Dog Kills Baby

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
So sad, another baby has been killed by the family dog. The 17 year old mother has been charged with manslaughter. Apparently, 3 children are killed by dogs every couple of years on average in Canada. This is 3 deaths too many. Are dogs worth the risk?
 
The manslaughter charge is justified.

Leaving a newborn in a room with 2 huskies: stupid.
 
So sad, another baby has been killed by the family dog. The 17 year old mother has been charged with manslaughter. Apparently, 3 children are killed by dogs every couple of years on average in Canada. This is 3 deaths too many. Are dogs worth the risk?

Are stupid parents worth the risk?
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child. The parents are just too stupid to either teach the child not to pull the doggies tails/ears/fur, or they don't separate them. I'm sorry that the kid died and all, but don't blame the dogs for it. They are just acting on instinct. You lash out when something/someone causes you pain, and so do they.
 
My thoughts exactly.

Same. I'm actually surprised the dog's owner's aren't being charged (well atleast, not according to that article). If you say who leaves their baby in a room with two huskies, you can also say who leaves two huskies in a room with a baby. The dogs will now be euthanized...
 
I just finished the article where the boyfriend says she is "a good mother". What part of a smoking, teenage mother with a boyfriend who is searching out welfare who leaves their child unattended with rather large dogs did he miss?
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child. The parents are just too stupid to either teach the child not to pull the doggies tails/ears/fur, or they don't separate them. I'm sorry that the kid died and all, but don't blame the dogs for it. They are just acting on instinct. You lash out when something/someone causes you pain, and so do they.

+1

The problem is not with the dogs, it is with the parents and their inability to integrate their children and pets to live in the same household. In the case of an infant, the child or the dogs should have been removed if they were unsupervised. In the case of a toddler, the child should be taught to respect the animal. An animal that is not aggressive will become aggressive if being mauled by a child.

My old dog (a Shih tzu) bit my ex's nephew, the boy was two and a half years old. The dog was thirteen and had never, ever been aggressive. The boy was pulling on his ears, and the dog snapped at him in warning. No blood was drawn, but my ex's sister was PISSED. Well, you know what? I was PISSED too. I was PISSED that my (gentle) dog had been put in the position of having to defend himself from an aggressive child.

I put the kibosh on it, and said that the dog was no longer allowed to be around the children until the children learned some manners.

It's really too bad when things like this happen. If parents were a bit more educated and actually taught their children how to respect and treat an animal right, we might have less dog bite incidents. In addition, a lot of people do not think about what type of breed they are getting, and what the temperament of that breed is. There are some breeds that are just NOT suitable for homes with young children. Think, people, before you get a dog!

Of course, there are always really aggressive dogs with which you can do nothing and never trust. But that scenario is the exception, not the rule. Any dog that is aggressive and uncontrollable should be euthanized.
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child.
Serenity, this may indeed be the case with a number of attacks on older children, but this was a three week old newborn. Given that Huskies are on the "adult" end of the juvenile - adult (dog - wolf) spectrum of dog behaviour, I suspect that they saw a three week old likely smelling of milk as prey.
 
Serenity, this may indeed be the case with a number of attacks on older children, but this was a three week old newborn. Given that Huskies are on the "adult" end of the juvenile - adult (dog - wolf) spectrum of dog behaviour, I suspect that they saw a three week old likely smelling of milk as prey.

People should read the article before making ridiculous assumptions as the poster you quoted has. Yes she is a young mother, yes she went outside on the balcony to have a cigarette, sure the father is trying to get on welfare to support his family, does that make her a murderer?? NO!! The baby was 3 weeks old, the dog WAS NOT provoked. I feel horrible that the mother after having a baby 3 weeks ago, had to sit in jail over what an uncontrolled dog did to her new born baby.

Sad story, I do not feel the mother should be charged. She needs grief counsiling now as far as Im concerned.
 
Serenity, this may indeed be the case with a number of attacks on older children, but this was a three week old newborn. Given that Huskies are on the "adult" end of the juvenile - adult (dog - wolf) spectrum of dog behaviour, I suspect that they saw a three week old likely smelling of milk as prey.

I agree. Huskies are a notorious breed for being killers. My girlfriend had a Husky, on her farm, and the dog went into the chicken coup and killed every living chicken. Not to eat, either...just to kill. Some breeds have a higher propensity for wanting to neutralize small animals, the Husky is one of them.

This incident is tragic. Had these people been educated, this may not have happened.

They sure are stupid, but are they criminal? I don't know.
 
It isn't the dog's fault. In the majority of these cases the dog is provoked by the child. The parents are just too stupid to either teach the child not to pull the doggies tails/ears/fur, or they don't separate them. I'm sorry that the kid died and all, but don't blame the dogs for it. They are just acting on instinct. You lash out when something/someone causes you pain, and so do they.

THE CHILD WAS STRAPPED IN A CAR SEAT AND ONLY 3 WEEKS OLD. what could the child possibly do to provoke a dog attack????
 
People should read the article before making ridiculous assumptions as the poster you quoted has. Yes she is a young mother, yes she went outside on the balcony to have a cigarette, sure the father is trying to get on welfare to support his family, does that make her a murderer?? NO!! The baby was 3 weeks old, the dog WAS NOT provoked. I feel horrible that the mother after having a baby 3 weeks ago, had to sit in jail over what an uncontrolled dog did to her new born baby.

Sad story, I do not feel the mother should be charged. She needs grief counsiling now as far as Im concerned.

People should read the comments here more carefully before posting ridiculous assumptions about a poster's opinion. No one here believes she is a murderer, because that would require intent to kill. She is being accused of manslaughter, whereby her actions negligently led to the death of the infant. I don't understand why the dog owner's aren't being charged with manslaughter, unless the mother was in "custody" of them while the couple was away.
 
People should read the comments here more carefully before posting ridiculous assumptions about a poster's opinion. No one here believes she is a murderer, because that would require intent to kill. She is being accused of manslaughter, whereby her actions negligently led to the death of the infant. I don't understand why the dog owner's aren't being charged with manslaughter, unless the mother was in "custody" of them while the couple was away.


You got my gist. I retract murder and add manslaughter, that was a typo not and ignorant assumption. Point is, the 3 weeks old baby DID NOT provoke the dog as some were suggesting.
 
I did not suggest that was the case. The point of my post was that it is the parents who fail in their responsibility to be informed on the breed of dog around their child, and to act accordingly to prevent these things from happening.

There will always be cases where inevitable tragedies occur. I'm not sure this tragedy was inevitable. Unfortunately.
 
I agree you can't blame the dog, dogs do what dogs do, they're dogs.

I agree you can't blame the infant child, strapped into its seat, unable to move.

That leaves the adults who put a husky and a baby in the same room. Unattended. Even ATTENDED that seems like a bad idea to me, a lot could happen before you could pull an attacking dog off a baby. And yes, these fucking morons have rightfully been charged with the serious crime they deserve.

Dogs and babies don't mix period. Ever.

Dogs and children don't mix at all until the kids can walk, and even then only when attended by an adult.

Dogs don't mix with kids unattended until the kids are big enough to boss the dog around on their own.
 
I agree. Huskies are a notorious breed for being killers. My girlfriend had a Husky, on her farm, and the dog went into the chicken coup and killed every living chicken. Not to eat, either...just to kill. Some breeds have a higher propensity for wanting to neutralize small animals, the Husky is one of them.

This incident is tragic. Had these people been educated, this may not have happened.

They sure are stupid, but are they criminal? I don't know.

German Shepherd dogs and Doberman are killer dogs too but
I bet parents are more likely to abuse their own children than these
doggies bite them. Dogs generally recognize children of their masters
as small members of the pack. As pack animals their pack-instinct is to
protect them. Among large dog breeds GSD's reputation as protector of
children is almost legendary. My former employer would entrust his
toddler child to a family with a large Husky during the day. I was once
with him when he was picking up his child and observed how the Husky
lovingly followed the chid to us. According to my employer if the Husky
caught the child crying he was smart enough to look around for the
baby sitter for help. Small dogs are generally not as good towards children
although some little-big dog breeds like Pembroke Corgi can be
very protective. I grew up in my teens with one small dog (mixed) who was
submissive only to my parents
but would growl at me for small provocation like pointing my finger to his
bone. Another small dog my family adopted when I was seven loved
children not only of his own pack but also those of the neighbourhood.
The one large dog breed I would never want to leave a child alone with
is a Chow dog. They have a deceptively kind look but some could
be surprisingly voracious.

Whatever the breed of the dog is it is both
stupid and irresponsible to leave an infant with a
large animal. When bringing an infant into the
family the baby has to be 'introduced' to the dog so it would
not view the children as rivals and show any aggressive
behaviour. But even with training no mother in her right
mind would leave her baby with a dog that weigh
ten times bigger. Several times after playing rough with my
neighbour's 2 year-old German Shepherd some years ago
I got bruises all over. It was such a powerful dog that a fragile
elderly could even get injured by having the dog jump over
for a hug. Naturally accidents can happen to an unaccompanied
infant. But I suspect that there is more to the story.
 
oil&gas, you bring up a really good point about dogs viewing children of small members of the pack. These dogs were not really part of the family,though, because the couple had just moved in and the dogs belonged to others who lived there.

But you are right. In general, dogs behave very well with children in the household and are protective rather than vicious. I too think there could be more to this story, but perhaps there isn't. Perhaps it was just one of those crazy things...