Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

I apply the same principle everywhere, not only to Israel. That principle is that it's acceptable to use military force against an armed enemy that uses military force against you. I accept that as lawful, justifiable behavior in any conflict anywhere on earth, and you don't. International law is on my side, and against you. That's how it is.

As usual, you are batting .000, Fuji Fromage. The settlements are a violation of international law. The blockade is a War Crime under international law. The transfer of Palestinian prisoners from the Occupied Territories are a violation of international law. The ethnic cleansing is a violation of international law.
 
If there was any doubt in anyone's mind about whether Hamas was committed to terrorism that doubt should be put to rest now. Hamas has resumed direct attacks against civilians.

I think everyone is wondering why they waited so long when Israel continued to commit War Crimes against them on a daily basis. You have to admit, they do act to a higher standard than Israel.
 
The settlements are a violation of international law.

They may well be, at least some of them--I agree with you. But that's irrelevant to the point I was making. It doesn't change that it's unacceptable to target civilians.

The blockade is a War Crime under international law.

Nope.

The transfer of Palestinian prisoners from the Occupied Territories are a violation of international law. The ethnic cleansing is a violation of international law.

They may well be, at least some of them--I agree with you. But that's irrelevant to the point I was making. It doesn't change that it's unacceptable to target civilians.

This one is muddied by the fact that there was a simultaneous ethnic cleansing on the other side so it's hard to assign blame or sort out who is at fault, or how it should be sorted out, but I agree that both sides committed crimes at the time.

Again, this doesn't change in any way shape or form the conditions under which civilian deaths are acceptable today--it's irrelevant to the present point.
 
I think everyone is wondering why they waited so long when Israel continued to commit War Crimes against them on a daily basis. You have to admit, they do act to a higher standard than Israel.

So you think they should have started murdering pregnant women sooner? Gryfin, do you support the murder of Israeli civilians by Palestinians?

This is the closest you've come yet to saying "yes" to that question. You are a disgusting, hate filled, morally bankrupt reprehensible bigot.
 
IF that had ever happened, then it would be pretty bad. Good thing it never did!

Israel made some questionable use of WP but it did not involve incinerating women or children from the inside out. Right now you are just making stuff up that you imagine could have happened but you know didn't happen and probably didn't happen because Israel took some care to see that it didn't happen.

ICRC has come out and stated that some uses of WP are acceptable and what's been debated ever since is whether Israel's use fits into what ICRC thinks is acceptable or not. One thing is clear though: It was never aimed at anything but a military target. The only question is how close those legitimate targets were to civilian areas.

Of course it happened. I have seen footage of the dried out bodies...pretty horrific. It was used in the last Gaza incursion. Sure white phosphorus use in very limited conditions is allowed, but Israel used it to saturate civilian areas because sniper and mortar fire was coming from those areas. They did it knowing MANY innocent people would die a horrible, painful death. They did it because they view the Palis the exact same way the Nazis viewed the Jews.
 
I apply the same principle everywhere, not only to Israel. That principle is that it's acceptable to use military force against an armed enemy that uses military force against you. I accept that as lawful, justifiable behavior in any conflict anywhere on earth, and you don't. International law is on my side, and against you. That's how it is.

How convenently you forget the principle of proportionality and the consideration of civilian casualties.
 
How convenently you forget the principle of proportionality and the consideration of civilian casualties.

I support the principle of proportionality, although not the way I have seen you misinterpret it. It does not mean eye for an eye. It means that civilian casualties are acceptable when associated with an attack on a target of sufficient military value. It's a relationship between the size of the civilian casualties and the significance of the military target.

Whereas I have seen you try and equate the number of Israeli to Palestinian casualties and then claim proportionality--which is not correct.
 
I apply the same principle everywhere, not only to Israel. That principle is that it's acceptable to use military force against an armed enemy that uses military force against you. I accept that as lawful, justifiable behavior in any conflict anywhere on earth, and you don't. International law is on my side, and against you. That's how it is.

How convenently you forget the principle of proportionality and the consideration of civilian casualties.
 
If there was any doubt in anyone`s mind about whether Hamas was committed to terrorism that doubt should be put to rest now. Hamas has resumed direct attacks against civilians.
In our previous discussion about the definition of terrorism (https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...Homeland-Security-Act-of-2002-Agree-Y-N/page2), I was left with the impression that, according to your definition, a government can commit acts of war and can be a state sponsor of terrorism, but cannot commit acts of terrorism.

I would appreciate if you would share again your definition of terrorism.
 
In our previous discussion about the definition of terrorism (https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...Homeland-Security-Act-of-2002-Agree-Y-N/page2), I was left with the impression that, according to your definition, a government can commit acts of war and can be a state sponsor of terrorism, but cannot commit acts of terrorism.

I would appreciate if you would share again your definition of terrorism.

I believe that the gunmen were elements of Hamas that do not participate formally in government. If the attack was carried out by the official agents of the Gaza government then I would view it as a war crime instead. The only real difference between "war crime" and "terrorism" here being whether the perpetrators were non-government entities (as I believe is the case here) or government operatives acting under orders.

To help you with a non-Palestinian example:

If a US president orders the US military to target and kill innocent civilians that would be a war crime. If instead militant members of President`s political party who do not work for the government kill the civilians then that would be terrorism. Same act, criminal in both cases, the label changes based on whether the agent is part of a government following orders or a non-governmental organization such as a political party or other.

In my mind the crime is just as bad either way, it`s merely a matter of using words correctly to call it terrorism vs. war crime, one is not any less reprehensible than the other. The methods used to contain and limit and prosecute the act, however, are likely to be different depending on whether you are going after a full fledged government and its leaders, versus a loose organization of individuals. In that sense, in the sense of how do you go about stopping it or catching it, there`s a difference. Not in how bad the crime itself is, though.
 
If you see Hamas as a legitimate government then sure you could call it a war crime instead of terrorism. That's the only difference in my mind really, whether the perpetrator is a recognized government or an NGO. One's terrorism, the other a war crime, or a crime against humanity if it's done outside of a war.

I believe that the gunmen were elements of Hamas that do not participate formally in government, though.
Am I correct in my assumption that you view governments as incapable of committing acts of terrorism (by your definition of terrorism)?

Do you see Hamas as a legitimate government?

What is your definition of a legitimate government?
 
I updated my post since you responded.

Am I correct in my assumption that you view governments as incapable of committing acts of terrorism (by your definition of terrorism)?

Correct. Although it is possible for a government to sponsor and support terrorism, if the government itself carries out the act it's a war crime, or a crime against humanity, not terrorism.

Do you see Hamas as a legitimate government?

No. I see Hamas as a defacto government though.

What is your definition of a legitimate government?

One that has assumed power lawfully. Hamas has assumed power by way of a coup. They were elected to the legislature (lawmaking) not to the executive (government). They assumed executive authority through violence. Also their term limits have expired and they should have called new elections now, in terms of the legislative seats.
 
Correct. Although it is possible for a government to sponsor and support terrorism, if the government itself carries out the act it's a war crime, or a crime against humanity, not terrorism.
I agree with you that Hamas is committed to terrorism. But mostly out of desperation. Don't you feel Israel also, out of desperation, is committed to killing civilians? They do so in large numbers with little remorse in order to hit their targets.
 
I agree with you that Hamas is committed to terrorism. But mostly out of desperation. Don't you feel Israel also, out of desperation, is committed to killing civilians? They do so in large numbers with little remorse in order to hit their targets.

No, I don't think so. Israel has every right to stop a rocket attack, and if the rockets are being launched from the midsts of civilians, that sucks, but there's no other way to stop the rocket attacks than to hit the launcher where it is.

I find Hamas entirely to blame for the placement of the rocket launcher in that case, not Israel.

There have been a LOT of confrontations and a LOT of conflicts and like in any war there have been cases of over-zealous Israeli commanders exceeding their authority and going beyond what is called for. The case of white phosphorous shells being used against military targets that were near to civilians is an example of that. You'll note that Israel disciplined the officer who ordered that strike--it was not in line with their general policy.

The question is what's the general policy? Is the general policy in line with acceptable standards? Is it just a few rogue individuals who cross the line?

In the case of Israel they are largely abiding by acceptable international standards with respect to the use of violence, and the exceptions seem to be exceptions, and Israel seems to be capable of self-policing the exceptions well enough, maybe not as harshly as you'd like, but they do act.

In the case of Hamas they are intentionally and knowingly breaching them and rather than disciplining the gunmen who killed the pregnant woman in even some lenient way they actually did the opposite and celebrated those gunmen as heros. So contrast that: Israel disciplined the officer who ordered the WP shells to be used, however leniently, while Hamas celebrated as heroes those who murdered the pregnant woman.

I see quite a difference there.
 
Of course it happened. I have seen footage of the dried out bodies...pretty horrific....

Wow, you must have some pretty good sources in Gaza because even Goldstone's report included no mention of bodies burnt up by WP. Could it be more propagandist 'news' you are trying to spread (like flub's quotes)?
 
Of course it happened. I have seen footage of the dried out bodies...pretty horrific.

Citation needed. I think you are full of shit, and have never heard of this before.

Israel used it to saturate civilian areas because sniper and mortar fire was coming from those areas.

False. You are just making stuff up as you go. Israel fired a couple of shells, for which a commander was disciplined.

Are you getting your news from some Hamas propaganda outlet? Try switching back to mainstream media, the jihadi blogs aren't giving you an honest picture.
 
Correct. Although it is possible for a government to sponsor and support terrorism, if the government itself carries out the act it's a war crime, or a crime against humanity, not terrorism.
No. I see Hamas as a defacto government though.

So, according to your definition, Hamas is not a terrorist organization, since they are the defacto government.

And, according to your previous posts, settler violence would count as terrorism, since they are not government agents, but acting on its behalf. Which would make the Israeli gov't, while not terrorist themselves, sponsors of terrorism and on the same level of Hamas.

And while we're on the topic of war crimes and white phosphorous, since you have said you are unaware of Israel's use, why don't I suggest you read the 71 page report that Human Rights Watch came out with last year, entitled 'Rain of Fire'.

http://www.hrw.org/en/reports/2009/03/25/rain-fire

This 71-page report provides witness accounts of the devastating effects that white phosphorus munitions had on civilians and civilian property in Gaza. Human Rights Watch researchers in Gaza immediately after hostilities ended found spent shells, canister liners, and dozens of burnt felt wedges containing white phosphorus on city streets, apartment roofs, residential courtyards, and at a United Nations school. The report also presents ballistics evidence, photographs, and satellite imagery, as well as documents from the Israeli military and government.
 
No, I don't think so. Israel has every right to stop a rocket attack, and if the rockets are being launched from the midsts of civilians, that sucks, but there's no other way to stop the rocket attacks than to hit the launcher where it is.

I find Hamas entirely to blame for the placement of the rocket launcher in that case, not Israel.

There have been a LOT of confrontations and a LOT of conflicts and like in any war there have been cases of over-zealous Israeli commanders exceeding their authority and going beyond what is called for. The case of white phosphorous shells being used against military targets that were near to civilians is an example of that. You'll note that Israel disciplined the officer who ordered that strike--it was not in line with their general policy.

The question is what's the general policy? Is the general policy in line with acceptable standards? Is it just a few rogue individuals who cross the line?

In the case of Israel they are largely abiding by acceptable international standards with respect to the use of violence, and the exceptions seem to be exceptions, and Israel seems to be capable of self-policing the exceptions well enough, maybe not as harshly as you'd like, but they do act.

In the case of Hamas they are intentionally and knowingly breaching them and rather than disciplining the gunmen who killed the pregnant woman in even some lenient way they actually did the opposite and celebrated those gunmen as heros. So contrast that: Israel disciplined the officer who ordered the WP shells to be used, however leniently, while Hamas celebrated as heroes those who murdered the pregnant woman.

I see quite a difference there.

There may not be a celebration but where is the remorse for the disproportional number of civilian Pal. deaths caused by Israel? Killing the many in order to save the few is not good policing and an act of desperation and should be pointed out as such. If one is to point out a few terrible acts of desperation by Hamas then one should point out the many terrible acts of desperation by Israel. All civilian lives are equal aren't they?