Chlorine filters

dsc

Active member
Oct 8, 2003
422
50
28
Had a continuing string of bad luck with residential plumbing this year. Just had a copper pipe coming into the house start to leak. It was minor but now I am thinking about the rest of the 25 year old lines. When talking with the plumber, he attributes the problam to excessive chlorine in the city water. The closer to the treatment plant, the worse the problem. Recommends adding a filter before the water softener to help the problem. He is honest that it will not stop and damage already done but slow down future erosion. Has anybody run into this? Plumbers says he fixes about 15 cases a month.
 
Last edited:
When talking with the plumber, he attributes the problam to excessive cholrine in the city water.

Doubt that's the cause.
My house is ~ twice as old as yours, all copper pipes and not one has leaked as yet with chlorinated water...:wink:
 
Recommends adding a filter before the water softener to help the problem. He is honest that it will not stop and damage already done but slow down future erosion.
I think you mean corrosion.
Not sure what the "filter" is going to do - your plumber might be referring to the plastic connector mentioned below.
http://www.aplumbers.com/pipe-fitting/corrosion
Water Pipe Corrosion
Under certain conditions, copper, steel and iron pipes and fittings are vulnerable to corrosion attacks. The joining of different metals like copper and aluminum or copper and steel causes corrosion in piping. Metal pipe corrosion is also called galvanic corrosion and is a result of electrochemical electron exchange from the differential galvanic properties between dissimilar metals. Plumbers control or prevent corrosion in pipes by using anti corrosion pipes or at least the same types of metals for plumbing connections. When corrosion resistant pipes are unavailable and plumbers cannot use the same metal - they will install pipe corrosion protection in the form of a fiber or plastic connector between the joints to prevent different metals from touching. The following variables influence the rate of corrosion in metal piping:
  • Chemical composition of water
  • Low pH values of water
  • Amount of oxygen in water
  • Water pressure in pipe
  • Galvanic corrosion
  • Water temperature

Copper Pipe Corrosion
Pitting corrosion causes pinhole leaks in copper water pipes. Copper pipe corrosion leads to the formation of small pits on restricted areas of the metal surface – resulting in leaky pipes that can waste as much as 70 gallons of water per day. Copper pipe corrosion forms for unknown reasons, but many plumbers attribute the chemistry of water passing through copper pipes to the development of pits.
 
Doubt that's the cause.
My house is ~ twice as old as yours, all copper pipes and not one has leaked as yet with chlorinated water...:wink:

Because you have the old style "Copper L grade" as opposed to the thinner walled "Copper M"

As far as I am aware, there are 3 grades of residential pipes - Copper K (used for underground water services and has a very heavy wall section and is commonly called "Copper K flex" as it comes in a big roll), Copper L (which is the best copper pipe as it has a good wall thickness and you can buy at home depot and the like, but it costs a lot more) or Copper M (which is bare code and virtually 100% of new homes use it. It's code, but it will develope pin holing in 25 years yes.)


To the OP, Chlorine is disolved in solution in the water. Therefore, it is IMPOSSIBLE to filter it out, regardless of what anyone tells you. The only way you can get it out of the water is to react the water with another chemical and precipitate out the chlorine. (I have no idea of what that would be.)

It's like once you disolve sugar in water, you cannot pass it through any filter and remove the sugar, you have to distill it out.

I would think your best solution is to replumb your house with Copper L pipes and it will outlive you.
 
Interesting. I had not heard of this before but after doing some research it appears that - if the water composition falls in certain ranges - chlorine can cause pitting in copper pipes. There are a lot of factors involved - the pH of the water, what types and concentrations of NOMs (normal organic material), water flow.... - that all contribute to the problem. Perhaps that's why the OP is having problems and WoodPeckr is not.

Water filtration system is nice as it takes the chlorine taste out of your drinking water as well as a host of other impurities.

Other option - depending on accessibility - is to replace the copper lines with plastic. Benefits include - better water flow because there are less elbows and less heat loss on hot water lines as plastic doesn't conduct heat as readily. Plus you can sell the copper to a scrapper and recoup some of your cost outlay. (If you go that route I recommend cutting off all the connecting bits from the copper pipes as you get a whack more money for "clean copper" than you do stuff that has solder on it)
 
Other option - depending on accessibility - is to replace the copper lines with plastic. Benefits include - better water flow because there are less elbows and less heat loss on hot water lines as plastic doesn't conduct heat as readily. Plus you can sell the copper to a scrapper and recoup some of your cost outlay. (If you go that route I recommend cutting off all the connecting bits from the copper pipes as you get a whack more money for "clean copper" than you do stuff that has solder on it)
As with all other things, there are disadvantages to plastic (Pex) piping.

Depending on who you listen to, the plastic pipes contaminate the water with quite the chemical cocktail that is hugely bad for your health.

There is also the issue that it is not proven long term, it employs compression fittings which are more prone to failure than a soldered connection, and plastic pipes are also prone to splitting failures.

Coppper has none of thoes issues.
 
As with all other things, there are disadvantages to plastic (Pex) piping.

Depending on who you listen to, the plastic pipes contaminate the water with quite the chemical cocktail that is hugely bad for your health.

There is also the issue that it is not proven long term, it employs compression fittings which are more prone to failure than a soldered connection, and plastic pipes are also prone to splitting failures.

Coppper has none of thoes issues.

Well if the chlorine is pitting the copper, that copper is going somewhere and I doubt it's all that good to be drinking it either. I haven't seen any reputable source on contamination problems from the PEX pipe. Now if you have the water turned off for a long while then I would agree that immediately drinking the water coming out after you turn it back on would not be a wise idea.

You may be right on the connection issue, I wasn't talking about the push-in fittings that you can get at Home Depot/Lowe's. I used the ones where you crimp on the ring to lock the connection piece in place.

As it sounds like the OP may be in a situation of having to redo his plumbing from source to end-point I merely wished to throw up a different option.
 
Because you have the old style "Copper L grade" as opposed to the thinner walled "Copper M"

As far as I am aware, there are 3 grades of residential pipes - Copper K (used for underground water services and has a very heavy wall section and is commonly called "Copper K flex" as it comes in a big roll), Copper L (which is the best copper pipe as it has a good wall thickness and you can buy at home depot and the like, but it costs a lot more) or Copper M (which is bare code and virtually 100% of new homes use it. It's code, but it will develope pin holing in 25 years yes.)

This would make a lot of sense. I have never seen copper pipe having pin hole leaks before.
I looked online at chlorine filters for residential plumbing and most are carbon filters. Didn't see any studies of the PPM before and after filter to know it works.
 
From a human health point of view, the best pipes were the old rigid iron pipes that they used in houses up to the 40 or 50's. The iron in the pipes is not toxic to humans.

HOWEVER, the problem was that the pipes would corrode and suffer a hardening of the arteries so to speak where the inside diameter would be reduced sometimes to almost nothing which wreaked havoc on water flow. ("Pressure" as most people incorrectly say.)

It's the same as watermains in the streets.

There used to be Cast Iron (which lasted a good long time).

Then Ductile Iron - which is less prone to cracking, but they coat it with concrete to reduce corrosion.

Steel - Usually used for the big stuff.

And now they use PVC - the blue stuff - which though it doesn't corrode like the iron stuff - does split.

They all have their advantages and disadvantages - with none being perfect.
 
Well if the chlorine is pitting the copper, that copper is going somewhere and I doubt it's all that good to be drinking it either. I haven't seen any reputable source on contamination problems from the PEX pipe. Now if you have the water turned off for a long while then I would agree that immediately drinking the water coming out after you turn it back on would not be a wise idea.

You may be right on the connection issue, I wasn't talking about the push-in fittings that you can get at Home Depot/Lowe's. I used the ones where you crimp on the ring to lock the connection piece in place.

As it sounds like the OP may be in a situation of having to redo his plumbing from source to end-point I merely wished to throw up a different option.
And before the water entered the city's purification and distribution system it was pure? Fish fuck in it you know.
 
And we used to belive all those plastic water bottles added nothing to the water.

Frankly, the more sensible position is to accept that water, the closest thing we have to a universal solvent, will; l;each or pick up something from everything it contacts. Including carbon particles from that filter. We just haven't thought to devote the time, energy and high-tech to know. And how do you 'replicate' a fifty-year install-life in a lab anyway?

Way smarter to go by the observed effects over real time, like what the galvanized pipes did to Gramps. Or what the lead pipes did for the Romans. How long have we been using PEX again?
 
Did you read the link?
Sorry, I hate smileys anyway, and didn't think there was one for rhetorical questions. Thanks for the link, and spelling it out. I note that we'd been using plastic water bottles and tubing for food processing somewhat longer before discovering there was stuff leaching that made us unhappy. To say nothing of asbestos, or even those lead pipes. Finally got the ones supplying my water changed last year.

There's a lot to be said for changing such stuff cautiously and slowly. Whatever lab tests they do that pretend to equal the passing of time, they are only simulations. And the way we actually use stuff is a lot different always from the way tests are designed and done. The devil you know and all that… remember UFFI?

All that said, the last two showers I installed were PEX-fed. But none of us drink shower water do we?