Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Mark Seamands called himself a devoted father, and as such, he wanted a way to demonstrate that devotion to his three children. So, on Thanksgiving Day of 2008 he asked a friend, Denny Secord, to use a homemade branding iron to burn a family crest into his skin. It's something he’d been planning for months.

"I just heated it up and touched it to him and took it off," said Secord as he testified in court Wednesday. "I said, ‘Jeez did that hurt?’ He said, 'No, not at all.'” Yeah, right...lol.

Secord says a short time later Seamands’ three kids showed up and excitedly asked to be branded themselves. Seamands admits he then took a propane torch, heated the iron up and branded Seamands' 13-year-old son’s chest and 15-year-old son’s arm with “SK” for "Seamands Kids."

A new family tradition had begun -- one the kids say they’re proud of. They don't think their dad did anything wrong.

-----------

Well, when I first read your post I was shocked that he would treat his kids like cattle and brand them. However, on reading the article, it seems the kids asked to be branded willingly, and had no regrets after the fact either. So in this case, they all are a bit nuts and so I don't think he should have been found gulity of assault. Being a goof, yes. I think assault (IMHO, not legally) implies the person assaulted is complaining about it/not happy. This article makes me glad my parents weren't goofs.
 
This article makes me glad my parents weren't goofs.

omg, you said it!

But don't you think, in light of the ages of his children, 13 and 15, who are (in my opinion) too young to have any perspective whatsoever, he should have been charged with assault? Apparently the law states that under the age of majority, assault charges can't be laid? I don't know, at best this is complete negligence as a parent. Complete and utter negligence. Shouldn't you be preventing your kids from making stupid decisions?!

This father is a goof, though. That much is for sure. But I am not sure whether or not he should have been charged for assault, to the full extent of the law.
 
Very sad!

Sad that they didn't throw the book at him! If your child begged you to tattoo him, would that be alright? If your child begged you to carve a happy face into their arm with a knife, would that be alright? If a child begged you to let them perform a Jackass type stunt, would you let them? If a child begged you to approve getting a tattoo on their face, would you sign a release? (<--btw, wasn't there a case like this recently? Not sure of the outcome.)

I don't care how much these children "begged" to be branded. It is the job of a parent to protect their children from harm, and attempt to prevent bad decisions from being made. Epic fail on the fathers side, as well as the justice systems part, I think.

I guess there aren't any laws against being a douche. Too bad.
 
People have a right to be stupid, and in my opinion this is just stupid. No criminal conviction required--they have all literally branded themselves as morons already!
 
People have a right to be stupid, and in my opinion this is just stupid. No criminal conviction required--they have all literally branded themselves as morons already!


A parent's right to be stupid should end where their kid's right to be taken care of begins.

Unfortunately, becoming a parent doesn't magically impart common sense.

Randy there was a case awhile ago where a teenage girl got stars tattooed all over her face, then tried to claim she had fallen asleep during the process and woken up surprised. She later recanted that story. I don't think she had parental permission for any tattoo, never mind all over her face.
 
What he did was repulsive; but it is impossible to assess the case legally without knowing what the law as to consent is in the jurisdiction and what defence was raised to the jury. We don't even use the terms "2nd degree assault" and "4th degree assault" in Ontario. So it is impossible to figure out what happened at the trial without a lot more info.
 
What he did was repulsive; but it is impossible to assess the case legally without knowing what the law as to consent is in the jurisdiction and what defence was raised to the jury.

i agree its beyond the pale.
 
I agree that the conduct is inexcusable but we do not know anything (at least I do not) about the definition of second degree assault in that jurisdiction. It may be that notwithstanding the egregious act it did not fit the definition. The jury was hung on the lesser offense and accordingly at least some of the jurors thought he was guilty. It may be that the prosecutor will elect to retry him on the leaser offense if there is a reasonable prospect of conviction. i don't think the article should necessarily be read as the jury having condoned the conduct. We (I) don't know enough to make that judgment.

It is beyond any doubt that the conduct was reprehensible.
 
What makes me somewhat sympathetic is that he branded himself first, and it was only because his children desired to copy his behavior that they wound up being branded. The children do not see themselves as victims, they appear to be proud to have the branding, just like their dad does.

I think the whole family are a pack of idiots, but if the behavior is illegal, it is illegal on a technicality--I have a hard time accusing someone of assault when all the participants are happy, willing, and proud.

The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent. The same act, if they are old enough to consent, is plainly not criminal. They implicitly have their fathers consent, they have the mother's consent, they themselves consent (for whatever it's worth), and the act was not done out of any desire to inflict harm, but rather, as stupid as it may be, it was done out of love.
 
What makes me somewhat sympathetic is that he branded himself first, and it was only because his children desired to copy his behavior that they wound up being branded. The children do not see themselves as victims, they appear to be proud to have the branding, just like their dad does.

I think the whole family are a pack of idiots, but if the behavior is illegal, it is illegal on a technicality--I have a hard time accusing someone of assault when all the participants are happy, willing, and proud.

The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent. The same act, if they are old enough to consent, is plainly not criminal. They implicitly have their fathers consent, they have the mother's consent, they themselves consent (for whatever it's worth), and the act was not done out of any desire to inflict harm, but rather, as stupid as it may be, it was done out of love.


i hope you don't have any kids
 
i hope you don't have any kids

Hey I think the guy is an idiot, I just don't see the harm, and I have trouble convicting people of crimes in which no-one is harmed. I wouldn't want to walk around with a brand on my chest, but then, I feel the same way about tattoos as well--have none of those either. I certainly respect other people's rights to have such things though.
 
Hey I think the guy is an idiot, I just don't see the harm, and I have trouble convicting people of crimes in which no-one is harmed. I wouldn't want to walk around with a brand on my chest, but then, I feel the same way about tattoos as well--have none of those either. I certainly respect other people's rights to have such things though.

Fuji, the kids are really not old enough to make the decision to undergo that type of pain and lifelong mutilation. That is the harm.

If a 12 year old Islamic girl requested to have her clitoris cut off because her mullah-worshipping Mom and Dad told her it was a good idea, would you be happy with that? Most of us would think it was unconscionable because the young girl should simply not be called upon the make that decision, especially at that age.
 
I don't think the female genital mutilation contrast is a fair one: That is offensive for reasons that have nothing to do with pain. You would still find that equally offensive even if it was performed in a pain free way at a medical center. This is more like getting a tattoo, or a piercing. There is some pain associated with getting a piercing, does that mean it should be illegal under the age of 18?
 
Yanno, the guy really should have gone with cell popping. It lasts only 6-9 months and you can get a much more detailed line to make it look more elegant.

Sounds like mom was a jealous wacko that the kids picked him over her.
 
...I just don't see the harm, and I have trouble convicting people of crimes in which no-one is harmed. I certainly respect other people's rights to have such things though.

You don't see the harm of branding and disfiguring children? They were children for f#@k's sake.
 
What he did was repulsive; but it is impossible to assess the case legally without knowing what the law as to consent is in the jurisdiction and what defence was raised to the jury. We don't even use the terms "2nd degree assault" and "4th degree assault" in Ontario. So it is impossible to figure out what happened at the trial without a lot more info.
Even as Oagre says there is more to the case:

1) The Jury found Mark Seamands not guilty of Second Degree Assault, however, they were deadlocked and a mistrial declared on the lesser charge of Fourth Degree Assault.

2) The prosecutor’s Office will decide whether to retry Seamands on the Fourth Degree Assault charge on May 28.

3) This all happened in the midst of a divorce, Seamands says his wife (the children’s mother) gave her consent. (However this is a poor defence irrelevant to the charges)

4) The boys may well have been persuasive enough at the ages of thirteen and fifteen, that they did not feel great pain or that they had been tortured, such that the jury felt unable to convict on Second Degree Assault.

Second Degree Assault in the State of Washington

(1) A person is guilty of assault in the second degree if he or she, under circumstances not amounting to assault in the first degree (i.e. without intent to inflict great bodily harm, the use of a firearm or other deadly weapon or force likely to produce great bodily harm or death, or the use of poison or other noxious substance or by exposure to HIV):

(a) Intentionally assaults another and thereby recklessly inflicts substantial bodily harm; or

(b) Intentionally and unlawfully causes substantial bodily harm to an unborn quick child by intentionally and unlawfully inflicting any injury upon the mother of such child; or

(c) Assaults another with a deadly weapon; or

(d) With intent to inflict bodily harm, administers to or causes to be taken by another, poison or any other destructive or noxious substance; or

(e) With intent to commit a felony, assaults another; or

(f) Knowingly inflicts bodily harm which by design causes such pain or agony as to be the equivalent of that produced by torture; or

(g) Assaults another by strangulation.

(2)(a) Except as provided in (b) of this subsection, assault in the second degree is a class B felony. (A Class B felony has a maximum penalty of ten years imprisonment, a $20,000 fine or both).

Fourth Degree Assault in the State of Washington

Assault in the fourth degree is the lowest of the four possible levels, (e.g. basic simple assault) and is a gross misdemeanor. A gross misdemeanor has a maximum penalty of up to year in jail and $5,000 fine or both.

http://apps.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=9A.36

Personaly I agree this was repulsive behaviour.