Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which the esteemed doctors explain fairly clearly why it is unlikely to get infected in a first world country.

If he was not taking care of it properly the appropriate charge for that would presumably be negligence. He wasn't charged with negligence.

Yes, because I imagine the Mother, the other custodial parent, took care of it. Just because it didn't become infected had nothing to do with it, fuji. They shouldn't have been branded in the first place.

As for branding being commonplace, come on, if it's something so common that even the goddamn President of the United States has probably done it, well it's pretty common. Again, I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which the esteemed doctors point out that it has become "fashionable".

I have met a LOT of people in my life. Never met anyone who was branded...wait...no, I haven't. Just because you found an article stating that one person had it done, and that it was the President (who may or may not have had it done, btw) does not make it commonplace. That is a bit of a stretch, even for you, fuji. We should do a poll to see how many board members personally know someone who has had a branding, and then do a contrasting poll to see who personally knows someone who has a tattoo or piercing. Oh wait, we don't need to, because BRANDING IS NOT COMMON. Unless you are an effin' cow.

It's something that has become fashionable.

You know what? At one point "MC Hammer" pants were fashionable. That don't make it right.
 
There's a couple of tattoo shops in Toronto that will perform human branding if you want to get one.

Since you're the one who thinks it's no big deal, why don't you go ahead? That would certainly give you more knowledge on the subject that any of us have.

I can see it now....TERB...in big bright third-degree-burned flesh. Where will you put it?
 
There's a couple of tattoo shops in Toronto that will perform human branding if you want to get one.

That does not mean it's common place, fuji! Seriously, that does not mean that there will be any takers. Try again. Simply because something rare is offered somewhere, does not make it less rare.

What are the figures for the general population having a brand? Quite low, I'm sure, no matter how often it's offered.
 
No, you are wrong, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. Not even adults. The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.

You are wrong and you do not understand the law. Adults can consent. Do you think if I cam up and punched you in the nose and broke it that would be serious bodily harm under our Criminal Code? It would. If we were in a boxing ring and I broke your nose would I have committed a criminal offense. i would not. Why not. You consented. Do you think if I tackled you on the street and broke your arm or leg that would be serious bodily harm? It would. if we were playing football would I be convicted? i would not.

You really do not understand the law and you are mixing concepts. Burning flesh and leaving a permanent scar would be serious bodily harm by most definitions, apparently other than yours.
 
You are wrong and you do not understand the law. Adults can consent.

I could not consent to having you intentionally break my arm. Not unless there were some medical reason. I can, however, consent to being branded. There is a big difference between you breaking my arm by accident while we are playing football--a risk I knew I was taking--and your setting out to do it on purpose. No matter what I sign I cannot consent to the latter, yet I can consent to branding.

Plainly there's a difference there which you are intentionally ignoring between consenting to the certainty of having my arm intentionally broken (not possible) and consenting to have a brand applied (possible).

edit: i meant the bolded word certainty instead of the word risk I originally typed by mistake, corrected now, sorry for any confusion.
 
Fuji, that is some of the most confused legal reasoning I've read in a while.

A University student of age, refuses to press charges nor talk about until after the statute of limitations has tolled, what could be charged as an aggravated assault (a fraternity branding). Therefore, this means that a branding cannot cause serious bodily harm. What the Hell!?!

It is not legal reasoning at all. in fact it is the opposite of legal reasoning because if he new anything at all about law he would not be making what is a silly argument.
 
She cannot consent to you breaking her arm with a baseball bat. She could, however, legally consent to being branded. I think you're arguing against your own case here.
Fuji, this is like banging my head into a wall with you. How on earth do you think that breaking her arm with a baseball bat is any different from branding in terms of consent.

Just because a jury refuses to convict doesn't mean the law has changed. Your argument is basicly the same as saying that killing your ex-wife and her friend is not a crime in Brentwood Los Angeles.
 
Fuji, this is like banging my head into a wall with you. How on earth do you think that breaking her arm with a baseball bat is any different from branding in terms of consent.

Because branding is legally consented to all the time in tattoo parlours around Canada and the United States, by the former President of the United States potentially, and so on. There is no question that branding can be consented to by adults. None. The only question is whether children in conjunction with their parents can consent to it.
 
You are wrong and you do not understand the law. Adults can consent. . . . Do you think if I tackled you on the street and broke your arm or leg that would be serious bodily harm? It would. if we were playing football would I be convicted? i would not.
As you know Toguy, Fuji is confusing activity which is not normally harmful and can be consented to e.g. athletic activity with activity which always causes serious bodily harm: i.e. branding or hitting someone with a baseball bat. Further as Oagre pointed out several posts ago, athletic consent is limited: a hockey player cannot start clubbing another player over the head with their stick as "part of the game."
 
I could not consent to having you intentionally break my arm. Not unless there were some medical reason. I can, however, consent to being branded. There is a big difference between you breaking my arm by accident while we are playing football--a risk I knew I was taking--and your setting out to do it on purpose. No matter what I sign I cannot consent to the latter, yet I can consent to branding.

Plainly there's a difference there which you are intentionally ignoring between consenting to the certainty of having my arm intentionally broken (not possible) and consenting to have a brand applied (possible).

edit: i meant the bolded word certainty instead of the word risk I originally typed by mistake, corrected now, sorry for any confusion.

You are missing the point. You cannot consent to being killed and you cannot consent to some form of harm which is life threatening etc. But the injury which must be suffered in order to sustain a conviction to aggravated assault or assault causing bodily harm etc. is fat less. It need not be life threatening or the degree of injury you would like to spin this debate into. Branding, ie the burning of flesh and the attendant pain would be sufficient to sustain the charge whether or not you think so. An adult could consent. A child could not and the parent could not consent on behalf of his/her child. You are simply grasping for something which does not exist and that is a legal justification for a barbaric act by a parent upon his children.
 
Because branding is legally consented to all the time in tattoo parlours around Canada and the United States.
Perhaps it is in Ontario. It certainly isn't legal for tatoo parlours to brand people in my part of North America.
 
Perhaps it is in Ontario. It certainly isn't legal for tatoo parlours to brand people in my part of North America.

Can you prove that? It's legal at Yale, so long as it's voluntary. I'd like you to cite a conviction that was registered anywhere in America for a voluntary branding of an adult.
 
As you know Toguy, Fuji is confusing activity which is not normally harmful and can be consented to e.g. athletic activity with activity which always causes serious bodily harm: i.e. branding or hitting someone with a baseball bat. Further as Oagre point out several posts ago, athletic consent is limited: a hockey player cannot start clubbing another player over the head with their stick as "part of the game."

Fujii is confusing different principles. A boxer is consenting to being punched in the face. In different circumstances that would support a conviction for aggravate assault etc. He is assuming incorrectly that the degree of injury to which someone cannot consent is the same degree as required to make out the offense of assault causing bodily harm etc. and this is just legally wrong. It is not black and white as he would like to argue because that is the only basis upon which he can make a silly and frankly embarrassing argument. They are very different standards.
 
It's legal at Yale, so long as it's voluntary.
There you go again. Who says it is legal? What you are really saying is that no one has yet been prosecuted because there needs to be a complaint and there hasn't yet been one. If all new pledges have their arms broken but they say that it is a result of injury in an intramural lacrosse game a crime has still been committed even if it is never reported.
 
There you go again. Who says it is legal?

The British Courts have ruled that it is legal provided there is no intent to commit cruelty, for example. In a case without elements of cruelty the courts ruled it was not assault, but in a case of sadomasochism where there were elements of cruelty they registered a conviction. So intent is key here, at least under British common law. You cannot consent to bodily harm ONLY when there are elements of cruelty or maliciousness present.

This is similar to sports--your arm may be broken in a sports game, but if there is no cruel intent, if it was not done maliciously, and you consented to the risks, then there is no assault. It is similar as well to medical practice: You may have serious harm inflicted on you by a surgical operation, but there was no cruel intent, so no assault.

I think you can't find a conviction for ANY consensual body modification practice where there is no cruel intent. Not for human branding, not for scarification, not for any of them. When it is consensual, and there is no element of cruelty, the courts are going to find that it is not an assault.

What was never tested anywhere before the case on the present thread is the extent to which children can consent to it in conjunction with their parents.
 
The British Courts have ruled that it is legal provided there is no intent to commit cruelty.
To state the obvious, the only problem is that this is not England (including Wales and Northern Ireland) or Scotland (separate legal systems).
 
To state the obvious, the only problem is that this is not England (including Wales and Northern Ireland) or Scotland (separate legal systems).

However the principles upon which the decision was based are old enough that it's likely American courts would find the same way, and it would not surprise me in the least to find out they already have, branding being such a common practice in America.
 
You guys are still arguing with this idiot? Let me explain something. Fugi has no real convictions. He will argue a point, any point, just for the sake of arguing. The more outlandish the better. It doesn't matter. He will continue just to see if he can win, or barring that, just to see if he can outlast anyone else. It's his own private little ego trip. That's all.