First Time Home Buyer seeks Advice

BayStreetBlues

New member
Apr 6, 2009
32
0
0
Janitor @ First Canadian Place
There is a tonne of smart insight on this board so thought I could get nab some 'free' advice from experienced real estate buyers on here.

I am late twenties, non-married, saved money since university and now looking to buy first house in either Durham or Brampton, mainly for my family ('doing the right thing' - Spike Lee) but partly as an investment as well.

I am keeping an eye to a 4 br detached house with a basement apartment (up to code) to generate income (keeping in mind taxes will eat into the revenue, but how much exactly I haven't figured out yet). The plan is my family to give me $1000 monthly, and $800-$900 monthly basement rental - this should cover mortgage, principle, taxes, utilities on the house. Plus a bonus to have my family as a tenant (report issues quicker, etc). Will need to do the credit check, etc on the basment tenant, single occupant preferred.

As an investment, I would be covered on building equity in the house (maybe shy $100 / month that I have to go out-of-pocket) and the rate I qualify for is 2.5% variable, or 2.99% fixed (4 year); in terms of appreciation however, my research shows positive appreciation in Brampton, slow flatline appreciation in Durham the further east you go. However you can buy a newer, larger house in Durham for the same price in Brampton, and I am looking for a 2000-2400 sq foot, preferably 4 bedrooms.

Why Durham or Brampton?
Only places I qualify for a decent detached house (375k - 420k range) and still be able to buy additional real estate later (when I tie the knot). As single-income buyer, I am priced out of Sauga, Markham, Richmond Hill (without really really stretching which I don't wish to do). I am aware however that the house will likely not be new, but 15 years old (on average) - have found houses that were only 6 years old, but really far north of the 401. We need to have easy access to 401/transit. I have budgeted maybe 10 k for immediate repairs/renovations (the rest can be done slowly overtime).

Am I on the right track? Something I am overlooking? Alternatives? Have to still choose between Brampton and Durham - bigger house or better appreciation. I have read Don Campbell RE Investing book - some of it was useful.

Confused...any advice is appreciated

Note: for those whose philosophy is rent only and invest elsewhere (Garth Turner), I have no choice..am forced to buy.

Note Note: I have talked to many real estate agents; I have yet to find one that is truly concerned with my situation - at first they seem to be, but later they like to push you into a more expensive house with a higher commission
 
Use the MLS service to look for the places you want.
Don't rely on your Realtor too much because as you said, they often try to push you to a higher price bracket.
Get preapproved for your mortgage and then knock between 5 and 10 % off.

Thanks, I use MLS which has a 48 hour delay in house status updates, making it unreliable at times - guess that's how agents retain some control and force dependency on them

Yeah I will have a high-ratio mortgage - I can knock off up to 15% but then I'd be cash poor (except for emergency fund) - so probably will go 10% and retain some for related expenditures, rather than borrow

Now only if I can figure out brampton vs. durham..and bigger house or more appreciation..
 
Yeah I will have a high-ratio mortgage - I can knock off up to 15% but then I'd be cash poor (except for emergency fund) - so probably will go 10% and retain some for related expenditures, rather than borrow

Yes, lock in to-day's historic low 2.99% mortgage interest rate. You lucky. When I bought my house, mortgage interest rates were in the teen's.
 
Yes, lock in to-day's historic low 2.99% mortgage interest rate. You lucky. When I bought my house, mortgage interest rates were in the teen's.

wow - but I'll be the house prices were nowhere near as inflated as they have become in the last 12 years..I kinda missed the boat

rate goes up, price comes down
price goes up, rate comes down

To what extent you probably know better..
 
No, I meant that if they are willing to give you a mortgage for 400,000 find a place for between 20 and 40 thousand less.
Save that money if you can for either a rainy day or for an annual paydown on your mortgage.
Remember that as a home owner you are going to find stuff wrong with your house be it a leaky faucet (Eventually) or the need to buy a new lawn mower or snowblower. Unless of course you move in next to "Ceiling Cat" then maybe he'll let you borrow his.

Ahh I see, yeah as there seems to be less buyers right now in the two areas (especially Ajax), I am finding some good bargains where sellers are accepting almost 20 k under asking

Good point, gotta worry about lawn mowing and snow blowers..
 
you sound very sneaky....do you work for free...like realtors should be providing free service while you are running around with your head up ur ass wasting peoples time
 
Does your mortgage provider know you will be renting out the property? I could be wrong but I believe they will want more than 10% down for such a property. I briefly toyed with picking up a 3-apartment building and the off-the-cuff answer from the bank was they would expect 25% down. Mind you that was about 12 years ago so anything may have changed since then.

Using MLS will likely mean you miss the good deals. My house sold in less than 48hrs after going on the market. My neighbour sold before me and her house sold 3 hrs after going on the market. In both cases our realtors had already "leaked" the fact the properties were going up for sale. In my case I had to delay the planned listing date by one week and my realtor's phone/email was busy with other realtors asking "when's it going to be listed, I have buyers looking in that area and price range?" Lol!

You can't expect good service from a realtor you just talk to. You want them working for you, you need to sign the papers making them your agent. Can be hard to find a good one I know. In my case we got really really lucky with ours, she was tireless in her efforts and was involved in helping determine what had to be done to get our old place ready to sell - including bringing bins of staging materials of her own to add the pizazz to our house. And she was very diligent in finding our new place. She didn't try to "upsell" us either. She sat down with us and asked what we were looking for and what our hopeful range plus what the max was and never tried to go over that even though there was about $75k difference between our max and what the bank was willing to give us.

If you were in the Hamilton area I'd recommend her in a heartbeat, but I don't think she works in the GTA.
 
you sound very sneaky....do you work for free...like realtors should be providing free service while you are running around with your head up ur ass wasting peoples time


Funny, I was thinking the same thing....only my reaction was, "this guy is a piece of work"

He talks about "doing the right thing" and buying a house for his "family" in one breath, but in the next breath he's saying that he figures they should be good for a grand a month rent and then he can rent the basement, blah blah blah.

I dunno, call me fucked up, but if you say you are "doing the right thing" for your family (I assume you mean mother and father and siblings) you let them live there for free.

Sounds to me like the OP is just wanting to buy an investment property and figures that his family would be good tennants
 
Funny, I was thinking the same thing....only my reaction was, "this guy is a piece of work"

He talks about "doing the right thing" and buying a house for his "family" in one breath, but in the next breath he's saying that he figures they should be good for a grand a month rent and then he can rent the basement, blah blah blah.

I dunno, call me fucked up, but if you say you are "doing the right thing" for your family (I assume you mean mother and father and siblings) you let them live there for free.

Sounds to me like the OP is just wanting to buy an investment property and figures that his family would be good tennants

Lol, bitter much??

I'm not going to take them to court if they can't help me with the payment, that is a pretty fucked up suggestion

At 1000/3 they're giving me what they can comfortably, I make up any shortfall
 
Does your mortgage provider know you will be renting out the property? I could be wrong but I believe they will want more than 10% down for such a property. I briefly toyed with picking up a 3-apartment building and the off-the-cuff answer from the bank was they would expect 25% down. Mind you that was about 12 years ago so anything may have changed since then.

Using MLS will likely mean you miss the good deals. My house sold in less than 48hrs after going on the market. My neighbour sold before me and her house sold 3 hrs after going on the market. In both cases our realtors had already "leaked" the fact the properties were going up for sale. In my case I had to delay the planned listing date by one week and my realtor's phone/email was busy with other realtors asking "when's it going to be listed, I have buyers looking in that area and price range?" Lol!

You can't expect good service from a realtor you just talk to. You want them working for you, you need to sign the papers making them your agent. Can be hard to find a good one I know. In my case we got really really lucky with ours, she was tireless in her efforts and was involved in helping determine what had to be done to get our old place ready to sell - including bringing bins of staging materials of her own to add the pizazz to our house. And she was very diligent in finding our new place. She didn't try to "upsell" us either. She sat down with us and asked what we were looking for and what our hopeful range plus what the max was and never tried to go over that even though there was about $75k difference between our max and what the bank was willing to give us.

If you were in the Hamilton area I'd recommend her in a heartbeat, but I don't think she works in the GTA.

I've mentioned the basment apartment but they didn't really care about how much I was putting down. You're right if one was buying a second property that's not their residence, they need to put 25% down

Finding the right agent is key, and it means quicker access to new listings... still on the search for one lol
 
If you declare it is a property that is not your primary residence, you will need to put 25% down. Period. If you later buy a second home, you'll need to have 25% equity on one or the other. In other words, you could be screwing yourself later on. If this property is your primary residence, and you plan on augmenting your income with a renter, the lender will not have an issue with that.

Second, seriously how are you bashing this guy? The guy is planning on renting a 3-4 bedroom house to his family, for $1000. Check rental prices in Durham or Brampton. That's a discount, so accusing the OP of screwing his family is just idiotic. You don't know where they're currently living and possibly paying more than that. He could be doing them a favor.

As for finding a real estate agent, pick a company, Remax, Century 21, whoever.. speak to an agent in both towns and tell them straight up you're not willing to sign, but would like to have them send you listings in the area within your range (Drop your range $30-45k and don't worry if they go a bit over your price).

If you're using the First Time Homebuyers plan, ensure that you have at least $20k in your RSP. If you don't - top it up as much as you're permitted. The money only has to be in for 60 days before you can withdraw it using the HBP, and you can put that $20k towards the downpayment, and immediately realize the benefit of a tax return this year. First time homebuyers also get a discount on land transfer taxes as well (I think up to $2500).

As for appreciation vs bigger house.. well.. you have the ugly issue again, if this is an investment property, you are subject to capital gains on appreciation and your interest payments are tax deductable. Not if it's a personal property. I'd go bigger house if this is the case.

If you're saying this is your primary residence, you'd be best to sell it again before you buy that 'second house' and realize the capital gains before they become taxable. Taking the profits at this point might be good as well to help push you up over the 25% for the property you are now classifying as the investment.

Hope that helps..
 
If you declare it is a property that is not your primary residence, you will need to put 25% down. Period. If you later buy a second home, you'll need to have 25% equity on one or the other. In other words, you could be screwing yourself later on. If this property is your primary residence, and you plan on augmenting your income with a renter, the lender will not have an issue with that.

Second, seriously how are you bashing this guy? The guy is planning on renting a 3-4 bedroom house to his family, for $1000. Check rental prices in Durham or Brampton. That's a discount, so accusing the OP of screwing his family is just idiotic. You don't know where they're currently living and possibly paying more than that. He could be doing them a favor.

As for finding a real estate agent, pick a company, Remax, Century 21, whoever.. speak to an agent in both towns and tell them straight up you're not willing to sign, but would like to have them send you listings in the area within your range (Drop your range $30-45k and don't worry if they go a bit over your price).

If you're using the First Time Homebuyers plan, ensure that you have at least $20k in your RSP. If you don't - top it up as much as you're permitted. The money only has to be in for 60 days before you can withdraw it using the HBP, and you can put that $20k towards the downpayment, and immediately realize the benefit of a tax return this year. First time homebuyers also get a discount on land transfer taxes as well (I think up to $2500).

As for appreciation vs bigger house.. well.. you have the ugly issue again, if this is an investment property, you are subject to capital gains on appreciation and your interest payments are tax deductable. Not if it's a personal property. I'd go bigger house if this is the case.

If you're saying this is your primary residence, you'd be best to sell it again before you buy that 'second house' and realize the capital gains before they become taxable. Taking the profits at this point might be good as well to help push you up over the 25% for the property you are now classifying as the investment.

Hope that helps..

Thanks, some great advice, especially regarding primary vs. investment residence

First and foremost priority is a home for the fam, and after re-thinking I'm leaning towards a bigger house in Durham (than you can buy in Brampton) - worrying less about appreciation, tax deductions, etc.

However the point you raised about buying the second house and needing 25% equity in the first is something I hadn't considered - need to research this more in detail. If I need to live there and declare as primary residence in order to buy, so be it..

Cheers
 
If I need to live there and declare as primary residence in order to buy, so be it.. Cheers

I'm a former mortgage broker, I said nothing about living there. Nobody's gonna knock on the door and check. Put the main bills: hydro, power, water, in your name. Voila you live there.
 
For the home buyer, Brampton has complex rules regarding basement apartments.

They are legal if built and permitted during a certain period of time, and illegal if not built and permitted during that period of time. Brampton is also keen to stamp out unpermitted basement apartments.

Something to watch out for if you are unfamiliar with the area.
 
Lol, bitter much??

I'm not going to take them to court if they can't help me with the payment, that is a pretty fucked up suggestion

At 1000/3 they're giving me what they can comfortably, I make up any shortfall

I am not bitter in the least.

I just find you to be full of shit. "Do the right thing"

Make me laugh. I've met lots of selfish phonies like you over the years. You are like so many other trash talkers. The truth is - it's all about you. Why not just be honest.
 
If you're using the First Time Homebuyers plan, ensure that you have at least $20k in your RSP. If you don't - top it up as much as you're permitted. The money only has to be in for 60 days before you can withdraw it using the HBP, and you can put that $20k towards the downpayment, and immediately realize the benefit of a tax return this year. First time homebuyers also get a discount on land transfer taxes as well (I think up to $2500).

Can do up to $25,000 for HBP and funds have to be in the RRSP for 90 days before withdrawal or they may not be deductible.
 
Just something to think about, but if $1000 a month is below market value, the taxman will eventually be on to you. any business must be run in a way to make money. if you intentionally don't, they will dis-allow your deductions. give some thought to that.

also, renting to family members makes it very difficult when they miss a payment.
 
Just something to think about, but if $1000 a month is below market value, the taxman will eventually be on to you. any business must be run in a way to make money. if you intentionally don't, they will dis-allow your deductions. give some thought to that.

also, renting to family members makes it very difficult when they miss a payment.

The OP mentioned he would also have a basement renter. The $1000 + the basement won't put it that far off market value, and even if it was significantly lower, you tell them you have a vacancy and are having a hard time filling it.

Also thanks Moraff for correcting, I forgot the ammendment last year allowed up to $25k rather than $20k, and the 90 day rule was just me not quite remembering fully. It's been years since I was in mortgages, either way the concept is there, max out that RSP for a tax break this year and then cash them out for the downpayment.
 
pie in the sky.
Doesn't know the first thing about renting out property business. It all looks good on paper but it will end in tears.
 
Just something to think about, but if $1000 a month is below market value, the taxman will eventually be on to you. any business must be run in a way to make money. if you intentionally don't, they will dis-allow your deductions. give some thought to that.

also, renting to family members makes it very difficult when they miss a payment.

Family is only helping with the payment as much as they can, I've budgeted to cover the whole payment for up to year or longer if I need to..so no worries there.

Now the basement rental will be a different issue, here I definitely want a tenant-landlord relationship. The candidate will be providing me with employee letter, credit check and signing an agreement. Still, this kind of contract can get messy fast, so I am considering hiring a property manager to manage this (until I'm competent myself)