Dating someone with herpes

afx

Banned
Mar 29, 2002
607
2
0
...... and perhaps to get this to be an even more broader discussion, any longer term STD in general, but specifically herpes due to its prevalance and unique nature.

Quick summary: I have met a great girl who, while I am not sure I would marry - just met her, who knows, but she'd be a great girlfriend for sure and I"d like to get the chance to know her more through a relationship. We haven't done anything physical yet, but she has indicated to me that she has HSV-2 - whether she is being honest or not, says that she got it from her ex-bf of 1 year who cheated on her, with the guy admitting it. Regardless of how she got it, she got it and was honest with me.

I know I have been tested for Herpes in the past, but do remember about 2 years ago going for a full check up with my doctor who told me that he does NOT test for Herpes unless he sees visible symptoms. I went to a walk in clinic last week here in Toronto, the doctor there also told me that she will not test for Herpes if no signs are there - she says that many people have HSV (I think she is just referring to type 1) and said "why bother getting tested if you have no symptoms or outbreaks? it will just stress you out". Countess google searches reveal this case to be, well, the dominant case. Many doctors claim that they just don't test for herpes unless you specifically ask.

On to my question - if you knew that someone had herpes - would you bother sleeping with them at all? She only had one outbreak, a year ago, and is on medication to supress. I realize that "shedding" is impossible to detect, so I could contract it even if she does not have signs visible.

It's making me question everything in general - 1 out of 4 women and 1 out of 5 guys apparantly have type 2. No doubt, at least one if not a handful of SP's I have seen MUST have this disease, though may have never had an outbreak at all in their life. Or, they could have had it and just weren't in the middle of an outbreak.

It seems that I have put myself at much greater risks just through this hobby alone in contracting the disease, but somehow 'knowing' that a girl actually has it, gets me scared.

Finally - is it possible I actually have it and so already have developed antibodies? I definitely will get tested, but it seems like Herpes testing is NOT a very common thing to do as part of a routine STD check - google this for yourself and see, it appears that you actually have to request a test. And even then, it seems like blood tests are not as accurate as an actual visual inspection and culture analysis of an actual blister.

Comments appreciated by anyone who has faced this dilema, or to anyone who does have herpes and has stories to share with dating experiences. It seems that while yes, Herpes is PAINFUL and can cause some issues, it boils down to a skin based STD that is more or less cosmetic longer term (unless you are a woman giving birth, that has its own issues I realize). But if 1 in 4 people have this, is it really that big a deal or is it just a social stigma to you terbies out there? I am still scared as hell about herpes more than anything else, but after researching and reading, it seems like I have already taken countless risks over the years of hobbying anyways - why does this one girl feel so much different in terms of going ahead and having sex with her?

final note - if i KNEW I was going to marry this girl, or, for example, if I was with a girl/wife who never knew she had herpes and then had an outbreak due to stress or something like that - i would 100% continue to date or be married to her - non issue on my part. At this point, after being with the girl or married, I would take the hit/risk to get the virus because, well, I would be with the girl I seemingly love. It's when it comes down to "dating" that it seems like an issue, due to having to explain your disease with a future potential mate.
 
The Reason they don't Test for it, is because the test does not distinguish between type 1 and type 2. So they figure there is no point, as many people have type 1.
 
Finally - is it possible I actually have it and so already have developed antibodies?

It's absolutely possible. Your doctor's reasoning for not testing you in the past is that that unless you're active it would simply stress you out. That was BEFORE you were dating a woman who has it. At this point I think NOT being tested is going to stress you out more. Go and tell your doc your feelings on this matter, that you are dating a woman with herpes, and you want to know whether you already have it. Tell him you suspect you do. Tell him it's murder on your relationship.

I can't fathom that given that information the doctor would not test you. If your doc still won't test you, see another who will.

It is absolutely worth avoiding herpes. Again, the best thing you can do here is go and have a very frank conversation with your doctor. Tell him that you are seeing a woman who has it, and ask what you can do, as a couple, to avoid you getting it. Don't get your medical advice on terb.
 
The Reason they don't Test for it, is because the test does not distinguish between type 1 and type 2. So they figure there is no point, as many people have type 1.

hmm. is this really the case? I have found through research that you can tell the difference - that said, the doctor at the walk in clinic seemed to suggest through her outlining of the test that they would not be able to tell the difference.

in which case, her reasoning to not test for it kind of makes sense
 
They can tell only with a PCR which often costs a few bucks out of pocket.
 
if you were considering her as a lifetime mate then it might be worth the risk. But if you already are not going in that direction, then I'd say that it is likely not worth the risk of the lifetime of consequences.
This is the best advice you can get without seeing a doctor.

Whatever steps you can take to protect yourself, you will always be at some risk of contracting Herpes from her if you form an intimate relationship. That said, Herpes can be lived with despite some periodic discomfort and hassle. However, you need to decide if the lady in question is worth the potential sacrifice.

If you stay with her, you'll probably not mind even if you do catch it. However, if you get infected and move on, it could significantly impair your options for future relationships.

Back to the first point tough, see a doctor, ask him/her the same questions you asked the "experts" on TERB, and get the best medical advice you can to compliment the ethical and emotional advice you get here. Better yet, go to the hassle-free or some other clinic specializing in STDs so you can get better advice than the average GP that does not see it so often can give.

Edit: Seriously, when it comes to medical questions, go to an expert, don't look for answers here. The membership here is (for the most part) very well meaning but you get some very misinformed opinions at times and you need to ask yourself if you want to take chances with your health based on the advice of an anonymous poster on a review board who might be very knowledgeable but could, conversely, be could be a sixteen year old boy, a bitter recluse, or someone who gets off on misdirecting people into dangerous circumstances.
 
Last edited:
thanks so much for the advice guys. my initial instinct seems to be confirmed by some of you - not worth the risk if I do not know if she will be more of a lifelong partner or someone with whom i may have a meaningful relationship with. i can't know that though until at least dating her and forming some sort of relationship with her, but perhaps more at the emotional level and seeing if the chemistry is there. which is what i will do. i think i will take the risk of making out with her (she has hsv2 of the genitals, so am assuming kissing her on the mouth is ok, or am i wrong in this assumption?).

also may resort to some mutual masturbation - look for getting HJ's from her, and perhaps i will finger and play with her - though I know that this can expose any cuts or broken skin on my fingers to being infected too. these both would be done though only if i feel like we are moving to something meaningful, and also as a stepping stone to the eventual intamacy if a long term relationship is what happens

i realize that many couples with one person with herpes can go for years without the other catching it through condom usage, no sex during outbreaks and the one with herpes being very, very aware of their body and the onset of any symptoms (while continuing to use protection at all times)
 
I thought herpes goes between being active and dormant? When its the latter, it cannot be spread.
 
I thought herpes goes between being active and dormant? When its the latter, it cannot be spread.

That's right, but the problem is that there is not always a visible symptom that it is active. Sometimes there is a rash when it's active, sometimes there is not.
 
The Reason they don't Test for it, is because the test does not distinguish between type 1 and type 2. So they figure there is no point, as many people have type 1.
yeah, if anyone has ever has a cold sore before, they have hsv1.
 
Had a girlfriend for 5 years who had it. She was gorgeous and very careful. I never had a problem but that doesn't mean you won't. If you really like her, goferit.
 
While I think you are well intentioned and do appreciate or advice, I suspect your mind is already made up and you WILL have sex with her.

I've learned in life that it is better to walk from risks of such serious lifelong consequences unless there is an overwhelmingly compelling reason to do so.

Seeing if there is something does not fall into that category.

So many guys would be so much happier if they really had the cojones to walk away from such situations. How many guys have had unprotected sex with a woman they were only marginally into and then ended up with a lifetime of child support. Or married a "good enough" woman to alleviate loneliness and then ended up with a fucking miserable life, expensive and acrimonious divorce.

If you DO get a handjob from her, finger her and then touch your lips or dick etc while she is asymptomatically shedding virus' and you DO get herpes... then what?

If things don't work out with her, I GUARANTEE you that ANY non-Herpes infected woman will NOT even ever consider sex or a realtionship with you if you disclose your Herpes status.

Fuck, 50% of marriages end in divorce. How many dating relationships end? More?

Then what?

You only have to learn from HER experience how her own failed relationship's herpes results profoundly affects a person's mate/relationship potential.

And SHE has a pussy. And guys (like you) will at least consider a diseased pussy. NO WAY A WOMAN CONSIDERS A DISEASED DICK when there are so many healthy ones begging for her attention.

Having said all that... enjoy the sex!

Why is Herbie so disliked?
 
I've heard that statistic Herpes sufferers use to make themselves (and potential mates) feel better. 1 in 4. Given all the vagueries of how they test for it, I think they are playing with stats and grouping the less serious and more serious infection together, but to her credit she is telling you about it.
 
While I think you are well intentioned and do appreciate or advice, I suspect your mind is already made up and you WILL have sex with her.

I've learned in life that it is better to walk from risks of such serious lifelong consequences unless there is an overwhelmingly compelling reason to do so.

Seeing if there is something does not fall into that category.

So many guys would be so much happier if they really had the cojones to walk away from such situations. How many guys have had unprotected sex with a woman they were only marginally into and then ended up with a lifetime of child support. Or married a "good enough" woman to alleviate loneliness and then ended up with a fucking miserable life, expensive and acrimonious divorce.

If you DO get a handjob from her, finger her and then touch your lips or dick etc while she is asymptomatically shedding virus' and you DO get herpes... then what?

If things don't work out with her, I GUARANTEE you that ANY non-Herpes infected woman will NOT even ever consider sex or a realtionship with you if you disclose your Herpes status.

Fuck, 50% of marriages end in divorce. How many dating relationships end? More?

Then what?

You only have to learn from HER experience how her own failed relationship's herpes results profoundly affects a person's mate/relationship potential.

And SHE has a pussy. And guys (like you) will at least consider a diseased pussy. NO WAY A WOMAN CONSIDERS A DISEASED DICK when there are so many healthy ones begging for her attention.

Having said all that... enjoy the sex!

thanks for the very honest and strong response - it has made me think. and for the record, no, i do not plan to have sex with her unless I actually do think this relationship will become something longer term. i have only known her a couple of months, and am not really even officially her boyfriend. it would take this relationship to move to the next level (i.e. i would be meeting her family, she would be meeting mine) for me to have sex with her. i have had previous long term relationships with women who i have held off sex for upwards of 6 months, with my first serious relationship being able to hold off for a year.

that said, temptation would be there for sure, especially given the fact that i have had a life of hobbying and experience with many sexual relationships since that initial time. that is why i was asking the questions on mutual masturbation, kissing, etc. - BUT your response has got me thinking about the consequences of those too. you are right on all accounts. i have some other non std related issues with my body already, so i am already a health conscious type person to begin with. i get worried easily. thinking about all of this now has my mind imagining symptoms now already - muscle aches, pains, fingers tingling, body scratching, feeling nauseous (but i have no temperature/fever) - so i can only imagine how much worse off i'd be if i had sex with her and then regretted later. so again, no sex at all. not worth the risk. i have already hinted these thoughts to her already, and she is understanding.

my question now is on how long can i hold out, and can i use masturbation and kissing/hugging etc as the only affection for the next 6 months to a year if i do decide to be with this girl. guess that will be test - i dont want to have sex with her until i am a bit more certain that this is a girl i will be with for some time. you are so right on everything you say though - if it doesn't work out, and if i catch it - i have quite a story to tell. and in this age where it's hard enough to find the right girl - try finding the right girl who is willing to also accept the fact that you have herpes.
 
So based on the reported statistics, 1 in every 5 Terb members has herpes? And 1 in every 4 MPA/SP has herpes? Which means that if you saw 8 different MPA/SP, 2 of them have herpes. And if your favourite MPA saw 10 clients that day, 2 of them have herpes. I guess that if you choose to be a hobbyist, you have already been exposed to herpes. Your new girlfriend atleast had the guts to tell you.
 
So based on the reported statistics, 1 in every 5 Terb members has herpes? And 1 in every 4 MPA/SP has herpes? Which means that if you saw 8 different MPA/SP, 2 of them have herpes. And if your favourite MPA saw 10 clients that day, 2 of them have herpes. I guess that if you choose to be a hobbyist, you have already been exposed to herpes. Your new girlfriend atleast had the guts to tell you.

yup. and that's the issue. it seems stupid to turn her down, but for some reason, actually knowing that she has it makes me think twice. but put in perspective with all the hobbying i've done, it doesn't seem like such a big deal. but still, it just doesn't sit right. i'm not jumping up and down wanting to have sex with this girl anymore, i feel like being very cautious.
 
my question now is on how long can i hold out, and can i use masturbation and kissing/hugging etc as the only affection for the next 6 months to a year if i do decide to be with this girl. guess that will be test - i dont want to have sex with her until i am a bit more certain that this is a girl i will be with for some time.
A mature response. Give it a try. You've nothing to lose, and a lot to gain.

So based on the reported statistics, 1 in every 5 Terb members has herpes?
No, 1 in 5 within the general population, of which Terb members are only a small subset and not representative.
 
Don't forget if you have a cold sore and DATY you can infect your partner or if she has a cold sore and does BBBJ you can be infected according to the websites I have looked at.
 
No, 1 in 5 within the general population, of which Terb members are only a small subset and not representative.

terbites should have a hell of a lot higher rate due to a high number of unprotected kissing/DATY/BJs