The ten solitudes of Toronto dating

You were factually wrong about adultery in Canada. You declared it was not a grounds for divorce here. It is.

I note you refuse to take up the factual challenge.

You are an intellectual fly weight...no substance at all. All talk.
 
You were factually wrong about adultery in Canada. You declared it was not a grounds for divorce here.

You're being a pedant. Do you acknowledge that adultery is not ground for asserting any fault or blame in Canada? Instead you're trying to focus on elements of my claim that were irrelevant to the debate, presumably because you know you can't win if you stick to the substantive issues. Namely--that there is nothing in Canadian law that is critical of adultery.
 
You're being a pedant. Do you acknowledge that adultery is not ground for asserting any fault or blame in Canada? Instead you're trying to focus on elements of my claim that were irrelevant to the debate, presumably because you know you can't win if you stick to the substantive issues. Namely--that there is nothing in Canadian law that is critical of adultery.

Factually wrong again. You don't understand the basics of divorce law either.

But I see you run like a scared little girl from the factual challenge. Are you going to take it up...or just keep running?
 
Factually wrong again. You don't understand the basics of divorce law either.

Adultery in Canada is the equivalent of separation. Are you saying the law considers separation to be immoral? The law in Canada is sensible. It allows people to work out for themselves how they want to deal with adultery. It recognizes staying together as a valid choice. It also recognizes splitting up as a valid choice. That's a sensible approach because humans, with their full emotional intelligence, social intelligence, and analytical abilities are able to figure out how to deal with sexual relationships in a way that a codified system of laws cannot. By leaving it up to the participants, and by concentrating on ensuring everybody gets their fair share of a split-up, the law has it right.
 
Whenever we part company on something I know I must be in the ballpark of having a reasonable and plausible view.

Blubbering.

While convincing you of anything is like trying to tell the Pope God doesn't exist, at least refuting your drivel provides others tempted to reason like you serious grounds for rethinking things.

More blubbering.

You again commit the naturalistic fallacy.

Get it through your bloody thick skull that I've given "morality should affirm life" as an assumption. You're free to disagree with that assumption. It is one of my "first principles" if you like. Given that assumption there is no naturalistic fallacy.

1. GIVEN THAT a morality should not prescribe against normal behavior (the assumption given at the outset of this debate, before you even joined it)

2. OBSERVING THAT infidelity is normal behavior (you've agreed to this)

3. IT FOLLOWS THAT a morality should not prescribe against infidelity (follows directly)

The transit from "is" to "ought" that you blubber on about mindlessly is captured in the assumption, not in the argument from empirical data.

You simply refuse to admit this point because you know it shows that you've been a ludicrous fool, arguing pointlessly, for the past 10 or 20 pages of this thread. You really are a clown.
 
Unless you can show it is all we are then your point is moot.

Why would I have to show that it is all we are. You are just being ludicrous again. It's good enough to show that it is normal human behavior, a part of who we are. It's absurd to contemplate ANYTHING being "all" we are.

One easy test is just Fuji, who unless he is completely lying about his marriage (I would not be surprised!), fucks his wife more than he cheatsmon his wife.

It's a 50-50 proposition. I fuck my wife more than I fuck my girlfriend, but since I also use SP's that evens it out. Unless you want to say SP's aren't cheating, which would be a weird thing to say.
 
It is certainly true that many moral codes have their beginnings in religious conceptions, and often religious conceptions that treat the material life and world as corrupt and the afterlife as pure.

Yes. This is the "life denying assumption", which I contrast with the life affirming assumption. The life affirming assumption is that real life is better than some false imaginary purity that does not exist.

Ironically, for all Fuji's posturing about rejecting these religious conceptions of moral conduct, he retains a key element of them, which is the aggressive prosletyzing and demeaning of others not sharing his view as impure, inferior, misguided, and as not living the right kind of life.

Absolutely! I reject moral relativism as a failed enterprise.
 
Factually wrong again. You don't understand the basics of divorce law either.

But I see you run like a scared little girl from the factual challenge. Are you going to take it up...or just keep running?

Fuji's continued fighting with lawyers on TERB about the fine points law and trying to sound informed is a real scream and shows how dumb he really is, except in his own mind of course, further showing the loooooooooooong line of his supporters that he's not what he thinks he is. As somebody put it earlier, so sad.

It must take him hours to shave in the morning.
 
Fuji's continued fighting with lawyers on TERB about the fine points law

Let's see if RLD actually disagrees with the idea that Canada has no fault divorce...

As for you, go back to the potty humour, really, you don't want to eat crow alongside RLD on this one.

It must take him hours to shave in the morning.

Ah, that's more like it--stick with that. It's more your style!
 
Let's see if RLD actually disagrees with the idea that Canada has no fault divorce...

As for you, go back to the potty humour, really, you don't want to eat crow alongside RLD on this one.

Ah, that's more like it--stick with that. It's more your style!

You simply refuse to enter the world of facts and you lie. You have no value. I will waste no more time with you, associating with such a coward is a waste.
 
You simply refuse to enter the world of facts and you lie. You have no value. I will waste no more time with you, associating with such a coward is a waste.

Divorce courts in Canada do not consider an adulterer to be at fault. You know it. I know it.
 
You were factually wrong about adultery in Canada. You declared it was not a grounds for divorce here. It is.
Don't worry, he had the same argument back several pages ago.

Further as I pointed out to him when it comes to division of joint property just because it is "no fault" doesn't mean the judge is stupid.
 
Divorce courts in Canada do not consider an adulterer to be at fault. You know it. I know it.

Since I never said they did...that would be just more dishonesty on your part. You know it. I know it.
 
Don't worry, he had the same argument back several pages ago.

Further as I pointed out to him when it comes to division of joint property just because it is "no fault" doesn't mean the judge is stupid.

Hoping to sneak back in with troglodeic moral rules? Sorry not in Canada. You'll note that RLD didn't bite. He knows there's nothing penalizing adultery under Canadian law.
 
Last edited:
If a morality should not prescribe against normal behavior then all that is being said is that if something is normal it can't be bad enough for a moral code to say something negative about it (a farking ought claim ya tool).

That's the assumption you tool. You really are thick aren't you? There is no problem with the statement just you blubbering on now.
 
Fuji "You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink."

I don't believe in making threats so I can only say that I hope for your sake that you are right and that in Ontario judges do not look quite hard to find legitimate reasons why the property division should be 65-35 unofficialy based on the fact that one party was used by the other even though that is nowhere in the order.

Judges tend to take a dim view of people trying to abuse others in family court through "sea lawyering."
 
Aardvark, let's say that you're right, and that I am unlucky enough to get some Troglodyte of a judge who intentionally thwarts the will of Parliament and attempts to impose unenlightened Victorian ideas of adultery on the proceedings. Let's say it winds up being a 35-65 split, which is really pretty extreme, considering we have a written agreement calling for a 50-50 split, in a country with no fault divorce. In that case I'm still happy with my choices.

I'm not going to start living a hobbled life just to have 30% more assets, when realistically I have far more than I need anyway.
 
Fuji "You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink."

I don't believe in making threats so I can only say that I hope for your sake that you are right and that in Ontario judges do not look quite hard to find legitimate reasons why the property division should be 65-35 unofficialy based on the fact that one party was used by the other even though that is nowhere in the order.

Judges tend to take a dim view of people trying to abuse others in family court through "sea lawyering."

what do you think would happen if a judge finds that a female was cheating on a male?