Shafia trial verdict.

The relatives of his first wife may be able to file some sort of civil claim for damages arising from her murder. Perhaps they can also try and lay claim to some of the assets, that should have belonged to her.

The surviving kids have a monster, slam-dunk wrongful death suit against Daddy-o. That'll scoop all his cash. Hopefully, they'll mail him photos of themselves posing on the beach in bikinis w their boyfriends while he rots his ass in jail.
 
One of the first times I can say I'm 'proud' of the legal system; for once, the jury and judge acted without reservation and handed down a verdict/sentence that hopefully will set a strong precedent and send a message that this kind of cultural 'norm' will not be tolerated here.
 
The surviving kids have a monster, slam-dunk wrongful death suit against Daddy-o. That'll scoop all his cash. Hopefully, they'll mail him photos of themselves posing on the beach in bikinis w their boyfriends while he rots his ass in jail.

Unless their family gets to them first and convinces them that the killers did the right thing.

Here is a quote from Rosie's column in the Star:


http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...mad-shafia-destroyed-more-than-three-children


Tooba’s brother-in-law observed, chillingly:“If any of (my) daughters dishonoured me, I would put them in a bag and eliminate them so no one would ever find their traces in Afghanistan."


With friends like these, the accused needed no enemies while on trial. Especially the mother who insisted she had never heard of honour killings before.
 
Having fumbled the ball badly once, I very much doubt that the Ministère de la Famille et de L'enfance are going to repeat that mistake!

In the wiretaps, the younger brother is very concerened with the acussed trio's welfare, not sure if he was as worried about the victims.
 
Yes. The Crown's theory is they were drowned nearby and then put into the cars. The evidence presented for that was that they died by drowning (coroner), and they were already dead or unconscious before the car went into the water (see above).

I understand that. They were drowned and then placed in the car before it was pushed into the lock.

What I imagined (I was out of the country last week) was that the Crown would have presented a theory on how and where they were drowned. I am just curious about how an old man and his wife and son managed to drown, supposedly one at a time, 3 young girls and a women.
 
You have to believe that the Defense--and they hired a good defense, they had money--raised every possible problem with the Crown's story that you possibly could raise. The Jury listened to all that, thought about it, and decided they were guilty.

At the end of the day trying to re-try the case based on the limited information that the newspapers bothered to report is really just sort of silly.

Unless you want to raise some reason to believe that the process itself was inherently unjust, that the rules of the court are unfair, that the system is rigged against them. I don't see any reason to doubt the fairness of this court and therefore at this point I think we are bound to believe that the Jury had good reasons for reaching their verdict.
 
Are you not more "curious" as to how an unlicensed 19 year old Montreal girl driver ostensibly managed to convince her sisters and step mother to drive along country roads, to a remote location, navigate past a closed gate, around rocks and drive neatly into a narrow triangle into the water... with the ignition off... and then all three sit quietly and resist their mammilian reflex and drown peacefully in a car with open windows, without seatbelts and in reclined seats?

All the time while their caring brother watched out for their safety?

Do contrarians like you ever actually think through any of this?
You have to believe that the Defense--and they hired a good defense, they had money--raised every possible problem with the Crown's story that you possibly could raise. The Jury listened to all that, thought about it, and decided they were guilty.

At the end of the day trying to re-try the case based on the limited information that the newspapers bothered to report is really just sort of silly.

Unless you want to raise some reason to believe that the process itself was inherently unjust, that the rules of the court are unfair, that the system is rigged against them. I don't see any reason to doubt the fairness of this court and therefore at this point I think we are bound to believe that the Jury had good reasons for reaching their verdict.

You guys are patently silly, or should I say stupid. Seeing conflict everywhere. I have no doubts about the verdict. I just missed the trial and am asking if any of you know what the Crowns theory or if you will version of events are. I cannot imagine that the Crown did not present a fairly detailled theory about how and where the 3 girls and the women were drowned. Drowning someone is a messy affair, at least as I remember it. I have enough trust in the Jury system that I refuse to believe that the Crown would have gotten a conviction if it only said that they somehow drowned them before they put them in the car and pushed it into the lock.
 
You guys are patently silly, or should I say stupid. Seeing conflict everywhere. I have no doubts about the verdict. I just missed the trial and am asking if any of you know what the Crowns theory or if you will version of events are. I cannot imagine that the Crown did not present a fairly detailled theory about how and where the 3 girls and the women were drowned. Drowning someone is a messy affair, at least as I remember it. I have enough trust in the Jury system that I refuse to believe that the Crown would have gotten a conviction if it only said that they somehow drowned them before they put them in the car and pushed it into the lock.


From the link I previously supplied:

http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/...mad-shafia-destroyed-more-than-three-children


The Crown could only speculate as to how, where and when the victims were killed. They were undoubtedly drowned — maybe in the turning basin at the locks, maybe elsewhere. We’ve no clue who reached in through the fully open driver’s window and turned off the ignition so that the running lights wouldn’t attract attention or who maneuvered the Lexus up against the Nissan, a kiss of metal before dying.
 
Unless

at the end of the day trying to re-try the case based on the limited information that the newspapers bothered to report is really just sort of silly.

Your a lawyer !!!!!

Fast
 
The Crown does not have to go into conclusive details of exactly how they were drowned, which hand was used, who did what... it is more than enough to put them in the immediate area and time of the deliberate murder (it was clearly a murder, not suicide or accident) to determine they were the murderers. More than enough and others are convicted on far more tenuous gaps.

You are entitled to your opinion, and it may well be shared by most.

I wonder what the Crown presented to the Jury. I am sure it is a crime to put 4 dead people into a car and push the car into a lock. However, it is not murder in the 1st degree. It is the killing of the 4 people that constitute murder, not what happened to them after their deaths.

If I was a juror, I would not have agreed to a conviction unless the Crown (which they may very well have done) presented a credible theory of how they were killed. That they somehow were drowned would not cut it for me.
 
Danmand, it is not only the person doing the actual killing who is guilty of first degree murder, but anybody who aids or abets them in doing so. Maybe Tooba stood around watching while they were drowned and her only participation was to supervise the crime, contributing ideas, and helping with the cover up--she's still guilty of first degree murder in that case. Especially if she was party to the planning of it, to the premeditation.

So yes, if you push four dead people into the water who have just been murdered by someone else, and you are doing it to help the murderer cover up the crime that you planned together, you too are guilty of first degree murder as an accessory.

For another example, Melissa Todorovic was convicted of the first degree murder of Stephanie Rengal, even though she wasn't physically present when it happened, her involvement was in helping to plan it, persuading her boyfriend to do it, and then helping to cover it up.

For all three to Shafia's to go down for first degree murder the crown only needed to persuade the jury that they were all in on the plan, regardless of who physically did what.
 
Danmand, it is not only the person doing the actual killing who is guilty of first degree murder, but anybody who aids or abets them in doing so. Maybe Tooba stood around watching while they were drowned and her only participation was to supervise the crime, contributing ideas, and helping with the cover up--she's still guilty of first degree murder in that case. Especially if she was party to the planning of it, to the premeditation.

So yes, if you push four dead people into the water who have just been murdered by someone else, and you are doing it to help the murderer cover up the crime that you planned together, you too are guilty of first degree murder as an accessory.

For another example, Melissa Todorovic was convicted of the first degree murder of Stephanie Rengal, even though she wasn't physically present when it happened, her involvement was in helping to plan it, persuading her boyfriend to do it, and then helping to cover it up.

For all three to Shafia's to go down for first degree murder the crown only needed to persuade the jury that they were all in on the plan, regardless of who physically did what.

I am not disagreeing with you, in principle. However, as a hypothetical juror, I would not have agreed to a conviction unless the Crown (which they may very well have done) presented a credible theory of how they were killed. That they somehow were drowned would not cut it for me. In theory (which I do not believe is the case), somebody else could have drowned them without the convicted three being in on the crime of murder.
 
Danmand, have you heard the term "circumstantial evidence"?
 
The crown presented lots of evidence that they had been planning the murder. The Jury had the opportunity to convict them of 2nd degree murder if they doubted the premeditation elements the crown presented, but the jury went for 1st.

I think the difficulty you're having is that you lack the couple of days of jury instruction that the judge provided the actual jury, clarifying what counts as first degree murder, what standards must be met, and so on. You appear to misunderstand those standards, as presumably do most people, but the jury had that cleared up for them by the judge (and the prosecution, and the defense) before they went away to give it a think.

I mean what are you suggesting here: They premeditated the crime but it was carried out by someone else, some unknown 4th accomplice who has gotten away with it, who they have aided and abetted by covering it up? They're STILL guilty of first degree murder, even if that's true.
 
Danmand, have you heard the term "circumstantial evidence"?

Some of which is really pretty shameful in its own right. Like, that this millionaire family went and bought a crappy $5000 Nissan the day before their trip. Apparently, they wanted to save money and not use the Lexus in the murder of their daughters so they picked up a disposable car just for staging the accident.

This is what I mean when I say don't murder someone if you are stupid.
 
Danmand, have you heard the term "circumstantial evidence"?

I have, councel. I am missing a theory about how the 4 women drowned.
 
I mean what are you suggesting here: They premeditated the crime but it was carried out by someone else, some unknown 4th accomplice who has gotten away with it, who they have aided and abetted by covering it up? They're STILL guilty of first degree murder, even if that's true.

That is not what I suggested. I simply find it very odd that the Crown did not (if it did not) present a theory for how the 4 victims died. It seems to me to be a central part of the case.