financing for a house

paying mortgage = a goal that can be done and be finished in 20 - 30 years
paying rent = till your last breath
both would suck if you lose your job but while paying rent would suck more. no matter what they say, there is still value in a house that you put your sweat blood and tears. paying rent sends your landlord laughing all the way to pay his mortgage. unless you have a hot gf you can pimp when rent money is due, you're better off buying one...but at your current state, not just yet.

Nice to live in a world with no property taxes, and where they never need maintenance. OTOH it must suck where there would be no place to invest your money that had gone into the equity portion of the property or the differential between your rent and your 5% down interest payments. Must also be nice to live in a world where housing prices never go down and interest rates never go up.

I know a guy in his late forties.. Never married and rents. He has no savings.

What do you all think of that?

I know a guy who bought a house, fucked his dog and now has dog herpies.
What do you all think of that.

Ok so 3 years ago I bought my last house at $180 000 on power of sale. Spent 10 000 in renovations, major cleaning, cosmetics etc..I wont shit you..I put a lot of sweat into the place. My first year all my vacation time was used up just fixing the place up. Last year sold it for 212 000..Tell me how much you get back when you rent?????

Almost doubled my money in the markets in a similar time period, mostly with REITS. Whose the bitch now.

But seriously I am sure there are a lot of Americans, Irish, Spanish and other people who did similar to you and are truly ass invaded. I am sure there are many people who did similar to me at various times with similar results [Japan late 80's, world 1929]

These I did X and it worked out for me, therefore what I did was smart and will always be a good idea and pretty retarded arguments. My actions the past few years really paid off, but it could have just as easily FUBARed me.

If you disagree, may I suggest investing all your money in tulips.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania

I figure the Toronto market is due for a correction, sadly I don't know if it will be tomorrow or if it will be 10 years from now. Or maybe I am wrong. Must be nice to live in a world where you can predict the future with total accuracy and mock those who don't agree with you.
What I do find is that the pro ownership people tend to leave out a LOT of factors when they make fun of the renters. As for the renters, well they tend not to make fun of the owners.


As for people who don't save. Tis indeed a sad state of society when the only way someone can save is via paying off a mortgage. I guess if you are dealing with a child, it would be better off to buy a house and be forced to make mortgage payments. My comments are directed at adults who can be counted to actually save money rather than spend every extra dime on toys and fun. Considering recent debates on extending the CPP I am guessing I should probably STFU, as most people in this country are obviously children, renters and owners. I would STFU but I hate to see someone unfairly insulted.

For the record I don't rent, but I figure I probably will in the future.
 
Good for you if you have taken profits from flipping a property. But I don't
think anyone sensible would suggest that buying a house is NEVER the right
thing to do. Somehow I got the impression some of the posters are saying
that buying a house with borrowed money is always smarter than the alternative
regardless of the price.

BTW, a gain of $20K from an investment of $190,000
over a 3 year period is peanuts.

Yeah, but he also had a place to live for 3 years.

If you assume his "rent" would have been $1,500 per month (going rate for a 2 bedroom apt. on Danforth), now do the math.

36 x 1,500 = $54,000

Add that to his return on his investment of 20 K = 74K

How's that looking now?

(Assuming he bought the place cash, you can deduct interest from the 74 for financing - say 4% on the amount mortgaged.)

He's still way ahead.
 
I figure the Toronto market is due for a correction, sadly I don't know if it will be tomorrow or if it will be 10 years from now. Or maybe I am wrong. Must be nice to live in a world where you can predict the future with total accuracy and mock those who don't agree with you.
What I do find is that the pro ownership people tend to leave out a LOT of factors when they make fun of the renters. As for the renters, well they tend not to make fun of the owners.


As for people who don't save. Tis indeed a sad state of society when the only way someone can save is via paying off a mortgage. I guess if you are dealing with a child, it would be better off to buy a house and be forced to make mortgage payments. My comments are directed at adults who can be counted to actually save money rather than spend every extra dime on toys and fun. Considering recent debates on extending the CPP I am guessing I should probably STFU, as most people in this country are obviously children, renters and owners. I would STFU but I hate to see someone unfairly insulted.

For the record I don't rent, but I figure I probably will in the future.

Yes, yes, everyone is always waiting for and praying for the big crash (usually the guys who rent because they want to get into the market and suddenly renting no longer makes sense and owning makes all the sense in the world). Prices dropped 15% in 2008 during the great meltdown and rebounded within 6 months.

Even in 94, real estate prices in Toronto dropped 30% to 1996, but then rebounded by 1998. Real estate is a commodity just like gold, oil, or pussy. The price fluctuates based on supply and demand, however, long term, the curve is a nice straight incline and a way to invest your money against inflation and give you a place to live at the same tim.

There are those who say that real estate prices in Toronto are too high. Well yeah, but if you talk to anyone over the age of 65 they will tell you that it's never been cheap to buy a house in Toronto.

Compared to European and Asian cities, and prime US cities (NYC, Chicago, San Francisco) Toronto is a screaming cheap play.

Take a look at the price of owning a home in London England:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/in_depth/uk_house_prices/regions/html/region10.stm

When I was in London last year, average housing prices in the downtown area were 5 million POUNDS for a semi detached home. The pound for the longest time was trading at 2.6 (now it's a deal at 1.6)

Still think paying a million bucks for a detached home in Riverdale is nuts?
 
Yeah, but he also had a place to live for 3 years.

If you assume his "rent" would have been $1,500 per month (going rate for a 2 bedroom apt. on Danforth), now do the math.

36 x 1,500 = $54,000

Add that to his return on his investment of 20 K = 74K

How's that looking now?

(Assuming he bought the place cash, you can deduct interest from the 74 for financing - say 4% on the amount mortgaged.)

He's still way ahead.

Correct. The renter is $54k in the hole after the same 3 year period. I'm sure his or her magical "investments" are more than picking up the slack. Yeah right.

By the way, where and whom are you folks investing with? Are you doing it through your bank?
 
Everyone thinks that "investments" are somehow guaran fucking teed.

Laughable.

Long story short, I'm in the Royal Bank the other day and buddy is trying to sell me on switching my RRSPs from Sunlife to RBC. Pulls up this chart and that chart that compares RBC mutual funds to the return of the TSX. I can assure you that there was lots of negative years in the charts over the last 15 years and rarely did the RBC whiz bangs beat the index.
 
Yeah, but he also had a place to live for 3 years.

If you assume his "rent" would have been $1,500 per month (going rate for a 2 bedroom apt. on Danforth), now do the math.

36 x 1,500 = $54,000

Add that to his return on his investment of 20 K = 74K

How's that looking now?

(Assuming he bought the place cash, you can deduct interest from the 74 for financing - say 4% on the amount mortgaged.)

He's still way ahead.

Are you comparing apples to apples? Was this house on the danforth? Can you buy a house on the danforth for $212k? I don't think you can so your rent estimates compared to THIS example are meaningless.

So he bought at $180 + $10k renovations and sold for $212.
That's $22,000 over 3 years.
Deduct from that $2000 in purchasing costs = $20,000
Deduct from that $2000 in selling costs = $18,000
Deduct from that about $12,000 in real estate fees = $6000

Let's not forget he put in a lot of his time to renovate the place. And what did he get? $6000, maybe as much as $10k depending on if his expenses were a bit less than I estimated. Whoopee!!!
His property taxes alone would wipe out that "profit". Hardly a steller example of why buying is better than renting.

Kirk, you're easily one of the smartest posters on this board. You seem to have lost your objectivity on this one. I'm disappointed, I've come to expect better from you :)
 
Under most circumstances I'm a believer that buying is better than renting, but I certainly don't believe that that is always true. If you believe that the housing market will always rise then renting will never be a good option for you. As I stated earlier, Garth Turner has given some very good numbers showing why buying now is usually a bad idea. I KNOW he's an idiot that's often wrong, but that doesn't invalidate his numbers. Even he can do math.

Here's a quote from a positing of his in December:

Why are young couples so aroused by real estate? Beats me. But let’s try to help Stefan and Brianna work through it. Yesterday, they sent this:

We’ve been following your blog for a little while now and decided to ask you for a piece of advice since you are after all an expert in this field. We’re in our 20′s (not married yet). We both have very solid jobs.

We are looking into buying a brand new house in Mississauga for approximately $550k. We are planning long term. The downpayment would cover 20% or $110 000 which would leave us with about $440,000 mortgage. After all the calculations and monthly deductions we would end up with approximately $2000 buffer each month.

We know that the market will correct a bit but believe that we are on a level where we would be fine even with the correction. What do you think we should do? Should we buy or not?

Of course, this is a very unusual case. Kids with cash. These twentysomethings, through work or generous families, have a mega-downpayment compared to the cab fare most couples use to leverage real estate. With 20% down a house should be a no-brainer, right?

Maybe not. For example, young buyers have to plan for the end of cheap money, with mortgage rates likely doubling over the next five years. But let’s not factor that in, to be generous. More immediate is a correction in housing prices after a 13-year run which landed us in history’s deepest pile of debt. Any kids buying now must understand they’re jumping in at the top, and risk having to endure a much weaker market.

So let’s assume Stefan and Brianna buy that perfect new house in the distant burbs for $550,000. With closing costs, of course, the price swells to $561,000 (actually a bit more, but it’s always a good rule of thumb to add 2% to the purchase price to close the deal). With a fat $110,000 to put down (and no mortgage insurance needed), their new debt would be $451,000.

With a mortgage of that size borrowed by virgins, the only sane action is to get a five-year fixed loan, which these days is about 4% at most major lenders. And if they do this in 2012, chances are they’ll be forced into a 25-year amortization, since I’m hearing the next federal budget will murder thirty-year loans. So, the monthly payment would be $2,394, not including any occupancy overhead.

Now let’s say the market corrects in the next year by 15%, taking the value of the house down to $467,500. So what?, cry Stefan and Brianna. We ain’t selling.

Good thing. Because if they did (not counting in selling costs or mortgage break penalty), their $110,000 in equity would dwindle to less than $17,000 – giving them a stunning 85% loss on their original investment. And you thought the stock market was risky…

So let’s say they stay in the love nest in this most romantic of Canadian cities for a full five years, and then decide to sell (long enough to get married, bummed and divorced). During those sixty months, Stefan and Brianna would pay $85,876 in interest charges for the privilege of borrowing the mortgage principal. Property taxes would be at least $25,000, while insurance and feathering would add a minimum of ten grand. Dumping the place triggers an average commission of 5%, plus legals and moving, for total selling costs of almost $31,000.

Now let’s assume the value of the house has been fully restored to what they paid – $550,000. After 60 mortgage payments (of $144,000 of which $85,876 was interest), they’d still owe $393,212. The sale proceeds (minus the mortgage and selling costs) would then be $129,913. Whoo-hoo, a profit!

Er. Nope. Remember that $110,000 of that was the original downpayment, which reduces the profit to $19,913. But if the $110,000 had been invested (at a modest 6%) for five years instead of sitting in the house, it would have earned $37,204, which must be considered opportunity cost. Therefore Stefan and Brianna would have actually lost $17,291, even though they sold for as much as they paid.

Now I hear the unemployed realtors on this blog grumbling about me fudging the numbers because S&B would have needed to rent a place if they didn’t buy. Quite true.

The actual cost of them owning this house for five years (finance charges, taxes and maintenance) was $179,000, or almost $3,000 a month. And at the end of it they got their deposit back plus $19,913, reducing the monthly cost to $2,651.

And what does it cost to rent a half-million-dollar house with five bedrooms and three bathrooms in the outer western GTA wasteland? Like this one? Hmmm. Two thousand five hundred a month. But wait. If the $110,000 they’d used as a downpayment was invested (at 6%), the $37,204 in returns would offset rent. So to make a fairer comparison, their occupancy costs would fall to $1,879 a month over five years.

I've highlighted somethign important. Most people would be in a far worse situation financially than this pair. I forget, but it's either 70% of 90% of new mortgages have CMHC insurance, which means down payments much less than these two are using.
 
Yes, yes, everyone is always waiting for and praying for the big crash (usually the guys who rent because they want to get into the market and suddenly renting no longer makes sense and owning makes all the sense in the world). ....

Even in 94, real estate prices in Toronto dropped 30% to 1996, but then rebounded by 1998. Real estate is a commodity just like gold, oil, or pussy. The price fluctuates based on supply and demand, however, long term, the curve is a nice straight incline and a way to invest your money against inflation and give you a place to live at the same tim.

I am sure one would see the same counter during every bubble in history as in the first paragraph.
As for the long term home prices if you compare same with same and take out inflation are stable. If one looks back over 100 years or even 400 years. There are several graphs available that show the results, one American, one Dutch and IIRC there is one for London. I would post it, but frankly I am a bit tired running in the terb special Olympics.

Everyone thinks that "investments" are somehow guaran fucking teed.

Laughable.

Yes it is Laughable. The only thing more laughable is that you don't see the irony in your statement.

About the only guarantee is that mutual funds will underperform the general market. I have little sympathy for those who are unwilling to do even the minimal research to reduce if not eliminate that hit.

I am not arguing that the market is better or worse than real estate, simply that there are legitimate investment options for the renter, that if he saves the difference, he is not a fool. Much of the argument for owning over investment ignores many of the costs of ownership and assumes that the renter is not able to save and invest a dime.

If you are argueing that ownership is better than renting because you are too much of a child to save money and to retarded to invest it in anyway but paying a 2.5% MER, then fine, I can believe that. If you further wish to argue that your typical person is as child like and retarded, sadly I must agree with that also. However I think for the right person renting can be a very valid option. Double plus so for the Toronto condo market as it stands today or for a single person or permanent DINKs who just don't need the space of a full scale home.

I am sure everything I've said others have said also. I am sure people have run numbers past you. So I give up on you. You win, I lose, congrats.

41784_2253543784_4474_n.jpg


I think I should go read a book, I am feeling really dumb right now.
 
I'm not saying that real estate is a great investment. It definitely has its ups and downs.

I'm saying it's better than renting and I firmly believe that.
 
Are you comparing apples to apples? Was this house on the danforth? Can you buy a house on the danforth for $212k? I don't think you can so your rent estimates compared to THIS example are meaningless.

So he bought at $180 + $10k renovations and sold for $212.
That's $22,000 over 3 years.
Deduct from that $2000 in purchasing costs = $20,000
Deduct from that $2000 in selling costs = $18,000
Deduct from that about $12,000 in real estate fees = $6000

Let's not forget he put in a lot of his time to renovate the place. And what did he get? $6000, maybe as much as $10k depending on if his expenses were a bit less than I estimated. Whoopee!!!
His property taxes alone would wipe out that "profit". Hardly a steller example of why buying is better than renting.

Kirk, you're easily one of the smartest posters on this board. You seem to have lost your objectivity on this one. I'm disappointed, I've come to expect better from you :)

Clearly it wasn't a great example of flipping for profit. But even so, at the end of the day, a renter over the same time is out of money, while the homeowner is at least breaking even.
 
Clearly it wasn't a great example of flipping for profit. But even so, at the end of the day, a renter over the same time is out of money, while the homeowner is at least breaking even.

What if the market is falling? I wonder if all the people who bought in Las Vegas, Phoenix and many other US cities in 2007 wished they rented instead?
 
What if the market is falling? I wonder if all the people who bought in Las Vegas, Phoenix and many other US cities in 2007 wished they rented instead?

There are two types of homeowners - those that buy what they can afford, and those that buy beyond their means. The former type of homeowner accepts that busts happen. Setbacks happen but markets do recover. This doesn't discourage them from wanting to live in a home they can call their own. Who would want to spend their entire lives renting because they're hedging bets on another catastrophic market crash? A man wants to be the king of his own castle. The latter type of homeowner is actually a renter who should never have been able to buy a home. If asked, she would probably say she wished she had stuck to renting.
 
There are two types of homeowners - those that buy what they can afford, and those that buy beyond their means. The former type of homeowner accepts that busts happen. Setbacks happen but markets do recover. This doesn't discourage them from wanting to live in a home they can call their own. Who would want to spend their entire lives renting because they're hedging bets on another catastrophic market crash? A man wants to be the king of his own castle. The latter type of homeowner is actually a renter who should never have been able to buy a home. If asked, she would probably say she wished she had stuck to renting.

I'm not nor did I ever advocate renting forever. But several people seem to have sweeping ideas that buying is always better. It makes sense RIGHT NOW to rent for a while and be patient EVEN if you are a buyer buying what they can afford. This is assuming you believe the market is going to correct (I do). If you believe that the good times will never end the surely buying will be the option for you. My friends parents bought at the peak in 1989 (well within their means, they are sensible with money). I think they sold it around 16 years later for maybe $15-20k more than they paid. Even though they always intended to stay there long term, if they could go back in time and rent instead of buying, would they? You fucking bet they would.
Could 2012 be the next 1989? It could be. Several areas of BC are already turning into oceans of for sale signs of those trying to get off the ship before it sinks. I sure as fuck wouldn't want to be buying now even if it's well within my budget.

To say that always buying is better, even for those than can comfortably afford it is silly.
 
My friends parents bought at the peak in 1989 (well within their means, they are sensible with money). I think they sold it around 16 years later for maybe $15-20k more than they paid. Even though they always intended to stay there long term, if they could go back in time and rent instead of buying, would they? You fucking bet they would.

I think that if they could go back in time, they still would have bought the house, but they would not have bought it at the 1989 peak and perhaps in a different location. How much further ahead would they be had they rented for those 16 years? So many variables would have to be considered - what if they had rented and invested in Nortel over those 16 years?

I agree, that buying is not always better. But market corrections and crashes aside, it's usually a more sound investment compared to renting.
 
I think that if they could go back in time, they still would have bought the house, but they would not have bought it at the 1989 peak. How much further ahead would they be had they rented for those 16 years? So many variables would have to be considered - what if they had rented and invested in Nortel over those 16 years?

I agree, that buying is not always better. But market corrections and crashes aside, it's usually a more sound investment compared to renting.

You're making assumptions that they could have bought instead, let's say 1985. Perhaps circumstances didn't allow for that to happen? You're also talking about renting for 16 years. I'm not advocating permanent renting!!! Using a little bit of analysis would perhaps lead one to determine now is not a good time to buy. I swear, people spend more time researching the purchase of a new TV than they do buying a piece of property worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. The market then, as it does now has warning flags all over it.
At least I've got you to say "usually" :)
 
You're making assumptions that they could have bought instead, let's say 1985. Perhaps circumstances didn't allow for that to happen? You're also talking about renting for 16 years. I'm not advocating permanent renting!!! Using a little bit of analysis would perhaps lead one to determine now is not a good time to buy. I swear, people spend more time researching the purchase of a new TV than they do buying a piece of property worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. The market then, as it does now has warning flags all over it.
At least I've got you to say "usually" :)

A wise man once said: Best investment on earth is earth.
 
If she had bought a house when she was 30, she would have been living in her own place now, just having to pay the utilities, a bit of up keep and the taxes. Instead, she's 2 steps away from the shelter.

This doesn't sound right.

I think the problem you're trying to highlight ("2 steps from the shelter") means she didn't invest RRSPs or despite her 250k income, didn't save much. You should be happy for her that she's clear and free of recurring liabilities of property tax, maintenance, housing insurance and more if her financial situation is that bad as you're describing. At least she can move herself to a better job market area if her situation gets worse, what would she do with a house and its fixed liabilities?
 
I'm saying it's better than renting and I firmly believe that.

Not when there's a bubble situation: why buy at the peak when you KNOW it's the peak? This was the story in parts of California, Las Vegas, parts of FL, parts of AZ, Spain, Dubai etc etc where real estate agents were singing the same song "we're different", "we have rich foreign investors buying", "we have large amounts of people moving in", "renting is paying someone else's mortgage" etc etc. And now, people are foreclosed on and without that home and also out of their down payment.
 
Buying a house should not be a short term investment unless you are in the right location and the market is right to sell. Investing should be long term and 99% of the time you will end up ahead compared to renting over that same period of time. It's not rocket science people.