Shafia trial verdict.

That is not what I suggested. I simply find it very odd that the Crown did not (if it did not) present a theory for how the 4 victims died. It seems to me to be a central part of the case.

They did present a theory. They said they were drowned near by in the river and then put into the car. The Crown says it does not know which of the accused carried it out or the precise location nearby, but that's not necessary. It's enough to know that whoever actually did it, the others all aided and abetted.
 
I have, councel. I am missing a theory about how the 4 women drowned.

Let me help you. They were drugged and then the 2 male murderers drowned them nearby 1 by 1 and then trucked their bodies to the crime scene where they did their pathetic attempt to make it look like an "accident".
 
If I was a juror, I would not have agreed to a conviction unless the Crown (which they may very well have done) presented a credible theory of how they were killed. That they somehow were drowned would not cut it for me.

Perhaps you wouldn't be so unconvinced if you had actually been a juror or had attended the whole trial. If you had and still chose to be contrary to your fellow jurors then one fears justice would not have so well served.
 
All three members of the Shafia family have been found guilty of first degree murder. Canada has set an example for dealing with honour killings. They were charged with killing three female members of the family and a first wife due to their conduct.

This wasn't what we were trying to protect when we sent our young men to Afghanistan, was it?
 
Let me help you. They were drugged and then the 2 male murderers drowned them nearby 1 by 1 and then trucked their bodies to the crime scene where they did their pathetic attempt to make it look like an "accident".

Is that what the Crown presented as a theory??

If it is your theory, I regret to inform you that there were no evidence of the victims being drugged.

They did present a theory. They said they were drowned near by in the river and then put into the car. The Crown says it does not know which of the accused carried it out or the precise location nearby, but that's not necessary.

Were there any evidence of the accused having been wetted with river water?
 
I'm sure my version is what went through all the jury members' minds, regardless of whether the Crown could properly present it as evidence. With a case based on circumstantial evidence, part of the situation has to be surmised according to the jury's common sense.
 
I'm sure my version is what went through all the jury members' minds, regardless of whether the Crown could properly present it as evidence. With a case based on circumstantial evidence, part of the situation has to be surmised according to the jury's common sense.

There were no drugs found in the victims, councel. Your theory is in conflict with the evidence presented in court.
 
Danmand I fail to see how you don't "get it" particularly after the jury had the law explained to them.

One doesn't need the smoking gun to convict. This was a very strong case:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ion/article2319036/singlepage/#articlecontent

Ostensibly, according to the defence, the four victims had been on a late-night joyride. But none of them was wearing a seatbelt. The ignition was in the “off” position. And the two front seats were fully reclined, making it difficult for even a tall person to have manoeuvred the steering wheel. Strangest of all, the driver's side window was fully open but none of the victims – who included three healthy teenagers had not tried to escape? The lock was not deep: The roof of the Nissan was less than 18 inches from the water's surface.

As an accident scenario, it almost defied belief. And neither did the location itself make much sense. A car could only reach the lock by navigating around a big rock outcropping, necessitating two U-turns, and the opening was so narrow there were just inches of clearance on each side of the car. All this in the dead of night, with no street lights anywhere.

Then you had the damage to both the Nissan and the Lexus and the paint marks on the lexus from the trash cans by the canal.

None of these key details supported the killers' cover story that the Nissan must have ended up in the water because the four women had taken it for a late-night spin, got lost in the darkness and had somehow driven in

Then you have the fact that the car was turned off - which makes absolutely no sense unless it was the turn off the running lights.

On his father's laptop computer Hamed Shafia did numerous Google searches that in hindsight seem incredible: How to commit murder? Does a person in a Canadian prison have control over their real estate holdings? There were also numerous inquiries involving bodies of water.

They also made numerous incriminating statements into the bugging devices the police concealed in their car and their house – even as they wondered aloud if anyone might be listening.

Nor did they factor in cellphone technology. The network of towers off which cellphone calls “ping” allows authorities to retrace with great accuracy where a user was, and when
 
Danmand I fail to see how you don't "get it" particularly after the jury had the law explained to them.

One doesn't need the smoking gun to convict.

One more thing things you fail to see does not a spring make.

Beyond any reasonable doubt the Crown proved that the accused put 4 dead bodies in a car and rolled the car into the lock.
 
Originally the defense had planned to have the son testify and changed their minds after the wife's testimony went so badly. Presumably they realized there were to many difficulties to allow the crown to have a go at explaining his actions.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/story/2012/01/27/shafia-trial-what-jury-did-not-hear.html

But on Dec. 14, just before court took a break for the holidays, it seemed all but certain that Hamed would testify. His lawyer Patrick McCann told Maranger after the jury was sent home that he would be calling his client to the stand. It's not clear at what point between then and the end of Yahya's five days of brutal cross-examination that a different decision was made.


Hamed said he was at the canal and witnessed his four relatives plunging into the water in a car. He said he honked the horn of his car once then dangled a rope in the water, but seeing no signs of life, he drove away and told no one. The Crown suggested the story was a "complete fabrication."
 
Beyond any reasonable doubt the Crown proved that the accused put 4 dead bodies in a car and rolled the car into the lock.
Then what on earth is your problem? Even the Defence didn't try to argue oh we didn't murder them we just disposed of the bodies.
 
Hamed said he was at the canal and witnessed his four relatives plunging into the water in a car. He said he honked the horn of his car once then dangled a rope in the water, but seeing no signs of life, he drove away and told no one. The Crown suggested the story was a "complete fabrication."
In the front wheel drive car that hung up on the lip of the lock and had to be pushed in order to fall into the lock, and which had to thread its way through boulders barely wide enough to squeeze through and which required two almost "U" turns in order to reach the lock.

One can see why he chose not to testify.
 
Then what on earth is your problem? Even the Defence didn't try to argue oh we didn't murder them we just disposed of the bodies.

I do not have a problem. But if I had been a juror, I would not have agreed to convict someone for first degree murder because the crown had proven that the accused put 4 women in a car and rolled the car into a lock. I would expect more from the Crown, at least a credible theory and some evidence about how and where the accused drowned the victims.

Maybe the defence lawyers were not doing a very good job. Maybe the convicted should have hired O J Simpson's lawyer.
 
Perhaps Dan is jonsing to become their appellate counsel...

If I had no other choice than to make a living as a lawyer, I would seriously consider killing myself.
 
If I had no other choice than to make a living as a lawyer, I would seriously consider killing myself.

I am happy to write a letter to help you get into law school...

But I expect you would have preferred that this family defend themselves and argue their own appeal.
 
if I had been a juror, I would not have agreed to convict someone for first degree murder because the crown had proven that the accused put 4 women in a car and rolled the car into a lock. I would expect more from the Crown, at least a credible theory and some evidence about how and where the accused drowned the victims.
It sounds as though you are a victim of CSI syndrome. You want everything to be tied up nicely with a bow.

The trout in the milk quotation of Henry David Thoreau's regarding circumstantial evidence just doesn't do it for you.
 
I am happy to write a letter to help you get into law school...
I happy to inform you that it will not be necessary. I am able to survive quite handsomely without predating other human beings. (By the way, one of my daughters are in Law school in Toronto)

But I expect you would have preferred that this family defend themselves and argue their own appeal.

I will lose no sleep over the fate of the 3 convicted murderers.