Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Even as Oagre says there is more to the case:

1) The Jury found Mark Seamands not guilty of second degree however, they were deadlocked and a mistrial declared on the lesser charge of fourth degree assault.

2) The prosecutor’s Office will decide whether to retry Seamands on the fourth degree assault charge May 28.

3) This all happened in the midst of a divorce, Seamands says his wife (the children’s mother) gave her consent. (However this is irrelevant to the charges)

4) The boys may well have been persuasive enough at the ages of thirteen and fifteen, that they did not feel great pain or that they had been tortured, such that the jury felt unable to convict on Second Degree Assault.


Based upon that definition and what may have been the evidence it may have been the case that the charge to the jury by the presiding judge resulted in the acquittal and in the circumstances it may have been the correct verdict.
 
What's your opinion on piercings and tattoos? Illegal for children as well? They're not..


Do you mean that in Canada a 12yr. old could go to a licensed tattoo parlor and get a tat? Or a piercing?

That surprises me...both carry the risk of infection and require aftercare, it seems parental consent would be required.
 
Second Degree Assault in the State of Washington

(1) A person is guilty of assault in the second degree if he or she, under circumstances not amounting to assault in the first degree (i.e. without intent to inflict great bodily harm, the use of a firearm or other deadly weapon or force likely to produce great bodily harm or death, or the use of poison or other noxious substance or by exposure to HIV):

(a) Intentionally assaults another and thereby recklessly inflicts substantial bodily harm;


Dunno, aardy, what the guy did sounds like 2nd degree assault to me. Maybe the defence is whether a teenager can consent to be mutilated in Washington.
 
Second Degree Assault in the State of Washington

(a) Intentionally assaults another and thereby recklessly inflicts substantial bodily harm;


Dunno, aardy, what the guy did sounds like 2nd degree assault to me. Maybe the defence is whether a teenager can consent to be mutilated in Washington.
I agree that I'd probably have convicted under (a), however, I think the Jury probably became fixated on (f).
 
No matter what the definition of second degree assault, or fourth degree assault, his actions were repulsive, and he clearly abused the power he holds as these kid's parent! At best that is assault, at worst, it is negligence.

Like SillyGirl said, your right to be stupid ends where your children's right to be cared for begins!

I believe from the story that the mother did not give consent, which adds a whole new dimension to the case. It's okay for a father who is caring for his children part time to consent to such an act?! Without the mothers knowledge? Disturbing, indeed!

Fuji, if you think what he did was not criminal, we have very, very different viewpoints on this matter.

I would go abso-freakin'-lutely ballistic if this happened to my thirteen year old child on a weekend at their fathers, no matter how much that child tried to tell me they "wanted it". Give me a break. Who's the adult there?
 
Do you mean that in Canada a 12yr. old could go to a licensed tattoo parlor and get a tat? Or a piercing?

That surprises me...both carry the risk of infection and require aftercare, it seems parental consent would be required.

Until the age of 18 a child requires parental permission to get either of these. Which raises the question of whether in the case of a divorce, if one parent can give consent while the other does not, does that make it okay? Under the law, perhaps it does? I don't know.

However, if I was these children's mother, and was not given the chance to state my disagreement, I would be filing my own civil lawsuit.
 
Until the age of 18 a child requires parental permission to get either of these. Which raises the question of whether in the case of a divorce, if one parent can give consent while the other does not, does that make it okay? Under the law, perhaps it does? I don't know.

However, if I was these children's mother, and was not given the chance to state my disagreement, I would be filing my own civil lawsuit.

Consent is a function of custody under Canadian law. If you have a custody order or custody under a separation agreement, you have the sole right to give or withhold consent.

Who knows what tf the law is in Washington State, a jurisdiction which apparently allows children to be mutilated.
 
Until the age of 18 a child requires parental permission to get either of these. Which raises the question of whether in the case of a divorce, if one parent can give consent while the other does not, does that make it okay? Under the law, perhaps it does? I don't know.

However, if I was these children's mother, and was not given the chance to state my disagreement, I would be filing my own civil lawsuit.
Randygirl, the article only mentions testimony that she agreed (not her own testimony) so who knows the truth of the matter. However, the larger issue is whether even with her consent, is such conduct permissible?

For an overly powerful illustration, obviously if your ex spouse gives permission to cut off your child’s right hand that consent is meaningless as to a defence to criminal charges.

This is to totally ignore the fact that consent goes with custody, however, joint custody is the norm at present in the U.S.
 
Randygirl, the article only mentions testimony that she agreed (not her own testimony) so who knows the truth of the matter. However, the larger issue is whether even with her consent, is such conduct permissible?

Sorry, I originally saw this on a newscast out of Seattle, or somewhere nearby. They interviewed both the mother and grandmother, both were described as being "saddened" by the verdict, and voiced their displeasure. That's where I got that from, not from the article. I first saw the story on tv, then searched the article for this thread.
 
It helped the family bond, is that so bad? I don't see any victims. Makes more sense than a meaningless tattoo.
They weren't old enough to consent though, the ceremony should have waited until they were of legal age. Jailing the father might help even more in bringing the family together, it would be them against society at large.
 
In Canada, the guy goes down and does 2 less a day. Plus, the CAS takes the kids and doesn't ever fucking give them back to him. In Ontario, kids cannot consent to anything more serious than a schoolyard push and shove. For example, the parent has to consent to any kind of medical treatment. And no one in Canada can consent to significant bodily harm. (I forget the correct verbal formula).

So in Ontario, this vile prick has no defence - NADA! - and the only question is whether he goes down for "wounding", "aggravated assault", or "assault bodily harm" and how hard the judge canes him on sentence. What the FUCK is wrong with Washington State??!!

In Ontario, you cannot even slap your kid's face hard without getting an assault charge and having the Aid snatch the kids.
 
An example of 4th degree assault in Washington I found on the net:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20081211154847AAdTP6U

My husband has been charged with 4th degree assault and the state has required a jury trial is this common?

We have been having problems with one of our neighbors and my husband went next door to ask what the deal was. As he approached the step the female resident came out yelling and right behind her was her dad. Her dad started telling my husband that he was going to kick his a$$ and break his nose. My husband responded with any time old man. Well the yelling went back and forth for a bit and then her dad which does not reside at the residence bumped my husband with his stomache my husband then pushed him back away from him. The ops were called and they placed my husband under arrest. Well after questioning all of us and 45 minutes later the police officer then took him out of the car and said due to the statements colaberating he was releasing him and gave him a court date. He went to the first court date and pled not guilty they then set another court date which we just attended he was assigned a public defender and while at court we found out that the state is requesting a jury trial is this common for this type of case in Washington? Is there any way this case can be dismissed due to the fact he was defending his self? If he is found guilty what will the punishment be for this type of offense? We have lived in Washington since Dec 2003 and the only other trouble he has been in is a seat belt ticket.The public defender said the defense we are claiming is Lawful use of force. Am I stressing this to much or do I have a reason to worry? If you have any answers to this please let me know.

---------------------

Branding your 13-year-old son across his chest with your custom "brand" (after months of thought about doing it and while sober) seems to me a lot worse than simple assault. Simple assault is two girls get into a tiff at a bar after a few drinks and one slaps the other in the face and the other pushes her to the ground or tosses a drink in her face. Bouncers call the police, and the police show up and make an arrest for (simple) assault. Simple assault (with no previous record) gets you what, a fine or probation?
 
It's a good idea. I will brand my future wife and children. Everybody will know who they belong to.
 
Branding your 13-year-old son across his chest with your custom "brand" (after months of thought about doing it and while sober) seems to me a lot worse than simple assault. Simple assault is two girls get into a tiff at a bar after a few drinks and one slaps the other in the face and the other pushes her to the ground or tosses a drink in her face. Bouncers call the police, and the police show up and make an arrest for (simple) assault. Simple assault (with no previous record) gets you what, a fine or probation?
You, Oagre, the District Attorney and I all agree, the problem is that the Jury did not as to Assault in the Second Degree. Hence the only thing left is the Simple Assualt (Assault in the Fourth Degree) the only question left for the D.A.'s Office is whether to retry him on that charge.
 
It helped the family bond, is that so bad? I don't see any victims. Makes more sense than a meaningless tattoo.

The children are the victims, they just don't know it. It's kind of like very young people who are molested by a trusted friend or family member. Often they don't realize that fucking your (uncle, priest, teacher, next door neighbor, step father, father, take your pick) was something bad until much later in life. Predators and molesters are very smooth operators, they make these children feel great and often the children think that they 'wanted' it. Of course, we know that behavior to be criminal, but it doesn't make it less so that the victim 'wanted' it, or was not in distress at any point.

Not all abuse is violent, you know.

The whole point of bringing him up on charges, for me, is the fact that he abused his power as their parent, failed to keep them out of harms way, permanently mutilated his kids' bodies, did not get consent from the mother, thinks what he did was alright, and has apparently brainwashed his children into thinking they 'wanted' it. These things are crimes against the children.

The branding was meaningless. Coaching your child's soccer team brings the family together, board games bring the family together, spending time together talking brings the family together, having supper together brings the family together. Branding your underage children? Not so much...
 
Randygirl, do you feel the same way about tattoos? Should parents be brought up on charges if they allow their child to get a tattoo? After all that permanently mutilates kids bodies too in essentially exactly the same way. How about piercings?
 
And no one in Canada can consent to significant bodily harm. (I forget the correct verbal formula).

Is this significant bodily harm? Is a tattoo? It sounds like the Washington judge or jury was unconvinced that this was significant harm or whatever their version of that is. Why would an Ontario judge or jury find differently?
 
What makes me somewhat sympathetic is that he branded himself first, and it was only because his children desired to copy his behavior that they wound up being branded. The children do not see themselves as victims, they appear to be proud to have the branding, just like their dad does.

I think the whole family are a pack of idiots, but if the behavior is illegal, it is illegal on a technicality--I have a hard time accusing someone of assault when all the participants are happy, willing, and proud.

The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent. The same act, if they are old enough to consent, is plainly not criminal. They implicitly have their fathers consent, they have the mother's consent, they themselves consent (for whatever it's worth), and the act was not done out of any desire to inflict harm, but rather, as stupid as it may be, it was done out of love.

Technicality? Done out of love? Branding your children? You've made some incredibly stupid arguments before but this one tops it.
 
Technicality? Done out of love? Branding your children? You've made some incredibly stupid arguments before but this one tops it.

Did you read the article? It is not disputed by anyone, not by the court, not by the prosecution, not by his family, not by his kids, that he did it out of love for his kids. The problem is that despite that they may be unable to consent to it, that's the only legal question really, whether they're able to consent.