Globalive Court Decision

WTF is "dufus"? Do you mean you as doofus? LOL

Plus, wtf is "origens"? Do you mean estrogen or something?



LOL, like nobody in Canada had a clue. Funny you never mentioned Alcan.



LMAO, that's the first time I hear those Russians know how to use wok to cook for dinner, while helping the Chinese to develop weapons.

Again, what are you smoking?

The last time I heard it was the Ukrainians and Belorussians who help the Chinese on aircraft carrier and TEL respectively. Both could speak Russians well due to the legacy of the Soviet days but they are no Russians.



Hire as paying them to spy in MIC and Pentagon and betray their own country, not working for SOEs like AVIC, Norinco and the Poly Technologies in China. :rolleyes:

Maybe you are deluded to believe non EE, Anglo-Saxon Caucasians working in those MIC over there. If so, where are the sources?



Again remind us why should we care?

Maybe we should care when Rio Tinto decides to spin off Alcan and have "new" IPO at TSX.

Why should you care? I have no idea...you are the one that mentioned them in the first place. Seeing that the C919 has annouced the use of GE engines and western avionics.. who do you think is doing all the integration work? You think there are no western engineers working on tech transfer? You think that knowledge will remain exclusively civilian? Yeah I make lots of typos sometimes. I can't really be bothered to fix them because I feel that any chimpanzee can figure out what I really meant to say..not the case apparently. Selling Alcan was a mistake.
 
The inevitable outcome of this decision will be changes to the Telecom Act allowing foreign ownership of Canadian telecoms. The results of THAT will be mixed:

1) Far more competition in marketplace as foreign behemoths muscle into Canada, and nobody, and I mean NOBODY, is going to cry for Bell and Rogers, the two most widely hated companies in the country.

2) Loss of control by Canada over a potentially strategic industry, with ill defined consequences
 
Ha ha ha for the Cons this is what being hoisted on your own petard means.


Wind Mobile ruling puts Ottawa on the hot seat over foreign ownership rules
IAIN MARLOW — TELECOM REPORTER
From Monday's Globe and Mail
Published Sunday, Feb. 06, 2011 6:42PM EST
Last updated Monday, Feb. 07, 2011 10:01AM EST
120 comments Email Print/License Decrease text size
Increase text size The confusion created by the Federal Court’s rejection of a cabinet order allowing cellphone company Wind Mobile to operate, despite a large amount of Egyptian capital, puts new pressure on Ottawa to remove foreign ownership rules for the telecom sector. .

On Friday, the court said the federal cabinet had overstepped its powers in 2009 by overturning a CRTC ruling that found Wind Mobile’s parent, Globalive Wireless Management Corp., was “controlled in fact” by its Cairo-based backer, Orascom Telecom. Globalive chairman Anthony Lacavera spent the weekend consulting with lawyers to figure out the best route of appeal during the 45-day stay granted by the court.

More related to this story
•It’s time for foreign competition in Canadian telecommunications
•Telecom ruling puts a leash on Tory cabinet authority
•Court scraps cabinet ruling on Globalive, dealing blow to new entrant
Video
Globealive responds to court ruling
Poll
Should cabinet have the power to overrule independent regulators such as the CRTC?
Yes No
Results & past polls

.96% 3767 votes Yes
.4% 164 votes No
.More polls

. Earlier Discussion
Small ISP reacts to CRTC reversal “We had the CRTC’s view. We had the government’s view. And now we’ve got the court’s view. And all three are different, which is, I guess, Canada,” Mr. Lacavera said. “It’s pretty strong evidence that our control and ownership regime needs an overhaul.”

Iain Grant, managing director with the Seaboard Group telecom consultancy, says legislative change is required if the government wants to continue increasing competition in the sector. That, Mr. Grant said, involves changing the Telecommunications Act’s Canadian ownership requirements to make it explicitly clear that foreign competitors are welcome in Canada.

The court’s surprise ruling, which came from a judicial review sought by rival wireless company Public Mobile, has further muddied the regulatory situation governing how much foreign capital telecom companies can use. Under current legislation, Canadian telecom companies cannot be owned by foreigners and there are strict limits on the amount of foreign investment. Orascom holds about 90 per cent of Wind Mobile’s equity and debt.

The government pledged in the last budget to remove the restrictions, but has been vague on its timeline to do so. RBC Dominion Securities Inc. analyst Jonathan Allen says Friday’s development could force the government to act sooner – to help stabilize Wind Mobile, which has more than 200,000 customers, and to prevent the Conservatives from embarrassment before a possible election.

“With Wind at risk of failing, we believe the government should be able to introduce the necessary legislation in the next few months – and other political parties would likely have to support it or risk being responsible for the company’s failure,” Mr. Allen wrote in a note to clients on Sunday.

The matter is crucial in this capital-intensive business where other new wireless companies use foreign investment to pay for licences and build network infrastructure.

Mr. Lacavera is among those pushing for change to how the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission determines whether companies here are too influenced by foreign capital.

Mr. Lacavera said the foreign financiers of Public Mobile, such as Columbia Capital and M/C Venture Partners of the United States, have more control over that company than Orascom does on his.

“There’s way more foreign influence in Public Mobile than in Globalive, but the incumbents have never gone after Public because they’re not a threat,” Mr. Lacavera said, referring to the fact that large wireless companies such as BCE Inc. and Rogers Communications Inc. have gone after Wind in the marketplace because of its size.

Public Mobile could not be reached to comment on Sunday.

At the same time, industry watchers say the government needs to step in and stem the mounting confusion, and that the only way to do so is by changing the foreign ownership rules. The matter is controversial because Canada’s carriers own broadcasting businesses, and powerful cultural interest groups object to foreign companies stepping in.
 
Why should you care? I have no idea...you are the one that mentioned them in the first place. Seeing that the C919 has annouced the use of GE engines and western avionics.. who do you think is doing all the integration work?

As usual you are digging on anything that remotely closed to bash our neighbor, your pinata called the Great Satan.

WRT C919, good luck for the mainland Chinese since this would be drastically upped the food chain, from producing spare parts, assembling Airbus A321 in China to integration.

Not going to be surprised you as a Canadian will jump up for joy like those Chinese netizens and say "so good..." should the Chinese become successful, even though the plane could undermine Bombardier C Series market.

BTW, Ka Ching, Ka Ching for GE stakeholders.

You think there are no western engineers working on tech transfer? You think that knowledge will remain exclusively civilian?

Again you sounds like somebody just finished enjoying weed harvested from Mendocino County, California, not organic oaked Chardonnay from the same region.

You still do not provide any shred of evidence to support western/Anglo-Saxon, non EE engineers having the Chinese SOEs/MIC as their employers and collecting the take home pay in RMB.

WRT those "knowledge", funny to notice you suggest people are that dumb not to know there's a thing called dual-use technology.

Yeah I make lots of typos sometimes. I can't really be bothered to fix them because I feel that any chimpanzee can figure out what I really meant to say..not the case apparently.

ROLFLMAO, not going to be surprised any chimpanzee is smart enough not to listen to the BS or funny sh*t from somebody who claims to know everything and yet his tardiness, sloppiness and serial lack of attention to details evident here suggest he's not walking the talk.

Selling Alcan was a mistake.

Richard B Evans did an excellent job to increase the shareholders value, thank you. :cool:
 
This makes Canada look like such a banana republic.

ROFLMAO, banana republic is an American clothing brand acquired by the Gap Inc, where the CEO is a Canadian. :rolleyes:

Man you are really that slow.

BTW, he is the same person who learn his trade at Loblaw and revived Shoppers Drug Mart before the latter IPO.
 
As usual you are digging on anything that remotely closed to bash our neighbor, your pinata called the Great Satan.

WRT C919, good luck for the mainland Chinese since this would be drastically upped the food chain, from producing spare parts, assembling Airbus A321 in China to integration.

Not going to be surprised you as a Canadian will jump up for joy like those Chinese netizens and say "so good..." should the Chinese become successful, even though the plane could undermine Bombardier C Series market.

BTW, Ka Ching, Ka Ching for GE stakeholders.



Again you sounds like somebody just finished enjoying weed harvested from Mendocino County, California, not organic oaked Chardonnay from the same region.

You still do not provide any shred of evidence to support western/Anglo-Saxon, non EE engineers having the Chinese SOEs/MIC as their employers and collecting the take home pay in RMB.

WRT those "knowledge", funny to notice you suggest people are that dumb not to know there's a thing called dual-use technology.



ROLFLMAO, not going to be surprised any chimpanzee is smart enough not to listen to the BS or funny sh*t from somebody who claims to know everything and yet his tardiness, sloppiness and serial lack of attention to details evident here suggest he's not walking the talk.



Richard B Evans did an excellent job to increase the shareholders value, thank you. :cool:

So by using American govenment actions as an example to SUPPORT what our govenment did, you think I am somehow bashing the US? I am not bashing the US or any other country for restricting ownership in certain industries. It just has to make sense for the entire economy. The Telco act made sense at the time, but it was more a cultural motive or to support what were at the time "natural monopolies". Now that is less relevant and several aspects of the act are obsolote. It is also clear that Canada is FAR behind many countries in wireless. If you have travelled you will know that this is sadly very true. C919 is a big step, it is a LONG way off, and does not yet compete with Cseries. I am hopeful and optimistic that Cseries will be a great success and I am really full of admiration for Bombardier for taking on such an amazing project. I hope it is successful enough that they will also build a C500. BBD is an example of a strategic company that I say should NEVER be allowed to be sold to foreigners. If you do not know the difference between banana republic and Banana Republic... well...I need not say much more.
 
The inevitable outcome of this decision will be changes to the Telecom Act allowing foreign ownership of Canadian telecoms. The results of THAT will be mixed

Telecom is not the only industry that has foreign ownership restrictions. Banking and air travel are two others that also restrict foreign ownership.

Lifting foreign ownership restrictions might simply mean that Telus, Bell and/or Rogers will be bought out by foreigners (maybe a U.S. private equity fund). Is that what Canadians want? After all, this same government blocked the sale of Potash to BHP.
 
So by using American govenment actions as an example to SUPPORT what our govenment did, you think I am somehow bashing the US? I am not bashing the US or any other country for restricting ownership in certain industries. It just has to make sense for the entire economy.

LMAO, sounds like somebody is backtracking his relentless America bashing in the past here.

Looking for rock bottom condos/real estates in Florida or Hawaii or California to flip for quick bucks, eh? Or just spend the overvalued loonies fast and furious before the bubble burst? :rolleyes:

WRT restricting ownership in certain industries, are you professing your naivety all of a sudden when it's cool to serve your interest?

The Telco act made sense at the time, but it was more a cultural motive or to support what were at the time "natural monopolies". Now that is less relevant and several aspects of the act are obsolote.

Obsolote?? WTF is this?

Nothing against Tony the Tory Clement decision but as a lawyer himself, he would probably know well his decision is on shaky ground legally. His decision speaks more of "vote-buying" than anything else, just like Potash decision.

Plus, if he is the champion of free trade he claims to be, please explain why he does nothing at minimum to start address this act 1st day of his job? Why all of a sudden he overrules CRTC decision?

Like it or not, thank goodness the Court really shows the backbones to uphold the spirit of the act. It is not fair to blame the Court playing politics when the politicians for all sides are the ones who drop the ball.

It is also clear that Canada is FAR behind many countries in wireless. If you have travelled you will know that this is sadly very true.

LOL, I travel, not travell. Are you thinking of Morton's toe or something? It doesn't make any sense.

BTW, that's YOUR problem since I don't own ridiculously expensive "smart phone" and no thank you to Netflix.

C919 is a big step, it is a LONG way off, and does not yet compete with Cseries. I am hopeful and optimistic that Cseries will be a great success and I am really full of admiration for Bombardier for taking on such an amazing project.

Sure, typically PC answer. Good luck they make it before another big refinancing in 2016.

I hope it is successful enough that they will also build a C500.

What does Bombardier have to with HTC Typhoon?

BBD is an example of a strategic company that I say should NEVER be allowed to be sold to foreigners.

What? Are you a Francophone or Quebecois or something?

Not going to be surprised Bombardier could end up like Fairmont and Four Seasons, namely owned by foreigners and managed by the locals. The day could come when Bombardier Transportation JV partner in China, CSR and/or CNR take over, while AVIC takes over the Aerospace Division. That would happen when the credit crunch make a come back and being high-yield/Junk in debt ratings, Bombardier needs bailout by somebody.

If you do not know the difference between banana republic and Banana Republic... well...I need not say much more.

What's the "difference"? Care to elaborate?
 
LMAO, sounds like somebody is backtracking his relentless America bashing in the past here.

Looking for rock bottom condos/real estates in Florida or Hawaii or California to flip for quick bucks, eh? Or just spend the overvalued loonies fast and furious before the bubble burst? :rolleyes:

WRT restricting ownership in certain industries, are you professing your naivety all of a sudden when it's cool to serve your interest?



Obsolote?? WTF is this?

Nothing against Tony the Tory Clement decision but as a lawyer himself, he would probably know well his decision is on shaky ground legally. His decision speaks more of "vote-buying" than anything else, just like Potash decision.

Plus, if he is the champion of free trade he claims to be, please explain why he does nothing at minimum to start address this act 1st day of his job? Why all of a sudden he overrules CRTC decision?

Like it or not, thank goodness the Court really shows the backbones to uphold the spirit of the act. It is not fair to blame the Court playing politics when the politicians for all sides are the ones who drop the ball.



LOL, I travel, not travell. Are you thinking of Morton's toe or something? It doesn't make any sense.

BTW, that's YOUR problem since I don't own ridiculously expensive "smart phone" and no thank you to Netflix.



Sure, typically PC answer. Good luck they make it before another big refinancing in 2016.



What does Bombardier have to with HTC Typhoon?



What? Are you a Francophone or Quebecois or something?

Not going to be surprised Bombardier could end up like Fairmont and Four Seasons, namely owned by foreigners and managed by the locals. The day could come when Bombardier Transportation JV partner in China, CSR and/or CNR take over, while AVIC takes over the Aerospace Division. That would happen when the credit crunch make a come back and being high-yield/Junk in debt ratings, Bombardier needs bailout by somebody.



What's the "difference"? Care to elaborate?

I suppose you are used to sheep that bleat to one tune and cannot overcome ideological biases. I think there is a place for foreign ownership restrictions, where it makes sense. I am not surprised you don't have a Smart Phone. I guess having a phone smarter then you would be tough on your ego.


If you are going to make a big deal about spelling, at least be RIGHT (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/travelled) its so humiliating to be an incorrect smart ass. If you do not know the difference between the term "banana republic" and the company "Banana Republic" then I think it says a lot about you. I suggest you buy a smartphone and let it take over, you need all the help you can get. As for the C500 of course I meant CS500 but of course you would rather let your wonderful personality show.
 
Last edited:
I suppose you are used to sheep that bleat to one tune and cannot overcome ideological biases. I think there is a place for foreign ownership restrictions, where it makes sense. I am not surprised you don't have a Smart Phone. I guess having a phone smarter then you would be tough on your ego.

ROFLMAO, what ideological biases are you talking about? Pinko and Anti-American like yours?

WRT Smart Phone, let those punters overspent their money hand over fist, while savvy, smart money build up stakes on RCI.B, BCE, T, CSCO to generate capital gains and collect increasing dividends over time.

Not a fan of government bureaucracy but CRTC is doing the right thing to encourage Internet usage "meter" in place. :cool:

Sounds like you are those punters who line up the night before to be the first person getting whatever first release of "gadget porn" and though highly doubtful, have the same gadget on sale at eBay or something.

If you do not know the difference between the term "banana republic" and the company "Banana Republic" then I think it says a lot about you.

Again what's the difference? Both are overrated IMHO.

I suggest you buy a smartphone and let it take over, you need all the help you can get.

No thank you. I may consider one if IPhone or HTC are promoted as $0 down or something after trading in old ones.

BTW, you do know a big chunk of people who change smartphone all the time are also open to one-night stand. Not sure they are BB if that's the case.

As for the C500 of course I meant CS500 but of course you would rather let your wonderful personality show.

Don't recall the Beaudoin Sr and Jr are really that reckless to take your dumb suggestion. Not going to be surprised ambitious Brazilian Embarer or Chinese AVIC would agree you are an idiot supremo in Portuguese and Mandarin.

If I could recall, their first priority other than making sure C Series to be rolled out, on budget and on time will be to have their debt ratings upgraded to investment grade.