Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

The West Bank is no where near a prison. There are continual imports and exports through Jordan and the economy is improving. It is generally peaceful with the PA police actually able to act like a modern responsible police force. There are not huge numbers of Palestinian dead in the West Bank and that is simply because the Palestinian Authority is not stupidly focused on attacking and destroying Israel.

As for the weekly protests being violent, both the protesters and the police are guilty of that.


That being said, I have not interest in moving to the West Bank (or Israel) and I have absolutely no respect for the settlement movement but the lives of Palestinians under Fatah are far better than those under Hamas.
 
Tell that to Gilad Shalit.

you are bitching about one prinsoner? What about the hundreds of prisoners Israel has? Including children and minors? What about the court sanctioned torture they conduct?
 
you are bitching about one prinsoner? What about the hundreds of prisoners Israel has? Including children and minors? What about the court sanctioned torture they conduct?

Court sanctioned torture? have not heard of any does not mean it is not happening, although I would rather be in ISrali custody than Hamas for some reason.
Unless memory fails me the prisoners that Isral is holding are entitled to court appearances, due process, and were apprehended braeking a law of some description. The one prisoner that you dismiss was kidnapped and has been held without any of the above due processes for a while.

And one more thing, yes kidnapping a citizen is a provocation for an invasion, 1 or 1000 the number does not matter
 
And one more thing, yes kidnapping a citizen is a provocation for an invasion, 1 or 1000 the number does not matter

Do you mean that Gaza and the West Bank should invade Israel? Do you mean the refugee camps should also invade?
 
You've done great. In a short period of time you justify shooting a pregnant woman because she was a settler and then you justify soldiers hiding among civilians. Maybe you should put away the bottle and go to sleep.

Well, perhaps in the interest of fairness, you could suggest to the IDF that they send in some soldiers armed only with stones. And while you're at it, why not suggest that they put a couple of baracks inside the security wall, and let Hamas run the gates into those baracks, confiscating weapons, food and what have you. Maybe then they wouldn't have to attack settlers or fire their tin can rockets into farmers fields.
 
Court sanctioned torture? have not heard of any does not mean it is not happening, although I would rather be in ISrali custody than Hamas for some reason.
Unless memory fails me the prisoners that Isral is holding are entitled to court appearances, due process, and were apprehended braeking a law of some description. The one prisoner that you dismiss was kidnapped and has been held without any of the above due processes for a while.

And one more thing, yes kidnapping a citizen is a provocation for an invasion, 1 or 1000 the number does not matter

Don't be rediculous, if that were the case the world would be in a constant state of war. Dubai could attack Israel for murdering someone in it's territory. The Turks could declare war on Israel for attacking their ship and murdering Turkish citizens in international waters. So to start a war for the kidnapping of one citizen is ludicrous. 1300 Lebenese were murdered by Israel, most of them had little to do with the kidnapping or hezbollah. At least Israel lost about 160 people...but the roughly 9:1 kill ratio for Israeli atrocities is pretty constant.

As for torture:

Like the United States, Israel lays claim to the highest moral standards, yet it is apparent that there are elements within the Israeli armed forces and indeed government for whom torture is a necessary and acceptable weapon. The two nations' refusal to accept the terms of to the International Criminal Court can only enhance the worldwide suspicion that these two countries wish to legitimize the torture of prisoners without ever being held to account by those they abuse.

An Israeli High Court ruling on 6 September 1999 prohibited a number of torture techniques. However, these methods were not completely outlawed. Instead the Court's ruling still allows the Knesset to enact laws that would give intelligence officers the authority to use such methods. The Court deemed the security difficulties faced by Israel to be grave enough to merit granting intelligence services the power to torture.
 
... Maybe then they wouldn't have to attack settlers or fire their tin can rockets into farmers fields.

Another pathetic clown who justifies attacks on civilians and thinks Hamas has no choice but to commit terror attacks.
 
Don't be rediculous, if that were the case the world would be in a constant state of war. Dubai could attack Israel for murdering someone in it's territory. The Turks could declare war on Israel for attacking their ship and murdering Turkish citizens in international waters. So to start a war for the kidnapping of one citizen is ludicrous. 1300 Lebenese were murdered by Israel, most of them had little to do with the kidnapping or hezbollah. At least Israel lost about 160 people...but the roughly 9:1 kill ratio for Israeli atrocities is pretty constant.

As for torture:

Like the United States, Israel lays claim to the highest moral standards, yet it is apparent that there are elements within the Israeli armed forces and indeed government for whom torture is a necessary and acceptable weapon. The two nations' refusal to accept the terms of to the International Criminal Court can only enhance the worldwide suspicion that these two countries wish to legitimize the torture of prisoners without ever being held to account by those they abuse.

An Israeli High Court ruling on 6 September 1999 prohibited a number of torture techniques. However, these methods were not completely outlawed. Instead the Court's ruling still allows the Knesset to enact laws that would give intelligence officers the authority to use such methods. The Court deemed the security difficulties faced by Israel to be grave enough to merit granting intelligence services the power to torture.

The Turks could declare war on Israel for attacking their ship and murdering Turkish citizens in international waters. So to start a war for the kidnapping of one citizen is ludicrous.

The blockade is legal if you get killed trying to run a blockade you arare the one who is in the wrong. Not to mention dead.

Refuseing to submit or recognize the ICC is neither here nor there, The ISreali govt has issues with teh make up of the court as do the Americans for that matter , if the issues were resolved they would infact recognize the court. 1300 Lebanese were murdered by ISreal when? I seem to ahve missed the mass murder, unless you are refering to people killed during military actions that is not murder as you know but are ignoring.

The court has allowed the Knesset to enact laws allowing torture, have any such laws been enacted, keep in mind Isreal has a free press and an elected government which has lare numbers of sitting members who would like nothing better than to embarase the govt , so any such law would not be enacted in secret.

And just so you know yes kidnapping one citizen is more than enough justification to go to war, if it was not no government could stand .

Any of the Arab states that are still in a state of war with Isreal are free to invade at their leisure, but that don't and there is a reason for that.
 
The Turks could declare war on Israel for attacking their ship and murdering Turkish citizens in international waters. So to start a war for the kidnapping of one citizen is ludicrous.

The blockade is legal if you get killed trying to run a blockade you arare the one who is in the wrong. Not to mention dead.

Refuseing to submit or recognize the ICC is neither here nor there, The ISreali govt has issues with teh make up of the court as do the Americans for that matter , if the issues were resolved they would infact recognize the court. 1300 Lebanese were murdered by ISreal when? I seem to ahve missed the mass murder, unless you are refering to people killed during military actions that is not murder as you know but are ignoring.

The court has allowed the Knesset to enact laws allowing torture, have any such laws been enacted, keep in mind Isreal has a free press and an elected government which has lare numbers of sitting members who would like nothing better than to embarase the govt , so any such law would not be enacted in secret.

And just so you know yes kidnapping one citizen is more than enough justification to go to war, if it was not no government could stand .

Any of the Arab states that are still in a state of war with Isreal are free to invade at their leisure, but that don't and there is a reason for that.

They we in international waters...also the Lebenese kidnapping was not conducted by the Lebenese govt but by an armed gang. Since it was not an act of the govt of Lebenon, please explain why in your fuzzy mind it was legal.
 
They wind up the same damp spot on the ground when they set the mortar up in a crowd, the only difference is they take civilians with them. Even within a city there are places they could set up that are not so closely packed in with civilians. Hamas CHOOSES to put civilian lives at risk--this is pretty well known.

If that were true... why are there so many rockets flying into Israel... or is that also not true? Hamas has to blend with the population in order to a) govern b) so they don't get liquidted by Israel. Why does the Israeli military blend with civilians?
 
They we in international waters...also the Lebenese kidnapping was not conducted by the Lebenese govt but by an armed gang. Since it was not an act of the govt of Lebenon, please explain why in your fuzzy mind it was legal.

An armed gang that makes up a significant part of the Lebanese government. Is it also worth noting that their possession of arms is in direct violation of resolution 1701? Besides that, it is the responsibility of any government to ensure that it's citizens do not engage in attacks on other countries (which is why in Israel's early existance the IDF used force to disarm terrorist groups (Irgun, Lehi).
 
If that were true... why are there so many rockets flying into Israel... or is that also not true? Hamas has to blend with the population in order to a) govern b) so they don't get liquidted by Israel. Why does the Israeli military blend with civilians?

Did you forget to renew you perscription?

Why are there so many rockets flying in to Israel? Because Hamas thinks that indiscriminant firing at civilians will somehow destroy Israel.

Why does the Israeli military blend with civilians? They don't.
 
They we in international waters...also the Lebenese kidnapping was not conducted by the Lebenese govt but by an armed gang. Since it was not an act of the govt of Lebenon, please explain why in your fuzzy mind it was legal.

The blockade is legal we have been over this numerous times, It is up to the lebanese government to control the groups in their territory, If the Lebaneses govt is in control of the country why did they NOT CAPTURE THE CRIMINALS, AND RETURN THE KIDNAP VICTIMS TO iSREAL?

Any effective govt would do this almost immediatly
 
The blockade is legal we have been over this numerous times,

Sure, but you still keep spouting your opinion or the IDF opinion or the opinion of one or two Jewish lawyers in the states.

vs.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and the International Committee of the Red Cross said that Israel's blockade of the Gaza Strip was illegal. In the United States, the National Lawyers Guild's International Committee said Israel's actions were "manifestly excessive" to the conditions of a lawful blockade;[261] Richard Falk, professor emeritus of international law at Princeton University said that the "ships that were situated in the high seas where freedom of navigation exists, according to the law of the seas"[undue weight?];[262] Anthony D'Amato, a professor of international law at Northwestern University School of Law, said the raid was illegal and that a legitimate blockade would have required a state of war between Israel and Hamas[

And of course the UN is working on an inquiry to the matter.
Until then, I'll take the backing of the UN, the Red Cross and the National Lawyers Guild.
Oh, and don't forget the Goldstone report called it a 'war crime'.
The blockade was illegal.
 
Another pathetic clown who justifies attacks on civilians and thinks Hamas has no choice but to commit terror attacks.

I'd like you to list some of their other choices please.
Lets start with peace - that's a no go because the US and Netanyahu have excluded Hamas from the latest peace talks
How about attacking soldiers - well, the soldiers aren't in Gaza anymore, can't do that
How about attacking the wall - well, they can't get within 1500m without being shot by automated guns
How about getting a day pass so they can get out and attack some army posts - well, they aren't allowed out of Gaza very easily, that's no good.
How about aiming their missiles at army posts - well, their homemade tin can missiles have no guidance systems or range, so maybe they are already and just can't hit anything with them
How about protesting peacefully - well they do that regularly, but they still get shot at
How about a voluntary one sided ceasefire - they did that for the last year, didn't help much, did it

Ok, Basketcase, what would you suggest Hamas do?
 
Well, perhaps in the interest of fairness, you could suggest to the IDF that they send in some soldiers armed only with stones. And while you're at it, why not suggest that they put a couple of baracks inside the security wall, and let Hamas run the gates into those baracks, confiscating weapons, food and what have you. Maybe then they wouldn't have to attack settlers or fire their tin can rockets into farmers fields.

Is it your view that war has to be fair? You're weird.
 
If that were true... why are there so many rockets flying into Israel... or is that also not true? Hamas has to blend with the population in order to a) govern b) so they don't get liquidted by Israel. Why does the Israeli military blend with civilians?

Why the rockets? Because Hamas are terrorists, obviously. And since when does the Israeli military blend with civilians????