Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Fuji, the jury was deadlocked, which means half of them were of different mind. They did not acquit him, at all.

btw, you make me sick. Sorry, but it's true.

Makes two of us. At the very least.
 
True, but from the story, it looks like the defense agreed to the rest.

And your keen legal analysis is based on what exactly. More supposition? at some point you are going to have to learn the distinction bewteen supposition and fact. It is obvious to me at least that you do not appreciate the difference.
 
And your keen legal analysis is based on what exactly. More supposition? at some point you are going to have to learn the distinction bewteen supposition and fact. It is obvious to me at least that you do not appreciate the difference.

The article states that the defense agreed to facts. They disagreed on whether it was a crime.
 
Where does it say that the branding was not serious bodily harm?

How was George W. Bush able to consent to it (whether or not he actually did) if branding is serious bodily harm? In the story it's the part where about the only thing the jury had to decide was whether it was the sort of thing the children could consent to in conjunction with their parents.
 
How was George W. Bush able to consent to it (whether or not he actually did) if branding is serious bodily harm? In the story it's the part where about the only thing the jury had to decide was whether it was the sort of thing the children could consent to in conjunction with their parents.

Firstly an adult can consent. Hence the injuries that arise from boxing generally do not amount to criminal offenses. Secondly you are reading into the verdict something that is not necessarily there and as usual turning supposition into fact.
 
Firstly an adult can consent. Hence the injuries that arise from boxing generally do not amount to criminal offenses. Secondly you are reading into the verdict something that is not necessarily there and as usual turning supposition into fact.

No, you are wrong, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. Not even adults. The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.
 
No, you are wrong, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. Not even adults. The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.

I think you are wrong. From Wikepedia, but I"m sure this information is available elsewhere.

United States

American common law has defined assault as an attempt to commit a battery.
Assault is typically treated as a misdemeanor and not as a felony (unless it involves a law enforcement officer). The more serious crime of aggravated assault is treated as a felony.

Four elements were required at common law:
1)The apparent, present ability to carry out;
2)An unlawful attempt;
3)To commit a violent injury;
4)Upon another.

Simple assault can be distinguished without the intent of injury upon another person. The violation of one's personal space or touching in a way the victim deemed inappropriate can be simple assault. In common law states an assault is not committed by merely, for example, swearing at another; without threat of battery, there can be no assault.

As the criminal law evolved, element one was weakened in most jurisdictions so that a reasonable fear of bodily injury would suffice. These four elements were eventually codified in most states.

Modern American statutes define assault as:
-an attempt to cause or purposely, knowingly, or recklessly causing bodily injury to another; or,
-negligently causing bodily injury to another with a deadly weapon.


Some states also define assault as an attempt to menace (or actual menacing) by placing another person in fear of imminent serious bodily injury.

States vary on whether it is possible to commit an "attempted assault" since it can be considered a double inchoate offense.

In some states, consent is a complete defense to assault. In other jurisdictions, mutual consent is an incomplete defense, with the result that the misdemeanor is treated as a petty misdemeanor.

Furthermore, the crime of assault generally requires that both the perpetrator and the victim of an assault are human. Thus, there is no assault if an ox gores a man. However, the Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2004 treats the fetus as a separate person for the purposes of assault and other violent crimes, under certain limited circumstances. See H.R. 1997 / P.L. 108-212[dead link]

Some possible examples of defenses, mitigating circumstances, or failures of proof are:

A defendant could argue that since he was drunk, he could not form the specific intent to commit assault. This defense would most likely fail since only involuntary intoxication is accepted as a defense in most American jurisdictions.
A defendant could also argue that he was engaged in mutually consensual behavior.



And, back to the original contention that as children, they were unable to consent.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault
 
No, you are wrong, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. Not even adults. The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.


Boxing punches?? Are you high?

Third-degree burns, risk of infection, scarred for life. You don't consider that serious???

I sincerely hope there are no children in your care.
 
Boxing punches?? Are you high?

Third-degree burns, risk of infection, scarred for life. You don't consider that serious???

I sincerely hope there are no children in your care.

I think you missed the part where this is routine in certain circles, for example, George W Bush's experience at Yale. You're making it sound worse than it is.
 
I think you missed the part where this is routine in certain circles, for example, George W Bush's experience at Yale. You're making it sound worse than it is.

Third-degree burns...fact.
Risk of infection....fact.
Scarred for life...fact, unless they're willing to undergo painful and expensive plastic surgery.

How did I make it sound worse than it is?

And please, don't use Bush as an example...he did a lot of coke too, should that be ok for minors as long as they really really want it?
 
No, you are wrong, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. Not even adults. The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.

No one can consent to serious bodily harm? Not even adults? As far as boxers go I could name several that are permanently damaged from pugilistic dementia. Adults consent to serious bodily harm all the time. They go to war and kill each other. These were kids supposedly under their fathers care. He scarred them permanently. Again, what about that don't you get?
 
I'm just establishing that branding cannot possibly be considered serious bodily harm. You're all making it sound a whole lot worse than it is.
Fuji, that is some of the most confused legal reasoning I've read in a while.

A University student of age, refuses to press charges nor talk about until after the statute of limitations has tolled, what could be charged as an aggravated assault (a fraternity branding). Therefore, this means that a branding cannot cause serious bodily harm. What the Hell!?!
 
Fuji, that is some of the most confused legal reasoning I've read in a while.

A University student of age, refuses to press charges nor talk about until after the statute of limitations has tolled, what could be charged as an aggravated assault (a fraternity branding). Therefore, this means that a branding cannot cause serious bodily harm. What the Hell!?!

I'm picking Bush as an example for obvious reasons of showing just how commonplace it is. There are, however, lots of other people who get brandings. Legally.
 
I'm picking Bush as an example for obvious reasons of showing just how commonplace it is. There are, however, lots of other people who get brandings. Legally.
Which does not "establish that branding cannot possibly be considered serious bodily harm" as you wrote.
 
If we pull back from the name-calling, and the sound byte styled logic, and employ a little more depth in critical thinking and analysis, we might obtain a better result.

I will preface my comment by saying that l will only deal with law as it is in Ontario not in any other jurisdiction. I have no idea of the laws of Washington state and have not the time or inclination to research them. I'm sure the detractors will seize on this point.

I would suggest the key questions are:
What are the limits on a parent’s ability to consent for a child?
At what point is branding an assault?

Clearly, there are limits on parental consent. They operate in a spectrum based on relative events and social norms.

Let us establish some ridiculous examples as outliers of the spectrum. Had the father elected to punish the child by placing a hot clothing iron on the child’s arm clearly that would be a criminal offence. At the other end, a father can take a child for a haircut without the police being called.

As we start to work our way in from these extremes some interesting things crop-up.
If the haircut was of a young girl with particularly long tresses and she is shaved bald, that would start to cross the line of harm to the child, not because of physical damage to her body but because of the psychological damage and distress she would endure.

At the lesser end, we see there are cases where everyday parents give consent to activities where children are harmed. They are sent to play hockey, soccer, karate and other activities where upon occasion a child suffers an injury and goes to hospital. The parent is never charged with an offence. The reason being is the lack of intent to harm and the totality of the circumstances. The parent’s intent is for the child to have fun. The sport is organized and supervised; it is commonplace and well within our social norms.

Can a parent consent to an assault?

[FONT=&quot]“Assault[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]265. [/FONT][FONT=&quot](1) A person commits an assault when[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](a) without the consent of another person, he applies force intentionally to that other person, directly or indirectly;”[/FONT]


then parental consent cannot be given.


[FONT=&quot]Consent[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](3) For the purposes of this section, no consent is obtained where the complainant submits or does not resist by reason of[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](a) the application of force to the complainant or to a person other than the complainant;[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](b) threats or fear of the application of force to the complainant or to a person other than the complainant;[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](c) fraud; or[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot](d) the exercise of authority.[/FONT]

In other words, a parent cannot consent to an assault.


At what point is branding an assault?

Some people voluntarily are branded as a form of body art. They are exercising a most fundamental freedom of expression within the integrity of their own body. While it is not my cup of tea, it is a fundamental constitutional right.

Some people use branding as part of a form of violence so that their victim is to bear a lifelong marker of the crime. Obviously a despicable act well deserving of imprisonment.

A review of the case law is difficult. It appears that incidences of a parent branding a child for social or entertainment purposes are an extremely rare occurrence. As opposed to those criminal cases where the ex-boyfriend brands his lost lover, or where the child is scarred by a hot implement as a punishment, both of which are unfortunately common

If nothing else, the lack of occurrence is some evidence that it is conduct that is far outside social norms and as such constitutes an assault.

Then when we look at the offence of aggravated assault.

[FONT=&quot]Aggravated assault[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]268. [/FONT][FONT=&quot](1) Every one commits an aggravated assault who wounds, maims, disfigures or endangers the life of the complainant.[/FONT]

The law is that once there has been a disfigurement it is a prima facia assault and there are very limited reasons for a defence (i.e. self-defence, a bona fide medical procedure, accident).

The branding is clearly a wound and it also disfigured. There is no availability of parental consent as a defence.

GUILTY.


A few asides;

There are also other offences such as criminal negligence, the “[FONT=&quot]Duty of persons undertaking acts dangerous to life”, and [/FONT]assault with a weapon, to wit a branding iron.

[FONT=&quot]In this jurisdiction, there are also potential civil lawsuits. Once the children turn 18 they are free to sue their father for these acts.[/FONT]
 
If we pull back from the name-calling, and the sound byte styled logic, and employ a little more depth in critical thinking and analysis, we might obtain a better result.

I appreciate your post. I have a few things to point out though:

Can a parent consent to an assault?

This is a rhetorical question because, if it can be consented to, by definition it is not assault. As you point out there are indeed situations in which parents can consent to their child experiencing harm or possible harm. You mentioned sports. I will mention open heart surgery, or the amputation of a gangrenous leg.

You might say that amputation is only valid if performed by a doctor, but I suspect that if a parent in a remote wilderness location amputated the gangrenous leg of their child in an effort to save their life, that there would be no charge of assault, providing it was all done in good faith and with rational justification.

Thus consent is not merely so simple a matter as quoting this and saying "guity":

(1) Every one commits an aggravated assault who wounds, maims, disfigures or endangers the life of the complainant.

Plainly there is a little more to it than that. Specifically, I think you're going to have to get around to a discussion of whether the child is going to be harmed, and ask questions about what "harm" actually means.

Then there is this:

The law is that once there has been a disfigurement

A disfigurement in whose opinion? The parents and the children do not consider it to be a disfigurement. They consider it to be a desirable branding.

Were it as clear cut as you say then anyone who applied a branding to an adult would be guilty of assault as well: Your argument that no consent can be given based merely on quoting this section of law would equally outlaw all branding of anyone ever, child or adult.

So it is not as simple as that. We are talking about something that plainly can be consented to by adults and that means it is not prima facie an assault for any intrinsic or inherent reason.

It really comes down to a pretty nebulous question of what can a parent and child in combination consent to?