Warhorse

I was on the receiving end of a lance charge from thirty mounted officers, with video camera in hand, and was blown away and how the ground shook then the noise.

Bet that was one hell of a gang-bang you played 'catcher' for!.....:eyebrows:
 
I was on the receiving end of a lance charge from thirty mounted officers, with video camera in hand, and was blown away and how the ground shook then the noise. I can only imagine the effect of a charge of 5000 mounted followed by another 5000 in the grand attack of the four French Cavalry Corps at Waterloo.
Here I thought you were going to go with the Heavy Brigade.

Scotland_Forever.jpg


Scotland Forever (The Royal Scots Greys at Waterloo)
by Elizabeth, Lady Butler - - - - - Leeds City Art Gallery

* Due to the ground, they actually attacked at the trot not the gallop.
 
Here I thought you were going to go with the Heavy Brigade.
Perhaps he is working up to being on the receiving end of a Heavy Brigade lance charge next.....:eyebrows:
 
Here I thought you were going to go with the Heavy Brigade.

Scotland_Forever.jpg


Scotland Forever (The Royal Scots Greys at Waterloo)
by Elizabeth, Lady Butler - - - - - Leeds City Art Gallery

* Due to the ground, they actually attacked at the trot not the gallop.

Contrary to what the painting shows, an all out full gallop, Hollywood style, most of the advance of heavy cavalry would be at less than a full gallop, more control, with the final perhaps 100 metres, basically extreme effective musket range, covered at speed, but the emphasis was a controlled approached arriving hopefully at the same time. Remember they were crossing in most cases unknown ground, certainly not parade ground.
 
Contrary to what the painting shows, an all out full gallop, Hollywood style, most of the advance of heavy cavalry would be at less than a full gallop, more control, with the final perhaps 100 metres, basically extreme effective musket range, covered at speed, but the emphasis was a controlled approached arriving hopefully at the same time. Remember they were crossing in most cases unknown ground, certainly not parade ground.
Entirely so. It was the shock of everyone hitting at once, not being strung out all over the place.

Still a great painting.
 
Perhaps he is working up to being on the receiving end of a Heavy Brigade lance charge next.....:eyebrows:

The Heavy Brigade was issued long straight swords, not lances. Actually the Scots Greys were part of the Union Brigade at Waterloo in 1815. The Heavy Brigade was at Balaclava in 1854 where they put in a more effective effort than the more famous Light Brigade. IIRC, the Greys charged over a hill through heavy clouds of gunsmoke and smashed into a French infantry column at little more than a walk. The French were taken by surprise and the column disintegrated. Still, you have to love artistic licence.

The only crit I've read elsewhere of Warhorse made the point that the horse would have slashed itself to pieces on the barbed wire and would have been shot to put a quick end to things and then butchered for rations. Still, you have to love artistic licence.
 
Actually the Scots Greys were part of the Union Brigade at Waterloo in 1815.
Duh, of course you are correct, although I point out that the Union Brigade were Heavy Calvary.

The French Infantry were caught completely out of formation unable to form squares and within minutes the French had lost 5,000 men killed, wounded and captured. Further the Royal Scots Greys captured the Eagle of the French 45th Regiment

Unfortunately the Union Brigade were intoxicated with their success and charged on across the valley up to the French artillery, killing gunners and putting the guns out of action. However, by this time their horses were exhausted and they lost about half their number in a counter attack by fresh French cuirassiers (heavy cavalry) and Polish lancers (light cavalry) including Major General Ponsonby and his horse. The Union Brigade were out of action for the rest of the Battle.
 
The only crit I've read elsewhere of Warhorse made the point that the horse would have slashed itself to pieces on the barbed wire and would have been shot to put a quick end to things and then butchered for rations. Still, you have to love artistic licence.
Still the best line of the movie is the Hospital Orderly who when Albert asks what kind of horse? Replies "a Bloody miraculous kind of horse would be my guess."
 
Duh, of course you are correct, although I point out that the Union Brigade were Heavy Calvary.

The French Infantry were caught completely out of formation unable to form squares and within minutes the French had lost 5,000 men killed, wounded and captured. Further the Royal Scots Greys captured the Eagle of the French 45th Regiment

Unfortunately the Union Brigade were intoxicated with their success and charged on across the valley up to the French artillery, killing gunners and putting the guns out of action. However, by this time their horses were exhausted and they lost about half their number in a counter attack by fresh French cuirassiers (heavy cavalry) and Polish lancers (light cavalry) including Major General Ponsonby and his horse. The Union Brigade were out of action for the rest of the Battle.

British cavalry were notorious for lack of control and the inability to follow orders after the first charge, especially the heavy regiments. They were the weakest branch of the British armed forces. You let them loose and kept no expectations of getting them back. If you did, it was a bonus. Somewhere in my library is a costing of training and equipping various unit types in the Europe of the time for various armies. Heavy cavalry was off the charts for everyone. Lancers had the speed of light cavalry and the punch of heavy on the charge, but their effectiveness went down in melee. For that reason not all the mounts in many regiments were armed with lances, often only half or a quarter and they were in the front on the charge. cavalry is very good at taking ground, but very poor at holding it.