Does The Burqa Dehumanizes Women?

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Ok, let's cut through all the crap. Do you think the burqa dehumanizes and demeans women (something that a true Taliban loves) and should be banned in civilize society? Yes? No?
 
Aye

Yes, it's probably the most oppressive piece of clothing i've ever seen other then the male speedo.Nothing says i'm better then you then saying "You can show your face when I say you can show your face"...that and assigned parking.
 
On a Florida beach where bikini and thongs are the norm it is
indeed dehumanizing. Otherwise wearing a Burqa shouldn't
violate the dressing code in most public places.

To those who see the Muslim women's veil as a sign of
oppression from a Christian perspective note that the apostle
Paul also obligated christian women to wear a veil in the new
testaments. But unlike the Christians who in practice hardly believe
more than 20% of the Bible Muslims (unfortunate for them)
subscribe to and practice the teachings in the Qur'an to this day.
 
Of course it does. At least in my opinion. However I doubt that they give a crap about what I think and I really don't see it as my place to tell them otherwise. My guess is that one day this will work itself out from within that community. Our culture has had similar issues in the past (racially, and sexually) and with each generation tolerance and equality has grown.
 
Of course it does. At least in my opinion. However I doubt that they give a crap about what I think and I really don't see it as my place to tell them otherwise.

I don't want to interfere with how they (Taliban?) treat their women in Muslim lands like Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, etc. however I do NOT support anything that dehumanizes and demeans women in Canada.
 
I think only .01 muslim women use burqa overall (except Saudi Arabia). I guess moslty use by choice or by choice of her husband. I don't see it as issue if I see burqa woman out of 1000s.
I always think if someone ask me to not use shorts, condom, underwear or not wear my designer cloth, then how would I feel.
If someone want to hide herself, I don't care.
 
Ok, let's cut through all the crap. Do you think the burqa dehumanizes and demeans women (something that a true Taliban loves) and should be banned in civilize society? Yes? No?
No.

I think treating women as less than equal to men dehumanizes them.

I think FORCING them to wear a burqua dehumanizes them.

I think FORCING them to wear high heels and a thong also dehumanizes them.

Women making a voluntary choice to wear either a burqa or a thong (or both) are neither dehumanized or degraded by their choice.

Our Society has taken on a rather disappointing direction in recent years. Instead of fighting the root cause of a problem, we make laws against some of the symptoms and hope that the problem will fall out of public view.

  • A few years ago, there was a park in Vancouver that put hand-rails on their park benches to make them harder to lie down on. This was designed to "solve" the problem of homeless people in the park because they'd have to go elsewhere. instead of dealing with the cause of homelessness, they passed a law to move the homeless out of view.
  • Last year, some of the beaches in Toronto had a problem with dog poo not being cleaned up by pet-owners. Instead of enforcing the already existing and reasonable 'poop and scoop" bi-law they passed additional rules to ban dogs from these areas completely. Thus, the responsible pet-owners who were cleaning up (and their dogs) also suffered.
  • Sadly, despite existing laws against child abuse, a small percentage of parents still beat their children. Instead of actually enforcing these laws more closely, some people are now calling for a law against spanking altogether. Somehow, they believe that even though they can't stop a few parents from behaving very badly, if they make criminals out of even more parents who are acting responsibly, the bad parents will stop beating their children.
Now we have a situation where some people treat women in abusive and offensive ways. Some of these people are Muslim. Some of these Muslims want women in their family to wear a burqa or other traditional garment or head-covering. Some of these women don't want to comply, however, SOME of them are forced to wear the garment against their will. What makes people think that banning the garment will suddenly address the actual problem: some (small percentage of) men are abusive toward women? Wouldn't it be more effective to address the actual issue than to legislate against one small symptom?

And what of those women who honestly choose to cover their heads and/or faces? Is their right to follow a traditional lifestyle not worth anything?

No. The Burqa is not dehumanizing. Abusive and repressive people are dehumanizing.
 
Ok, let's cut through all the crap. Do you think the burqa dehumanizes and demeans women (something that a true Taliban loves) and should be banned in civilize society? Yes? No?

Yes I do think that it is dehumanizing because it was brought about some radical islamists. The burqa is quite different from the hijab and rids of any sort of individualism a woman may have in public society. Some women have grown to accept it, and through years of coercion have began to justify it being a part of the religion....it isn't. The burqa is cultural. In no way religous.

When completing the Hajj and being in Mecca, women have to remove the burqas to reveal their faces. They are not allowed to cover their faces. It is not because of potential terrorist activities, but because they are not to cover their face in the eyes of god. I find this to be so interesting because the Burqa is only predominant in Saudi Arabia, yet Mecca is in Saudi.

I am all for a ban on the Burqa! At least some countries are standing up against religous extremism that has been hiding under the guise of orthodox religion and culture.
 
No. The Burqa is not dehumanizing. Abusive and repressive people are dehumanizing.

However, it is abusive and repressive people like the Taliban that force women to wear the burqa under threats of death. The burqa is a symbol of female oppression just like the Nazis forcing Jews to wear the yellow Star of David badge with the German word Jude in WW II is a symbol of Nazi oppression. We should ban all symbols of oppression.
 
Yes, it's probably the most oppressive piece of clothing i've ever seen other then the male speedo.Nothing says i'm better then you then saying "You can show your face when I say you can show your face"...that and assigned parking.

Well, actually, it isn't when "I say" it is when their religion says.

Who are we to judge when most of us commit sins as denoted in the dominant religion in our society?

BTW: for the record you have to agree that it takes superficiality out of the equation and every woman is treated the same and not treated any better because of the way she looks....

The only time it is "oppressive" is when the woman in question (notice I said WOMAN) doesn't want to wear it and is forced to.
 
However, it is abusive and repressive people like the Taliban that force women to wear the burqa under threats of death. The burqa is a symbol of female oppression just like the Nazis forcing Jews to wear the yellow Star of David badge with the German word Jude in WW II is a symbol of Nazi oppression. We should ban all symbols of oppression.

Oh, ok, so, will you be the first? There are THOUSANDS of symbols of oppression in our society but that all depends on your concept of what oppression is. Is oppression the keeping down of someone? Limiting their ability to succeed? To better themselves? Their freedom?
 
There are THOUSANDS of symbols of oppression in our society but that all depends on your concept of what oppression is.

Not sure there are thousands (oh, maybe in Afghnaistan and Saudi Arabia) of symbols of oppression. For example, does our society tolerate the wearing of the KKK white costume and hood? What about flying the swastika flag in front of your house?
 
The burqa is a symbol of female oppression just like the Nazis forcing Jews to wear the yellow Star of David badge with the German word Jude in WW II is a symbol of Nazi oppression.
There you go. You've actually said it in the above quote without realizing it.

The yellow star was offensive BECAUSE Jews were forced to wear it and it served to identify them for other abuses.

There would have been nothing wrong if SOME Jews had CHOSEN to wear a yellow star.

Likewise, there's nothing wrong with SOME Muslims Choosing to wear a burqa. It's women who are FORCED to wear one that are being dehumanized. It's the FORCING and not the WEARING that is the dehumanizing agent. If the burqa was banned, those Muslim men who are abusive toward their female relatives will just find a different way of expressing their abuse.

Banning the burqa solves nothing for the dehumanized women. All it does is make the abuse less visible and, as a result, makes some people feel like it does not exist.
 
Not sure there are thousands (oh, maybe in Afghnaistan and Saudi Arabia) of symbols of oppression. For example, does our society tolerate the wearing of the KKK white custume and hood? What about flying the swastika flag in front of your house?

I would be curious if either were actually illegal.

BUT, how about all the ferraris lambos and rolls spinning around downtown? How about the new Trump Tower that is being built? How about the ghettos? How about the preponderance of places like Money Marts? Stores on bloor like Holt Renfrew? fur Coats? Walmarts? $3000.00 purses and $5000.00 shoes? Rolex watches?

One could argue that those are status symbols not symbols of oppression but considering that whoever is wearing a $5000 pair of shows most likely made the money off the sweat of those less fortunate....
 
It's women who are FORCED to wear one that are being dehumanized.

Well, we know that women in Afghanistan are FORCED to wear a burqa under threats of death. Why would we think it is different for a Muslim woman in Canada when we see one wearing a burqa? Is this woman not forced to wear a burqa by her father, brother, husband, etc.? Or, are we so naive as to think that she is choosing to do so of her own free will?

As I mentioned in another thread, my Muslim Iranian friends said the burqa is not a religious requirement and none of their female relatives and friends wear burqas.
 
BUT, how about all the ferraris lambos and rolls spinning around downtown? How about the new Trump Tower that is being built? How about the ghettos? How about the preponderance of places like Money Marts? Stores on bloor like Holt Renfrew? fur Coats? Walmarts? $3000.00 purses and $5000.00 shoes? Rolex watches?

I am so glad you didn't mention SP's. Please don't mention Victor Malarek, please don't.
 
Women making a voluntary choice to wear either a burqa or a thong (or both) are neither dehumanized or degraded by their choice.

Bingo. What is dehumanizing is a lack of choice. Some women are dehumanized by having their choice taken away from them, such as by the Taliban. Others freely choose to wear it, in fact, some wear it despite the objections of their own families.

Pressuring a 14 year old girl to wear a burqa is no more dehumanizing than Cosmopolitan pressuring her to dress up like a slut. Give her a choice and respect it--whether it's to wear a burqa or a thong.
 
No it does not dehumanize women. (the burqa or hijab or whatever)

What dehumanizes women is when they are forced into doing something. If they want to do it by their own choice, then its their choice. Leave it to them. Its their religion and so let them do it.

If being forced to come to work naked or in a bikini, or being forced to wear inappropriate clothing is a tradition in a culture or society, and being forced to do that, is also DEHUMANIZING.
 
No.

I think treating women as less than equal to men dehumanizes them.

I think FORCING them to wear a burqua dehumanizes them.

I think FORCING them to wear high heels and a thong also dehumanizes them.

Women making a voluntary choice to wear either a burqa or a thong (or both) are neither dehumanized or degraded by their choice.

Our Society has taken on a rather disappointing direction in recent years. Instead of fighting the root cause of a problem, we make laws against some of the symptoms and hope that the problem will fall out of public view.



  • Now we have a situation where some people treat women in abusive and offensive ways. Some of these people are Muslim. Some of these Muslims want women in their family to wear a burqa or other traditional garment or head-covering. Some of these women don't want to comply, however, SOME of them are forced to wear the garment against their will. What makes people think that banning the garment will suddenly address the actual problem: some (small percentage of) men are abusive toward women? Wouldn't it be more effective to address the actual issue than to legislate against one small symptom?

    And what of those women who honestly choose to cover their heads and/or faces? Is their right to follow a traditional lifestyle not worth anything?

    No. The Burqa is not dehumanizing. Abusive and repressive people are dehumanizing.


  • Good post. Its a complex issue.