another outer space question: the spinning space station

  • Thread starter Thread starter burt-oh-my!
  • Start date Start date
B

burt-oh-my!

OK, I get the idea of the spinning living quarters - the centrifugal force can act as a proxy for gravity.

However, my question is this: if you were to jump up as high as possible while in this thing, wouldn't there be a slight tendency to land a little bit tilted? Suppose you are facing the direction that the cynlinder is turning. At the moment you jump up, you have momentum on a tangent (please forgive my potentially poor use of mathematical terms etc - high school was many, many years ago) to the circle. Your momentum is NOT curved - it is straight line, so as you jump, your momentum moves you along that tangent line, while the floor beneath you turns on an arc, so if you jumped high enough wouldn't you land tilted forward? The smaller the cylinder, the bigger the effect.

And what happens to all the air in those things - the air is not attached to the cylinder, but of course there would be friction with the floor, so wouldn't there be a kind of constant wind generated?
 
NASA can give you more info
 
In this case size matters. If we're talking about the ISS, tilting may be a teeny tiny bit obvious relative to your initial position, more a result of not being able to jump up perfectly straight, but if you're talking about something like Babylon 5, it wouldn't matter.
 
If one jumped straight up on a spinnning space station, it would be very tricky to control direction. In a spinning environment, both acceleration and velocity are related to radius. Similar control problems occur when guiding ICBMs or rockets to and from space. A similar effect can be seen when launching a high-altitude balloon, however wind-speed effects tend to dominate for balloons.

In terms of rotation creating wind, this would not easily happen. Everything in the frame of reference is turning together. If everything is spinning together, the wind velocity will be constant. On the earth, the majority of average wind velocity comes from the gravitational effects of the moon, and the fact that the earth and moon spin at different speeds.
 
Ok - I'll give it a try. When you jump up - you have the same speed (thus momentum) as the floor that you are jumping from so you will cover the same distance and appear to land virtually in the same spot because your whole body keeps the same momentum. Since centripetal & gravity are acting the same on your body, you have the same effect as on the surface of the earth as pressed against the spinning floor. If this wasn't the case, the earth is traveling about 1,000mph as it rotates (equator) so if you jump up - why wouldn't you move backward at 1,000 mph ? Similarly we are orbiting the Sun at ~ 65,000 mph. If you jump up, why would you not move backward and out into space ?

My guess - do actually have a science guy on terb ?
 
Spinning does not create gravity it simulates it

If the earth was not spinning you would still have gravity

So if you junmped up in a spinning space station then your mometum would start to get lost as soon as you jumped so you would not land in the same spot ( as you would on earth) but behind it ?

Also as Cassiini pointed out the further you are from the center of the station the faster you are rotating so the more simulated gravity ?

This simulated gravity is really C force is it not ?

But why does this force hold you down instead of throwing you against the wall ? Is the floor you are walking on really the wall of the station ?
 
Spinning does not create gravity it simulates it

Gravity is just the name of the force holding you to the earth. A force is a force is a force, no matter the source!!!


it really is about frame of reference..... You're in a stationary car, toss a coin straight up, it comes straight down.... you toss a coin straight up in a moving car, it also comes straight down.

I assume it would be the same in a space station.
 
I've found my answer:

http://www.straightdope.com/columns...ing-a-space-station-create-artificial-gravity

Dear Straight Dope:

I was lying awake the other night and started reading some old science fiction by Heinlein, where he talks about rotating space stations. The theory is that the station spins and the centrifugal force creates pseudo-gravity. Now I can see this working when you are in physical contact with a surface but what happens if you are floating and they impress a spin on the ship you are in--does everything else experience "gravity" except you? What happens if you jump--do you go back down or do you head up to the ceiling? Questions like these do not help on a restless night.

— Steven, London, England

Spinning your space station will work (but of course! Would Heinlein lie to you?), but it's not quite perfect. To understand why, we need to go into the physics of the matter.

The first thing to consider when you're doing a problem like this is what frame of reference you're in. You can approach this from an inertial (non-rotating) frame, or from a non-inertial frame that's rotating with the space station. In the non-rotating frame you're not experiencing acceleration and Newton's laws of motion apply. In the rotating frame you are and they don't. The significance of this will become apparent in a moment.

For your first question, let's consider the inertial frame. You start off floating, then someone hits the switch and the space station starts rotating. In the inertial frame, things don't accelerate unless there's a force on them, and all forces need to be exerted by something. Since the only force on you is from the moving air (which we'll ignore), you just keep on floating there, in the same position relative to the outside inertial frame. Meanwhile, the solid structure of the space station is moving, so one of the walls will eventually come along and smack into you. Suddenly, you've got a force, and very quickly end up going the same speed as the station.

Staying in the inertial frame for a while, you've now recovered from hitting the wall (or rather, the wall hitting you), and have your feet on the floor--that is, the space station's outer rim. You're moving in a circle, so your direction of motion is constantly changing. Since acceleration is a change in velocity, and velocity includes speed and direction, that means that you've got a constant acceleration towards the center of the space station.

We'd better pause, because a lot of people get lost at this point. Let me repeat what I said above: When you're moving in a circle, you're under constant acceleration. This is counterintuitive. The space station (merry-go-round, whatever) is turning at a steady rate, and your speed doesn't appear to vary, so why do we say you're accelerating?

Because force is constantly being applied to you. Think about it. The laws of inertia tell us that an object in motion tends to remain moving in a straight line. To keep you moving in a circle, the rotating object must continuously apply force to you. As long as force is being applied, you're accelerating.

The direction of this force is inward, toward the center of the space station, so it's called the centripetal force (literally, towards the center). The force is being exerted on you by the floor (outer rim) of the space station, which is pushing on the soles of your feet. A force on your shoes from the floor is exactly what you feel here on Earth, so the result feels like gravity.

You may find this talk of centripetal force confusing. Most people are accustomed to thinking of rotating objects as imparting centrifugal force, i.e., one that flings you out rather than pulls you in. They're not wrong to do so; they're just using a different frame of reference--the rotating frame, to which we'll now turn our attention.

In the rotating frame, since you're just standing there, you're at rest. It's not an inertial frame of reference, though, and Newton's laws are designed only for inertial frames, so we need to fudge things a bit by introducing a couple of "fictitious" forces. Whereas real forces are always exerted by something, fictitious forces are not: They're just there, as a consequence of the frame you're in. Don't say they're not "real," though: They're useful, and that's all that really matters for physics. Einstein tells us that gravity is actually just a fictitious force, too, but that doesn't stop physicists from treating it as real.

The two fictitious forces we need to use here are the centrifugal force and the Coriolis force. The centrifugal is the easier to explain, and the more widely understood. Since you're standing "still" (in the rotating frame), and you can feel the force of the floor on your feet, it's necessary to posit another force, acting like gravity, pulling you down and countering the force from the floor. Since this force is pointing out from the center, it's called centrifugal, or "fleeing the center."

The Coriolis force is a bit more complicated. It only acts on moving objects, and causes their path to curve. The explanation for this is a bit involved, so I'll omit it here. Suffice it to say that if you jump straight up on the space station, you'll travel on what (in the co-rotating frame) appears to be an arc, and land "forward" (i.e., in the direction the station is rotating) of where you started. This is a key difference between artificial gravity and the real kind. So, if you wake up some morning and you're not sure where you are, jump up. If you land where you started, you're on earth. If you land forward of it, you're on a space station. Let it never be said we don't give you news you can use.

— Chronos
 
The first thing to consider when you're doing a problem like this is what frame of reference you're in. You can approach this from an inertial (non-rotating) frame, or from a non-inertial frame that's rotating with the space station. In the non-rotating frame you're not experiencing acceleration and Newton's laws of motion apply. In the rotating frame you are and they don't. The significance of this will become apparent in a moment.

For your first question, let's consider the inertial frame. You start off floating, then someone hits the switch and the space station starts rotating. In the inertial frame, things don't accelerate unless there's a force on them, and all forces need to be exerted by something. Since the only force on you is from the moving air (which we'll ignore), you just keep on floating there, in the same position relative to the outside inertial frame.

WTF ??? What outside inertial frame is he talking about if the whole thing starts moving ?

Is he saying everything moves except the outside wall?

Meanwhile, the solid structure of the space station is moving, so one of the walls will eventually come along and smack into you. Suddenly, you've got a force, and very quickly end up going the same speed as the station.





Staying in the inertial frame


But the frame is no longer inertial as it is moving !!!

for a while, you've now recovered from hitting the wall (or rather, the wall hitting you), and have your feet on the floor--that is, the space station's outer rim. You're moving in a circle, so your direction of motion is constantly changing. Since acceleration is a change in velocity, and velocity includes speed and direction, that means that you've got a constant acceleration towards the center of the space station.

We'd better pause, because a lot of people get lost at this point. Let me repeat what I said above: When you're moving in a circle, you're under constant acceleration. This is counterintuitive. The space station (merry-go-round, whatever) is turning at a steady rate, and your speed doesn't appear to vary, so why do we say you're accelerating?

Because force is constantly being applied to you. Think about it. The laws of inertia tell us that an object in motion tends to remain moving in a straight line. To keep you moving in a circle, the rotating object must continuously apply force to you. As long as force is being applied, you're accelerating.

The direction of this force is inward, toward the center of the space station, so it's called the centripetal force (literally, towards the center). The force is being exerted on you by the floor (outer rim) of the space station, which is pushing on the soles of your feet. A force on your shoes from the floor is exactly what you feel here on Earth, so the result feels like gravity.

You may find this talk of centripetal force confusing. Most people are accustomed to thinking of rotating objects as imparting centrifugal force, i.e., one that flings you out rather than pulls you in. They're not wrong to do so; they're just using a different frame of reference--the rotating frame, to which we'll now turn our attention.

In the rotating frame, since you're just standing there, you're at rest. It's not an inertial frame of reference, though, and Newton's laws are designed only for inertial frames, so we need to fudge things a bit by introducing a couple of "fictitious" forces. Whereas real forces are always exerted by something, fictitious forces are not: They're just there, as a consequence of the frame you're in. Don't say they're not "real," though: They're useful, and that's all that really matters for physics. Einstein tells us that gravity is actually just a fictitious force, too, but that doesn't stop physicists from treating it as real.

The two fictitious forces we need to use here are the centrifugal force and the Coriolis force. The centrifugal is the easier to explain, and the more widely understood. Since you're standing "still" (in the rotating frame), and you can feel the force of the floor on your feet, it's necessary to posit another force, acting like gravity, pulling you down and countering the force from the floor. Since this force is pointing out from the center, it's called centrifugal, or "fleeing the center."

The Coriolis force is a bit more complicated. It only acts on moving objects, and causes their path to curve. The explanation for this is a bit involved, so I'll omit it here. Suffice it to say that if you jump straight up on the space station, you'll travel on what (in the co-rotating frame) appears to be an arc, and land "forward" (i.e., in the direction the station is rotating) of where you started. This is a key difference between artificial gravity and the real kind. So, if you wake up some morning and you're not sure where you are, jump up. If you land where you started, you're on earth. If you land forward of it, you're on a space station. Let it never be said we don't give you news you can use.

Can someone explain the difference between the inertial and non inertial frames ???
 
OK, I get the idea of the spinning living quarters - the centrifugal force can act as a proxy for gravity.

However, my question is this: if you were to jump up as high as possible while in this thing, wouldn't there be a slight tendency to land a little bit tilted? Suppose you are facing the direction that the cynlinder is turning. At the moment you jump up, you have momentum on a tangent (please forgive my potentially poor use of mathematical terms etc - high school was many, many years ago) to the circle. Your momentum is NOT curved - it is straight line, so as you jump, your momentum moves you along that tangent line, while the floor beneath you turns on an arc, so if you jumped high enough wouldn't you land tilted forward? The smaller the cylinder, the bigger the effect.

And what happens to all the air in those things - the air is not attached to the cylinder, but of course there would be friction with the floor, so wouldn't there be a kind of constant wind generated?
No, because you would also be spinning with the same angular velocity as the space station. The earth spins, we jump and spin with the earth.
 
Gravity is just the name of the force holding you to the earth. A force is a force is a force, no matter the source!!!


it really is about frame of reference..... You're in a stationary car, toss a coin straight up, it comes straight down.... you toss a coin straight up in a moving car, it also comes straight down.

I assume it would be the same in a space station.

Except that the spin doesn't create a force on the person. The force of the floor is really the person attempting to travel in a straight line and being stopped by the floor that is accelerating towards the center.

p.s. for an earlier poster - "centrifugal force" isn't a force but a result of newtons law of inertia.
p.p.s. The straightdope answer looks good to me.
 
Gravity is just the name of the force holding you to the earth. A force is a force is a force, no matter the source!!!


it really is about frame of reference..... You're in a stationary car, toss a coin straight up, it comes straight down.... you toss a coin straight up in a moving car, it also comes straight down.

I assume it would be the same in a space station.

There would be lots of differences - gravity & fake gravity work differently.

These are just off the top of my head:

With gravity, if you drop 2 lead balls from the same height, but let's say chest width apart, they get closer to each other as they get closer to your feet.

If your space station is a sphere and you drop 2 lead balls - since here's nothing actually pushing the balls away from the centre, they will stay equidistant. Depending on the direction of rotation and its relative position to balls on release they may hit the ground at different times.

take light coming from your feet, the "direction of the gravity" or "the way gravity is pulling you". For the space station, this direction for the light is coming in toward the center - the light would be unchanged,

light coming from your feet on earth (say from a first floor to the top floor of a building) would be redshifted.

You could never make black holes with fake gravity (because the matter isn't really drawn together) ... you could smash stuff together after accelerating objects across 2 fake gravities, but that looks nothing like the gravitic case.

(I have to invent a slightly different situation for this, I explain at this paragraph's end) Suppose your spherical station is transparent (imagine living platforms at the ends of paired, symmetrical ropes/rods - like bolos - you live on the "inside surface" of the platforms - unlike bolos, these would be like lily pads - another picture: imagine a bicycle wheel with radial spokes, spoke nipples, and no rim) light passes by you (if it doesn't hit the tethers) and is completely unaffected - your "gravity" will not change the light in any way. I had to invent this type of space station - if you imagine say a clear glass station you have to account for refraction & slight speed slowdown

real gravity will bend the light (change the direction, independent of red/blue shifting) - for example you can see star B that's directly behind another star, A. A blocks B's straight-line, but you can still see B because A bends light from B that would have gone to the left or right, sending it to you. This was the classic experiment that "proved" general relativity. Some astronomers saw a star even when another star was known to be directly in the line of sight to earth and should have blocked the direct light.
 
Last edited:
No, because you would also be spinning with the same angular velocity as the space station. The earth spins, we jump and spin with the earth.

Except once you jump, the centripetal force of the space station/floor is no longer acting on you so you don't have an angular velocity, just the linear tangential velocity that you had (like swinging an old fashioned slingshot and then letting go - the stone will fly in a straight line) plus a radial component from the 'jumping force'.
 
zero motion or steady linear motion is inertial. Moving frames can be inertial. Accelerated frames are not.

Circular motion (say a car on the face of the earth, even if it moves exactly the same speed) is not inertial because it's accelerated (toward the direction of earth's center) but the radius of the earth is large enough that for all practical purposes you can treat it as inertial;

Even an orbit let's say like Pluto is not inertial - it's not linear, it's still being accelerated.

WTF ??? What outside inertial frame is he talking about if the whole thing starts moving ?

Is he saying everything moves except the outside wall?
But the frame is no longer inertial as it is moving !!!
Can someone explain the difference between the inertial and non inertial frames ???
 
WTF ??? What outside inertial frame is he talking about if the whole thing starts moving ?

Is he saying everything moves except the outside wall?

He starts with nothing moving. he says "start the thing rotating" - meaning the space station - so the outside wall starts rotating. If you are not touching the wall you will stay completely still. The wall and anything attached to it is the ONLY thing that moves. You (who started floating above the wall) may be in an inertial frame. The wall itself is no longer an inertial frame.

But the frame is no longer inertial as it is moving !!!

he's wrong; after hitting the rotating frame and moving with it one is no longer inertial;

you're wrong: it's not inertial because it's ROTATING; if it were just moving in a completely straight line it would be inertial.
 
Take the simplest case: you jump 1000 times faster than the linear rotational velocity: you'll hit your head on (almost but not quite) the station's other side - almost straight across the diameter.

Now work yourself down to simpler cases.

Left as an exercise for the student

OK, I get the idea of the spinning living quarters - the centrifugal force can act as a proxy for gravity.

However, my question is this: if you were to jump up as high as possible while in this thing, wouldn't there be a slight tendency to land a little bit tilted? Suppose you are facing the direction that the cynlinder is turning. At the moment you jump up, you have momentum on a tangent (please forgive my potentially poor use of mathematical terms etc - high school was many, many years ago) to the circle. Your momentum is NOT curved - it is straight line, so as you jump, your momentum moves you along that tangent line, while the floor beneath you turns on an arc, so if you jumped high enough wouldn't you land tilted forward? The smaller the cylinder, the bigger the effect.

And what happens to all the air in those things - the air is not attached to the cylinder, but of course there would be friction with the floor, so wouldn't there be a kind of constant wind generated?

If the cylinder's perfectly smooth and there's no temperature gradients, and you ignore the end caps (length much greater than radius) there would be wind at initial startup but it would settle down - for a cylinder the rotation itself would cause no wind - the winds would happen because of temperature gradients. There would not even be coriolis force winds (except at the end caps)

The rotation and the temperature gradients both would both cause winds for a spherical station.
 
Earth's mass "eats" the spacetime at your feet more than the spacetime at your head.

This looks like a force, acts like a force, smells like a force. but It ain't a force like friction or a magnet.

Gravity is just the name of the force holding you to the earth. A force is a force is a force, no matter the source!!!


it really is about frame of reference..... You're in a stationary car, toss a coin straight up, it comes straight down.... you toss a coin straight up in a moving car, it also comes straight down.

I assume it would be the same in a space station.
 
God, don't you guys know about inertial dampeners.