The ten solitudes of Toronto dating

Your complete ignorance of basic reasoning does not make your reasoning right.

My reasoning is about a billion times better than yours. You keep repeating the same failed point over and over, without realizing your own errors. Arrogant, but stupid -- that's a bad combination you have there. You don't have the first least foggiest clue what you are talking about.

You can scream and yell "naturalistic fallacy" all you like but it's unclear you even understand it. First of all you confuse it with the "is ought" problem. Secondly you apply it in some pedantic way without understanding. When you're corrected, you pull the wool over your own eyes and repeat it again.

You can't apply those fallacies to assumptions. They apply only to connective statements. Yet you continue to try and use them to attack an assumption ,which is just fucking retarded.

Every moral code is sooner or later based on some set of assumptions. In my case, the assumption is that life should be affirmed. Others have different assumptions. I'm willing to defend my assumption, and explain why it is a better assumption than the alternatives, but it's an assumption--it's a statement that inherently cannot be proven, like "there is a God".
 
considering we have a written agreement calling for a 50-50 split
You keep dropping these little bread crumbs along the path. This is the first time you have mentioned that you have a prenuptial or antenuptial agreement. Although generally I am all in favour of them in this case your spouse was ill-advised to sign it.

It has nothing to do with the larger point - but case specifically indeed it does.

Perhaps you richly deserve each other, I have no way of knowing, but my first reaction is to feel sorry for your wife.

Further, to say that I'm damn glad that to the best of my knowledge (from the facts you've given us) that you aren't married to any relative of mine.
 
You keep dropping these little bread crumbs along the path.

More accurately you keep making ignorant and unwarranted assumptions about my life, which are then corrected by a dose of reality. Perhaps if you stopped assuming things about me it would be better for you.

At the time I met my wife I had considerably more assets than she did. I'm 10 years older than she is, and at that time she was quite young, with no income and little education, having just been discharged from her military service. She now pays for half our expenses, for example, she paid half the mortgage on our home, but it wasn't always so. In the early days I had income and assets while she had nothing and the agreement protected me for the first few years of our marriage, but contained various sunset clauses. We've been together enough years it now specifies a 50-50 split, which I consider to be eminently fair, and so would anybody else.

Moreover I paid for her education, and supported her through the development of her now somewhat lucrative career, none of which would be counted in the split. I have a hard time imagining how anyone would believe she's getting the short end of the stick here.
 
she paid half the mortgage on our home, but it wasn't always so.

Earlier you said she had paid for half the house, what you wrote then and what you write now can be very different things.

Moreover I paid for her education, and supported her through the development of her now somewhat lucrative career, none of which would be counted in the split.
Although I leave it for one of the Upper Canada brethern, in the U.S., that indeed generally would go in your favour particularly if she was now making more than you are.

More accurately you keep making ignorant and unwarranted assumptions about my life.
No, you keep providing additional information.
 
Oh, I understand it. You don't. That's the problem. I've given arguments, and if making a point about a fallacy

No, Sw1tch, you don't. You're like some philosophy school dropout. You learned all these big words, but you didn't learn how to apply them properly.
 
Earlier you said she had paid for half the house, what you wrote then and what you write now can be very different things.

Same. We bought it since she started working. She paid half the downpayment and then half the mortgage.

Although I leave it for one of the Upper Canada brethern, in the U.S., that indeed generally would go in your favour particularly if she was now making more than you are.

I still make more, but she has been closing the gap and certainly now makes an income well above average. She might one-day out earn me if she manages to get into iBanking, which is her career goal. So far she is working in related areas of finance, but not as lucrative as iBanking.
 
As I have noted a few times, earlier in the thread you waxed on and on about how irrelevant moral codes are to sexual relations

Yes, correct. I argued both that moral codes cannot apply to sexual relationships, because they're too complex. I also argued that moral codes should not prescribe against normal human behavior, because that would be life denying.

You weren't able to make headway against either argument.
 
No, Sw1tch, you don't. You're like some philosophy school dropout. You learned all these big words, but you didn't learn how to apply them properly.

As opposed to someone who simply ignores the real world in creating theories?
 
Moral codes already apply to sexual relationships. Like one ought not rape, torture, or commit unsolicited violence in regard to sexual relations, or have sex with minors.

Sure, but actually those are universal codes, that did not need the word "sexual" to apply. It's moral codes specific to sex that you can't substantiate.

This is also reflected in law, with some jurisdictions granting fault divorce and others not, which shows that codes of conduct are applied to institutionalized sexual relations all the time.

Those that do are on the wrong side of history. Some jurisdictions, also on the wrong side of history, advocate female genital mutilation, breast ironing, and stoning to death wayward women.

subsuming alot of our sexual conduct under more general social conventions to do with lying, honesty, communication, and so forth.

Nice try, but we DON'T have a universal moral convention with regards to those things. Lying, unlike violent coercion, is only immoral in some specific cases. For example, lying for financial gain--bad. Lying to win poker? Lying about whether your wife looks fat in her jeans? Not immoral.

Nothing about the normalness of something implies it has to be good

True, unless you have started with the life affirming assumption that normal human behavior cannot be bad.

If you wheel in an assumption that a moral code which labels bad something that is normal, well that is just special pleading.

You have to wheel in an assumption sooner or later, otherwise morality in and of itself cannot exist. It's inherently based on assumption. We humans simply make it up, it's not present in the real world, it's a fiction, and we're its authors. We have to choose what it is we're going to make it up, and there are two general paths available (though you could come up with more) -- the life-affirming path of embracing who and what we are, and the life-denying path of rejecting who and what we are in favour of some assumed higher ideal.

You cannot generate ANY morality from logical first principles. All moralities rest on some assumption anywhere.

It's not special pleading because I specified it as an assumption at the OUTSET of the debate. I didn't come up with it later. I gave it to you initially as a first principle. You can accept it, or reject it. If you want to reject it that's fine--but then please walk around chanting things like "I love death more than you love life", as other life deniers are wont to do.
 
Sure, but actually those are universal codes, that did not need the word "sexual" to apply.
So then what is "betraying your spouse causes great hurt and generally destroys your marriage and alienates your children when discovered." Is that universal or is that sexual?

One also has to love your declaration that jurisdictions with fault divorce are "on the wrong side of history." I have to smile at your omnipotence in being able to know what side "history" is on.
 
So then what is "betraying your spouse causes great hurt and generally destroys your marriage and alienates your children when discovered." Is that universal or is that sexual?

Sexual. Clearly. Was it not clear to you? Words in your sentence that might have tipped you off: spouse, marriage, children.

One also has to love your declaration that jurisdictions with fault divorce are "on the wrong side of history."

It's a correct statement. Similarly jurisdictions that oppose gay marriage, and jurisdictions that endorse torture--all on the wrong side of history.
 
Moral codes already apply to sexual relationships. Like one ought not rape, torture, or commit unsolicited violence in regard to sexual relations, or have sex with minors. So your view is prima facie refuted. Moral codes can be applied to sexual relations and are in fact applied. This is also reflected in law, with some jurisdictions granting fault divorce and others not, which shows that codes of conduct are applied to institutionalized sexual relations all the time. Yes those sexual relations are complex, as the law example shows, with political outcomes infusing what moral conduct is deemed relevant or not. So moral codes and politics can often both be needed to deal with sexual relations.
Sure, but actually those are universal codes, that did not need the word "sexual" to apply. It's moral codes specific to sex that you can't substantiate.
So then what is "betraying your spouse causes great hurt and generally destroys your marriage and alienates your children when discovered." Is that universal or is that sexual?
Sexual. Clearly. Was it not clear to you? Words in your sentence that might have tipped you off: spouse, marriage, children.
It certainly seems you are getting confused and contradicting yourself.

So rape, sexual violence and sex with minors are universal but betrayal of your spouse is sexual. Boy that tap dancing on the head of the pin must be getting damn tiring by now.
 
It certainly seems you are getting confused and contradicting yourself.

Nope. You should read more carefully:

So rape, sexual violence and sex with minors are universal but betrayal of your spouse is sexual. .

Correct. Those are universal codes, that did not need the word "sexual" to apply. It's moral codes specific to sex that you can't substantiate.

The words in italics might look familiar to you, as you quoted them in your reply.

Rape is violent coercion. Violence is always wrong. Rape is therefore wrong because it includes violence, which is always wrong. You don't need to refer to sex or sexuality to explain why rape is wrong. It's the application of a universal principle, "violence is wrong", to the sexual domain.

On the other hand, how would you explain "betrayal of a spouse" without reference to sex? No physical violence is inflicted on my spouse by my having sex with another woman, my spouse does not lose any property, she isn't denied anything she would otherwise have. In fact, the act which "betrays" her does not involve her at all, in any way, she's not even physically present when it happens. So how is she harmed? Any attempt by you to explain what harm is done is going to have to refer to the sexual relationship.

No, it's not just the same thing as "lying". You know, and I know, that being cheated on feels a whole hell of a lot worse than, say, someone bluffing you in a poker game, or telling you that you don't look fat in your jeans (when really you do).
 
A brick is less thick than you. Why can't normal behaviour be bad?

It can. That's a different assumption, you blithering idiot.

So you are just saying if it is normal it is good, by which I mean 'normal is good' is a strict logical deduction of your so-called life affirming assumption.

No. Saying that normal behavior cannot be bad is the life affirming assumption itself. Wake up.
 
You said you cannot generate morality from first principles, then said your assumption was given AS a first principle

You're right I wasn't very clear there, I should have said "you cannot generate morality from first principles without making some assumptions".

Any attempt to derive morality MUST start out with some value judgement. You have to decide, somewhere, somehow, that something is good. You can then reason about what else is good, by applying logic to your value judgements.

Sometimes--even THAT is not clear. A case can be made that human beings don't care whether their value judgements are logically consistent or not. Most complex systems of morality contain contradictions and inconsistencies, and yet most people are still happy to subscribe to those systems of morality, and simply shrug off the inconsistencies. This then leads to the question of what morality is, and what it is for--it's perhaps not a logically consistent "system" so much as a bunch of rules of thumb.

Is there a good reason why a moral system should be logically consistent? Objectively moral system appear to serve their purpose WITHOUT logical consistency. Meaning, by observation the moral systems that are in widespread use today seem to serve their adherents well enough despite being logically inconsistent. This raises the possibility that it is inappropriate to apply logic to morality, at least in some cases.

As a Platonist you will probably disagree violently with that--you prefer some sort of ideal world of mathematical perfection. Just note that what I am doing here is observing what people do in the real world, which is neither ideal nor mathematically perfect. Which world does morality belong to? Plainly it cannot belong to the world of mathematical perfection because it relies on human value judgement to get it started in the first place.

This is a more general claim than my specific attack on the morality of sex: there is a general claim that morality is not a logical/axiomatic system at all.
 
So how is she harmed? Any attempt by you to explain what harm is done is going to have to refer to the sexual relationship.
Frankly I believe most people talk about the emotional damage. You go ahead trying to convice us all that Sex Crimes are Universal and don't involve the sexual and betrayal of your spouse is entirely sexual and doesn't involve the emotional.
 
Frankly I believe most people talk about the emotional damage. You go ahead trying to convice us all that Sex Crimes are Universal and don't involve the sexual and betrayal of your spouse is entirely sexual and doesn't involve the emotional.

Emotional damage from what? You can't evade the point, it's not the same as if your friend had another friend, the emotions are deeply connected to the sexual relationship and you know it.
 
Personally I would not want to pin everything down to moral codes, so would prefer to add social conventions and norms too.

However social conventions and norms, unlike morality, are just short-cuts that enable us to get along with one another better. Violating a social convention or norm where there is no moral violation simply confuses the people around you--they don't know how to deal with your strange behavior. It can't be called 'wrong', only 'unexpected'.

For greater clarity the argument I've made applies to *any* attempt to use language and logic to codify behavior and conclude that an action is right or wrong. Most people would call that morality. If you want to try and stretch the concepts of convention and social norms into that space then they will get shot down by the same argument.

Now if you want to argue on a case by case basis, without general categories, not codified, then sure more is possible. Individual human beings, drawing on their full experience, utilizing all their skills and abilities, thinking rationally, but also drawing on emotional intelligence, social intelligence, intuition, empathy, and whatever other faculties we have to bring to bear, can in the full experience of a situation decide how to react to a specific event with greater insight than you can reproduce through a codified morality.

However, you can't abstract that away and form general rules and principles. To the extent that general rules and principles can be abstracted they are over-simplifications which, in the case of sexual behavior, fail to be expressive enough to be useful. To a greater extent than in rational language some of these concepts can be expressed through art, in poetry or music, or painting, or sculpture. However collateral like that cannot be used as tokens in rational analysis, you can't generate a moral code based on what people experience internally when they view the painting "The Scream". You need to write down your moral code with logic and language, and that will fail to be expressive enough to cover sexual behavior.

Fuji has never heard of war.

What you're doing now is stone-walling. Plainly the universal prohibition on violence allows for the use of force for self defense. We do think that wars of aggression are immoral. We understand that individuals have a right to defend themselves from violence by others. We extend that principle collectively to defensive war, and to police action.

Now you had a choice here: You COULD have proposed that yourself, as a way of better understanding the argument I'm making. That would have indicated that you're interested in the debate, and that you want to debate the spirit of the idea.

But no, you want to stonewall. You need me to clarify even blatantly obvious points for you, because you are either too malicious, or too stupid, to clarify them yourself. If you want everything clarified to that level then we're going to wind up debating the definition of words like "and", and we're going to wind up debating concepts like "I think therefore I am". You can always question any definition, any statement, to some pedantic level.

It's the strategy of someone who knows that they have lost the debate, but who is trying to draw their defeat out as long as possible.

Of course every time you stonewall like this I'm going to be able to elucidate the point in the obvious way. You are just delaying the inevitable admission that you've lost.

It is true that it won't be entirely without sex.

Q.E.D.

But it is ludicrous to think that sexual beyrayal won't simultaneously betray other things, such as trust that was placed in a person.

Stonewalling again. We all know that if you removed the sexual component from the betrayal it wouldn't be perceived as all that harmful. If I went out for the evening and lied to my wife about what I'm doing--turned out that I was secretly going to the local Tim Hortons to have a donut without telling her--it has all the same element of lying, betrayal, etc., other than the sexual component. However we all know that having a secret donut is no big deal. Having a secret fuck is different. Why is it different? Because of the sexual component.

Stop stonewalling. You've lost, just admit it and save us all some time.

It is hard to fathom any adult postulating that, because their partner was not there when they were fucking someone else, therefore he/she cannot be harmed.

That's exactly my point. Perhaps you didn't grok it. The point here is that without the sexual betrayal there is really no harm. The other individual is not present. They have not been injured. They have not suffered any loss of property. They have not been restricted or limited. They haven't been denied anything. And yet you still want to say they are harmed--why? Because of the evolutionary threat arising from sexual betrayal, because it interferes with their reproductive opportunities, because it diminishes their reproductive advantages. It's entirely for sexual/selection/evolutionary reasons that they are harmed.

Stop stonewalling already and admit you've lost. Your main objections were long ago overcome, your hollow repetition of "naturalistic fallacy" is dead and gone, and now all you have left is this pathetic stonewalling.
 
moral codes contain inconsistencies and people just shrug them off and use the moral code to guide their actions anyway, well his whole argument about moral codes being bad if they prescribe against normal behaviour had just collapsed.

Why would that be? I didn't say that applying morality to sexual behavior was logically inconsistent, I said it wasn't expressive enough. It's still not expressive enough. That fact that it's probably not even logically consistent just makes that even worse, there is even less good reason to apply those moral conventions to sexuality, not more.

The main obfuscation Fuji introduces above is that he concedes my point that even moral codes as seemingly universal as "violence is wrong" are actually case specific

You think you can get away with just ignoring what I wrote, and saying bullshit like this?

I said no such thing.

What I pointed out was that the universal prohibition againts violence is actually against aggressive violence. It's still a universal principle. No doubt if we look into the universal principle that violence is wrong we can elucidate it even further. The fact that it can be elucidated further does not detract from the point that it is universal.

My point establishes that one does not require norms specific to sexual relations in order to see that broad moral codes and social norms can interlock enough and be flexible enough to encompass such relations.

I see. When you lose the debate, you hope that by repeating your failed points you will sound like you are making an argument.

I pointed out that any other universal norms that may apply are insufficient to describe the harm arising from sexual betrayal. You have had no reply for that. Telling my wife that I'm going to work, when I'm secretly slipping out to have a donut, plainly does not harm her the same way as if I tell her I"m going to work, and then slip out to fuck the neighbour's wife. If you ignore the sexual component both events are equivalent: I'm doing something away from her presence for my own pleasure and lying to her about it. But we all know she isn't going to give a flying fuck about the donut, meanwhile the sexual betrayal will hurt.

So you have failed to bring these other moral principles to bear--they are insufficient to explain why there is any harm. You have to start asking questions like, "why does sexual betrayal hurt so much more than ordinary betrayal" to understand what has actually happened there. It isn't something you can answer without reference to sex and sexuality.