East Side Mario's

Would anyone:

1) Want to admit to trying it?
2) Survive the experience of trying it?

Sorry - years ago when I was in my 20's I thought East Side Mario's was "All that and slice of pie too", but my tastes have fortunately changed. ESM is now on my list of "only if I'm starving and there are no live plants around to eat restaurants".

+ 1.
 
Dude, you're better off going to No Frills and picking up No-name ketchup & Italian TV dinners.
 
If "all you can eat Italian" is what your looking for go to Frankie Tomato's Woodbine north of Steeles in Markham. But don't let fugi know,or he will want your before and after BMI!!
 
Bada Boom, Bada Bing
 
I've not ever had a good meal at ESM. i've been because others wanted to go, but the food is formula stuff and inconsistent at best.

Frankie Tomatoes is much better.
 
If "all you can eat Italian" is what your looking for go to Frankie Tomato's Woodbine north of Steeles in Markham. But don't let fugi know,or he will want your before and after BMI!!

Not to mention that I've eaten there, and the food is terrible, often not fresh. Maybe it's better than ESM. Maybe. We're still scraping the bottom of the barrel with a suggestion like that.
 
Honestly... When you are shopping in a Mall with children in hand who are freaking out because they want food now and it is a choice between a half arsed food court, and ESM... ESM is stellar for their kids menu (kids eat free Monday I believe and a lot of ESM host evenings that a percentage benefits various places and programs like Autism Ontario, etc.).

Recommendations - Cheese Cappelletti. Hearty Vegetable if a soup person. Cesar Salad if a salad person.

Alternates - Classic Lasagna
- Chicken Tettrazini
- Seafood Linguine

I do actually miss the Mulberry Street Connection with the Eggplant Parmigiana. I suppose saying that dates me doesn't it? (Not to mention it is impossible to find good E.P.)

Outside of those... I probably wouldn't venture too far outside of their classics menu.

While it is not the type of place I consider fine dining... It is reasonably consistent, and they make an effort. Overall I would say it is manageable for the events and an emergency dining experience when I am out with friends and their children.

Oh and - Frankie Tomatoes is fairly good for a buffet but not always a worthwhile drive at times.
 
Would anyone:

1) Want to admit to trying it?
2) Survive the experience of trying it?

Sorry - years ago when I was in my 20's I thought East Side Mario's was "All that and slice of pie too", but my tastes have fortunately changed. ESM is now on my list of "only if I'm starving and there are no live plants around to eat restaurants".

Ditto.

It's crap, but sometimes you just have no choice.

Olive Garden was better crap back in the day. Hey ba da boom ba da bing.
 
Thanks for the info! Where would then is the best value for pasta in Toronto? And I'm not talking about places that charge $50 for a plate of fettucini.

Probably Rocco's Plum Tomato on the Queensway or Bloor / Bathurst area.

Very good (not great) Italian Food and not over the top price wise.

Mamma Martino's on the Queensway is good and very very reasonably priced. It's not Sotto Sotto by a long shot, but pretty much everything on the menu is 10 bucks and it's good solid neighbourhood Italian Food.
 
http://www.frankietomatto.com/

This is a pretty good all you can eat Italian restaurant. Food is very good, and prices are pretty good ($16 for weekday dinner, $20 for weekend)

I've been to Frankie Tomatto's a few times (always a work thing, never my idea to go, but when you need to feed 20 people cheap....)

It's fucking terrible.

I think I'd prefer ESM over Frankie Tomattos. Hell, I'd prefer Mcdonalds (seriously) over FT.
 
Terroni - Downtown

Regina's - College Street

Marcello's - St. Clair

Vesuvio's - West End/Junction.

All good restaurants with reasonably priced food with dishes at or less than $20.00.

ESM is assembly line, impersonal service with sanitized, clinical, mediocre content that they try to pass off as food.

Run fast. Run Far.
 
Mamma Martino's on the Queensway is good and very very reasonably priced. It's not Sotto Sotto by a long shot, but pretty much everything on the menu is 10 bucks and it's good solid neighbourhood Italian Food.

OMG. It's the worst Italian EVER! I can't believe there are line ups for this place?
(must be for 'cakers' only)

I remember the first time I went there (after hearing about it and seeing the long line ups), I ordered the spaghetti & meatballs. Guess what I got? Watery ketchup sauce, powdery uncooked pasta and dry cardboard meatball -- terrible.

Second time (birthday party), ordered the same thing. Guess what? The same crap -- AWFUL!! Never again!

Thank god, there's a Rocco down the street!
 
To be honest if you are looking for "family restaurant italian" the Richtree (formerly Marche) restaurants are not bad. The pasta selections are limited (they probably only have 2 or 3) but it's made fresh and for line cooked food (i.e., without a supervising chef, such as Terroni would have) it's pretty good. Much better than FT or ESM. Not on the same level as Terroni, but slightly lower price level too, and of course they have all sorts of other non-Italian food as well, much of it also quite good for the price you pay.

There's one around York Mills and... Bayview?

Note Richtree. Some of the locations (like King & Yonge) have been taken over by Marche/Movenpick and have much worse food. The "Marche" branded locations are crap now, although the pasta is still fresh, the pasta sauce is completely flavourless and tastes likes it's mostly water. The ones that are still branded "Richtree" are much better.
 
rocco's is great, and has a lunch special for 12.99 with an appetizer (have a calimari salad) entree, and dessert. i think its 19.99 for dinner, great promo.