Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

By the way, Aardvark was talking about not being able to consent to assault, as it is defined under the law. His post is still correct.

Tattoos, piercings and (gasp!) even brandings are not, for an adult, assault under the law. Same goes with boxing matches, or football games, where consent is given when you decide to participate in the activity.

Breaking an SPs arm, would be considered assault. Often abuse occurs, such as between spouses, and the victim does not want to press charges. The law does so for them, whether or not the victim want to give the perpetrator a free pass. The victim in that case, has consented to being assaulted, but the law says otherwise. Hence, an adult can not consent to being assaulted as it is defined by law. If they could consent to that assault, then the police would not be able to charge the perpetrator of the assault if the victim says not to. This is untrue, because often, no matter what a victim says, charges are still laid. . . .
Fuji attempted to argue that Fraternity Hazing* at Yale four plus decades ago was analogous to minors giving consent to being branded.

Indeed both, as you point out Randygirl, involve assault and therefore raise the issue of whether consent was even possible. Fuji also then attempted to argue alternatively to the last mentioned that of course consent could be given because tattoo parlours routinely brand people. I mentioned that perhaps that was true in Ontario - I don't know. But in my neck of the woods - tattoo parlours are not allowed to brand people and if they did could (and generally would) be charged with assault.

* Further Fuji might have considered why Fraternity Hazing is now banned at probably all Universities in North America and when it does occur is almost always prosecuted, and how his Hazing example is quite different from a Tattoo Parlour, and similar to a father conducting a home made branding of his children.
 
My argument hasn't changed since the start of the thread, if you want to go back and read something and save yourself the time of searching, just go to page 1 of the thread and read post #12 which was my first lengthy post.

In that post I said I do not see anything particularly wrong with what they did, although I think it's stupid. I thought that if it's illegal it's on a technicality: they aren't old enough to consent legally by a couple of years.

Much of what followed was to demonstrate to all the "oh my god burning flesh" crew on the thread that branding is somewhat commonplace and not all that terrible--George Bush probably has one, adults can do it, etc., and so doing it to a child is not as bad as, say, breaking their arm, or beating them--things which would be criminal if done to an adult or child.

Yes, it is illegal because they are children. That is not a technicality, fuji, that is the law.

Also, I am still waiting for you to tell me how many people you know of personally who are branded? If it is so widespread, as you claim it to be, you should be able to tell us how many people you've encountered with a brand?

As for it being terrible, you are the only one arguing that it isn't a terrible thing. Taking a piece of iron and heating it up to 2000 degrees, then touching it to your child's skin? How is that not terrible, fuji?

Branding your child may not be as bad as breaking their arm? Are you serious? THAT is your rationale?! I could say something like "branding your child is not as bad locking them in a cellar for a month in the dark with nothing but a pot to piss in and the company of cockroaches, and only feeding them stale bread".

What is your point? No matter what you decide to compare it to, fuji, it's still terrible. A child should never have been put in the position that these children were put into. The fact that they defended their father and seemingly "wanted" it, can't be taken into consideration either. They are children, and easily influenced.
 
Fuji attempted to argue that Fraternity Hazing* at Yale four plus decades ago was analogous to minors giving consent to being branded.

Indeed both, as you point out Randygirl, involve assault and therefore raise the issue of whether consent was even possible. Fuji also then attempted to argue alternatively to the last mentioned that of course consent could be given because tattoo parlours routinely brand people. I mentioned that perhaps that was true in Ontario - I don't know. But in my neck of the woods - tattoo parlours are not allowed to brand people and if they did could (and generally would) be charged with assault.

* Further Fuji might have considered why Fraternity Hazing is now banned at probably all Universities in North America and when it does occur is almost always prosecuted, and how his Hazing example is quite different from a Tattoo Parlour, and similar to a father conducting a home made branding of his children.

In Ontario extreme body modification including branding is in a grey limbo and the parameters are being laid as the tattoo industry pushes the limits of what they do. Even tattoo artists differ in what they think.

Read the comments of the MDs in this articles. I think they know what they're talking about.

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/De...+performed+tattoo+parlours/2760389/story.html

In the seemingly no-boundaries world of tattooing and body piercing, artists no longer just poke and pinch parts of the body.

They split tongues, create artistic scars by cutting or branding, and implant three-dimensional objects underneath the skin.

But how far is too far?

It's a debate roiling not only within the body-modification industry, but among medical professionals -- and even among law-enforcement agencies.

Police in Guelph, Ont., say they are considering criminal charges after receiving an anonymous package that contained a DVD showing genital surgery being performed at a local tattoo parlour.

But some in the industry say that if the surgery was performed with the client's informed consent, they don't see a problem.

"If you own anything, you own your body. If the state or society says no, we have more control of your body over you, you're not free," said Shannon Larratt, the Toronto founder of Body Modification Ezine, an online magazine.

"We've said it's OK to play risky sports. Why can't they make risks with their own body?" he said.

Dr. Richard Warren, a spokesman for the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgery, says some procedures clearly cross the line.

He said life-threatening complications could result if the modifications are not performed properly.

"At some point, invasive body modification becomes practising medicine without a licence," he said.

The anonymous packages in Guelph -- each containing a DVD, a letter of complaint and photographs -- arrived on March 2, and had been sent to Guelph's public health office, city hall and the local newspaper.

The envelope had no return address and was marked "urgent," said Janice Walters, manager of infectious disease control for Wellington-Dufferin-Guelph Public Health.

Officials turned over the package to police after viewing the DVD.

"It was obviously a surgical procedure in a non-surgical setting," Walters said.

According to the Guelph Mercury newspaper, the DVD shows a labia-reduction procedure being performed on a woman as heavy metal music blares in the background.

Hands and arms with distinct tattoos are visible but views of faces are fleeting and unclear, the newspaper reported.

It is clear that people in the room know the surgery is being taped.

Guelph police Det.-Const. Kevin King said he and his partner were stunned by what they saw.

"We looked at each other. We have never seen anything like this come across our desk before," King said.

But it was clear an investigation needed to be launched, he said.

King said the investigation could result in aggravated assault charges or charges of violating the provincial Health Professions Act, which states that this type of procedure can be performed only by a medical professional.

Consent will be one factor that police have to consider, he said.

In January 2009, Andrew Niland, a tattoo artist in North Bay, Ont., was charged with aggravated assault after police learned he had performed a similar procedure.

In a news release, North Bay police said: "Our service would caution the general public to seek professional medical opinion in any surgical procedure."

Niland died while the case was making its way through the courts.

Dr. Wayne Carman, president of the Canadian Society for Aesthetic (Cosmetic) Plastic Surgery, says anyone who performs a surgical procedure -- which he defines broadly as an act that involves significant breaking of the skin and that requires suturing or stitching and healing -- should have medical training.

"For someone to take on some of these ideas -- even splitting a tongue -- it's not something you do in some-one's basement," he said.

There's no consensus within the tattoo and piercing industry. Calgary tattoo artist Steve Peace says he thinks most practitioners of extreme body modification are unqualified and unaware of the risks.

"Where do you stop? Now, they're cutting nipples off," he said. "I'm a tattoo artist. I'm not a doctor."

But most doctors won't perform these types of procedures, said Russ Foxx, a body-modification specialist in Vancouver. "That leaves us in a predicament. Who do I go to?" he said.

Foxx said he learns how to perform procedures from talking to veteran practitioners, reading books and travelling to conventions.

He says he always informs clients of the risks involved before beginning any procedure.

Too much regulation could have the effect of driving these activities further underground, said Jason MacDonald, an environmental health officer in Edmonton who inspects tattoo parlours to make sure instruments are sanitized and records are properly kept.

MacDonald added that new forms of body modification are constantly coming out.

If lawmakers start banning certain procedures, he said, the practitioners will just start doing "10 more things that we hadn't thought of."

© Copyright (c) The Vancouver Sun

Remember the recipient was 15 year boy. I wonder how many tattoo artist would have done it. I know artist that won't put name in tattoos; too much hassle later.
 
Yes, it is illegal because they are children. That is not a technicality, fuji, that is the law.

It is the law, but I think it's a case where the law isn't actually preventing any harm from being done.

Also, I am still waiting for you to tell me how many people you know of personally who are branded?

One, personally, though not very well. Very few of my friends have tattoos either.

As for it being terrible, you are the only one arguing that it isn't a terrible thing. Taking a piece of iron and heating it up to 2000 degrees, then touching it to your child's skin? How is that not terrible, fuji?

If it was so terrible so many people wouldn't do it voluntarily. As someone pointed out, the high heat actually makes it less painful than if it wasn't as hot.

Branding your child may not be as bad as breaking their arm?

Breaking anyone's arm is worse than branding anyone. In the case of adults, it is always illegal to break someone's arm--even adults can't consent to that, however, they can consent to being branded.
 
Yes, it is illegal because they are children. That is not a technicality, fuji, that is the law.

Also, I am still waiting for you to tell me how many people you know of personally who are branded? If it is so widespread, as you claim it to be, you should be able to tell us how many people you've encountered with a brand?

As for it being terrible, you are the only one arguing that it isn't a terrible thing. Taking a piece of iron and heating it up to 2000 degrees, then touching it to your child's skin? How is that not terrible, fuji?

Branding your child may not be as bad as breaking their arm? Are you serious? THAT is your rationale?! I could say something like "branding your child is not as bad locking them in a cellar for a month in the dark with nothing but a pot to piss in and the company of cockroaches, and only feeding them stale bread".

What is your point? No matter what you decide to compare it to, fuji, it's still terrible. A child should never have been put in the position that these children were put into. The fact that they defended their father and seemingly "wanted" it, can't be taken into consideration either. They are children, and easily influenced.

Every one of these points is bang on. Well said. Now in Fuji's alternate universe .......................

I know more than my sharing of bikers, past and present, and I know only one with very small brand obviously done by someone with skill and she said it was the dumbest thing she ever did. So it's not very common among a crowd that you might think it would be.

I should sound out my Goth friends.
 
Aardvark: "Fuji is confusing activity which is not normally harmful and can be consented to e.g. athletic activity with activity which always causes serious bodily harm: i.e. branding or hitting someone with a baseball bat. "

At this point, blackrock, I'd be really interested to hear whether there is anything I've posted that you can say you disagree with. Be specific. It's certainly NOT my point that an adult can consent to be branded that you disagree with.

You may be interested, but I'm not taking the bait as it's all been said before by me and most of the other members.
 
You may be interested, but I'm not taking the bait as it's all been said before by me and most of the other members.

Right. So you're just a disagreeable person. You thought you were disagreeing with me, but then you found you were repeating my point without realizing it. Now you don't know what to say, but you are hoping to find some way to be disagreeable.
 
Right. So you're just a disagreeable person. You thought you were disagreeing with me, but then you found you were repeating my point without realizing it. Now you don't know what to say, but you are hoping to find some way to be disagreeable.

Nope. i never found out any such thing. you think that's the case and we all know how good you ability to read and understand what you're reading is, You've shown us over and over again. Your skill at reading things that aren't there is unsurpassed by any member on Terb.

Please refer to #261 and a number of various post where others seem to disagree with you about the point of the thread.
 
You need to read the thread for context, but in post #173 it becomes clear that he thinks branding is outright illegal all the time for everyone.

LOL. And from that you say that you have been defending the right of adults to cosent for 15 pages. Sir you are either unbelievably disingenuous or a complete moron. My bet is the latter. You are a classic.
 
You need to read the thread for context, but in post #173 it becomes clear that he thinks branding is outright illegal all the time for everyone.


Where does he say that Fuji?

Originally Posted by fuji

Because branding is legally consented to all the time in tattoo parlours around Canada and the United States.

Aartie responds;

Perhaps it is in Ontario. It certainly isn't legal for tatoo parlours to brand people in my part of North America.

He's saying it may or may not, the definition of 'perhaps', be illegal in Ontario. Then he says it's certainly not legal in HIS PART of North America, not everywhere for everyone. Take the needles out of your eyes and you may be able to read english better. It's the comprehension that I have my doubts about though.
 
LOL. And from that you say that you have been defending the right of adults to cosent for 15 pages. Sir you are either unbelievably disingenuous or a complete moron. My bet is the latter. You are a classic.

I refer you to my post #12 for a clear statement of my position.
 
Where does he say that Fuji?

Originally Posted by fuji

Because branding is legally consented to all the time in tattoo parlours around Canada and the United States.

Aartie responds;

Perhaps it is in Ontario. It certainly isn't legal for tatoo parlours to brand people in my part of North America.

He's saying it may or may not, the definition of 'perhaps', be illegal in Ontario. Then he says it's certainly not legal in HIS PART of North America, not everywhere for everyone. Take the needles out of your eyes and you may be able to read english better. It's the comprehension that I have my doubts about though.

Please. Lets get real here. he is grasping for anything which would somehow justify his complete change in what he says was the point of his posts. Anyone who takes the time to read the thread (and I would not encourage anyone to waste their time if they have not been following because it will be 20 minutes of your life you will never get back) will see that he has bee trying to justify some cockeyed view of the law which the lawyers and everyone else has disputed. He now laughably says that his point was always that adults can consent. DUH. The man is a moron and this is not an ad hominem attack but rather directly responsive to his most recent position.
 
He plainly wrote that he thinks branding is like having your arm broken--something that not even adults can consent to.



Where does he say that Fuji?

Aartie responds;

Perhaps it is in Ontario. It certainly isn't legal for tatoo parlours to brand people in my part of North America.

He's saying it may or may not, the definition of 'perhaps', be illegal in Ontario. Then he says it's certainly not legal in HIS PART of North America, not everywhere for everyone. Take the needles out of your eyes and you may be able to read english better. It's the comprehension that I have my doubts about though.


Please find the words broken and arm in the response.