Natalie Wood

If I had to guess based on the few facts that are known, I think it likely that Wagner is a lying bastard. I also think it won't matter. If he did it, he'll most probably get away with it. What's most damning is that he waited so long before alerting authorities, knowing full well her extreme phobia of water.
Quite what evidence they think they will uncover thirty years after ruling it an accidental death*, which will convince the D.A.'s Office to even bring charges, let alone a jury to convict is a puzzlement to me.


* presumably Coroner, Police, and District Attorney were all involved at the time.
 
Here is one possible scenario. JR in a rage beat the crap out of Natalie (explains all the bruises on her body) and then tossed her into the water. Tells the Captain not to turn on the searchlight.
 
It could be that Walken saw Natalie getting the shit beat out of her but he's protecting Wagner who was his lover at the time.
Walken will tell all when he's ready.
 
Show us the evidence, Aardvark.

They *supposedly* had an affair. No need for the sort of evidence demanded in court.
I remember reading somewhere that at one point Robert Wagner yelled at Walken 'you
want to fuck my wife?'.
 
Wagner felt he was more attractive and skilled than Natalie, the captain overheard him crying out "I'm better with your cock, dammit!"
 
Show us the evidence, Aardvark.
One could say the same thing Brill, I've never read a single article saying that Wagner was having gay affairs, but there certainly are articles which allege that Walken and Wood were having an affair.

Whether these rumors had even the slightest scintilla of truth to them, I do not know - hence the term "supposedly."
 
Wagner felt he was more attractive and skilled than Natalie, the captain overheard him crying out "I'm better with your cock, dammit!"
From what little any of us know, my initial impression is that the boat captain's credibility is to put it mildly less than sterling.
 
Hence I said "It could be".
The art of writing Brill:
It could be that Walken saw Natalie getting the shit beat out of her but he's protecting Wagner who was his lover at the time.
It could be refers to "Walken saw Natalie getting the shit beat[en] out of her" not to the following clause "but[,] he's protecting Wagerner who was his lover at the time." You would need to put another modifier into that clause, such as "who may have been".
 
From what little any of us know, my initial impression is that the boat captain's credibility is to put it mildly less than sterling.

Actors have zero credibility with me, they hide their true nature and are often performing a role offstage to look good to the general public. They have handlers to protect them and to filter the truth from the real world.

I haven't experienced too much of that with boat captains, the worst they do is smile at people who hire them and that's to be expected.