Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Lagavulin, thanks for the great post! If by some miracle we are both at that spring fling party, I would love to buy you a drink!

Fuji, both parents did NOT consent to the branding.

http://justice4caylee.forumotion.net/adjudicated-cases-f31/branded-the-children-the-seamands-kids-port-angeles-wa-t6402.htm

Both the mother and the grandmother were horrified when they saw what occurred to the kids, and by the newscast I watched, were also saddened by the verdict.

In some cases, as Lagavulin pointed out, a guardian commits assault by something completely innocuous, such as a haircut. I am reminded that foster parents of aboriginal or first nations children are unable to and require special permissions cut the hair of the children in their care, as that hair can be used for "bad medicine".

By no means is this "serious bodily harm", fuji's favorite argument (gangrene?! come ON!), but it is still an assault. In addition, a parent may or may not intend harm when it is done, and in fact may be trying to do good, but does that negate the fact that the child was assaulted?

It depends on the perspective of the one doing the protesting and claiming assault (often it is the lawmakers, no matter what the 'victims' have to say about it.) In this case, it seems like everyone but the father and children (and fuji) are protesting these actions. This fact does not make what the father did any less criminal, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
According to Oagre, no-one can consent to serious bodily harm, so take it up with him. He was referring to Canadian law but I would imagine a similar principle applies in the United States.
In addition to the excelent points raised by Lagavulin, you are confusing consent with refusing to press charges.

Let's go to an overly powerful illustration again. An SP agrees that for $1.5 million I can break her arm with a baseball bat, she agrees not to report it to the police, I know something of orthopedics so I set her arm without the medical establishment becoming involved but her arm is permanently damaged. Can she validly consent to my breaking her arm, what if we successfully cover it up and she only tells someone about this 50 years latter?

Can you not see that the consent is invalid, what actually occurred was that she did not press charges and the cover-up of a crime. *


* your fraternity branding.
 
No one can consent to serious bodily harm? Not even adults? As far as boxers go I could name several that are permanently damaged from pugilistic dementia. Adults consent to serious bodily harm all the time. They go to war and kill each other. These were kids supposedly under their fathers care. He scarred them permanently. Again, what about that don't you get?

There is an implied consent to the normal risks of a sport when you volunteer to participate in it. The consent does not extend to abnormal activities. For instance, an NHL player consents to getting roughly bodychecked and to low level penal-izable activities like elbowing and high-sticking. He does not consent to being hunted and beaten by a larger, stronger player who brutally injures him - i.e. the Todd Beruzzi incident.

Yes, a boxer consents to being punched as part of the sport and in this instance, it is understood that the sport is very dangerous and the normal activities of the sport can lead to serious physical harm. This is right at the borderline of what can be consented to under Canadian law.

War is different. It is declared formally and has its own rules and laws. Ditto police officers - I suppose - consent to be shot at when they deal with dangerous criminals. But again, that is a far different kettle of fish.
 
This is a rhetorical question because, if it can be consented to, by definition it is not assault.
...

Can a parent consent to an assault is not a rhetorical question, it is a legal one and is explicitly sent out in section 265 of the Criminal Code of Canada (which I copied in my first post, here it is again, I’ll use different colours to highlight it)

Consent
(3) For the purposes of this section, no consent is obtained where the complainant submits or does not resist by reason of
…

(d) the exercise of authority.


There is a two-step analysis.
First, was there an assault?
Second, is there a defence?

The branding of a child is an assault.
It meets the definition of wounding in section 268 of the Criminal Code (again another copy with different colours).

268. (1) Every one commits an aggravated assault who wounds, maims, disfigures or endangers the life of the complainant.

I believe it is a disfigurement in addition to being a wound, you do not, but the point is moot since it is without a doubt a wound. There is a substantial amount of appellate case law on these definitions.

If you adopt the position that what is shown in the image of the OP’s linked article is not a wound, then there is no point of further debate, but you have not made that argument.

Had the father committed the exact same act, except at the time he had been swearing and cursing at the child and doing it for punishment, there would be no doubt that it was an assault. The mark on the child would be identical and it would be evidence of an assault; the difference is in the circumstances that may lend a defence to the father.

Had the father and son been in a remote area, the son had cut open his arm, and the father branded the arm in order to cauterize a wound and stop bleeding then the elements of the defence of necessity could be made out.

I explicitly stated previously that there are defences available.
(i.e. self-defence, a bona fide medical procedure, accident).
I did not give an exhaustive list, the point was that there are defences but the father has not availed himself of a defence that is tenable at law in this jurisdiction.

In this case, your presentation of the father’s defence is that of consent. Consent is not a defence in these circumstances.

Your raising the definition of “harm” is not applicable. The Criminal Code has defined aggravated assault as wounding and that has occurred. The concept of, definition of, and spectrum of injuries that encompass harm may very well be relevant vis a vis sentencing of the father, but not for the finding of guilt. It would appear that these events would attract a lower range in the sentencing guidelines, but there would still be a finding of guilt.

There may also be a misunderstanding about consent in general. The freedom that a person can exercise over their own body is not the same as the more limited consent that a parent can grant on behalf of a child. They are very different standards.

This would also lead into a discussion of the doctrine of parens patriae where the court can stand in the place of the parent, but that can wait for another thread.

Suppose there had been foreknowledge by the mother and she would have had time to go to court and obtain an injunction against the father. I have no doubt that she would have been granted an injunction and the father barred from branding his children. But admittedly that would be a civil matter not criminal.

Now it is time for an ale, and some peppers and goat cheese on a baguette delicately roasted.
 
There is an implied consent to the normal risks of a sport when you volunteer to participate in it. The consent does not extend to abnormal activities. For instance, an NHL player consents to getting roughly bodychecked and to low level penal-izable activities like elbowing and high-sticking. He does not consent to being hunted and beaten by a larger, stronger player who brutally injures him - i.e. the Todd Beruzzi incident.

Yes, a boxer consents to being punched as part of the sport and in this instance, it is understood that the sport is very dangerous and the normal activities of the sport can lead to serious physical harm. This is right at the borderline of what can be consented to under Canadian law.

War is different. It is declared formally and has its own rules and laws. Ditto police officers - I suppose - consent to be shot at when they deal with dangerous criminals. But again, that is a far different kettle of fish.

As I'm sure you understand, I pointed that out only to show that adults can agree to put themselves in a position that will likely result in serious harm. These were under age kids under their father's care. Fugi seems to think that doesn't matter, or that it was done out of love, or that it wasn't serious harm. One or all three. I think he's warped.
 
Well there's a jury out there that would seem to agree with me. I do not see a branding as a wound or a disfigurement any more than I see a piercing as a wound or a disfigurement. I think the concept of a wound requires that it be something that is either undesirable or cause for medical concern. Tattoos, piercings, etc., that are desirable do not cut it.

Now if I put a tattoo on you that you did not consent to have that would be a fairly serious assault on your person, so yes, I think the issue here is consent.

The only real difference between a branding and a tattoo is that it hurts more to get the branding. Since it is in fact quite a common practice, one resorted to even by former Presidents of the United States apparently, it does not seem to be that far out of the pale for a parent to grant consent to a willing child to engage in this common and widespread American practice.
 
Well there's a jury out there that would seem to agree with me. I do not see a branding as a wound or a disfigurement any more than I see a piercing as a wound or a disfigurement. I think the concept of a wound requires that it be something that is either undesirable or cause for medical concern. Tattoos, piercings, etc., that are desirable do not cut it.

Now if I put a tattoo on you that you did not consent to have that would be a fairly serious assault on your person, so yes, I think the issue here is consent.

The only real difference between a branding and a tattoo is that it hurts more to get the branding. Since it is in fact quite a common practice, one resorted to even by former Presidents of the United States apparently, it does not seem to be that far out of the pale for a parent to grant consent to a willing child to engage in this common and widespread American practice.


Um, how did we get to "common and widespread" ? Even if you're correct about Bush and his fratboy friends, I hardly think that makes it common.

You made me curious, though, and I tripped over this...

Introduction

Branding refers to a process whereby third degree burns are inflicted on the skin with a hot iron rod or metallic object. Branding employs the phenomenon of "counter irritation," and is widely used by faith healers in developing countries for therapeutic purposes. Some methods, which are very crude and inhuman, carry a large risk of complications. The purpose of this study is to present a series of complications and to familiarize clinicians with this dangerous method of treatment.
Case presentation

Four Pakistani patients, three male and one female, ranging from 25 to 60 years of age "branded" with a red hot iron rod for various medical reasons presented with severe medical complications to our tertiary care hospital. The mean duration between the procedure and presentation to the hospital was 6 days. At the time of admission, two patients had septic shock, one patient had cavernous sinus thrombosis and one patient had multiple splenic abscesses. All patients received standard care for wound management and systemic infections. Two patients eventually died during the course of treatment.
Conclusion

Severe complications from branding are troublesome and the potential risks of this treatment outweigh its benefits. Globally, there is a great need for heightened awareness about the dangers of branding among patients and physicians, as this will have an important effect on patients who seek branding for various medical conditions.



Here's the link if you'd like to read the whole thing.... http://jmedicalcasereports.com/content/3/1/25

Apparently, it's a bigger deal than you think.
 
Apparently, it's a bigger deal than you think.

The same thing happens with piercings. If you do read the full article you will find that the complications in the cases resulted from infection: the third world country "faith healers" did not understand the concept of sterilization and did not properly cover the brands or clean them with soap and water. Presumably anyone in a 1st world country with at least a highschool education would not have made those mistakes.

The authors of your article say this themselves quite clearly:

Branding has recently become more fashionable in Western countries [1,3], where it is increasingly practised as body art. In these settings branding is usually performed in safe conditions, or with more precautions against serious infection, and is not used for counter irritation as it is in people whose health is already seriously compromised.

...

There is no direct association between the behavior associated risk problem in Western populations and the complications seen in our patients. Thus people who seek branding for body-art do not have the same sequelae of acute infections because of better sterile techniques.

By the way SillyGirl, also note that your article indeed does confirm my point that "Branding has recently become more fashionable in Western countries". In fact it's been around here for a long time--GWB's fraternity has been branding people since forever. We're talking the elites of the United States here, students at Yale. Don't think for a second that the practice is limited to Yale either. Branding has been a fine American tradition since the country was founded so far as I can tell.
 
Let's go to an overly powerful illustration again. An SP agrees that for $1.5 million I can break her arm with a baseball bat

She cannot consent to you breaking her arm with a baseball bat. She could, however, legally consent to being branded. I think you're arguing against your own case here.
 
The same thing happens with piercings. If you do read the full article you will find that the complications in the cases resulted from infection: the third world country "faith healers" did not understand the concept of sterilization and did not properly cover the brands or clean them with soap and water. Presumably anyone in a 1st world country with at least a highschool education would not have made those mistakes.

The authors of your article say this themselves quite clearly:


sigh....ok, let's say it's the new In thing to do. I agree with you about the need for it to be done with properly-sterilized equipment and in sterile conditions.

That wasn't the situation when Dad burned the kids.
 
Well there's a jury out there that would seem to agree with me.

The jury in the OP article did not convict. Was it because they agreed with you I do not know.



I do not see a branding as a wound ...

As I said previously if that will be your position then there is no point for debate.
If you adopt the position that what is shown in the image of the OP’s linked article is not a wound, then there is no point of further debate


There are certain facts that are plain and obvious perhaps best described as rational. If those underlying rational facts cannot be recognized then the debate becomes irrational.

The definition of wounding is part of a standard charge that judges give to juries in Canada.

To “wound” means to injure someone in a way that breaks or cuts or pierces or tears the skin or some part of the person’s body. It must be more than something trifling, fleeting or minor, such as a scratch.

http://www.canlii.org/en/ns/nssc/doc/2007/2007nssc215/2007nssc215.html

http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onca/doc/2006/2006canlii18516/2006canlii18516.html

If you believe that branding does not amount to the legal definition of a wound then there is nothing further for me to say.

BCzrf.jpg
 
Can she validly consent to my breaking her arm, what if we successfully cover it up and she only tells someone about this 50 years latter?

...the consent is invalid, what actually occurred was that she did not press charges and the cover-up of a crime.


* your fraternity branding.

Yes, I agree. Assault depends on the assaulted person telling others of the assault, or pressing charges, or having it occur in front of witnesses.

If Bob and Joe are drinking in Bob's backyard and they get into a dispute and Bob punches Joe, Joe could call the police and report it and get Bob charged with assault, or he could say nothing and let it go and therefore no assault charge. He can consent to covering up the assault, in other words. It doesn't mean it wasn't an assault, legally speaking.

In the case of a child, if there is a divorce and Dad isn't going to get custody and the kids are sad about the divorce and love him, and he says to keep our family bond alive post-divorce lets get branded with SK, and the kids go along with it, if they all keep quiet about it there may indeed be no charge so the consent works in the form of a group cover-up. If however the kids go home to mom and she sees they have been branded and isn't happy and takes them to a doctor who calls police, the consent of the kids is not valid as the cover-up is blown. Since the kids are minors they can't say "I'm not prressing charges" as the State acts on their behalf.
 
When done on an adult who consents it is NOT the case that a branding is an unreported assault. It is not an assault period. The only question is whether children can consent to it the way adults can. Consenting to a properly performed branding is plainly unlike trying to consent to have your arm broken--no court is going to convict someone for performing a piercing or branding or tattooing on a consenting adult.

That right there tosses the notion out that it is prima facie an assault just because some part of the code uses the word "wound". It's not. By that definition even a regular old piercing would be an assault as it plainly creates a wound to the same extent that branding does, sometimes just as painfully.
 
What makes me somewhat sympathetic is that he branded himself first, and it was only because his children desired to copy his behavior that they wound up being branded. The children do not see themselves as victims, they appear to be proud to have the branding, just like their dad does.

I think the whole family are a pack of idiots, but if the behavior is illegal, it is illegal on a technicality--I have a hard time accusing someone of assault when all the participants are happy, willing, and proud.

The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent. The same act, if they are old enough to consent, is plainly not criminal. They implicitly have their fathers consent, they have the mother's consent, they themselves consent (for whatever it's worth), and the act was not done out of any desire to inflict harm, but rather, as stupid as it may be, it was done out of love.

I think the parents here should be punished...for some sort of crime of assault. The fact (if it is a fact) that the children are happy with it makes it even more despicable. You hear the same arguments from the abusers in the fundamentalist mormon sects...that these child brides really wanted to get married, etc. ....and it is probably true in some sense, making it all the worse.

The time when society can shake off the idea that children are the property of the parents needs to come sooner than later. Children should have a set of rights that includes the right to freedom from abuse in the name of religion or any other belief.
 
That wasn't the situation when Dad burned the kids.

It looked clean and uninfected in the images I saw. I imagine that the brand was properly cleaned with soap and water unlike the case in the third world countries. The iron in and of itself is extremely sterile--not much lives at the 2000 degrees or whatever the iron is at. The key is how you care for it afterwards--do you rub it in dirt and use unclean water, or properly wash it and clean it? Anyone with a highschool education is going to properly wash and clean it. Not everyone in 3rd world countries has a highschool education though, or maybe they lack access to clean water and soap, so they wind up with infections for stupid reasons.
 
When done on an adult who consents it is NOT the case that a branding is an unreported assault. It is not an assault period. The only question is whether children can consent to it the way adults can.

You're correct that is the question. And what are they? Underaged children. The fact that you continue to argue this is amazing. They are disfigured for life. They were not competent to make any call about going through with this. As I said, their father had one role to fulfill. To protect his kids and provide guidance. He blew it. You say it was an act of love. What that tells me is that you will argue any point just to see if you can win.
 
It looked clean and uninfected in the images I saw. I imagine that the brand was properly cleaned with soap and water unlike the case in the third world countries.

You imagine it was, huh? Perhaps it was a fluke that it didn't get infected...that's what I imagine.

Maybe their Mother cared for their injuries afterwards?

I agree with Asterix. You seem to want to argue this point over and over ad infinitum, when clearly, you are the only person on this thread who thinks these underaged children were able to consent to having a permanent disfigurement. In addition, arguing that it was an "act of love", is a sick stance to take. Abusers will often claim that their abuse was done "out of love", which doesn't make it any less egregious. In fact, victims often rationalize abuse as an "act of love"; "He hits me because he loves me so much, he just can't handle it.", or, "We wanted Daddy to brand us with that crest because we just love each other so much!".

Constantly comparing what happened here to a tattoo or piercing, calling a branding a "normal" societal ritual (It has a loooonnnnngggg way to go before it's as mainstream as tattoos), and denying that it is "bodily harm" are all very weak arguments.

Children are NOT adults. The same standards are impossible to apply.
 
You imagine it was, huh? Perhaps it was a fluke that it didn't get infected...that's what I imagine.

Maybe their Mother cared for their injuries afterwards?

I agree with Asterix. You seem to want to argue this point over and over ad infinitum, when clearly, you are the only person on this thread who thinks these underaged children were able to consent to having a permanent disfigurement. In addition, arguing that it was an "act of love", is a sick stance to take. Abusers will often claim that their abuse was done "out of love", which doesn't make it any less egregious. In fact, victims often rationalize abuse as an "act of love"; "He hits me because he loves me so much, he just can't handle it.", or, "We wanted Daddy to brand us with that crest because we just love each other so much!".

Constantly comparing what happened here to a tattoo or piercing, calling a branding a "normal" societal ritual (It has a loooonnnnngggg way to go before it's as mainstream as tattoos), and denying that it is "bodily harm" are all very weak arguments.

Children are NOT adults. The same standards are impossible to apply.

What she said.
 
You imagine it was, huh? Perhaps it was a fluke that it didn't get infected...that's what I imagine.

I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which the esteemed doctors explain fairly clearly why it is unlikely to get infected in a first world country.

If he was not taking care of it properly the appropriate charge for that would presumably be negligence. He wasn't charged with negligence.

As for branding being commonplace, come on, if it's something so common that even the goddamn President of the United States has probably done it, well it's pretty common. Again, I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which the esteemed doctors point out that it has become "fashionable".

I agree with you that it's stupid but criminal is a much stricter standard. The branding was seen as desirable. It's something that has become fashionable. It is a reasonably safe procedure, as documented by the medical article provided by SillyGirl, provided you clean it properly. It's apparently not even as painful as you might think it would be.

In short it sounds a lot worse than it really is, and what makes it stupid, in my opinion, is just that you wind up with a stupid mark on your body. I'm not a fan of that, but some people are.