Shafia trial verdict.

Being a lawyer myself, let me tell you there ain't much you can do with a lying moron as a client. And the guys who defended this case had 3. A lawyer is only as good as the material he has to work with.
Isn't that another way of saying "a bad workman blames his "tools" "
 
Proving conclusively that the accused put 4 victims in a car and rolled it into a lock is what the Crown did beautifully.

That is not identical to proving a) premeditation or b) proving the coverup of a murder.

There was LOTS of evidence of premeditation. LOTS. Had there been any doubts about the premeditated nature of the crime the jury would have returned a 2nd degree verdict. They went with 1st, because the evidence of premeditation was compelling.

You are in effect arguing that if someone disposes of dead people in a suspicious manner, it is first degree murder. The criminal code does not support that interpretation.

The jury went with the interpretation that they were killed, and felt that it had been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, based on the evidence presented. You are just wrong here, but you won't admit it.

You are clinging to this flawed belief that you cannot be guilty of murder if all you did is hide the bodies of the murder victims.
 
There was LOTS of evidence of premeditation. LOTS. Had there been any doubts about the premeditated nature of the crime the jury would have returned a 2nd degree verdict. They went with 1st, because the evidence of premeditation was compelling.



The jury went with the interpretation that they were killed, and felt that it had been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, based on the evidence presented. You are just wrong here, but you won't admit it.

You are clinging to this flawed belief that you cannot be guilty of murder if all you did is hide the bodies of the murder victims.

You just don't comprehend plain english.
 
Oh Mr. Smarty Pants Contrarian.... let's say the girls were NOT dead when the car they were in was pushed into the water?

Does that satisfy you that the convicted intended to, or did, cause the death of the four?

Of course I would, but it has been conclusively proven that they were dead before the car was pushed into the water.

Here is what you are not admitting. The Crown does not have to wrap every nuanced aspect up in a tidy bow. If there was no evidence of footprints nearby the river's edge or in the motel's bathtub, then they would be foolish to advance that theory. It IS enough to convict by being the last one in the presence of a now-dead person and having a bad alibi etc.
Just for the heck of it, please tell me how anybody can serially drown 4 healthy females in a river without creating some kind of evidence.
Here is an example I recall but am not certain on the exact details:

A man was seen getting into an airplane with his wife somewhere in New England. It was just the two of them.

The plane arrived a couple hours later at another airport and only the husband got out. The wife was never seen again. Ever.

He once mentioned throwing his wife out of the plane to kill her as the body would never be found.

The man was convicted of murder, absent a body ever being found.

I would buy that story.
 
Originally Posted by cye

Hamed said he was at the canal and witnessed his four relatives plunging into the water in a car. He said he honked the horn of his car once then dangled a rope in the water, but seeing no signs of life, he drove away and told no one.
He may have said this at some point, but to my knowledge he was not put on the stand, and for good reason.
 
Really, all of us????

I believe Fuji has a comprehension problem, while I believe you willfully ignore information, that is contrary to your agenda.
 
I believe Fuji has a comprehension problem, while I believe you willfully ignore information, that is contrary to your agenda.

You simply refuse to accept that under Canadian law it's sufficient to show that they aided and abetted murder to be convicted of murder. You're the one with the comprehension problem.

The crown did provide a very strong case that they premeditated murder, that it was all planned in advance. So here you have some people who plotted murder, the girls are somehow killed, and then these people, who premeditated killing them, care caught disposing the bodies. The jury filled in the obvious gap. Why you have so much trouble with it is really your problem--it's just your radical refusal to accept Canadian law.

Here's SOME Of the evidence of premeditation:

-- Their taped conversations
-- Their google searches
-- Their recon of the region
-- Purchasing a cheap car presumably just for this purpose
-- Their confusion IN ADVANCE of how many were checking into the hotel
-- The testimony of many who knew them

That's a lot of trout. In any case the jury was persuaded that it was pre-meditated.

You appear to think the Crown needs to prove its case beyond a mathematical doubt, whereas in reality the Crown only needs to prove the case beyond a reasonable one.
 
you simply refuse to accept that under canadian law it's sufficient to show that they aided and abetted murder to be convicted of murder. You're the one with the comprehension problem.

The crown did provide a very strong case that they premeditated murder, that it was all planned in advance. So here you have some people who plotted murder, the girls are somehow killed, and then these people, who premeditated killing them, care caught disposing the bodies. The jury filled in the obvious gap. Why you have so much trouble with it is really your problem--it's just your radical refusal to accept canadian law.

Here's some of the evidence of premeditation:

-- their taped conversations
-- their google searches
-- their recon of the region
-- purchasing a cheap car presumably just for this purpose
-- their confusion in advance of how many were checking into the hotel
-- the testimony of many who knew them

that's a lot of trout. In any case the jury was persuaded that it was pre-meditated.

You appear to think the crown needs to prove its case beyond a mathematical doubt, whereas in reality the crown only needs to prove the case beyond a reasonable one.

q.e.d.
 
If you can come up with an explanation other than murder that fits the evidence you missed your calling in life.
 
I am left to wonder if danmand also fails to understand the burden of proof, as the Americans would say, "beyond a reasonable doubt".

It does not mean that the Crown has to have videotape evidence, notarized by fifty witnesses who can attest to the tape not having been altered, and that the tape fairly and accurately depicts the actions of the accused, of the crime being committed.

As has been explained countless times above, it similarly does not mean that the Crown needs to establish how the victims died, at what time they died, or precisely where they died.

The Crown has to esablish, as they did beyond a reasonable doubt, that the actions of the accused were the cause of the death of the victim(s), or equivalently that the accused were party to a conspiracy which was the cause of death.

Perhaps one day his daughter can explain the law to him.
 
Being a lawyer myself, let me tell you there ain't much you can do with a lying moron as a client. And the guys who defended this case had 3. A lawyer is only as good as the material he has to work with.

I'm not a lawyer, but I couldn't help but feel sorry for the defence in this case. They did the best they could with what they had, but they really didn't have a lot to work with, especially given how poorly their clients seem to have performed on the stand.

I'd actually argue for their being 4 morons in this case. The 4th being the translator who decided he ought to be a private investigator instead, and single-handedly tried to clear the family but instead wound up making them look worse than they already looked.
 
I'm not a lawyer , but I think this applies.

Criminal Code (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-46)

(5) Irrespective of whether a murder is planned and deliberate on the part of any person, murder is first degree murder in respect of a person when the death is caused by that person while committing or attempting to commit an offence under one of the following sections:
(a) section 76 (hijacking an aircraft);
(b) section 271 (sexual assault);
(c) section 272 (sexual assault with a weapon, threats to a third party or causing bodily harm);
(d) section 273 (aggravated sexual assault);
(e) section 279 (kidnapping and forcible confinement); *
(f) section 279.1 (hostage taking).


(6) Irrespective of whether a murder is planned and deliberate on the part of any person, murder is first degree murder when the death is caused by that person while committing or attempting to commit an offence under section 264 and the person committing that offence intended to cause the person murdered to fear for the safety of the person murdered or the safety of anyone known to the person murdered.


279.01 (1) Every person who recruits, transports, transfers, receives, holds, conceals or harbours a person, or exercises control, direction or influence over the movements of a person, for the purpose of exploiting them or facilitating their exploitation is guilty of an indictable offence and liable


This is just what I found via a google search, but it's clear one can be convicted of first degree murder even if it is not planned or deliberate. I'm taking it as if you commit a criminal act towards someone, and that results in their death, you will face first degree charges.
 
or, did you take offence to your fellow brothers being exposed ?

You're right, no white man has ever killed his wife. Violence against women is exclusively a Muslim problem. White men don't do it.

Read through the last year worth of newspapers and count what percentage of the murdered women were murdered by Muslims. Then give your head a shake. Violence against women is not a problem that is bounded by religion.
 
I am left to wonder if danmand also fails to understand the burden of proof, as the Americans would say, "beyond a reasonable doubt".

It does not mean that the Crown has to have videotape evidence, notarized by fifty witnesses who can attest to the tape not having been altered, and that the tape fairly and accurately depicts the actions of the accused, of the crime being committed.

Some lawyers, Crown Attorneys in particular (I would imagine District Attorneys in the U.S.) refer to this as the "CSI" syndrome. Too many jurors (like danmand) come to a trial thinking they are going to see evidence like they see on CSI - they think a ballistics test is going to have the same picture perfect clarity that they see on TV or that there is some magic machine you can put a piece of material in to identify the stain on the material as nail polish remover.

Danmand thinks there is some way you could test the water in the victims' lungs and distinguish the water in the canal where they were found from the water at some other spot. He thinks there would be some "evidence" that the murderers' clothes were "wetted" (I presume he thinks there is some magical chemical test you can do that can tell you not only if an article of clothing was "wetted" but could also identify the source of the water that "wetted" the clothing). I know this sounds ridiculous (much like danmand) but it is really a cause for some concern - prosecutors now face jurors who really don't understand the difference between the concept of "reasonable doubt" and "any half assed theory the defence presents as a possibility no matter how preposterous" and who expect the prosecutor to produce some magic, silver-bullet, super enhanced photograph downloaded from some ATM or traffic camera.

I know people have accused danmand of being a "contrarian" and I hope to God you are right but consider this - what if he actually believes what he is saying? What if he believes that there is reasonable doubt in the facts of this case - in other words that there is a real possibility that the victims did go on a joyride and, by sheer coincidence, all drowned by accident in a location their father (who despised them) had visited days before (or were, again by coincidence, all drowned by some as of yet unidentified person who was not seen by Hamad, notwithstanding his admission he followed them to the locks) and that those now convicted of murder (but are, in fact, not guilty of pre-meditated murder), for reasons that defy comprehension or explanation, simply loaded the 4 dead bodies of their immediate family members into a car, pushed the car into the lock, staged a motor vehicle accident and proceeded to tell a series of ever changing lies to the police.

Danmand asks, "please tell me how anybody can serially drown 4 healthy females in a river without creating some kind of evidence"- what kind of evidence does he want? The "scene of a struggle" or the "defensive wounds" or the "victims' DNA under the accuseds' fingernails" that are so popular on TV? He simply doesn't understand that this kind of evidence is not availble in every single case. The defence does not bear any burden of proof in a murder case but when the circumstantial evidence is so overwhelming as to allow a jury to conclude, beyond a reasonable doubt, the facts as alleged by the Crown, than the defence better rebutt or explain the evidence or face conviction. In this case the defence did not come close to rebutting or explaining the evidence and simply kept digging their hole a little deeper every time they opened their mouths.

If Danmand represents a potential juror in some future case how confident do you feel about our justice system now?

While it is true that some pretty incredible things can be done with computers, cell phones and DNA (at a trial going on in Hamilton right now the accused's DNA was lifted from the grip of a gun) most of what you see on TV is (spoiler alert) fiction. The fact that danmand does not understand that is amusing. The fact that modern day jurors might not understand that is frightening.
 
Some lawyers, Crown Attorneys in particular (I would imagine District Attorneys in the U.S.) refer to this as the "CSI" syndrome. Too many jurors (like danmand) come to a trial thinking they are going to see evidence like they see on CSI - they think a ballistics test is going to have the same picture perfect clarity that they see on TV or that there is some magic machine you can put a piece of material in to identify the stain on the material as nail polish remover.

You make a very good point.