What do you think of Bridgette DePape's protest

What do you think of DePape protest?

  • Shit disturbing twit

    Votes: 55 62.5%
  • Couragous self sacrifiing and admirable

    Votes: 33 37.5%

  • Total voters
    88
39.62% of Canadians voted for Harper. 60.38% voted against him. This was her point. While Harper has the seats to do what he wants, he does not have the popular support. She is 100% correct that Canada is NOT a conservative country by nature. Our election system is IMHO not democratic as it does not deliver a government that is representative of the peoples wishes.

Jean Chretien ruled us as liberal overlord for 12 years with the same popular vote. Never had the mandate of the majority, never listened to voters. In fact he did nothing for most of those 12 years except increase taxes and slash health care. (That's right, it was the federal liberals and not the Harris pc's who decimated health care in Ontario, do some research if you don't believe me). That's some awesome governing. 60% of the country didn't support him.

Did you speak out about our flawed electoral system then?

If not, STFU now.

The right to vote should be based directly on the amount of federal taxes you pay. Don't pay taxes? No right to vote. Someone pays $50,000 per year in tax? They should have 10 times more say than someone who pays $5,000 in tax.

That would eliminate the left wing lunacy support from people either too young, too ignorant or too lazy to contribute to society.
 
Jean Chretien ruled us as liberal overlord for 12 years with the same popular vote. Never had the mandate of the majority, never listened to voters either. 60% of the country didn't support him.

Did you speak out about our flawed electoral system then?

If not, STFU now.

The right to vote should be based directly on the amount of federal taxes you pay. Don't pay taxes? No right to vote. Someone pays $50,000 per year in tax? They should have 10 times more say than someone who pays $5,000 in tax.

That would eliminate the left wing lunacy support from people either too young, too ignorant or too lazy to contribute to society.

Now that's just idiotic. I'll assume you're talking Income Taxes, but There is a fair portion of our society that don't pay any income taxes as they are self employed, taking all the risks that it brings to the table and getting the tax breaks that it gives.

Then you can also take in to consideration that 'everyone' pays Federal taxes somewhere and some how in everything thing they buy or do so I guess it's kind of a hollow demand, but hey.

So someone who pay more taxes should get more votes at election time? Talk about lunacy.

I suggest you tighten your chin chin strap.
 
Now that's just idiotic. I'll assume you're talking Income Taxes, but There is a fair portion of our society that don't pay any income taxes as they are self employed, taking all the risks that it brings to the table and getting the tax breaks that it gives.

Then you can also take in to consideration that 'everyone' pays Federal taxes somewhere and some how in everything thing they buy or do so I guess it's kind of a hollow demand, but hey.

So someone who pay more taxes should get more votes at election time? Talk about lunacy.

I suggest you tighten your chin chin strap.
Almost every self-employed person I know of pays taxes so don't understand your logic here. Generally the ones who don't pay taxes are seniors with relatively low income, students and obviously those on social assistance.

That said I agree with the premis of your post, the amount of taxes you pay should not have any effect on your voting power.
 
Almost every self-employed person I know of pays taxes so don't understand your logic here. Generally the ones who don't pay taxes are seniors with relatively low income, students and obviously those on social assistance.

That said I agree with the premis of your post, the amount of taxes you pay should not have any effect on your voting power.

Not that's it's big topic in my circle of self employed fiend and acquaintances and more from what they don't say about it than what they say but I would guess it's about of half them have enough to right off or get credits for or however you want to calculate it and those who do, pay very little certainly not enough to buy many votes
 
Now that's just idiotic. I'll assume you're talking Income Taxes, but There is a fair portion of our society that don't pay any income taxes as they are self employed, taking all the risks that it brings to the table and getting the tax breaks that it gives.

Then you can also take in to consideration that 'everyone' pays Federal taxes somewhere and some how in everything thing they buy or do so I guess it's kind of a hollow demand, but hey.

So someone who pay more taxes should get more votes at election time? Talk about lunacy.

I suggest you tighten your chin chin strap.

Voting rights based on being a taxpayer happen today (all municipal voters are property tax payers, or people who pay property tax via rent) so it can't be all that idiotic. My idea just takes it further and makes it proportional, which while I admit is not feasible, would be ideal. Hey, one can wish.

The point is to put control of the money in the hands of the people who actually pay, as opposed to those who just want to suck from the system.


To you, fairness = lunacy. Well, that has always been the left wing point of view.
 
You sure do read a lot into a silent protest carrying a sign that said 'stop Harper'. I suspect that's you opinion or stance.
Her points in her subsequent interview has been get out and vote especially the younger people.

Her potest is a little more visceral that that as pointed out by an information sheet handed out by supporters ;

"This country needs a Canadian version of an Arab Spring, a flowering of popular movements that demonstrate that real power to change things lies not with Harper but in the hands of the people, when we act together in our streets, neighbourhoods and workplaces."

Her second term was going to come to an end in a couple of weeks when the Senate rise for the summer.

She was interviewed in a video after she was fired. She made the point that conservative values are not the values of a majority of Canadians and the popular vote reflects that. Unfortunately our electoral system has delivered absolute power to a government that does not align with the values of our nation. So the only viable means left to restrain it's agenda is through protest. That is a VERY COSTLY and VERY DANGEROUS side effect of a broken democracy. You can argue it was the same when the Libs were in power, but not so. If you add up NDP and Liberal votes you have a natural majority and their values are both left leaning....like our country.
 
Voting rights based on being a taxpayer happen today (all municipal voters are property tax payers, or people who pay property tax via rent) so it can't be all that idiotic. My idea just takes it further and makes it proportional, which while I admit is not feasible, would be ideal. Hey, one can wish.

The point is to put control of the money in the hands of the people who actually pay, as opposed to those who just want to suck from the system.


To you, fairness = lunacy. Well, that has always been the left wing point of view.

To say that renters pay property taxes is a real stretch. Are you saying that the stay at home spouses who don't work and therefore don't pay income taxes can't vote?

If you really paid attention during your/my time on TERB you know I'm not a leftist. I'm very much closer to a centrist and waffle from side to side depending on the individual topic.
 
All she did was to place herself, and those with similar opinions into a bad light.
 
She was interviewed in a video after she was fired. She made the point that conservative values are not the values of a majority of Canadians and the popular vote reflects that. Unfortunately our electoral system has delivered absolute power to a government that does not align with the values of our nation. So the only viable means left to restrain it's agenda is through protest. That is a VERY COSTLY and VERY DANGEROUS side effect of a broken democracy. You can argue it was the same when the Libs were in power, but not so. If you add up NDP and Liberal votes you have a natural majority and their values are both left leaning....like our country.

Our system has delivered heavy majorities a number of times over our history so this is not news. Get the 40% out who don't care to vote and make the BQ a non issue and you'll find things will get more to the middle.
 
She was interviewed in a video after she was fired. She made the point that conservative values are not the values of a majority of Canadians and the popular vote reflects that. Unfortunately our electoral system has delivered absolute power to a government that does not align with the values of our nation. So the only viable means left to restrain it's agenda is through protest. That is a VERY COSTLY and VERY DANGEROUS side effect of a broken democracy. You can argue it was the same when the Libs were in power, but not so. If you add up NDP and Liberal votes you have a natural majority and their values are both left leaning....like our country.

That just reeks of intolerance for other's point of view.
 
She was interviewed in a video after she was fired. She made the point that conservative values are not the values of a majority of Canadians and the popular vote reflects that. Unfortunately our electoral system has delivered absolute power to a government that does not align with the values of our nation. So the only viable means left to restrain it's agenda is through protest. That is a VERY COSTLY and VERY DANGEROUS side effect of a broken democracy. You can argue it was the same when the Libs were in power, but not so. If you add up NDP and Liberal votes you have a natural majority and their values are both left leaning....like our country.

You are making an assumption that everybody in that 60% does not support the tory platform, iffy at best. The preferences of the bulk of the eligible voters who did not vote are also not know, to simply assume that thye are anti tory is stupid .The platform that the Tories ran on was published and debated for several months, the bulk of the population apparantly liked it enough to approve of it during the election, that the bulk of the non voting eligible voters did not turn out is interesting as well, if they had really disapproved of the platform I expect they would have shown up to vote against it.
 
To say that renters pay property taxes is a real stretch. Are you saying that the stay at home spouses who don't work and therefore don't pay income taxes can't vote?

If you really paid attention during your/my time on TERB you know I'm not a leftist. I'm very much closer to a centrist and waffle from side to side depending on the individual topic.

In a word yes. But since under our current tax scheme the working spouse pays so much more tax than if both spouses were working and generating the same household income, things even out.

I guess by centrist you mean liberal, as they always claim to be nearest to the middle. I wish I had a party that represented me. I'm a fiscal conservative but a social liberal. I want lower taxes and less government, but I support gay marriage, right to choose and legalizing pot and prostitution.

I wish I had a party to vote for.
 
Double-posting here, but now that she has betrayed the trust that her employer placed in her, would you want her as a doctor, a lawyer, or teaching your kids? She has shown herself to be someone who places her own values and opinions ahead of her professional duty.
 
In a word yes. But since under our current tax scheme the working spouse pays so much more tax than if both spouses were working and generating the same household income, things even out.

I guess by centrist you mean liberal, as they always claim to be nearest to the middle. I wish I had a party that represented me. I'm a fiscal conservative but a social liberal. I want lower taxes and less government, but I support gay marriage, right to choose and legalizing pot and prostitution.

I wish I had a party to vote for.

So the working husband get to vote alone in a family based solely on the amount of taxes he pays. Who cares what his wife thinks or wants. So i guess we're gong back to the early 20th century when wives were chattel and had no rights to vote, only this time the wives who worka nd pay taxes get the vote. How many votes does the taxpayer get, 1 vote for each $5000 dollars in taxes. That would mean a mega rich business would get ~100's of votes. Welcome back to Victorian Times.

*0% of Canadian women earn a salary but many can little or no income tax after deductions. Do they get a vote. The 20% who don't work don't get a vote. So we have second class citizens. how about stay a home dads, more second class citizens. How about the many seniors who don't pay any taxes. Do they lose they vote.

I've voted for the Liberal quite a few time but for the other two parties totally about an equal number of times. So it's hard to pigeon hole in any way. So it's about a 50/25/25 split. Before Harper came on the scene most high level analyst would say that the three major parties were an part socialist, specially when compared to other non Scandinavian countries and Canada by definition a socialist country.

Has there ever been a party anywhere that believed like you. I suspect not. That should tell you something, it's a bad or unworkable idea.
 
39.62% of Canadians voted for Harper. 60.38% voted against him. This was her point. While Harper has the seats to do what he wants, he does not have the popular support. She is 100% correct that Canada is NOT a conservative country by nature. Our election system is IMHO not democratic as it does not deliver a government that is representative of the peoples wishes.

I wonder if she was as upset when Jean Chretien winning Liberal majorities with about the same percentage. The Liberals were bullies too and they had roughly 60% against them.

Then again she was a toddler when the Liberals got their first majority so I wouldn't expect her to recall. And looks like she doesn't pay attention to history.
 
harper does not represent my vision of canada and i support this girl and her courage.........hope we see plenty of this peaceful civil disobedience in the next 4 years. Harpo may be our dictator for the next few years, but we ( the 60 % who voted against him) need to let him know that we don't agree with him .

[SIZE=+6]+1!!!!![/SIZE]
 
She is the darling of the left-wing right now and you can bet that NOW Magazine, The Star and other left-wing media would love to have her join their ranks.
So only slightly more respectable than community organizer for "Friends of the clubed seals."
 
I wonder if she was as upset when Jean Chretien winning Liberal majorities with about the same percentage. The Liberals were bullies too and they had roughly 60% against them.

Then again she was a toddler when the Liberals got their first majority so I wouldn't expect her to recall. And looks like she doesn't pay attention to history.
[SIZE=+6]+1!!!!![/SIZE]