Or even 10?
 
Seriously, you want to talk integrity of the game? Bill Belichick is a proven and admitted cheater. The guy used to have practice film of every team in the league. HOURS of it. Until he was caught and FORCED to turn it back in. It was pretty well known that he used film to beat Philly a few years ago.

Also, telling your team to LET the other team score.. gamesmanship? Integrity? Wow.. Am I denying this was a genius football play? No, not at all. But, can you imagine how degraded your defence is when the coach runs in a play that says, let them score.

You're talking about 1 play, and a play btw that was undetected by the officials, as there was other too many men penalties in this game, and there was also a penalty for too many men in the huddle earlier in the game. There should never be a too many men penalty, it should be detected before the play was run.

As for the situational substitution.. with 10 seconds left or whatever there was, yes, you're substituting in an extra safety, who's to say that a linebacker that was supposed to get off the field didn't notice. You're team is about to win the Super Bowl.. there's a little bit of excitement.

If you want to talk about integrity and class, let's talk about Bob Kraft. I felt sorry for him, how they kept showing the replay of him, during the final play. Losing his wife earlier in the year, and the entire team dedicating their season to her. A win would have been fitting.
 
The rest of the last series.... they moved the ball from the 5 to about the 45, stopping the clock each play, save for one intentional grounding. That play was 3rd and 10, with 17 seconds. 17 seconds is enough time to run 2, maybe 3 more plays. But they only had 9 seconds after the penalty. My only bitch is, they should have reset the play clock to 17 seconds. Both long shots, I get it. But I'd still rather have 17 seconds at mid field than 9.
 
Seriously, you want to talk integrity of the game? Bill Belichick is a proven and admitted cheater. The guy used to have practice film of every team in the league. HOURS of it. Until he was caught and FORCED to turn it back in. It was pretty well known that he used film to beat Philly a few years ago.

Already had 0 respect for Belichick. Simply adding Coughlin to the list. :)
 
The rest of the last series.... they moved the ball from the 5 to about the 45, stopping the clock each play, save for one intentional grounding. That play was 3rd and 10, with 17 seconds. 17 seconds is enough time to run 2, maybe 3 more plays. But they only had 9 seconds after the penalty. My only bitch is, they should have reset the play clock to 17 seconds. Both long shots, I get it. But I'd still rather have 17 seconds at mid field than 9.

So would I, but the rules don't work that way, and both teams were constrained by the same rules.

But the odds of the outcome being different, with the extra 8 seconds, are still very small.
 
Already had 0 respect for Belichick. Simply adding Coughlin to the list. :)
Yeah. No way one can respect a coach who has accomplished as much as he.

Aside from the video thing, what other egregious fouls has he created over a long career.

Letting NYG score was very smart. You are the only person I've heard paint this as a negative.

Even if it was intentional, again, I heard nobody say the too many men was a sleazy move.

You just sound like a NE/Belichick hater. The backlash of being successful.

BTW, I am in no way a Pats fan. I like to see them lose (except when I bet on them LOL) but I have the utmost respect for what they've accomplished.
 
the way the game ended it was nys game to lose barring a fuck up they had the game in the bag so that so called dirty play was a moot point.
 
...... Letting NYG score was very smart. You are the only person I've heard paint this as a negative.

Even if it was intentional, again, I heard nobody say the too many men was a sleazy move.

You just sound like a NE/Belichick hater. The backlash of being successful.

BTW, I am in no way a Pats fan. I like to see them lose (except when I bet on them LOL) but I have the utmost respect for what they've accomplished.


Really??? you don't like my opinion therefore I am a hater... the backlash of being successful? Nice....

What part of me saying the Pats got Screwed for time is confusing in this thread.... I'm supporting the Pats!!! I had a $5 bet with my kid that the Pats would win.

I didn't paint "Letting NYG score" as a negative. I said the last 2 minutes of the game were very well coached on both sides of ball.

I really don't mind you name calling.... but please try to get my points correct.