Robert Baltovich Lawsuit

Nobody has to prove he is innocent --- HE IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY and he was not proven guilty
My point was simply that he could very well be guilty.
It's not like they solved the case and exonerated him.

Even if he is innocent, it doesn't mean he has any basis for a lawsuit.
If his claims are true, then of course he does deserve compensation.

Juries, judges, lawyers, and cops all make mistakes.
Proving malice and intent is not a simple matter.
 
My point was simply that he could very well be guilty.
It's not like they solved the case and exonerated him.

Even if he is innocent, it doesn't mean he has any basis for a lawsuit.
If his claims are true, then of course he does deserve compensation.

Juries, judges, lawyers, and cops all make mistakes.
Proving malice and intent is not a simple matter.


I don't think you need to prove malice and intent. All you need to show is there was no reasoble evidence. Also, even if there were mistakes, the province is liable. Malice is only required for PERSONAL liability.
 
I don't think you need to prove malice and intent. All you need to show is there was no reasoble evidence. Also, even if there were mistakes, the province is liable. Malice is only required for PERSONAL liability.
Completely WRONG.
 
...He is now suing the Ontario government and two police officers for $13million...

I believe he is also suing his original lawyer. Looks like the shotgun theory. He knows none of them acted maliciously and seems to hope that if he sues enough people, he'll get something. Maybe he should sue the judge/jury that originally convicted him. Sure it sucks that he lost a chunk of his life but unless someone did something wrong...
 
Don't think so. Otherwise, the state owes me $28million dollars. Here is an example, if you make a mistake on your tax return they will penalize you but if they make a mistake in assessing your tax return they will penalize you.

with all due respect..you are the misinformation king on this discussion board....i made a mistake on 2007 taxes..to my favour..they sent me 240$ more than i expected..last year i got a letter saying i made a mistake and i owned them 68$, no interest tacked on...2 points proven..you are usually full of hot air, and 2nd i need an accountant..
 
When there is a lack of evidence then the presumption of innocence kicks in.

oh man , here we go again.. in our system, there is always a presumption of innocence from the word go..it doesnt "kick in" at some point....man oh man..
 
When there is a lack of evidence then the presumption of innocence kicks in.

He is presumed innocent in terms of not being is jail. But that does not mean he was wrongly convicted. Many obviously guilty people are released due to loopholes or trial errors. Like cases where there was 100% proof evidence, but found with an unjustified search, so the culprit is freed. Legally, he is presumed innocent, in reality, he clearly did it. I am not saying that applies to RB, I do not know the facts of the case well enough.
 
....i made a mistake on 2007 taxes..to my favour..they sent me 240$ more than i expected..last year ..

Try watching W-5 sometimes and see how many people were wrongly assessed. Or, do you think W-5 fabricated all those stories?

The government makes mistakes all the time and not just with taxes. How many men and women were wrongly convicted for murders they didn't commit? Did you know that Doctor Charles Smith worked for the government and he made blunder after blunder?
 
oh man , here we go again.. in our system, there is always a presumption of innocence from the word go..it doesnt "kick in" at some point....man oh man..

I was referring to the second trial. Mr. Baltovich walked into that second trial as an already convicted felon.
 
Completely WRONG.

So if a government employee is incompetent and I am harmed as a result there is no liability on their part? I doubt that is correct. If you can show material loss (not a problem in this case) I am pretty sure you can receive compensation.
 
Nobody has to prove he is innocent --- HE IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY and he was not proven guilty

Innocent UNTIL proven guilty????..... That's a laugh..... Not in this country bub..... I know a guy who got charged with something back in '07, spent 4 months in jail pretrial custody, lost his wife, his home, his job, cost him almost a quarter mill. (and counting) in lost wages and other expences directly related to this mess. Got released on bail and has spent almost 3 years under house arrest (and counting) waiting for the trial.
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY?????..... Like I said..... NOT IN THIS COUNTRY!!!!!

Might I add that he's still waiting for his day in court so he hasn't been found guilty of anything yet!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Innocent UNTIL proven guilty????..... That's a laugh..... Not in this country bub!

Also, think of all the lives ruin because of false accusations of child molestation. Many of these false accusations date back decades due to "repressed memory syndrome". Anybody who has ever worked with children live with the risk that they can be falsely accused 10, 20, 30 years or more down the road. Of course, children never lie, yeah sure.
 
So if a government employee is incompetent and I am harmed as a result there is no liability on their part? I doubt that is correct. If you can show material loss (not a problem in this case) I am pretty sure you can receive compensation.
The onus on Baltovich is more than simply showing material loss.
If his claims are true and can be proven, he does deserve compensation and some heads should roll.
If his claims are not true or can't be proven, I don't think he deserves compensation simply because the Crown chose not to pursue another trial.
Let's hear about this suppressed evidence that his lawyer claims proves his innocence.


The statement of claim argues that Baltovich's wrongful conviction was the result of "reckless, bad faith, negligent and intentional acts and omissions" by the defendants.

Among those named in the lawsuit are the attorney general, Toronto police, the two lead detectives in the investigation of Bain's death, and the two lawyers who represented Baltovich at his first trial.

The suit further alleges that police and the Crown had evidence Baltovich was innocent but chose not to disclose it, and that Baltovich's first trial lawyers failed to review all the evidence.
 
I don't think you need to prove malice and intent. All you need to show is there was no reasoble evidence. Also, even if there were mistakes, the province is liable. Malice is only required for PERSONAL liability.

You may wish to consult a lawyer or legal text because that is not the law in Ontario or elsewhere in Canada.
 
The onus on Baltovich is more than simply showing material loss.

Surely, there must be some standard of compensation when the government inflicts pain and suffering on an ordinary citizen. That Arar (check spelling) guy got $10million. That Polish guy's mother got an undisclosed "settlement".
 
So if a government employee is incompetent and I am harmed as a result there is no liability on their part? I doubt that is correct. If you can show material loss (not a problem in this case) I am pretty sure you can receive compensation.

As I said before, completely WRONG.

"To succeed in an action for malicious prosecution, a plaintiff must prove that the prosecution was:
(1) initiated by the defendant;
(2) terminated in favour of the plaintiff;
(3) undertaken without reasonable and probable cause; and
(4) motivated by malice or a primary purpose other than that of carrying the law into effect"

This is directly from the recent Supreme Court of Canada Case of Miazga which threw out a malicious prosecution accusation against the Crown in a 7 to 0 decision.

http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2009/2009scc51/2009scc51.html

Suing the government to recover a damage for negligence i.e. they bulldozed your house to put in a new road but had the wrong address by mistake, is a completely different case from malicious prosecution.

Different torts have different tests.
There is also judicial immunity so that the judge in the first case cannot be sued.

As an aside, if the Crown elects to oppose Mr. Baltovich what essentially could happen is a murder trial to a civil standard of balance of probabilities rather than beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the Crown leads evidence that they think he did it, but could not prove it beyond a reasonable doubt the Crown wins, he gets a bill for the Crowns' legal fees.

If Baltovich has evidence that the police or Crown withheld exculpatory evidence, write him a HUGE cheque.

It is a fact driven case, but very few of the relevant facts are published and there is a lot of supposition.

Another aside, is that he is suing his first lawyers, this will allow them to bring SOME privileged statements into evidence at the civil trial in their own defence. For example, of Baltovich ever told his first lawyer "get me a deal of less then 5 years and I will take it", that previously privileged conversation can now be brought in as evidence.
 
Surely, there must be some standard of compensation when the government inflicts pain and suffering on an ordinary citizen. That Arar (check spelling) guy got $10million. That Polish guy's mother got an undisclosed "settlement".
Like I said, if his claims are proven to be true, he deserves compensation and some heads should roll.

The fact that the Crown chose not to pursue another trial after so many years does not mean that any of his claims are true.
 
As I said before, completely WRONG.

"To succeed in an action for malicious prosecution, a plaintiff must prove that the prosecution was:
(1) initiated by the defendant;
(2) terminated in favour of the plaintiff;
(3) undertaken without reasonable and probable cause; and
(4) motivated by malice or a primary purpose other than that of carrying the law into effect"

This is directly from the recent Supreme Court of Canada Case of Miazga which threw out a malicious prosecution accusation against the Crown in a 7 to 0 decision.

http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2009/2009scc51/2009scc51.html
Thanks for the link.
Some good information there.


Malice is a question of fact, requiring evidence that the prosecutor was impelled by an “improper purpose”. The malice element of the test will be made out when a court is satisfied, on a balance of probabilities, that the defendant Crown prosecutor commenced or continued the impugned prosecution with a purpose inconsistent with his or her role as a “minister of justice”. The plaintiff must demonstrate on the totality of the evidence that the prosecutor deliberately intended to subvert or abuse the office of the Attorney General or the process of criminal justice such that he or she exceeded the boundaries of the office of the Attorney General. The need to consider the “totality of all the circumstances” does not mean that the court is to embark on a second‑guessing of every decision made by the prosecutor during the course of the criminal proceedings. It simply means that a court shall review all evidence related to the prosecutor’s state of mind, including any evidence of lack of belief in the existence of reasonable and probable cause, in deciding whether the prosecution was in fact fuelled by an improper purpose. While the absence of a subjective belief in reasonable and probable cause is relevant to the malice inquiry, it does not equate with malice and does not dispense with the requirement of proof of an improper purpose. By requiring proof of an improper purpose, the malice element ensures that liability will not be imposed in cases where a prosecutor proceeds, absent reasonable and probable grounds, by reason of incompetence, inexperience, honest mistake, negligence or even gross negligence.
 
As I said before, completely WRONG.

"To succeed in an action for malicious prosecution, a plaintiff must prove that the prosecution was:
(1) initiated by the defendant;
(2) terminated in favour of the plaintiff;
(3) undertaken without reasonable and probable cause; and
(4) motivated by malice or a primary purpose other than that of carrying the law into effect"

This is directly from the recent Supreme Court of Canada Case of Miazga which threw out a malicious prosecution accusation against the Crown in a 7 to 0 decision.

http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2009/2009scc51/2009scc51.html

Suing the government to recover a damage for negligence i.e. they bulldozed your house to put in a new road but had the wrong address by mistake, is a completely different case from malicious prosecution.

Different torts have different tests.
There is also judicial immunity so that the judge in the first case cannot be sued.

As an aside, if the Crown elects to oppose Mr. Baltovich what essentially could happen is a murder trial to a civil standard of balance of probabilities rather than beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the Crown leads evidence that they think he did it, but could not prove it beyond a reasonable doubt the Crown wins, he gets a bill for the Crowns' legal fees.

If Baltovich has evidence that the police or Crown withheld exculpatory evidence, write him a HUGE cheque.

It is a fact driven case, but very few of the relevant facts are published and there is a lot of supposition.

Another aside, is that he is suing his first lawyers, this will allow them to bring SOME privileged statements into evidence at the civil trial in their own defence. For example, of Baltovich ever told his first lawyer "get me a deal of less then 5 years and I will take it", that previously privileged conversation can now be brought in as evidence.

So you're not just a pretty face with a good taste in liquor.
 
You may wish to consult a lawyer or legal text because that is not the law in Ontario or elsewhere in Canada.

No I am pretty sure to sue a police officer or crown attorney personally (not just use the police force or the Ontario crown) you have to prove mailce. But if you want to sue the crown you can sue for negligence.