Robert Baltovich Lawsuit

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Robert was one of many Canadians wrongfully convicted of murder and spent 8 years in the prime of his life in jail and had his good name tarnished. He is now suing the Ontario government and two police officers for $13million. I think he definitely deserves compensation. The question is how much?

Note: Under the laws of estoppel I think a citizen can successfully sue the state only if he can prove the state acted in a malicious manner.
 
Robert was one of many Canadians wrongfully convicted of murder and spent 8 years in the prime of his life in jail and had his good name tarnished. He is now suing the Ontario government and two police officers for $13million. I think he definitely deserves compensation. The question is how much?

Note: Under the laws of estoppel I think a citizen can successfully sue the state only if he can prove the state acted in a malicious manner.

From recent cases, it's been a convention of $1 million for each year served.
 
l I think a citizen can successfully sue the state only if he can prove the state acted in a malicious manner.

There was a very recent Supreme Court decision that raised the bar on proving malice. An officer simply doing his/her job and making a mistake is not enough.

From what I heard today, one of the allegations is that the police had evidence that proved he did not commit the crime and withheld that evidence.
IF and I repeat IF, that is accurate and proven then this case should set a new high water mark for wrongful imprisonment.

There has been a large range in the damage awards from $250,000 per year to over $1 million per year, but it is far more than a formula of dollars for time wrongfully served, the entire impact on his overall life will be reviewed, the institution he was placed in, how he was treated etc etc etc. Given his counsel this will certainly go to the higher end.

The other question is, does the Crown want a public trial and full public disclosure of all the police and Crown conduct, me thinks not, and a settlement is very likely.
 
From recent cases, it's been a convention of $1 million for each year served.

There was a very recent Supreme Court decision that raised the bar on proving malice. An officer simply doing his/her job and making a mistake is not enough.

From what I heard today, one of the allegations is that the police had evidence that proved he did not commit the crime and withheld that evidence.
IF and I repeat IF, that is accurate and proven then this case should set a new high water mark for wrongful imprisonment.

There has been a large range in the damage awards from $250,000 per year to over $1 million per year, but it is far more than a formula of dollars for time wrongfully served, the entire impact on his overall life will be reviewed, the institution he was placed in, how he was treated etc etc etc. Given his counsel this will certainly go to the higher end.

The other question is, does the Crown want a public trial and full public disclosure of all the police and Crown conduct, me thinks not, and a settlement is very likely.

Or not. So much for conventions.

Go RB! sic'em.
 
Robert should get everything he deserves ..........
 
I think he has a very tough task.

Juries have been known to make mistakes.
Doesn't mean you have grounds for a lawsuit.

The fact that the Crown did not pursue another trial does not prove that he is innocent.
They likely weighed the time and costs against their chances of success after so many years plus they considered the time he has already served as being significant punishment.

If his claims are true and can be proven, I hope he gets a good settlement.
He should take a lie detector test.
 
A million per year is a bit much.
They should subtract the free room and board he got and make it $980,000 per year.
 
It's been alleged that the girl he was convicted of killing was actually a victim of Paul Bernardo.

Seems to me there was another case a year or two ago of some poor sap who pled guilty to a Bernardo sex assault when the vitim's mother swore she saw him and his lawyer told him to take a plea bargain.
 
Was there actually any evidence that he did not do it? From what I recall, it seemed like they changed their minds and let him go, but it wasn't like they found someone elses DNA or anything, did they? Being released due to lack of evidence is far from the same as actually being innocent.

If, on the other hand, the police had evidence that he did not do it, and hid it, that would be very bad, and he should be suitably compensated.
 
How about if the state acted in a stupid manner?

Don't think so. Otherwise, the state owes me $28million dollars. Here is an example, if you make a mistake on your tax return they will penalize you but if they make a mistake in assessing your tax return they will penalize you.
 
I think part of the problem was the manner in which the trial judge acted. This was the reason the original verdict was set aside. The trial judge is a provincial employee and it is the responsibility of the province to ensure judges are competent and act according to law.
 
I think he has a very tough task.

Juries have been known to make mistakes.
Doesn't mean you have grounds for a lawsuit.

The fact that the Crown did not pursue another trial does not prove that he is innocent.
They likely weighed the time and costs against their chances of success after so many years plus they considered the time he has already served as being significant punishment.

If his claims are true and can be proven, I hope he gets a good settlement.
He should take a lie detector test.

Nobody has to prove he is innocent --- HE IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY and he was not proven guilty
 
A million per year is a bit much.
They should subtract the free room and board he got and make it $980,000 per year.

He deserve 10 million per year for being wrongfully imprisoned!