The accused’s side of the story didn’t add up from day one, and they were hiding something. That doesn’t prove murder. To me, the parents lying to protect their son, makes sense. The son lying to hide his guilt or whatever happened that night makes sense.
Setting up the wiretap really should have made the case, but it didn’t. The dad says a whole bunch of stuff about how the daughters were whores and they got what came to them, but they never once talk about drowning them. Everything hateful that the dad said can be explained as him being angry over pictures (that came to light to the family after the deaths) they found and how he’s shamed by it. One of the most incriminating things he says (Toronto Star):
About risqué photos on cell, Shafia says "Whenever I see those pictures I am consoled. I say to myself, 'You did well. Would they come back to life a hundred times, for you to do the same thing again.' That's how hurt I am. Tooba, they betrayed us immensely"
If he drowned them, that makes sense. But it makes sense if he hadn’t either: He was feeling guilty about them dying, how he scolded them, how the daughter was rebelling because of his own actions, how he’s to blame for her taking the car for a joy ride. After seeing the pictures, he’s like, “No, I did the right thing, I tried to bring them up the right way.”
The Google searches are weak. I assert that you could have found evidence of contemplation if you searched my laptop or some other guy’s, instead of that laptop. Especially when you have an entire month of searches by 2 people to go through. It’s not much of a stretch to think a couple of high school boys would search for random stuff on their laptop, murder being one. I think this kind of evidence is usually weak, because you can take anybody’s activity on their computer over a month, cherry pick certain things and create any picture you want.
Not very relevant and it’s American, but this came to mind: Casey Anthony’s computer had searches for internal bleeding, death, chloroform, neck breaking, how to make weapons. She was found not guilty because the prosecution didn’t prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that Casey killed her baby.
Autopsies found no evidence of substances to support they were drowned elsewhere. Meaning they had to be drowned one by one by the 3 accused. There were no signs of struggle. Killing them one by one, then carrying them to the car while the other victims waited somewhere else to be called to be killed? Prosecution gives no evidence or even theories as to how this might have happened.
The Google evidence, and their sad family history, much like ALL the evidence I’ve seen so far are circumstantial. It’s easy to paint the picture of their guilt, like, “because of all these different things, they are PROBABLY guilty.” But that’s not enough to prove that they’re guilty.
I haven’t seen a single outline/theory of how they ACTUALLY committed the murder, how they moved the bodies into the car, did all three participate in it, with no drugs, how did they control the 4 women at the time? The evidence for planning (big family buys 3rd car, some internet searches) is weak and the evidence for the first degree murder is non-existent. (Events that led to car crash could have been manslaughter or second degree, and certainly could have included just one of the three accused) A lot of questions are left unanswered. Feels like they were convicted because the defense couldn’t come up with a solid story, stick to it and present it in a way that it seems at least plausible that it didn’t go down the way the crown says it did. The parents definitely shouldn’t have taken the stand.
My opinion at this time is that the justice system failed the 3 accused.
Also…I’m put off and confused by the judge’s action here:
From an article on The Star: In his closing instructions to the jury, Mr. Justice Robert Maranger briefly recounted that testimony. As he did so, the son - now a spectator in the courtroom - broke into a broad grin.
Didn’t know judges could question witnesses or sway the jury in anyway. Thought that’s what the lawyers are for…I thought all a judge does in jury trials is oversee defense and prosecution and give instructions to the jury.