another outer space question: the spinning space station

  • Thread starter Thread starter burt-oh-my!
  • Start date Start date
I agree with Master_Bates analogy of tossing a coin in a car. Why would you land 'tilted'?
 
I used to use dilithium crystals in mine, before switching to cold-fusion zero-point antimatter generators.

Yeah, but what a lot of people don't know is that zero-point antimatter generators (ZPAGs) have a history of randomly disturbing the space-time continuum. That's why I switched to floating-point dual-synchronized non-peripheral static imbalance devices (FPDSNPSIDs) whenever I get the SLIGHTEST irregularity from my Space-Time Continuum-dometer.


Hell of a mess afterwards, but worth it for the extra margin of safety. Just like snow tires.
 
OK, enough. I call BS

Yeah, but what a lot of people don't know is that zero-point antimatter generators (ZPAGs) have a history of randomly disturbing the space-time continuum. That's why I switched to floating-point dual-synchronized non-peripheral static imbalance devices (FPDSNPSIDs) whenever I get the SLIGHTEST irregularity from my Space-Time Continuum-dometer.

Hell of a mess afterwards, but worth it for the extra margin of safety. Just like snow tires.

SNOW TIRES? You've been playing with me all along, haven't you? Come on, pull my positronic -nueuron finger again.
 
I agree with Master_Bates analogy of tossing a coin in a car. Why would you land 'tilted'?

Take the simplest case: you jump 1000 times faster than the linear rotational velocity: you'll hit your head on (almost but not quite) the station's other side - almost straight across the diameter. Draw a line from where you started, to the station's "center" to where you land. At 1000 times faster, this angle is slightly less than 180 degrees. You don't travel this path - you travel a straight line. To someone who didn't jump you travel an arc.

Now solve the problem for lower speeds. At each lower speed you you'll reduce that almost 180 degrees a bit more.

work your way down. If your jump speed is some lower multiple, say 2 to 3(just a guess) , you'll land on your stomach.

Less than that and you start landing on your "feet", more and more vertical.
 
Except once you jump, the centripetal force of the space station/floor is no longer acting on you so you don't have an angular velocity, just the linear tangential velocity that you had (like swinging an old fashioned slingshot and then letting go - the stone will fly in a straight line) plus a radial component from the 'jumping force'.
I guess that the example of jumping up and down on earth is different due to measurement scales and/or radii of curvature. A rigorous solution of the equations of motion can answer definitively whether the subtlties will be important and whether a jumper will notice that he/she lands in a different location. But, then again, a Foucault pendulum proves your point most clearly on the earth scale of dimensions, I would think.

It's late and I want to go beddie bye, my SO is calling me...........
 
he's wrong; after hitting the rotating frame and moving with it one is no longer inertial;

Upon rereading I think he is refering to the space outside the station ( not the walls of the station)when he says

"in the inertial frame, things don't accelerate unless there's a force on them, and all forces need to be exerted by something. Since the only force on you is from the moving air (which we'll ignore), you just keep on floating there, in the same position relative to the outside inertial frame"


He is also saying it is really centripetal forces at work not centrifugal ??

"The two fictitious forces we need to use here are the centrifugal force and the Coriolis force"
 
I guess it depends on the size of the spinning space station. The larger the radius, the less effect it would have.

There have been experiments on creating artificial gravity. The problem is that if you’re standing on the inside surface of rotating cylinder, your feet are moving at a faster rate than your head. Your brain can sense that you’re spinning and you get nauseous.

You would need a radius of perhaps several hundred meters before it would feel like real gravity.
 
A cheap way to get a real big radius would be to have the living module attached to long parallel cables (parallel to stoptwisting) , with either another one opposite or a counterweight attached opposite at shorter length. I suppose one could grab a small asteroid or two to provide the counterweight.

The design of the module would be with a floor curved slightly to match the arc of the circle you are swinging in.
 
I think in a space station you are in two reference frames at once. One is an inertial frame under-going constant acceleration (because you are standing on a floor going in a circle) so that centripetal force pushes you inward (the floor pushing on you). The other is a rotating frame of reference, which is really the frame of the station, from which it looks like you are at rest (you are standing on the floor) and in which centrifugal force pushes you outward (pulling you to the floor).

Referring to post 9 I believe you are correct

There are two points of view

In the inertial frame of reference Newtons laws apply but in the rotating frame of reference they do not so you make up fictitious laws to explain what happens if you jump up
 
Given the costs of getting building materials into orbit, the station's ceiling will be low enough to eliminate the possibility of jumping at all.

Please go on to discuss the truck full of budgies exceeding the weight limit for the bridge and whether accidentally leaving the back doors open and starting the truck when they're all in the air, would make it regain the weight it had lost as they were now dumped out the back.
 
Returning to the original question..... you actually wouldn't "fall back" in a sufficiently large vessel. While the ship is rotating you are rotating too. As is whatever atmosphere that exists inside the vessel. You just can't tell because your frame of reference is within the station. Someone watching from the outside of the station would see you jumping up and down in the same direction of the rotation.
A similar exercise can be performed on earth. Remember that you are on a planet that rotates at roughly 1670 kph. You cannot repeatedly jump vertically and find yourself in California.
There is no such thing as centrifugal force. It is centripetal acceleration.
 
Given the costs of getting building materials into orbit, the station's ceiling will be low enough to eliminate the possibility of jumping at all.

Please go on to discuss the truck full of budgies exceeding the weight limit for the bridge and whether accidentally leaving the back doors open and starting the truck when they're all in the air, would make it regain the weight it had lost as they were now dumped out the back.

Newtons third law states the truck will weigh the same if the door is closed but if it is open I suspect it will weigh less because some of the force applied by the flapping wings escapes ??

Consider: a truck with an airtight enclosed box holding a bag of balloons and a tank of helium. While the truck is sitting on the scale, the balloons are inflated and rise to the ceiling, which they push on. Does the truck weight become lighter?

Can you tell just by weighing the truck whether the balloons are inflated or not?
 
Last edited:
Returning to the original question..... you actually wouldn't "fall back" in a sufficiently large vessel. While the ship is rotating you are rotating too. As is whatever atmosphere that exists inside the vessel. You just can't tell because your frame of reference is within the station. Someone watching from the outside of the station would see you jumping up and down in the same direction of the rotation.
A similar exercise can be performed on earth. Remember that you are on a planet that rotates at roughly 1670 kph. You cannot repeatedly jump vertically and find yourself in California.
There is no such thing as centrifugal force. It is centripetal acceleration.

If you are implying you fall like you would on earth I believe you are wrong

" Suffice it to say that if you jump straight up on the space station, you'll travel on what (in the co-rotating frame) appears to be an arc, and land "forward" (i.e., in the direction the station is rotating) of where you started. This is a key difference between artificial gravity and the real kind. "


I beleive you are correct when you state "There is no such thing as centrifugal force. It is centripetal acceleration" because we are accelerating and not in an state of inertia ( it just seems like we are) and we are actually being drawn towards the center

But if you measured your speed would it not be constant ??? Yes but you have to take into account the force that is drawing you into the center This force can be considered accelaeration
 
Last edited:
Y.F. even on earth when you jump "vertically" in YOUR frame of reference you are simply jumping straight up and down however to an outside observer you have to add the rotation of the earth to your trajectory. Therefore if you have a "hang time" of lets say 10 seconds and a vertical jump of about 50 meters (for the sake of argument you are a very springie individual!) the outside viewer would have seen you cover a rotational distance of .464 meters. You LAND in the same spot but in the mean time that spot has moved almost half a meter under you and you have moved with it.
Einstein's discussion of frames of reference tells a similar story. if you are going down in an elevator and I shoot a bullet through it (without hitting you of course) I will see the path of the bullet remain straight while you as an observer from within the elevator will see the path of the bullet to actually be climbing from the point of entry to the point of exit.

But if you measured your speed would it not be constant ???

Relative to what?
 
But if you measured your speed would it not be constant ???

Relative to what?


The laws of inertia tell us that an object in motion remains moving in a straight line unless a force is applied. To keep you moving in a circle, the rotating object must continuously apply force to you to overcome this law of the straight line. As long as a force is being applied, you're accelerating, and a force is being applied so you are accelerating. End of argument

It seems to me that even though you are moving at the same speed you are accelerating but this acceleration force is neutralized by the centripetal force

From what relative point of view would I seem to be accelerating ( if I was in a space station or a fun wheel at the CNE ) in your opinion?
 
velocity has a speed AND a direction

if you are changing direction you are being accelerated

It seems to me that even though you are moving at the same speed you are accelerating but this acceleration force is neutralized by the centripetal force

centripetal force is the force that's doing the acceleration (aka the force that's changing the direction)
 
If you are on the earth the force of gravity would be of course pulling you back down to the earth.
Within the fictional rotating space station the outward "force" that pushes you back towards the "floor" is part of the original centripetal acceleration that you had - you may momentarily neutralize it however as it is constantly being applied to you it eventually pushes you back out.
Therefore if you are on the INSIDE of the ring you will be constantly pushed onto the ring. On the outside of the ring you would be flung away from the space station in the direction that the acceleration was being applied to you. (Remember that the acceleration is not along the circle of the ring but from the CENTER of the craft.)
A very good explanation is actually in a series of books by Ben Bova referred to as "Ringworld"
Acceleration = Force x distance. if there is no distance there is no acceleration.