Osteopathy and Naturopathy

The Fruity Hare

Well-known member
Dec 4, 2002
5,110
33
48
I have a couple of health issues that haven't responded well to regular medical attention, and was wondering if anyone has had any experience or can offer any thoughts on Osteopathy and Naturopathy?

Thanks.
 
I have a couple of health issues that haven't responded well to regular medical attention, and was wondering if anyone has had any experience or can offer any thoughts on Osteopathy and Naturopathy?

Thanks.
Two great alternatives to conventional medicine. Unless you are covered by some health insurance, cost can add up. I have confidence in both. But of course it depends on what your health issues are. Let me know if you want a referral.
 
I swear by my osteopath. You get massage therapy and chiropractic care all in one!
 
I tried osteopathy for tennis elbow. Did absolutely nothing for me 3 sessions and close to $300 later I left thinking the whole thing was a ruse.
 
I tried osteopathy for tennis elbow. Did absolutely nothing for me 3 sessions and close to $300 later I left thinking the whole thing was a ruse.

I did 3 months of physio for tennis elbow. Then my insurer cut off my long term disability (which I was not claiming against) until I could prove that tennis elbow was fixed. What tennis elbow had to do with my office desk job I have no idea but it was an example of USA style insurance company operating in Canada. Anyhow my gf at that time suggested I try her chiro. I said Chiros are quacks but she insisted.

3 visits a week for 2 weeks and my elbow was fixed.
 
Naturopathy is a broad term. Most people don't realize it simply refers to a doctor who's completed a naturopathic college degree. What they actually practice once they've graduated varies tremendously.

Some mix herbs, diet, nutritional supplements with quasi-scientific treatments for allergies, massage, etc., while others mix in rather bonkers things like pendulum swinging and vibrational medicine, Rudolph Steiner stuff and blood type stuff.

Naturopathy is not to be confused with homeopathy. They have nothing to do with each other. Some naturopaths use homeopathic treatments, but they're totally different approaches to health. The only thing they share, really, is a belief in the body as a unified, whole system, rather than Western medicine which sees the body as interchangeable parts. Personally, I think homeopathy is junk, but it's harmless junk (assuming you don't ditch emergency treatment for it).

Osteopathy is expensive, but very subtle. I've had incredible results with it, but then I have a lot of athletic injuries from childhood that respond very well to it.

Try Chinese medicine.
 
I tried osteopathy for tennis elbow. Did absolutely nothing for me 3 sessions and close to $300 later I left thinking the whole thing was a ruse.

Perhaps the therapy was misdiagnosed. I have used a whole variety of natural methods for health and sports for over 35 years. Not everything works each time. Usually if I don't respond within the first couple of visits of treatment or first week on natural med's I look for an alternative method.
I'm a strong believer in your body doing its own repairs. Sometimes it needs a little push start.
 
Lots of herbs have science behind them, lots don't.
Like the science of diluting the active ingredient over and over and over again to the point that it's probably more pure than drinking water and expect it to have amazing results.

They ought to do sales pitches from covered wagons in the town squares. W. S. Walcott's medicine show.
 
Actually the principle of it is the same as immunization. And it's homeopathy, not herbs.
It is very different than immunization. There has to be at least a certain amount of the attenuated non-infective organism to trigger a response from the host.

As I said, the homeopathy uses a supposed curing element and dilutes that to the point where it is barely detectable. It's like watering down a shot of booze to 1/1,000,000 and expect it to have an enhanced effect.
 
it's all quackery. there's no "alternative medicine". that's just a trick phrase like calling themselves "doctors". there is proven and unproven. if proven using double blind etc testing, the product becomes part of "western" medicine. if unproven, it gets called "alternative". Do it if you like, just realize the reason your doctor doesn't prescribe it is because it either hasn't been shown to work or has been shown NOT to work. Neither of these conclusions bother the naturopath.

incidently, Dr. Oz has his feet in both camps. difficult to understand. (his wife is a reiki master tho).
 
It is very different than immunization. There has to be at least a certain amount of the attenuated non-infective organism to trigger a response from the host.

As I said, the homeopathy uses a supposed curing element and dilutes that to the point where it is barely detectable. It's like watering down a shot of booze to 1/1,000,000 and expect it to have an enhanced effect.

You're preaching to the choir. I was merely pointing out that homeopathy's basic premise of small amounts of a problematic substance being introduced to the immune system is similar in concept to immunization.

I agree that the watering down endlessly makes it junk. A drop of a substance in a body of water the size of Lake Ontario.
 
Actually the principle of it is the same as immunization. And it's homeopathy, not herbs.

LOL...that's the problem...comparing something like homeopathy with immunization. They are in no way alike...in any real way. Homeopathic dilutions guarantee there is nothing of the original substance in the medication.

It is the ultimate 20th century fraud...amazing when you think about it. People worldwide are spending billions of dollars on pure water. What a racket.
 
I have a couple of health issues that haven't responded well to regular medical attention, and was wondering if anyone has had any experience or can offer any thoughts on Osteopathy and Naturopathy?

Thanks.

I think both are a total and absolute waste of time and money...and should be prosecuted for misleading people. Many people have died unecessarily by putting their hope and faith in fraudulent medicine.
 
I think both are a total and absolute waste of time and money...and should be prosecuted for misleading people. Many people have died unecessarily by putting their hope and faith in fraudulent medicine.

Considering that western "evidence" based medicine is totally biased toward profit for drug companies and protecting the turf of MD's, I would tend to respect a good RMT, Osteopath or Acupuncturist more so than some schmuck who just got his degree in order to drive a Lexus on Yorkville Ave. It's funny but those of you who hate on the alternative meds so angrily are the ones with all the pent up venom which could probably be released by a good RMT therapist. Perhaps Cranial Sacral could help, but of course this advice will just further enrage you and your angry mind will remain closed.
 
Considering that western "evidence" based medicine is totally biased toward profit for drug companies
Exactly. Why in the world would for-profit drug companies want to patent these wonder drugs instead of trying to suppress? It would only make billions and billions for them. That is, if they actually worked. Which they don't.

Pretty dumb theory.