financing for a house

Buying a house should not be a short term investment unless you are in the right location and the market is right to sell. Investing should be long term and 99% of the time you will end up ahead compared to renting over that same period of time. It's not rocket science people.

I agree with you in some way. I don't care about short term fluctuation of prices
when I buy a stock being an old fashioned buy-n-hold type of investor. I would apply
the same principle when buying a house. I always brought my stocks at a reasonable
price with 100% cash. Hence I find the idea of buying a house with *borrowed money*
at a horrendous price crazy. If I am to buy a home price may be no object depending
on how much spare cash I have in excess of the price.
 
Under most circumstances I'm a believer that buying is better than renting, but I certainly don't believe that that is always true. If you believe that the housing market will always rise then renting will never be a good option for you. As I stated earlier, Garth Turner has given some very good numbers showing why buying now is usually a bad idea. I KNOW he's an idiot that's often wrong, but that doesn't invalidate his numbers. Even he can do math.

He can do math but his underlying assumptions are pretty suspect. 1) he assumes that, at best, in five years, the value of the home will remain unchanged - as James T. Kirk noted, historically, that has not been the trend in real estate values; and 2) he assumes they could invest with an annual return of 6%. If anyone can tell me where you can invest with a guaranteed annual return of 6% these days I would be most grateful.
 
'till your last breath'.. you talk like you're certain everyone will live till their 70's. Life is uncertain. One could die in a month or in 90 years. The only time one can be certain of is NOW. Do you really want to work like a slave during your youth, paying off a mortgage which you complete by 60 or 70? then start thinking about enjoying life in the feeble and weak state you've gotten to?

so true that not everyone will live past their 50's. but what money you have put down, can be acquired by your beneficiaries (if you have kids or your wife). paying rent 'til you're 50's just doesn't cut it...
 
1) he assumes that, at best, in five years, the value of the home will remain unchanged - as James T. Kirk noted, historically, that has not been the trend in real estate values;

The prices have been rising for more than a decade, so it must continue right? You have to be brain damaged to believe that.
Historically real estate prices rise - long term - with inflation. Canadian prices are so far ahead of inflation that common sense says a correction is coming. It's not even a question of will it happen, merely a question of when.

As for the 6%, I don't know the answer to that. But investing is somewhat art, somewhat luck, somewhat skill for those that are able to interpret the data. I am sure there are many investments, while not guaranteed offer a decent prospect of an annual return of 6% over the next 5 years. No way is real estate (a primary residence) one of them.
 
In the late 80s to early 90s interest rates were 10-12 percent.

Sure 3% is great, but it won't last forever. Those fools who take out a huge 300K+ mortgage, then push themselves even deeper into dept with expensive cars, wall mount TVs, and expensive vacations will eventually face a day of reckoning.

Eventually inflation will take hold, interest rates will move up, and people with huge debt loads will find it unmanageable and at the same time house prices will be declining. They will declare bankruptcy because their mortgage will be bigger than the diminished value of the house. Reminds me of 1989.

The only way this makes sense to buy now is that you buy now, lock in the 3% rate and then try to pay the mortgage off ASAP while the rates are low.

And then prepare for your property value to drop when the rates go up because one day, yes, that scenario you're outlining will happen.

Question is: buy now or keep renting.
 
i've been looking at some online calculators which determine if it is cheaper to buy or rent

after running through the calculators a few times (which themselves have many HUGE assumptions), the jist of it is:

if you are buying a "house" version of your apartment (i.e. a cheap condo), it is cheaper to buy the condo

if you are buying a house-house (single family home), it is cheaper to rent

main thing that determines what's cheaper is the amount you are financing (the more you finance, the cheaper the rent option becomes)
 
but people rent and buy through different phases in their lives ...

i don't think there's a universal answer for this

rent vs. buy is, imo, a personal decision, that no one but you can decide, ultimately

owning a home, ultimately, gives you a rent-free place to call your own ... but you'll need to maintain it, or pay someone else to maintain it (everything breaks), and there's still property taxes and insurance to pay

some people rent their whole lives and have no problems with it, they can keep up with increased rent ... but you never have a place of your own, rent always goes up, and you're under the control of the landlord (most people don't like this, but for some, they never have an issue)
 
I would not say that the "Canadian Market" is over valued persay.

It's more like certain markets are over-valued - Vancouver, Toronto, Calgary, Victoria, GTA, etc. And they are over-valued in terms of their historical prices, not by world prices by any means. Not even close. So the arguement takes on a huges social political context if you start looking at Toronto (say) real estate prices in comparison to other world class cities. If you do that, Toronto's prices are still extraordinarily cheap. The debate becomes one of whether or not the world is becoming "globalized" or not?

If you want cheaper home prices in Southern Ontario, you only need to drive to Hamilton or the Niagara Region.

There, housing is less than HALF of Toronto. In dowtown Hammer, you can find a 3 storey Victorian with 5 bedrooms and all the charm of a home in Cabbagetown for around 200 to 250 grand. (Less if you want a basket case or a bit dodgier of a neighbourhood.) If you want a suburban McMansion, the prices are also half of the GTA. If you want in "inner suburb" you can find a place on Hamilton Mountain akin to say Etobicoke or Scarborough for 200,000 easy.
 
A couple of other thoughts on owning a home and this thread.

Most of the posters on this thread are fixated on the economics of owning a house. They are thinking of it purely as an investment. This probably stems from the Canadian experience we grew up with where often one would hear, "it's the best investment I ever made" or, "it's the biggest investment most people will ever make" etc. But is owning a home really an "investment" in that one lets only economics govern all decisions governnig our choices pertaining to home ownership? I'm sure that the answer for many people is a resounding "yes", however, in that "yes" one finds the question - "from an economic point of view - is a house worth it?"

Who knows.

To me, I am a house guy. Even though I am a single male, I own (me and the RBC) my own house. I hate the idea of living in an apartment, or a condo, or paying rent. Part of that is that I really don't like people that much and don't want to be in close quarters with them and part of it is my Eastern European / Jewish upbringing where I was always told (and truly believe) - "why would you pay someone else's mortgage and end up with nothing?"

Never the less, I digress......

I didn't buy my house as an investment. I bought it as a place to live and I enjoy my privacy and where I live and doing renovations. Unlike most men these days, I do know which end of the hammer is which and I could easily build my own home with my own 2 hands. I have renovated my house from top to bottom as it needed one of everything when I bought it. I have done roofing, windows, a complete rewire, gas work, plumbing, drains, sewers, framing, insulation, drywall, tiles, painting finish carpentry - all myself. (And no, I am not a tradesman by profession, I'm just the kind of guy who loves designing and building things and I don't trust other people and contractors to do a good job so I've taught myself how to do everything. Oh, I can also take a car apart down to the frame and rebuild it too (and have done so many times and no, I'm not a mechanic either.) Obviously I have a part of me that is technical and creative. I can (and enjoy) designing, creating, and building many different things. But I have never trained, or apprenticed, or schooled in any of these things. I just got off my ass and figured out how to do them. I have 0 respect for any many who cannot do simple repair work around the house. In fact, I have less than 0 respect. I despise your incompetence and laziness (because that's what it boils down to). A man who can't or change out a dishwaher or change an electrical recepticle, or an overhead light fixture is a pathetic excuse of a man to me. (Probably the resut of me growing up in the time (1970s) and place (Hamilton) that I did where "the men folk" knew how to do stuff like this (and a lot more).

So a house needing work doesn't scare me in the least. Hell, if and when I ever move I will be looking for another gut job - though I won't be living in it again. (Been there done that.)

I look at it this way. I'm in the market. If the market rises or falls, I don't really care (as long as I'm employed (knock on wood)) because I simply rise and fall with it. My house is not generating me income and I'm not using it as a bank to the extent that it is currently worth (or even close to). So I rise and fall with the tide. If I choose to sell, and the market has dropped, I don't really care because the house I want to buy has also dropped so it's apples to apples. The only time you have a problem is if you are own in a market segment that drops more relative to the market segement you want to buy into. (For example, if you own in the condo market and you want to buy a single detached home and the condo market drops 30% and the SDH market drops 15% - then you have a problem. Or, if you own in T.O. and the market drops 50% and you want to buy into Ottawa and it only drops 10% (as unlikely as that scenario might be) - then you have a problem.
 
The canadian market is over-valued in my opinion but I doubt it will go down anytime soon. There are a ton of immigrants coming here with $ to spend.

I was looking to purchase a condo at Aura http://www.collegeparkcondos.com/ and was told there was a significant number of foreigners who had purchased these units. I spoke to a few of the foreign guys and they thought canadian real-estate is a good bet in terms of return on investment. So for them a purchase of 800K is peanuts and alot of them do not want o report their income in their own country due to being taxed (e.g. china and india).

The foreigners also buy the property outright, so to them as long as they get the maintenance fees from the tenant they are good because they do not need to cover the mortgage. This aspect works to the tenants advantage so renting maybe preferable.

I want to address this "tons of immigrants with $$$" and the "foreign guys thinking Canadian real estate is good ROI" crap that the real estate industry puts out.

Have you heard of the Dubai story?

Read through this please: http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2026934,00.html

Their market was inflated by "rich foreigners" a.k.a SPECULATORS who drove up the prices and then when the economy went down, pulled out their money and dumped units on the market leading to a supply glut.

As in Las Vegas. As in California.

Real estate agents would make you believe that Toronto is special. No it's not.
 
Why is he an idiot if he has no wife and kids.. And only needs a room to sleep in and a bathroom?

You also said he has no savings. Obviously he's planning to work until the day he dies. If he ever had any dreams of retiring, then he's an idiot.
 
I didn't buy my house as an investment. I bought it as a place to live and I enjoy my privacy and where I live and doing renovations. Unlike most men these days, I do know which end of the hammer is which and I could easily build my own home with my own 2 hands. I have renovated my house from top to bottom as it needed one of everything when I bought it. I have done roofing, windows, a complete rewire, gas work, plumbing, drains, sewers, framing, insulation, drywall, tiles, painting finish carpentry - all myself. (And no, I am not a tradesman by profession, I'm just the kind of guy who loves designing and building things and I don't trust other people and contractors to do a good job so I've taught myself how to do everything. Oh, I can also take a car apart down to the frame and rebuild it too (and have done so many times and no, I'm not a mechanic either.) Obviously I have a part of me that is technical and creative. I can (and enjoy) designing, creating, and building many different things. But I have never trained, or apprenticed, or schooled in any of these things. I just got off my ass and figured out how to do them. I have 0 respect for any many who cannot do simple repair work around the house. In fact, I have less than 0 respect. I despise your incompetence and laziness (because that's what it boils down to). A man who can't or change out a dishwaher or change an electrical recepticle, or an overhead light fixture is a pathetic excuse of a man to me. (Probably the resut of me growing up in the time (1970s) and place (Hamilton) that I did where "the men folk" knew how to do stuff like this (and a lot more).

And he enjoys romantic walks on the beach and candlelit dinners.

Sorry, couldn't resist.
The only real worry is if the market does what it did in the states, where prices dropped enough that people lost all their equity and it became cheaper to walk away from the mortgage then to continue to pay into a mortgage worth way more then the house. Once that happens, the whole market gets screwed, neighbourhoods vacate and it becomes near impossible to sell anything.

But, if you've got a manageable mortgage and don't care about the equity and can ride it out, maybe you'll be ok.
That's pretty much what I'm hoping.
 
The only real worry is if the market does what it did in the states, where prices dropped enough that people lost all their equity and it became cheaper to walk away from the mortgage then to continue to pay into a mortgage worth way more then the house. Once that happens, the whole market gets screwed, neighbourhoods vacate and it becomes near impossible to sell anything.

I'd think that a US style meltdown might not happen here simply because in Canada, the banks can come after you for owed debt.

In some US states (esp California), one could walk away without consequence other than a 7yr credit hit. And people figured that's not a big thing. It's called a "no-recourse" state for the bank.

But in Canada, one can't walk away from the mortgage. The bank will sell the house for what it's worth on the market and then the amount is still owed.

So this situation is even more dangerous from a borrower's perspective. There are NO "outs" that were available to the US borrower (short sale/distressed sale).
 
Dubai was highly leveraged and people were depending on the tenant to pay their mortgage but in canada the banks do not allow extreme leveraging like other jurisdictions.

The cost of housing in Toronto is most likely going to be stable and not take a huge hit, but the surrounding areas will most likely take a hit.

Respectfully, Canadian banks are accepting 5% down payments and chucking the risk over to CMHC just like the US banks were taking 0% down and getting an AIG policy.

TD Chief in Dec 2011 passing the buck onto the Fed government while continuing to write 5% mortgages: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/glob...s-should-be-stricter-td-chief/article2271588/

So my point is: if Toronto is going to depend on the same chinese, indian, russian buyers.....those guys are looking at CA, AZ, NY, FL as well. What's so special about Toronto? The cold weather?
 
^^^ What's so special about Toronto is the Canadian banks.

Though I agree with you that 5% downpayment is not enough, it should be put back to 10% (where it was prior to 1996) in order to put some risk on the buyer.

But getting back to the banking system. Canadian banks are pretty careful with their money when it comes to loaing it out. They will only give you a mortgage for 3 times your annual salary, maybe 3.5 if you're lucky. So if you make 100 grand a year (which is a pretty damn good salary and not that many people make it given that the average wage in Canada is 44 grand a year) they will give you a mortgage of $300,000.00 over 25 years.

Now contrast that to the USA where pre-meltdown the banks were giving 100 year mortgages of $500,000.00 to guys making 8 bucks an hour (16,000.00 per year) who really had no business having a mortgage they could not possibly pay. Everything was predicated on the continuing increase in real estate prices. Soaring in fact. 3 bedroom bungalows in San Francisco - the kind you'd find all over the map in Scarborough or Etobicoke were going for 1.3 million dollars (I know, I saw it with my own eyes on a trip to SF premeltdown.)


That is the difference, or at least part of the difference.
 
Why do Canadian banks make you fight to get less than 25% downpayment on commercial properties but are apparently willing to accept 5% down on homes? Commercial properties actually generate revenue and pay their own way yet the bank makes it harder to buy. The Canadian system is sometimes so anti-capitalist, anti-business. I don't get it.
 
There are 2 things that will cause a major decrease in prices in real estate in Toronto.

1. A 3 point increase in interest rates. (Or more.) Probably not going to happen any time soon, but if it did, I would expect to see a 10 to 15% haircut on the prices of homes in T.O.

2. Another serious recession - 20 percent drop.

Combine both (the perfect storm) and you have the makings for a 30 to 40 percent drop.

So I suppose if one was wanting to buy that first house in T.O. one could sit and wait and pray for either or all of the above figuring it would be possible to pick up a place for cheap.

There's only 2 problems.


1. Odds are you will be unemployed, so you won't be able to afford a house or get a mortgage.

2. If interest rates rise - you're fucked there too.


The only people who will be able to take advantage of a downturn in real estate prices will be the rich bastards who have cash on hand. For the average schmuck who needs a mortgage, you're fucked either way.
 
^^^ What's so special about Toronto is the Canadian banks.

Though I agree with you that 5% downpayment is not enough, it should be put back to 10% (where it was prior to 1996) in order to put some risk on the buyer.

But getting back to the banking system. Canadian banks are pretty careful with their money when it comes to loaing it out. They will only give you a mortgage for 3 times your annual salary, maybe 3.5 if you're lucky. So if you make 100 grand a year (which is a pretty damn good salary and not that many people make it given that the average wage in Canada is 44 grand a year) they will give you a mortgage of $300,000.00 over 25 years.

Now contrast that to the USA where pre-meltdown the banks were giving 100 year mortgages of $500,000.00 to guys making 8 bucks an hour (16,000.00 per year) who really had no business having a mortgage they could not possibly pay. Everything was predicated on the continuing increase in real estate prices. Soaring in fact. 3 bedroom bungalows in San Francisco - the kind you'd find all over the map in Scarborough or Etobicoke were going for 1.3 million dollars (I know, I saw it with my own eyes on a trip to SF premeltdown.)


That is the difference, or at least part of the difference.

But post-meltdown haven't US banks tightened the noose? Why wouldn't foreigners buy up all kinds of luxurious decked out properties in warm weather for cheap in the US rather than buying in Toronto?

If they are in fact buying up in Toronto I'm happy, and I'm also happy that Toronto may be expensive for the average Canadian but still cheap compared to other major cities worldwide. Theoretically this should mean Toronto property values should be ok (not completely tank like in the US) even if the Canadian housing market crashes. Surrounding areas in the GTA would be hit harder.
 
Last edited: