Grabovski Shootout Goal

Kilgore Trout

Active member
Oct 18, 2008
2,489
0
36
Should the Leafs trade Grabovski ?? His market vaule is at his highest or is he a keeper ... Durning every contract renewal the Leafs will have to over pay cause of the threat of KHL ..
I would agree he might fetch more return than he is worth.
I think the shoot out has been good for the NHL ... It's like the NHL's version of slam dunk competion

As a traditionalist I disagree as I have no problem with the game ending in a tie.
 
the shootout is the biggest joke going, the novelty is gone from this piece of crap.
 
the novelty is gone from this piece of crap.
As was terribly evident from the moment they even discussed it. They cited the excitement of a shootout in the Olympics, but I knew it was only exciting because it was, as you say, a novelty.

There has been talk that the league feels too many games are going to a shootout. I guess that means they can either go back to allowing a tie (I agree with Oracle) or try to trick up the overtime. Is there any doubt as to which way they'd proceed?
 
Should the Leafs trade Grabovski ?? His market vaule is at his highest or is he a keeper ... Durning every contract renewal the Leafs will have to over pay cause of the threat of KHL ..

If the deal is right make the trade. At the moment he is arguably the Leaf's best player.I don't think their is a player on that team that is untouchable.
If you can improve the team make the trade. That seems to be Burke's theory but so far not very successful.
 
It was an amazing goal.

Too bad the "purists" think that sort of thing is showboating... unless their teammate is the one doing it. (See: Tampa Bay's reaction to the Oilers' Omark vs. their reaction to Stamkos.)

I think the shoot out has been good for the NHL ... It's like the NHL's version of slam dunk competion

...Except regular season NBA games aren't decided in a dunk-off. :rolleyes:
 
It was an amazing goal.

Too bad the "purists" think that sort of thing is showboating... unless their teammate is the one doing it. (See: Tampa Bay's reaction to the Oilers' Omark vs. their reaction to Stamkos.)



...Except regular season NBA games aren't decided in a dunk-off. :rolleyes:

I don't consider myself a "purist" as I do like to see changes that make sense; but IMHO hockey is a team game so it's fundementally wrong to determine the final outcome by individual plays. I'd rather see a 3-on-3 or 4-on-3 pp to decide the extra point, if we really have to do that.

Shootouts belong to the all-star games or as a skill contest. Just because soccer is doing it doesn't make it right. Can you imagine if NBA should decide to end o/t with free-throws ?
 
I don't consider myself a "purist" as I do like to see changes that make sense; but IMHO hockey is a team game so it's fundementally wrong to determine the final outcome by individual plays. I'd rather see a 3-on-3 or 4-on-3 pp to decide the extra point, if we really have to do that.

Shootouts belong to the all-star games or as a skill contest. Just because soccer is doing it doesn't make it right. Can you imagine if NBA should decide to end o/t with free-throws ?

That wasn't my point. The goal WAS amazing - one of the best I've seen.

I don't like the shootout as currently constituted - hence the comment about NBA games not being decided by dunk-offs - although I think if done right, there is a place for it in the regular season.
 
That wasn't my point. The goal WAS amazing - one of the best I've seen.

I don't like the shootout as currently constituted - hence the comment about NBA games not being decided by dunk-offs - although I think if done right, there is a place for it in the regular season.

So .... what way would be the correct way?
 
The biggest issue I have with the shootout is not shootout itself, but that it becomes a three point game.

They have essentially killed the value of a tie game in the third period, when both teams start to play for overtime and the extra "expected" points. If they made a win in regulation worth three points that might make the third period of a tie game much better.
 
The biggest issue I have with the shootout is not shootout itself, but that it becomes a three point game.

They have essentially killed the value of a tie game in the third period, when both teams start to play for overtime and the extra "expected" points. If they made a win in regulation worth three points that might make the third period of a tie game much better.

I like what you are saying but take it a step further 3 pts for a win in regulation 2 pts for a win in OTor a SO and 1 pt OTL
 
What is the rule on a shootout? Does the shooter have to constantly move forward? Can a shooter move sideways or even backwards?

Another question: I'm watching the Leafs Thrasher game. The Thrasher pulled their starting goalie and then put him back in again. What is the rule on pulling your goalie and then putting him back in again?
 
What is the rule on a shootout? Does the shooter have to constantly move forward? Can a shooter move sideways or even backwards?

Another question: I'm watching the Leafs Thrasher game. The Thrasher pulled their starting goalie and then put him back in again. What is the rule on pulling your goalie and then putting him back in again?

The rule is if you pull a goalie, you can only put him back in againn if the coach wants to.
 
The rule is if you pull a goalie, you can only put him back in againn if the coach wants to.

I wonder why baseball doesn't adopt the same rule for their players. It gets a little ridiculous in a 16 inning game when the shortstop is pitching for your team.
 
So .... what way would be the correct way?
Well, you and Maurice already touched on it:

The biggest issue I have with the shootout is not shootout itself, but that it becomes a three point game.

They have essentially killed the value of a tie game in the third period, when both teams start to play for overtime and the extra "expected" points. If they made a win in regulation worth three points that might make the third period of a tie game much better.
I like what you are saying but take it a step further 3 pts for a win in regulation 2 pts for a win in OT or a SO and 1 pt OTL[/SOL]

For me: 3 points for a win in regulation OR overtime to avoid teams playing for a point at all. Then 2pts for a SO winner and 1pt for the loser.

I'd also like to see the shootout expanded to five shooters. If you're going to "entertain the fans," then go all-in. Plus it takes away some of the luck.

But then again, I'd also like to see two five-minute sudden victory OT periods before getting to the shootout: one four-on-four, the other three-on-three.

As you can tell, I'm open to a variety of formats. I just don't love the current system.
 
For me: 3 points for a win in regulation OR overtime to avoid teams playing for a point at all. Then 2pts for a SO winner and 1pt for the loser.
I say zero for the loser. That is what overtime should be and that makes it exciting. Everyone knows overtime in the playoffs is way more exciting than regular season. That is because everything is on the line. It's all or nothing. Otherwise get rid of the bloody gimmicky overtime and a tie is a tie. One point each.

Might as well leave it at 2 for the win in that case.