Does The Burqa Dehumanizes Women?

Another side to the issue is integration into our society. The burqa prevents that. It usually takes a second or third generation for immigrants to attain the freedoms of Canada or the US. Islam isn't about freedom. Not to highjack the thread, but extreme modes of attire keep whole generations from success. One more example is the rap-based style of low pants on men. Who would hire them? Different group. Same result. "Allowing" some groups to dress or act sufficiently different from the mainstream is much more acceptable than segregation or discrimination. The next step would be to give them their own schools (oh oh we are doing that in Toronto).

Same result.

The burqa is a small thing. Sharia law and it's imposition in Canada is much bigger. The Islamists have tried to get it accepted. But failed. As they get more powerful here and begin to control politics, they will try again. I'm sorry for their women. A little help from society may help a few escape the oppression of their culture/religion. (and I'm not even going to mention female mutilation).
 
I disagree that it prevents integration into "our" society. You forget our society is made up of jews, muslims, hindus, catholics, baptists, taoists, shintoists, and just about everything in between. I personally love the fact that our society is made up of so many different cultures and religions. The ONLY time any practise prevents integration is when a practise of that religion prohibits integration (eg: the muslim ideaology that all westerners should be killed as per law). A mode of dress doesn't do that IMO.

I mean, how boring would our streetscape be if we all dressed exactly the same?

I've had very casual dealings with women in the burqa and frankly, found it rather intriguing. What's she like under there? what's she wearing? In fact, I'd say (to me) it produced the opposite effect. With our mode of dress you pretty much know what you get with women. (other than padded bras, control top panties etc).
 
Another side to the issue is integration into our society. The burqa prevents that

Why?

Who would hire them?

If your notion is that society is so prejudiced against Muslims that you cannot be hired because you wear a burqa, wouldn't you say that the problem is racism against Muslims, and not the burqa?
 
With that said, the Majority (98% I'm estimating) of Muslims in the Middle East choose to wear it.

Since women have few rights in those societies, it is doubtful that they choose to wear it of their own free will but more out of fear of being beaten or killed if they fail to wear it.
 
If your notion is that society is so prejudiced against Muslims that you cannot be hired because you wear a burqa, wouldn't you say that the problem is racism against Muslims, and not the burqa?

Don't know where you work but my friends and I have always worked for employers who have some form of dress code (despite business casual) and it has nothing whatsoever to do with racism (the most overused word in Western society).
 
Just using your rhetoric as a jumping off point, the Islamists may be counting on prejudice to isolate their women. Thus they win. And playing the race card when it doesn't apply is silly. I can't use that at all.
 
Since women have few rights in those societies, it is doubtful that they choose to wear it of their own free will but more out of fear of being beaten or killed if they fail to wear it.

You're over-generalizing. There are no doubt some women who wear it only out of fear, especially in places like Afghanistan. The women I see wearing burkas to their graduate classes at the University of Toronto, though, I suspect they fall into the free will category.
 
Don't know where you work but my friends and I have always worked for employers who have some form of dress code (despite business casual) and it has nothing whatsoever to do with racism (the most overused word in Western society).

I work in Ontario, where the Human Rights Code insists that any dress code accomodate religious beliefs where possible. I believe our system results in fair decisions on this topic. There have been several precedents in this area, for example, the Mounties at one point argued that their dress code prohibited officers from wearing turbans on the job. They were over-ruled. On the other hand there were some women who insisted on wearing long flowing robes to their assembly line job, which mandated pants for safety reasons--they lost, as there was a valid safety reason as the loose clothing might get caught in the machinery. If I recall correctly the company was asked to find them jobs that where their loose fitting robes were not unsafe.

A burka is a fairly formal piece of clothing. I can't imagine a scenario where it would be found to be too casual for a respectable business place?
 
I think we give women too much power too many choices. While society should respect women's opinions and treat them fairly, women are natural followers and men are natural leaders by the design! Saying things like "if a woman chooses to qear Burqa then it is not oppression" is bullshit! Most women do not freely choose, they FOLLOW the lead, the lead of their social group, family, husband, religion. So yeah, it should be banned, so should bikini and miniskirts. Anything that stereotypes attractive women should be banned because they dehumanize women. But then what should they wear? maybe women are not supposed to wear anything. Their true naked forms are the most natural and fair.
 
I work in Ontario, where the Human Rights Code insists that any dress code accomodate religious beliefs where possible.

According to my Muslim Iranian friends, the burqa is not a religious requirement. Don't believe everything that OBL and Mullah Omar says.
 
The women I see wearing burkas to their graduate classes at the University of Toronto, though, I suspect they fall into the free will category.

We don't know what happens behind closed doors. Maybe the U of T women were told by their male relatives to "dress as told" or suffer the same fate as that poor 16 year old girl murdered by her father and brother.
 
According to my Muslim Iranian friends, the burqa is not a religious requirement. Don't believe everything that OBL and Mullah Omar says.

That's not an opinion universally shared by all Muslims, although it is an opinion of a great many of them. Like Christianity there are different Muslim sects and beliefs, and there are people who take those sects more or less seriously.
 
We don't know what happens behind closed doors. Maybe the U of T women were told by their male relatives to "dress as told" or suffer the same fate as that poor 16 year old girl murdered by her father and brother.

Why don't you ask them? I mean, instead of just making stuff up and speculating wildly?
 
In an Islamic society, women have to cover themselves to avoid getting raped by men with no self control. If a woman gets raped it’s her fault for causing the man to desire her.

That kind of barbaric misogynist thinking has no place in western society. Banning the Burka and making it illegal to force someone to wear one is a good start.
 
Banning the Burka and making it illegal to force someone to wear one is a good start.
Those are two separate acts.

Making it illegal to force someone to wear a burqa (or anything else for that matter) is a good idea except that it's not necessary. We already have laws against harassment and abuse and no new laws are required. Perhaps we need to enforce our existing laws against abuse more closely.

Banning the burqa is completely unnecessary and inappropriate. Those women who want to wear one should not be prohibited by society. If we force someone NOT to wear a burqa, we're no better than those who force someone TO wear a burqa.

Rockslinger: I know that you are genuine in your concern and respect for women, however, you are risking taking away legitimate rights of choice if you advocate for an indiscriminate ban.
 
I think we give women too much power too many choices. While society should respect women's opinions and treat them fairly, women are natural followers and men are natural leaders by the design! Saying things like "if a woman chooses to qear Burqa then it is not oppression" is bullshit! Most women do not freely choose, they FOLLOW the lead, the lead of their social group, family, husband, religion. So yeah, it should be banned, so should bikini and miniskirts. Anything that stereotypes attractive women should be banned because they dehumanize women. But then what should they wear? maybe women are not supposed to wear anything. Their true naked forms are the most natural and fair.

So, um, the ugly ones can wear what they want?


7kkD5.jpg
 
One assumes that was meant as a joke, zardoz.
 
But unlike the Christians who in practice hardly believe
more than 20% of the Bible Muslims (unfortunate for them)
subscribe to and practice the teachings in the Qur'an to this day.

Very well put. Its just too bad that we are living in the 21st century, and many Muslims are practicing a religion based in the 1st Century.