Which is better for a person's career

havingfun

Active member
Jun 7, 2003
1,248
1
38
Is it better for a person's career to be well-liked or is it better to be considered several cuts above average in ability?
 
They are both excellent traits, and either one multiplies the value of the other. It also depends somewhat on your industry which one matters more.
 
Every work place has its "cliques" of employees. If its important to you to be "one of the in crowd" then being liked is your aim. Just remember your fellow workers and your bosses are concerned about their own jobs too and being a high caliber employee with skill and something to offer to your employer will always trump in my view being the "liked" guy. At some point in time someone will always ask why you still have your job.
 
Brocko, I agree with you that being a high skilled guy is a great thing for job security. Being a high skilled guy that is well liked is even better--that's how you get into management.

Certainly someone who is well liked but BAD at their job will (in a good company) eventually be outed. But a well liked guy who is just OK at his job (but not bad) can go pretty far too.
 
Be well liked but not to be messed with. Often times if you're too well-liked, people take advantage of you, use you for their gain. You have to be well liked but must make it know that you won't tolerate it if people try to take advantage of you. During my early years of employment out of highschool, I used to always have or be better skilled than most of my co-workers. I was a very friendly and quite guy too. But I realized people use you for their advantage and act like its no big deal. Lessons I learnt from reading the book "The Prince - Niccolo Machiavelli" is you have to be very nice and also feared to lead or get ahead in life. And by being nice, it usually means you don't try to take away the other person's property, belongings, wife, or in this case their job.
 
Is it better for a person's career to be well-liked or is it better to be considered several cuts above average in ability?

It depends. As was said, a balance is best, but it really depends if the person is in a job where they have to play well with others. If you have somebody who's above average in ability but a royal arse, and stick them into a close knit team, you have to ask if the gains from 'above average' outweigh the potential for disruption and turnover on a team or in a group. A demotivated and demoralized group, bitching to management, where a couple of people leave is a huge cost. If you can stick the above average arse on some relatively self contained task, then that's where you want them.
 
I think it depends on the career and the job environment. Starting at the "worker bee" level in a white collar environment can be treacherous.
All the talent in the world won't help you dodge backstabbers whose biggest talent is pointing the finger while covering their ass at the same time.
 
I'd say the equation is 60% talent 40% likability, unless you're an SP in which case it is 100%lickability.
 
I would say if you work with people, well liked.If you have a tech job where a mistake can ruin everyones work, talent wins out.
 
I would say if you work with people, well liked.If you have a tech job where a mistake can ruin everyones work, talent wins out.

Err, if 'the wizard' fucks up a working and productive team that's the exact sort that should be farmed out to a self contained task. "Arsehole Wizards" are the bane of IT and the first thing you should do is put them into a fucking bubble. It doesn't matter if he's as productive as two other people and has high level insight into a given problem area, if he blows up and established team of 6 he just cost you a fortune.
 
Is it better for a person's career to be well-liked or is it better to be considered several cuts above average in ability?

Both "hard" and "soft" skills are valuable. However, be very careful of this career ender or limiter. Be very careful what you do or say when with women or minority groups (like White people, hee, hee, hee). For example, saying the "wrong" thing can get you charged with sexual harassment. Also, in our company we have a "no hugging" policy, something you wish want to consider.
 
I think it depends on what you mean by likeability. If you mean "gets along well with others" then I think ability trumps that (there's always exceptions but ability usually wins out). But if you mean "schmoozability" or personal magnetism (i.e., a "natural leader") then I know of countless examples where a person's charisma (i.e., personal magnetism) has enabled them to punch well above their weight and thereby outperform others with better ability.

But the original question is the type of question asked by someone who believes they are a cut above others in terms of ability (whether that's true or not is debatable since most people think they're better than they really are) but are being surpassed by people they deem to be "inferior" but are nevertheless well liked.

My experience has been that the people who are "well liked" usually aren't trying to be well liked but it's just a natural gift they have. In other words, they aren't spending their time worried about what others think of them; they're just natural leaders. And that drives people with ability but without charisma absolutely fucking crazy.
 
Nepotism trumps both of those. I have seen shit stains that shouldn't even be allowed on a jobsite, get away with what ever they want, just because they are friends with or related to someone high up in a corporation. So if you really want to get ahead, marry someone who is related to a CEO.