Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

Should the engagement ring be returned after divorce?

  • Yes

    Votes: 47 50.5%
  • No

    Votes: 46 49.5%

  • Total voters
    93
Under Roman Law, the ring is the man's and it is his way of showing that the woman is his wife. If the marriage ended, the ring was to be returned to its rightful owner, the husband.

Hmm, any idea what the divorce rate was back then? I think 'til death do us part was probably more than just wishful thinking.
 
Poor guy goes from being whipped by his wife to being whipped by all his female relatives.

Maybe he just needs a healthy dose of 'Who gives a fuck".
 
Are you suggesting that it is merely impolite to take the ring, say no, and then keep it?
I wouldn't say merely. Polite behaviour is more important that the law to people of good character.

However, if you give a gift without being forced to do so, you have no moral claim to ask for it back. While the courts may not always agree, the courts are not always right. To suggest a woman must return the ring after a periof of marriage suggests that she was somehow purchased with that ring; I find that idea offensive.
 
To suggest a woman must return the ring after a periof of marriage suggests that she was somehow purchased with that ring; I find that idea offensive.
I agree but you said keep the ring after turning down the marriage proposal, not keep the ring after some period of being married.

"While it is considered impolite for the lady to keep the ring if she does not accept the marriage proposal"

So the guy proposes while holding out the ring, the girl takes the ring and looks it over, thinks about it and says no, and then sticks the ring in her pocket? :Eek:
 
To suggest a woman must return the ring after a periof of marriage suggests that she was somehow purchased with that ring; I find that idea offensive.

You are almost correct but it is the woman who is placing a dollar value on the ring. The thing should represent a symbol of love and committment. Clearly those feelings are long gone. The only reason for her to hold on to it is the monetary value.

That said, you don't honestly believe that many marriages and/or relationships aren't influenced by money. There is a natural attraction to money because it implies the potential mate is a good "provider'. In a sense the union is being "purchased". Is it offensive, sort of. Does it happen, every day of the week.

BD
 
I agree but you said keep the ring after turning down the marriage proposal, not keep the ring after some period of being married.

"While it is considered impolite for the lady to keep the ring if she does not accept the marriage proposal"

So the guy proposes while holding out the ring, the girl takes the ring and looks it over, thinks about it and says no, and then sticks the ring in her pocket?
A woman who behaved in this way would be extremely rude.

Nevertheless, at the end of the day, people need to remember the difference between gifts and payments. A gift is freely given and has no strings attached; otherwise it would be a payment or a bribe. A Gentleman of good character would never be so rude as to ask that a gift be returned (nor would a lady). Men and women of good character would also never accept a gift if they felt it was not appropriate.
 
A woman who behaved in this way would be extremely rude.

Nevertheless, at the end of the day, people need to remember the difference between gifts and payments. A gift is freely given and has no strings attached; otherwise it would be a payment or a bribe. A Gentleman of good character would never be so rude as to ask that a gift be returned (nor would a lady). Men and women of good character would also never accept a gift if they felt it was not appropriate.
A woman who behaved like this would be a thief.
The engagement ring is being offered along with the proposal.
It is not handed over as a gift and then the proposal is made as a separate matter.
It is only given and accepted in contemplation of marriage.

Some people think that the ring should be returned even if the marriage falls apart years later.
More people think that the ring should be returned if the engagement falls apart.
The idea that the engagement ring is a gift and can be kept if the proposal is rejected and there isn`t even an engagement is absurd. :rolleyes:
 
Buy a cubic zirconia engagement ring.
(duplicate of the real thing)

She will never know
if she does figure it out - because she went for an appraisal
then she is not the right woman for you

swap the ring for the real thing after you are married

... alternatively buy a used diamond ring
diamonds are relatively cheap on the secondary market
https://www.torontoauctionhouse.com/catalog/1
 
Buy a cubic zirconia engagement ring.
(duplicate of the real thing)

She will never know
if she does figure it out - because she went for an appraisal
then she is not the right woman for you

swap the ring for the real thing after you are married

... alternatively buy a used diamond ring
diamonds are relatively cheap on the secondary market
https://www.torontoauctionhouse.com/catalog/1

I remember getting a ring made out of twisted grass....we were kids tho :-p
 
A woman who behaved in this way would be extremely rude.

Nevertheless, at the end of the day, people need to remember the difference between gifts and payments. A gift is freely given and has no strings attached; otherwise it would be a payment or a bribe. A Gentleman of good character would never be so rude as to ask that a gift be returned (nor would a lady). Men and women of good character would also never accept a gift if they felt it was not appropriate.

I agree with your definition of what a gift is. The question I have: is an engagement ring a gift? Or something else entirely. An engagement ring inherently comes with strings attached! The engagement ring comes with the expectation that the receiver will marry the giver; like a deposit on work still to be completed. Seems to me like the ring is a hybrid between a gift and a deposit. The fact that the courts see it as a gift, doesn't make that opinion the be-all.
 
I think this poll is not an accurate reflection on the reality one would see in the general population.
The vast majority of those voting here are likely guys, many jaded whoremongering guys. :wink:

Agreed there. If TERB is 50/50 on this issue, the general public could be around 75 No, 25 Yes or less.
 
I agree with your definition of what a gift is. The question I have: is an engagement ring a gift? Or something else entirely. An engagement ring inherently comes with strings attached! The engagement ring comes with the expectation that the receiver will marry the giver; like a deposit on work still to be completed. Seems to me like the ring is a hybrid between a gift and a deposit. The fact that the courts see it as a gift, doesn't make that opinion the be-all.

I don't understand why this is still being debated. It is an engagement ring. The strings attached are marriage. She married him. She meant her end of the deal. Gift/deposit doesn't matter anymore. They got married.
 
I wonder how many would still vote yes if we were talking about a typical engagement ring and not a precious family heirloom.

I think that's the real focus here. If the guy went out and spent money on an engagement ring and the marriage ends then too bad for the guy..

But in this case the ring wasn't really given to the girl by the guy.. In this case the ring was really given to the couple by the guy's mother. The ring is an heirloom and there's no two ways about it. I don't think this would be an open and shut case if it went to court. I think it could be easily argued that there was a verbal understanding between the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law that the ring was understandably the property of the family and that if she seized to be a member of that family, she would be forced to return the ring.

I'm sure this conversation didn't take place.. But it's reasonable to assume that the conversation COULD have taken place. The mother-in-law could simply make this claim and if the ex daughter-in-law can't prove otherwise, a judge might just side with the mother-in-law.
 
I don't understand why this is still being debated. It is an engagement ring. The strings attached are marriage. She married him. She meant her end of the deal. Gift/deposit doesn't matter anymore. They got married.
I agree but half the people in the poll think the ring should be returned even after years of marriage.
There are people, including 2 lawyers, who claimed that the ring is a gift and can be kept even if there is no wedding.
And now we have a person who claims that it is a gift that is given with no strings attached even if there is no engagement.
 
I think that's the real focus here. If the guy went out and spent money on an engagement ring and the marriage ends then too bad for the guy..

But in this case the ring wasn't really given to the girl by the guy.. In this case the ring was really given to the couple by the guy's mother. The ring is an heirloom and there's no two ways about it. I don't think this would be an open and shut case if it went to court. I think it could be easily argued that there was a verbal understanding between the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law that the ring was understandably the property of the family and that if she seized to be a member of that family, she would be forced to return the ring.

I'm sure this conversation didn't take place.. But it's reasonable to assume that the conversation COULD have taken place. The mother-in-law could simply make this claim and if the ex daughter-in-law can't prove otherwise, a judge might just side with the mother-in-law.
That is a reasonable argument but the default is that engagement rings are not returned after years of marriage so the onus would be on the family to prove otherwise.
The default is not that the woman should have something in writing stating that the ring is hers.

The ring is hers and she deserves to be compensated for giving it up.
Perhaps she wants what she could sell the ring for.
At the very least, she should be offered what the guy would have reasonably had to spend on an engagement ring had he not used this family ring.
 
I don't understand why this is still being debated. It is an engagement ring. The strings attached are marriage. She married him. She meant her end of the deal. Gift/deposit doesn't matter anymore. They got married.

I can understand that that's one way to look at it. But you do see the flip side, don't you? If the "strings attached" was being married, not just getting married, how is the wedding the "end of the deal". I'm not saying you're wrong. But it is cause for debate.
 
That is a reasonable argument but the default is that engagement rings are not returned after years of marriage so the onus would be on the family to prove otherwise.
The default is not that the woman should have something in writing stating that the ring is hers.

The ring is hers and she deserves to be compensated for giving it up.
Perhaps she wants what she could sell the ring for.
At the very least, she should be offered what the guy would have reasonably had to spend on an engagement ring had he not used this family ring.

I disagree.. The default might be that she gets to keep the ring if the ring was purchased. But in the case of family heirlooms being passed on, I would imagine there is another "default" and that would be that the ring would be returned to the family...

The ring wasn't purchased so asking for money for it's return seems more like a ransom to me.

In my opinion the ring wasn't just a gift to the girl. If the girl wasn't joining their family, it's clear that she would not have been given this ring as a gift. To me this ring came with an "implied contract"...
 
I think he sholud take her on one last fishing trip with a pair of custom made cement block shoes....if you catch my drift!