A Surprising Request from a former S.O.

I don't think she was being manipulative, or cold, or calculating. I would have listened to her intently, thanked her for the honour of asking me, told her I would really think about it. I would then do her the honour in return and really think about it, but then probably told her a day or two later that after a lot of thought it wasn't something I was prepared do, and express again how proud I am that she considered me worthy of asking.

I think the only thing DD did wrong is blew her off a little rudely. When someone asks you a Big Thing like that, whether it's "marry me", or "father my child", or whatever, you should show a little respect in the way you answer the question, especially when the answer is "no". She asked a big enough thing that it deserved a real think, unless you really just wanted to insult her--in which case, that really must have put her down.

Showing some respect doesn't mean you have to compromise on your beliefs or values.
 
I don't think she was being manipulative, or cold, or calculating. I would have listened to her intently, thanked her for the honour of asking me, told her I would really think about it. I would then do her the honour in return and really think about it, but then probably told her a day or two later that after a lot of thought it wasn't something I was prepared do, and express again how proud I am that she considered me worthy of asking.

I think the only thing DD did wrong is blew her off a little rudely. When someone asks you a Big Thing like that, whether it's "marry me", or "father my child", or whatever, you should show a little respect in the way you answer the question, especially when the answer is "no". She asked a big enough thing that it deserved a real think, unless you really just wanted to insult her--in which case, that really must have put her down.

Showing some respect doesn't mean you have to compromise on your beliefs or values.

thank you, you explained it better than i could have. it is for this reason that i feel an apology may be in order.
 
I'm with Fuji on this. One needs to take time to decide on such a major matter.

Not that it matters in this case, but I probably would have said "yes".
 
I'm with Fuji on this. One needs to take time to decide on such a major matter.

Not that it matters in this case, but I probably would have said "yes".

I see your point, and if one has not thought about the subject being raised that is indeed a good course to follow. But if you have already considered your feelings on the subject, why make her wait only to turn her down?

If someone proposes marriage, how often is the return reply "Lemme think about it and I'll get back in touch with you in a few days"? And if such a reply is made, how likely is it to be considered a good thing by the proposer?

Assuming she laid it out on the table in the manner the OP related, I would expect that a reply in a similar format would not be taken amiss.
 
I don't think she was being manipulative, or cold, or calculating. I would have listened to her intently, thanked her for the honour of asking me, told her I would really think about it. I would then do her the honour in return and really think about it, but then probably told her a day or two later that after a lot of thought it wasn't something I was prepared do, and express again how proud I am that she considered me worthy of asking.

I think the only thing DD did wrong is blew her off a little rudely. When someone asks you a Big Thing like that, whether it's "marry me", or "father my child", or whatever, you should show a little respect in the way you answer the question, especially when the answer is "no". She asked a big enough thing that it deserved a real think, unless you really just wanted to insult her--in which case, that really must have put her down.

Showing some respect doesn't mean you have to compromise on your beliefs or values.

Even thinking about something like that is nothing short of crazy in my opinion. Regardless of what you two agreed on, Ontario law recognizes you as the father. If she was to find herself in tough financial times what's to stop her from stating you are the father? Courts will set a monthly support amount and it will be retroactive. If you can't make timely payments they'll simply garnish your wages until you are caught up. So if you're behind by 5 years at say 5000 a year, you owe her 25 grand. The FRO (to my knowledge) takes 50% of your salary when playing catch up.

Any chick that asks a question like this is either 1 of 2 things. She's stupid as bag of hammers or has an ulterior motive (or both). Not to mention how irresponsible that is to just have a baby on a whim. I think the reality is pretty easy on this one dude. She's aging, her eggs are fading & she sees you as a chump that's stupid enough to consider it. Me, I'd run for the hills.

I do have to ask one thing. Don't you think that it's extreme to not date her just because she smokes? I am a fitness buff and I hate cigarettes myself but it wouldn't be a deal killer. Given the number of women with REAL issues (gold diggers, clingy, etc) I can't see smoking as that bad.
 
Even thinking about something like that is nothing short of crazy in my opinion.

Ever turn down a marriage proposal? Or just turned someone down when they said they wanted to be your girlfriend? Were you a complete fucking asshole about it?

When someone puts themselves out there for you, pays you a huge complement by saying you're the one they've chosen, for any of these things, then even if you know in a split second that your answer is "no" you take your time and at least appear to think about it before telling them "no" just as a sign of respect.

I would have answered "no" to this question too. I would have said something like, "You know right now I don't plan on having kids, and I may never have kids of my own, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't love my kids if I had them. I think if I had kids, I would feel I had to be part of their life. I'd have to be their father. I couldn't live with myself if I wasn't. And you know, right now, I'm not in a good position to be a father, so I think this isn't something I can do for you at this point in my life."

That's the message I would have delivered the next day. Even if I didn't really have to think about it, even if I knew my answer right away, I would, on protocol, out of respect, demonstrate that I took the request in all the seriousness it was asked, and that I respected that she was paying me a compliment and an honour by thinking of me as the best person to father her children.
 
If someone proposes marriage, how often is the return reply "Lemme think about it and I'll get back in touch with you in a few days"?

Always???

If you mean the moment in which the question was REALLY asked, rather than the formal question, I think it's ALWAYS let me think.

In your own way you should have asked and answered the question before actually asking the question. My wife knew I was going to propose to her long before I actually did. We had already had had enough "what if" conversations that I already knew what her answer would be. The actual proposal when it came was just a formality--an event I tried to make beautiful and memorable, but we both already knew what was going to be asked, and what was going to be answered.

Certainly the first time we had those "what if" conversations the "what if" answer was "let me think about it".
 
Hey DD, good on you. As soo as I heard "Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important." I'd have been out of there. It's akin to a dancer telling me she didn't care about me, she just cared about the contents of my wallet. The least she could have done was shine you on a bit, make it worth your while. As far as the "No Strings Attached" goes, everyone here is right. You'd be at the XSOs mercy when it came down to it financially. Keep on keepin' on.
 
with all due respect to you, i'm not sure what your issue was here. she asked you to be a donor, not a father or husband. as a previous poster mentioned, you should take this as a compliment and an honour that she would ask you in the first place. you have your own outlook on childrearing which you are completely entitled to, but was there really a reason for you to come down on her because her ideas about childrearing and the concept of family differ from yours? lots of people come from mixed families, single parent families.... sure i also think that its ideal for both a mother and father to be present in a childs life, but just because that isnt possible for this woman, does that mean she should be denied a child of her own?

furthermore, i dont really think that you can consider the desire to have a child as a "checklist" item. its not like you can just go have a kid and then say, ok great! got that one done! most women feel the biological urge to have children, its not like she wants to keep up with the jones'es by having one.

love definitely is the higher law, but maybe she wants a child so she can experience that kind of love (the love between a mother and child)?

i didnt really see the "cold calculating and clinical" that you saw. wouldnt it be more calculating and clinical to go get a sperm donor? she obviously thought highly enough of your good qualities that she wanted you to be the father, that seems quite warm and thoughtful.

i feel that you may owe this lady an apology...

I disagree.

IMHO, he owes her nothing. He was honest with her, she just didn't like the answer.

She was just looking for a Sperm Donor and the OP wasn't comfortable with the notion of simply impregnating her and walking away. After reading the OP's description of the woman's outlook on relationships with men (almost a necessary evil) I would think that the only reason she was tearing up was because she wasn't getting her way. She had hatched a plan, had fantasized about what it might be like and DD had the unmitigated gall to burst her balloon.

Sorry, I have no sympathy for her. If she wants to have a baby, she should put more effort into finding a good man to be a father.
 
Ever turn down a marriage proposal? Or just turned someone down when they said they wanted to be your girlfriend? Were you a complete fucking asshole about it?

When someone puts themselves out there for you, pays you a huge complement by saying you're the one they've chosen, for any of these things, then even if you know in a split second that your answer is "no" you take your time and at least appear to think about it before telling them "no" just as a sign of respect.

I would have answered "no" to this question too. I would have said something like, "You know right now I don't plan on having kids, and I may never have kids of my own, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't love my kids if I had them. I think if I had kids, I would feel I had to be part of their life. I'd have to be their father. I couldn't live with myself if I wasn't. And you know, right now, I'm not in a good position to be a father, so I think this isn't something I can do for you at this point in my life."

That's the message I would have delivered the next day. Even if I didn't really have to think about it, even if I knew my answer right away, I would, on protocol, out of respect, demonstrate that I took the request in all the seriousness it was asked, and that I respected that she was paying me a compliment and an honour by thinking of me as the best person to father her children.

Hey dude, I'm no saying he had to be rude about it, but he could answer immediately saying no. I'm sorry bud, but turning down a marriage proposal, etc is far different from having someone ask you to knock them up.

Look man, a woman asking that = the following: She gets pregnant, realizes "holy fuck, raising a kid is expensive" then turns to the "father" to pay up. This costs him $5000 a year in support for 20 years. Total 100K. Plus, on top of that there is going to be Christmas, Birthdays & likely some type of visits costing a dude his weekends. Oh, plus hockey and college.

Assume the total cost is 150 grand. So does replying no way immediately seem so "fucked up" now?

Any chick that seems so hell bent on having a kid like that probably isn't suitable to have a kid anyways AND dude will end up paying.
 
I think it's OK for a woman (or a man for that matter) to make a rational decision to be a single parent. It's not for everyone but the "nuclear family" isn't for everyone either.

On the other hand, I would personally be pretty uncomfortable with the knowledge that a child of mine was "out there" in the world without my involvement. I would have declined her request too but I would not fault someone else if they took a different decision.

Of course, there's a danger to getting involved in this sort of circumstance. The lady may really believe she can do this on her own and may be shocked to learn just how big of a responsibility and life-changer become a parent can be. As the man in this transaction, you don't want to get a phone call at 3:00am when the baby is five months old telling you she needs your help and/or financial support.
 
Since I decided to share this with the Collective Brotherhood (and a few select sisters), I thought a little further clarification on some comments might be in order:

I'd say the "benefits" part of the relationship just ended!

Truth be told, I have no further desire to partake of the benefits anymore. Firstly, it just wouldn't be prudent and an odd conversation to have after this particular episode. Secondly, my heartlust is just not in it anymore when it comes to her.

I think the only thing DD did wrong is blew her off a little rudely. When someone asks you a Big Thing like that, whether it's "marry me", or "father my child", or whatever, you should show a little respect in the way you answer the question, especially when the answer is "no". She asked a big enough thing that it deserved a real think, unless you really just wanted to insult her--in which case, that really must have put her down.

I felt that since I knew what my reply would be, it would be cruel to string her along for a day or two more. Please keep in mind that she is a former S.O. and we have a history. We lived together for two years at one point and the topic of children came up then but she decided she wasn't ready. I was one of the relationships she sacrificed in order to advance her career. I suppose she thought I could always be her 'Plan B'. I am nobody's 'Plan B'. Nobody should be.

I also have to keep in mind my present S.O. who I have a great deal of affection for. I could never do something like this to her. Hobbying occasionally and flirting on business trips is one thing. Those little adventures are like intermissions or musical interludes. They are not permanent. Also. I'm not married to and don't live with my present S.O. If and when I cross that bridge, adaptation to lifestyle will be included. Having a child with another woman is a permanent thing. You can't negotiate a baby.

Any chick that asks a question like this is either 1 of 2 things. She's stupid as bag of hammers or has an ulterior motive (or both). Not to mention how irresponsible that is to just have a baby on a whim.

She's not stupid. She's also half British/half Korean, well raised, impeccable manners and a stunner to look at. I'm sure she thought hard and long how she would present this scenario to me.

I do have to ask one thing. Don't you think that it's extreme to not date her just because she smokes? I am a fitness buff and I hate cigarettes myself but it wouldn't be a deal killer. Given the number of women with REAL issues (gold diggers, clingy, etc) I can't see smoking as that bad.

As I mentioned, I lived with her for two years during our relationship. I put up with the smoking then and during our courtship time. I already lost two very close relatives to cancer (non-smokers) and hated to see her give that evil disease a 'helping hand'.

He was honest with her, she just didn't like the answer.

I'm still very honored that she asked me. The least I could do was to be honest with her.
 
You gave her your honest opinion/answer, you kept your morals and priorities in order...you didn't fall into a trap just because you still had a thing for her. Don't regret anything, you made the right choice, the one's on here that said you handled it wrong...aren't in your shoes.
 
"I felt that since I knew what my reply would be, it would be cruel to string her along for a day or two more. Please keep in mind that she is a former S.O. and we have a history. We lived together for two years at one point and the topic of children came up then but she decided she wasn't ready. I was one of the relationships she sacrificed in order to advance her career. I suppose she thought I could always be her 'Plan B'. I am nobody's 'Plan B'. Nobody should be."

HERE! HERE!! Never be someone's fall back position.
As well as you said that the ship had sailed you never mentioned another SO.
Out of respect for her (and the fact that there may be OTHER SO's in the future) being a Sperm donor in any case is just plain silly.
 
DD, you answered badly.

In her imagination, getting ready to pop this question to you, she was probably dreaming of you answering: "Yes, I would love to do that. In fact, if you'll let me, I'd like to share the parenting costs with you."

So, that's what you should have said. Then ho! for a vasectomy, asap.
 
I think the OP handled it reasonably well. I'd be flattered too if offered such a thing, but would also have declined. In fact her response was indeed cold and calculating - and as cynical as I am about some male-female relationship issues, I doubt that she represents most women's view on relationships and family.

There are also likely financial obligations (apart from the noble parental instinct ones) too.
 
Shocking, never heard this kind of story before. Average westernized/urban woman that is unsuitable as a mother or wife fucks around/jumps from cock to cock--I mean, "sacrifices" relationships (LOL)--until her earl/mid 30s then gets baby rabies.
 
there's this amazing thing i noticed about women...

when they get the biological clock ticking inside them thats ticking so loud that they don't care or are no longer aware of their own common sense anymore...

they become hell bent on having children. they'll even throw out the window the notion of any other potential they might have, any other promising future they could have, any dreams or hopes they had or could pursue...

i knew a girl who had everything going for her. she even told everyone she wanted to build and manage/set up/direct a centre for youth because she said she cared for youths that are troubled/lost, etc etc etc...

she was very tall, had the body of a supermodel, the face of a supermodel, the measurements of a supermodel, the legs that went on for miles and miles...when her hair was dyed blonde...she honestly looked like a victoria secret catwalker.

so, she had everything. her dreams, she went to school for youth counselling (or something, i forgot) and graduated after her aunt paid the full tuition of 20,000.

and so she had everything to succeed and go far in life. all she had to do was pursue a job, land herself a career and start saving up for her dream home and decent very well off living with modelling on the side. (She even took some modelling training..)

suddenly, she hits her 25th birthday.

and she starts talking about how she is getting really old...

and she starts dating guys like mad.

the first player gets her pregnant and he turns out to be a total asshole, dumps her immediately and only wanted NSA and FWB. so she decides to go through the pregnancy alone and delivers her first baby. forgetting all about school and landing a job and forgetting she graduated college in youth counselling.

she dates boyfriend #2 and he gets her to move in with him. the very next year. she has baby #2.

now she just had baby #3 and they haven't even gotten married yet.

with 3 kids and now a stay at home mom for more than three years, raising 3 kids. her career in youth counselling and any notions of modelling has been placed on the backburner for years to come...

when the biological clock hits women and they get the need to have children, nothing else matters. they throw everything else out the window.

and the notion of money and how much its gonna cost them and the risks they take doesn't even enter their minds. they just go all gung-ho and take on all the risks that go with it.



---

another example is this girl i knew back in elementary.

she and her husband is flat broke. they can barely afford to pay the rent. the landlord is trying to get them evicted. They are trying to fight it in court and trying to pay the legal fees as well. she's flat broke, she has two kids and yet.....she's still in her 20's and even after all this...she still wants to have one or two or three more kids before she hits 30. Even with all the legal troubles, with the looming threat of being homeless with 2 kids already and while feeling seriously depressed....

she wants to get pregnant yet again. have another kid before she hits 30....even though she's struggling through some serious issues...and even though she might not even be able to afford to feed 1 extra mouth. its amazing that women don't even think about these things when they suddenly feel the need to have children.
----

the bottom line?

when a woman wants to have kids. they want to have kids before it is too late. they want to have kids before they hit 30 years old - which is the age that is considered by all women to be the age number where it is too late to have kids amongst all women. they will get impregnated by any guy if necessary. nothing else matters. not money. not their current situation. not their financial situation, not their future, not their career. not their s.o. nothing else matters.
 
Granted, I am not from North America and am very proud of my warm European roots.

Warm European Roots?? Dude, you dropped a hot, intelligent, financially independent woman who liked you only for you ...because she smokes? You Sir are a Canadian if ever there was such thing!

Other than that ... thanks for the thread and talking point. It's your life and your sperm and you are absolutely entitled to your choice - it's a highly personal decision for which you do not actually owe an explanation - and if you offer an explanation as a courtesy, it does not have to make sense to anyone but yourself.

I don't think you need to dwell on it or conciously re-visit the matter as some have hinted. The choice is best made on gut instinct and what "feels right" intuitively.

Of course, you must never have sex with this woman again or let her withing 300 yards of your semen unless you have a vasectomy. When a woman has tunnel vision on pregnancy for whatever reason, she will stop at nothing.
 
Last edited: