Dog Kills Baby

First off; I said IN THE MAJORITY OF CASES. Not all, the majority. Stop jumping down my throat people. The OP had made a comment about dogs in general, I responded in kind.
As for a three week old being unable to provoke a dog, what planet are you people living on? The child I've cared for for about a year now, and known since birth, was notorious for grabbing and pulling the tails on any dog within reach, even at three weeks. He was fortunate the dog he tormented most was the most docile dog I've ever met, or he would have been bit. At three weeks. So don't tell me a three week old can't provoke a dog. As for the kid being strapped to a car seat, so what? The kid has arms and hands, it can reach out to grab onto a tail/ear/tuft of fur. Have none of you ever spent time around very young children when pets were around?

That being said, I need to clear something up, as many of you seem to have misunderstood me; I am not saying it was the kids fault by any means. Children need to touch and feel to learn. I put the blame solely on the parent. Under no circumstance should she have left her three week old alone at all, nevermind the dogs.

So before you all jump down my throat again, try reading what is actually there, not what you assume I mean. I was defending the dogs. I was not blaming the child. I was blaming the parent and calling her stupid for what she did.
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child. The parents are just too stupid to either teach the child not to pull the doggies tails/ears/fur, or they don't separate them. I'm sorry that the kid died and all, but don't blame the dogs for it. They are just acting on instinct. You lash out when something/someone causes you pain, and so do they.

First off; I said IN THE MAJORITY OF CASES. Not all, the majority. Stop jumping down my throat people. The OP had made a comment about dogs in general, I responded in kind.
As for a three week old being unable to provoke a dog, what planet are you people living on? The child I've cared for for about a year now, and known since birth, was notorious for grabbing and pulling the tails on any dog within reach, even at three weeks. He was fortunate the dog he tormented most was the most docile dog I've ever met, or he would have been bit. At three weeks. So don't tell me a three week old can't provoke a dog. As for the kid being strapped to a car seat, so what? The kid has arms and hands, it can reach out to grab onto a tail/ear/tuft of fur. Have none of you ever spent time around very young children when pets were around?

That being said, I need to clear something up, as many of you seem to have misunderstood me; I am not saying it was the kids fault by any means. Children need to touch and feel to learn. I put the blame solely on the parent. Under no circumstance should she have left her three week old alone at all, nevermind the dogs.

So before you all jump down my throat again, try reading what is actually there, not what you assume I mean. I was defending the dogs. I was not blaming the child. I was blaming the parent and calling her stupid for what she did.

Pot calling kettle! You admit to leaving a child that apparently had the ability and inclination to yank on the dog within the reach of the dog! REGARDLESS of the breed of the dog in question, you should count yourself lucky that the dog didn't nip, or worse, the little one. And of course during the year that the child was in your care I assume you attempted to teach him/her NOT to grab the dog, right? Or at the VERY least, not leave the child in a position that he/she could "provoke" the dog.
 
Some breeds are typically much better with children, particularly small children, than others. Ironically some of these are not what one would expect - Irish Wolfhounds for example. However, as has been stated by several people common sense (as well as past incidents) dictate that one should not leave a newborn alone with a dog.

Sweet Serenity, my point (which I believe was somewhat lost with the follow on posts) was that as Randygirl wrote, Huskies have a particularly bad reputation with barnyard livestock and infants, I don't believe the infant had to have done anything at all other than being an infant to have provoked the attack.

As to the dog owners being charged, as a general comment without looking at the Criminal Code. The principal responsibility for the well being of the infant is with the custodial Parent(s) - hence the manslaughter charge. The owners of the dog, unless they knew of the dogs disposition (previous acts), if charges are preferred, are likely facing only animal charges if that.
 
One notes that it is a Labrador Retriever a breed that is typically very good with children (and which not surprisingly is strongly on the juvenile end of the Juvenile - Wolf spectrum of dog behaviour)

When my son was born, my brother had a Lab, approx 7 years old. The dog didn't really pay much attention to my son UNTIL non-family members come to the house. When that happened, she would calmly get up off the couch, and place herself - at all times - between my son and the "stranger". It was amazing to see.

Having said that - my boy was never alone on the floor with the dog, ever.
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child. The parents are just too stupid to either teach the child not to pull the doggies tails/ears/fur, or they don't separate them. I'm sorry that the kid died and all, but don't blame the dogs for it. They are just acting on instinct. You lash out when something/someone causes you pain, and so do they.

Well, this is a double edged sword that you're swinging. This was an infant, so I'm doubtful the infant did anything to cause pain, but maybe the crying got to the animals. Nobody will ever know the real story though.

http://mypethuskyclub.com//index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=42&Itemid=138

http://mypethuskyclub.com//index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=31&Itemid=135

The mother has been charged with manslaughter and is a young offender - 17.

In Canada we need a license to:
1. Drive
2. Marry
3. Work (education)

But anyone can make a baby.
 
Well, this is a double edged sword that you're swinging. This was an infant, so I'm doubtful the infant did anything to cause pain, but maybe the crying got to the animals. Nobody will ever know the real story though.

The baby doesn't have to cause pain to provoke a dog, just waving a hand too close is often enough to get a reaction. But infants can cause pain, it's surprising how tightly they can grasp at you.
But you can't blame the baby or the dog, only the adults in charge.

I suspect the manslaughter charge will be dropped, she did lose her child.
 
huskies are meant to pull sleds.
what is it with people and dogs? I totally understand dogs who serve a purpose, like pulling a sled, guarding, sniffing etc
but otherwise, dog owners seem like lonely people who are looking for some type of fulfillment
 
First off; I said IN THE MAJORITY OF CASES. Not all, the majority. Stop jumping down my throat people. The OP had made a comment about dogs in general, I responded in kind.
As for a three week old being unable to provoke a dog, what planet are you people living on? The child I've cared for for about a year now, and known since birth, was notorious for grabbing and pulling the tails on any dog within reach, even at three weeks. He was fortunate the dog he tormented most was the most docile dog I've ever met, or he would have been bit. At three weeks. So don't tell me a three week old can't provoke a dog. As for the kid being strapped to a car seat, so what? The kid has arms and hands, it can reach out to grab onto a tail/ear/tuft of fur. Have none of you ever spent time around very young children when pets were around?

That being said, I need to clear something up, as many of you seem to have misunderstood me; I am not saying it was the kids fault by any means. Children need to touch and feel to learn. I put the blame solely on the parent. Under no circumstance should she have left her three week old alone at all, nevermind the dogs.

So before you all jump down my throat again, try reading what is actually there, not what you assume I mean. I was defending the dogs. I was not blaming the child. I was blaming the parent and calling her stupid for what she did.

I'm with you hun
why are people 'assuming' it was a vicious attack? Any number of things could have happened.As SS stated,the dogs could have gone near to the infant who would have grabbed out with its hands,or perhaps they recognised the babys cries as an infant in need of help and were trying to pick it up as if it were a puppy,which of course would have caused catastrophic injuries to a newborn.
Never forget the case of the first facial transplant victim who was unconcious from an overdose when her dog tried to REVIVE her.The dog was labelled as dangerous and euthanised and it was only after careful probing into the background in the story that the whole circumstance came to light
 
In Canada we need a license to:
1. Drive
2. Marry
3. Work (education)

But anyone can make a baby.

That's a scary thought. But think of the uproar it would cause if you had to buy a baby license!
 
Pot calling kettle! You admit to leaving a child that apparently had the ability and inclination to yank on the dog within the reach of the dog! REGARDLESS of the breed of the dog in question, you should count yourself lucky that the dog didn't nip, or worse, the little one. And of course during the year that the child was in your care I assume you attempted to teach him/her NOT to grab the dog, right? Or at the VERY least, not leave the child in a position that he/she could "provoke" the dog.

When at any time did I say I left the child alone with the dog? I've only cared for the child for a year, he is nearing three years now. Yes, he is still being taught not to grab at dogs, and has for the most part stopped. He still grabs at the dog I spoke of on occasion, but the dog has learned to growl at him to tell him no, and the child has learned to listen to the dog.

Before you make wild accusations and insult my intelligence, try asking for the facts.
 
huskies are meant to pull sleds.
what is it with people and dogs? I totally understand dogs who serve a purpose, like pulling a sled, guarding, sniffing etc
but otherwise, dog owners seem like lonely people who are looking for some type of fulfillment

Lol, yeah. Kinda like everybody else. You serve a purpose to your wife (I'll go out on a very very long limb here and say you have one). You provide her with sex, children, a livelihood, etc. Maybe that's all the good she sees in you too.
 
I'm with you hun
why are people 'assuming' it was a vicious attack? Any number of things could have happened.As SS stated,the dogs could have gone near to the infant who would have grabbed out with its hands,or perhaps they recognised the babys cries as an infant in need of help and were trying to pick it up as if it were a puppy,which of course would have caused catastrophic injuries to a newborn.
Never forget the case of the first facial transplant victim who was unconcious from an overdose when her dog tried to REVIVE her.The dog was labelled as dangerous and euthanised and it was only after careful probing into the background in the story that the whole circumstance came to light

Much like the famous incident where the man fell to the stage, and the female tiger leaped to him, grabbed him by the back of the neck and carried him off stage. She was trying to be a protective parent, carrying him by the 'scruff' of the neck, as she would a kitten from her litter. But most people didn't understand that, and labeled it a vicious attack. This could very well be a similar case. But no one knows, and everyone is making assumptions and accusations based on pieces of the story.
 
huskies are meant to pull sleds.
what is it with people and dogs? I totally understand dogs who serve a purpose, like pulling a sled, guarding, sniffing etc
but otherwise, dog owners seem like lonely people who are looking for some type of fulfillment

When I worked in northern Manitoba huskies were chained well apart or they kill each other. And you never walked through them or attempt to pet them. They are an aggressive dog by nature, beautyful yes, but agressive.
 
I don't agree the mother should be charged. Was it stupid, sure. But WTF is achieved by charging the mother? She is pretty much mentally screwed and probably a suicide risk. Nothing can be achieved by charging her, it is mean spirited and is just rubbing salt in some very deep wounds. I hope the morons in charge of this case drop the charges as soon as possible. I hope somehow this young lady will be able to put this incident in her past and move on.
 
but otherwise, dog owners seem like lonely people who are looking for some type of fulfillment

Or the kind of people that seek complete control over and a need to feel superior to another living creature, especially one that will remain 'loyal' at all costs. You love animals so much? Let them rome free in the wild where they belong, instead of having them as your little playthings for your satisfaction. I have a deeper reverance for animals than any pet owner.
 
Or the kind of people that seek complete control over and a need to feel superior to another living creature, especially one that will remain 'loyal' at all costs. You love animals so much? Let them rome free in the wild where they belong, instead of having them as your little playthings for your satisfaction. I have a deeper reverance for animals than any pet owner.

Would you mind setting all cattle, poultry, sheep and every kind of livestocks
free from the farm so they can roam free in the wilderness? A lot of fishes
we eat these days are farmed fishes. We should return these fishes to the
sea as well. I guess that won't be a problem for vegetarian. The rest of the
omnivorous population in the world will have to hunt in the wild to
supplement their miserable veggie diet.
 
So sad, another baby has been killed by the family dog. The 17 year old mother has been charged with manslaughter. Apparently, 3 children are killed by dogs every couple of years on average in Canada. This is 3 deaths too many. Are dogs worth the risk?

Expect more and more as these as young tramps continue to get themselves knocked up.