Toronto Police Officer Killed

Apparently you're not aware that the police have a no fire from moving vehicle rule, kind of makes sense, don't want any friendly fire victims ... most likely you would be screaming loudly had he opened fire after he got the idiot to stop in the first place so that's not a solution.

As for compensation ... of course this Officer's family will be compensated and it's very generous both from the Police Services and the Police Association ... now lets hear your rant about unfair uses of City tax dollars.

As for training, well I think this being a rather rare event speaks volumes about the training our Police receive. You seem to forget that this officer was the victim of a criminal bound and determined to cause as much damage as possible. This is why Police work is dangerous ... people are unpredictable.

Why are there always uneducated people out their willing to express their hatred and show their ignorance at the expense of a pointless tragedy.



kf1



I didn't suggest they fire from a moving vehicle, but fired on the plow as it approached the block.
 
Hmm, not surprising they charged him with 1st degree murder, but I think the chances of making that one stick are about zero. Probably 2nd degree murder or something of the nature. Proving intent and motive will be pretty difficult.
 
Very odd that this guy was homeless and didnt have a criminal record whatsoever
 
As I understand it in Canada "the party raising the issue must show based on the probabilities that 1) the person who committed the act was suffering from a disease of the mind, and 2) that at the time of the offence they were a) unable to appreciate the nature and quality of the act, or b) did not know it was wrong."

The Code section reads: 16. (1) No person is criminally responsible for an act committed or an omission made while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong.

This language is almost identical to that of the Federal Court standard in the U.S.

If you want a quick example D goes to a shoping centre and stabs several people killing them. D has sent several e-mails which say 'don't be angry with me when you hear what I've done.', D leaves the market and attempts to avoid capture. D is going to have a hard time with an insanity defence even if D is "nuts." since it seems that D knew what he was doing was wrong. Now on the other hand D, doesn't send any e-mails, walks out the door calmly starts walking down the street and stops to talk with people, pick flowers etc. . . it would seem that perhaps D didn't know that what he was doing was wrong. These are overly simplistic examples and I know there are holes in them - but hopefuly you get the idea. It all boils down to knowing right from wrong. Look at David Berkowitz the Son of Sam Killer he will likely die still in the New York State Prison System.

Actually a perfect example of this is Jeffrey Dalmer.

He was nuts, we all know he was crazy and had problems, but Wisconsin law is similiar to ours, in that since he knew what he was doing was wrong ( something he freely admitted too ) he was not considered criminally insane by law. So off to regular prison he went.

This does not mean he was "sane" by any stretch of the imigination , just he was responsible for his actions regardless of them.
 
its a ferrari/masserati dealership. Just one question, what makes this death sadder than other residents of this city? We live in a capitalistic society, you choose what you want to be. I am sad for any needless death like this, but lets realize people die everyday and we never even hear a whisper.

maserati...great..i imagine they would be even more pompous!
 
Whenever anyone dies on the job it's a tragedy performing their chosen career. It bothers me when a police officer is killed on the job its portrayed as more tragic then a person killed in another profession.

All lives lost while on the job are equal yet they don't make the headlines if your profession involves a gun in your hand like a cop or a solder.
 
Whenever anyone dies on the job it's a tragedy performing their chosen career. It bothers me when a police officer is killed on the job its portrayed as more tragic then a person killed in another profession.

All lives lost while on the job are equal yet they don't make the headlines if your profession involves a gun in your hand.

When was the last time you stood in from of the memorial just east of the CBC downtown and pondered 'anything'.
 
Whenever anyone dies on the job it's a tragedy performing their chosen career. It bothers me when a police officer is killed on the job its portrayed as more tragic then a person killed in another profession.

All lives lost while on the job are equal yet they don't make the headlines if your profession involves a gun in your hand
Also most people (myself included) feel an attack on a cop is an attack on us all
 
Also most people (myself included) feel an attack on a cop is an attack on us all

Maybe there's more of an attachment than that one. I don't remember the last time my mailman, my housekeeper, or the guy building the new highrise across the road putting themselves in harms way against the crazies of the world. There aren't many who do.
 
I was there...http://www.google.ca/imgres?imgurl=...aXQCA&esq=1&page=1&ndsp=12&ved=1t:429,r:0,s:0

Any of us in that picture are at higher risk of being injured of killed on the job then a police officer.

Nice google. The construction workers do risk themselves, but do they protect or save people from whomever.

Considering there are perhaps a million workers in construction and less than 70,000 police officer, maybe it's a sense of the thin blue line between us and them that gives rise to that bond.
 
Nice google. The construction workers do risk themselves, but do they protect or save people from whomever.

Considering there are perhaps a million workers in construction and less than 70,000 police officer, maybe it's a sense of the thin blue line between us and them that gives rise to that bond.

Just to be clear I'm not trying to demean this guys death yesterday while on the job but you'll never ever convince me the loss of his life is more important then any other worker.
 
I actually took the time to look up your recent posts and nearly 70% of them blast the police in some way ... hey good for you ... you got a hobby, your mommy must be proud.

As for firing on a moving vehicle, or from a moving vehicle sorry it's actually kind of hard to follow your particular form of paranoia. I actually have to reference a previous poster in this thread who essentially said had they opened fired you would be the first to complain about reckless Police behavior and why couldn't they box the truck in a peacefully take the guy away ... need I remind you that's exactly what the murdered Police officer was in the middle of doing when the driver gunned his car and smashed the officer between the truck and the Police car.

What I find sad about pathetic whiners like yourself is you wish people to hear your paranoid views when we all really don't care and that instead of being a Monday morning quarterback we should be expressing sorrow for a man who gave his life to his community so that we can be safe.

Crawl back into your hole I'm sure the demons in the dark of that hole will be interested in your brand of paranoia.

kf1

I am noty a big fan of the Police in Canada.. so what.. I may not be in the majority, but it is a substantial and growing minority....as I said, WTF did he get out when the vehicle was not fully imobilized.
 
Hmm, not surprising they charged him with 1st degree murder, but I think the chances of making that one stick are about zero. Probably 2nd degree murder or something of the nature. Proving intent and motive will be pretty difficult.
Nottyboi, I provided you with the pertinent statutory language yesterday. If you read it you would realize why you are mistaken.
 
Just to be clear I'm not trying to demean this guys death yesterday while on the job but you'll never ever convince me the loss of his life is more important then any other worker.

I'm not accusing you at all of that and your words do reflect your thoughts regarding his death, but you asked about why people seem to hold police in a different light and I hope I explained that bond.
 
Regardless of mental illness being involved it remains a criminal offense. The fact that there is a possibility that this individual couldn't form the intent required to be found responsible is a legitimate defense and something for the courts to decide. As such I have to say the behaviour is criminal so I don't get your point.

kf1
Ok let's put it in "plain English": The guy may be "crazy", however just because you are "crazy" does not mean that you are not legaly responsible for his death.

Or

You may be "crazy" but you may still be legaly responsible for your actions.
 
So your saying the action is criminal, why did you make a post quoting my criminal action part ... seemed kind of pointless.

Let's see I wrote: From what has been in the newspapers there seemingly may be mental illness involved. That does not, however, necessarily mean Richard Kochkar has an insanity defence.

You then wrote:

Regardless of mental illness being involved it remains a criminal offense. The fact that there is a possibility that this individual couldn't form the intent required to be found responsible is a legitimate defense and something for the courts to decide. As such I have to say the behaviour is criminal so I don't get your point. This was in many ways a paraphrase of what I had posted

To which I replied: Ok let's put it in "plain English": The guy may be "crazy", however, just because you are "crazy" does not mean that you are not legaly responsible for his death.

Or

You may be "crazy" but you may still be legaly responsible for your actions.


And then you say my post seemed kind of pointless, I can certainly say the same.