CBC - What is it good for?

I stand corrected on the cost to taxpayers -- $1.1 billion it is.

As for the Deloitte study, that's interesting, but I think the key words are "says a report prepared for the public broadcaster...". I'm always skeptical of reports that are paid for by people with a vested interest in the conclusions. Call me a cynic.
 
…edit…Some of the assumptions in this thread -- that CBC… gives them a better sense of the country's history -- seem to be no better substantiated than the existence of the Tooth Fairy.

Certainly, if some of the findings released over the years by the Dominion Institute are any indication, the CBC is definitely failing the test when it comes to promoting Canadian history:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/canada-is-failing-history/article1184615/
To be true to your own statement above, doen't you have to assign equal blame to private broadcasters for Canadians' ignorance?
 
To be true to your own statement above, doen't you have to assign equal blame to private broadcasters for Canadians' ignorance?

No, because the private broadcasters aren't funded by taxpayers under the rationale that they're supposed to be helping us better understand our history and tell our stories to ourselves.
 
No, because the private broadcasters aren't funded by taxpayers under the rationale that they're supposed to be helping us better understand our history and tell our stories to ourselves.
Assuming you believe that's worth doing, then all you're saying is the CBC should do it better for the $3 a month it costs each Canadian

Just how would you suggest they spend your 10¢ a day better than they do now?

Do the profit-taking broadcasters not have an equal duty to use our airwaves productively?
 
Last edited:
When something costs $1.5 billion per year, I don't think it's "silly" to ask whether or not Canadians are getting anything for their money.

Does CBC provide entertainment, news and current affairs. Sure, but so do the private networks. Some of the assumptions in this thread -- that CBC makes viewers/listeners smarter than people who watch the private networks, or more cultured, or gives them a better sense of the country's history -- seem to be no better substantiated than the existence of the Tooth Fairy.

Certainly, if some of the findings released over the years by the Dominion Institute are any indication, the CBC is definitely failing the test when it comes to promoting Canadian history:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/canada-is-failing-history/article1184615/

So, according to your article, only 4 provinces have mandatory history courses in their high schools but you're blaming the CBC because Canadians are so woefully ignorant about their own history? Hello!!! The CBC's mandate is to OFFER programming that promotes greater awareness of Canadian history and culture but that is no substitute for teaching it in schools. Your article points out that too many provinces don't take teaching history seriously and claims that this is a big mistake:

"Why should we care about the teaching of history? Class time is limited and there are many important subjects to teach, but Canadian history cannot be lost. For citizens to function in a modern democracy such as Canada's, they must develop an appreciation and understanding of the country's past."

So YOUR article finds that history is being ignored by the provinces and, furthermore, YOUR article feels that we need to do a lot more to make our population aware of our own history. Meanwhile, you're using this article as evidence that we should pull the plug on the CBC even though the CBC offers plenty of historical programming. In other words, lets make a bad situation even worse.
 
I stand corrected on the cost to taxpayers -- $1.1 billion it is.

As for the Deloitte study, that's interesting, but I think the key words are "says a report prepared for the public broadcaster...". I'm always skeptical of reports that are paid for by people with a vested interest in the conclusions. Call me a cynic.


Always a good position to be skeptical, but what is the report can you argue against. In case you really want to look, here's the report in big print and double space to help.

http://www.cbc.radio-canada.ca/about/Economic-Impact-Deloitte.pdf

The last thing DT, not a minor company with a marginal reputation, would want would be is for others critics to come back showing weakness in their report. So far not peep from anyone, save you and Niels Veldhuis with the Fraser Institute.
 
I disagree with at least part of your premise. I don't consider education to be a matter of taste, and have already said it should be funded. In terms of the priorities for the curriculum, that should be based on what produces the best outcomes for students. There's nothing in your list of public education subjects that I disagree with, recognizing that public education isn't my area of expertise......

Interesting that you'd gas the CBC yet continue to pay public school teachers to teach history, social studies, Canadian geography etc. You obviously don't watch much of CBC's historical or cultural programming or you'd appreciate that it's just as educational as anything you'd get in a classroom and probably a lot more interesting thanks to the CBC's excellent production values.

Since education is vital enough for you to pay for it in a classroom setting, how exactly is it not so vital when it unfolds in front of the whole family on TV? Isn't it important for working adults, seniors, homemakers, etc to learn about Canada too? Sure they could take evening courses or borrow videos and books from the library but only a very small number of people will take the trouble to do that. CBC programming is so accessible it reaches an audience that would otherwise not be exposed to much of our history, culture etc. Working immigrants, in particular, have very little background in Canada and they're far less likely to learn about their adopted country unless it is easily accessible at home. And when you consider how much we spend on formal education in classrooms, the paltry amount we spend for the CBC to bring Canadian history and culture into our lives becomes one of the greatest bargains of all time.
 
Since education is vital enough for you to pay for it in a classroom setting, how exactly is it not so vital when it unfolds in front of the whole family on TV?

The difference is that you can make certain subjects in the schools mandatory. By contrast, television viewing is optional, and my suspicion is that most of the people watching the history programs on CBC already have an interest in the subject.

Indeed, we've reached a point where long-time reporters on Parliament Hill don't know the difference between Vichy and Vimy Ridge (http://www.steynonline.com/content/view/4237/26/). And given the number of pundits who have appeared on Newsworld, I can't believe the explanation is that reporters in Ottawa don't have access to CBC broadcasts. :D

Generally, I feel a bit like Richard Dawkins in a room full of Christian fundamentalists. If it upsets people that I'm unconvinced the CBC is one of the "greatest bargains" of all time, that's unfortunate, but I'm not prepared to believe it just because others have accepted that idea as a matter of faith.

In the new knowledge economy, I think we should assess the role of public broadcasting. Why does it exist? And if taxpayers are going to fund it, does it have a clear mandate that makes sense in the 21st century? And what benchmarks are we using to ensure it is fulfilling that mandate?

On that last question, in particular, I think the answers are far from clear.
 
Their news and documentary stations are top notch. The main TV network has it's high points beyond hockey as well.

A viable, well funded, arms length public broadcaster (Be it on Radio, TV, or the Internet) is a valuable public service. The only developed Western nation without a strong arms length public broadcaster is due south, and even their 'good news' is pretty bad for a large variety of reasons. Predominantly private reflecting cooperate biases, highly consolidated, ratings driven, and with an interpretation of free speech that makes spin, lies, opinions, wanking, and propaganda into news and high culture. Not that you only want public broadcasters, but you want two strong systems in parallel with some asymmetric competition.

Well, it's not completely true that the US does not have an arms-length public broadcaster. There is PBS on television and NPR for the radio and both produce excellent programming (in particular, news and documentaries and children's programming). In a similar vein, CBC also excels in news and documentaries as well as children's programming as well.