Even as Oagre says there is more to the case:
1) The Jury found Mark Seamands not guilty of second degree however, they were deadlocked and a mistrial declared on the lesser charge of fourth degree assault.
2) The prosecutor’s Office will decide whether to retry Seamands on the fourth degree assault charge May 28.
3) This all happened in the midst of a divorce, Seamands says his wife (the children’s mother) gave her consent. (However this is irrelevant to the charges)
4) The boys may well have been persuasive enough at the ages of thirteen and fifteen, that they did not feel great pain or that they had been tortured, such that the jury felt unable to convict on Second Degree Assault.
Based upon that definition and what may have been the evidence it may have been the case that the charge to the jury by the presiding judge resulted in the acquittal and in the circumstances it may have been the correct verdict.

