Peak Oil - imminent?

If Hydrogen were developed on a scale the Apollo Moon project was, we would not be importing one drop of OIL today!

Hydrogen has been developed on the same scale that the Apollo Moon project was.

All projections are, if we had an economy based on Hydrogen, we would have severe resource shortage problems. It is not practical to have an energy storage medium dependent on rare precious metals that are in extremely short supply.
 
Hydrogen has been developed on the same scale that the Apollo Moon project was.

All projections are, if we had an economy based on Hydrogen, we would have severe resource shortage problems. It is not practical to have an energy storage medium dependent on rare precious metals that are in extremely short supply.

You're assuming we won't find a more efficient way to make hydrogen. In my post I intentionally left open what technology would be used to store energy, hydrogen is one possibility. In the long term I am fairly certain that we will develop an efficient fuel cell technology of some kind. In the short and medium term we can cut our use of petroleum via hybrid products.

By the way, what is your opinion of catalytic converters? Do they make gasoline burning vehicles impractical because the energy use is dependent on a rare precious metal?
 
Roger Ebert on movie "Collapse" - concerned with peak oil.

Quote:
----
"If this man is correct, then you may be reading the most important story in today’s paper.

I have no way of assuring you that the bleak version of the future outlined by Michael Ruppert in Chris Smith’s “Collapse” is accurate. I can only tell you I have a pretty good built-in B.S. detector, and its needle never bounced off zero while I watched this film. There is controversy over Ruppert, and he has many critics. But one simple fact at the center of his argument is obviously true, and it terrifies me.

That fact: We have passed the peak of global oil resources. There are only so many known oil reserves. We have used up more than half of them. Remaining reserves are growing smaller, and the demand is growing larger. It took about a century to use up the first half. That usage was much accelerated in the most recent 50 years. Now the oil demands of giant economies like India and China are exploding. They represent more than half the global population, and until recent decades had small energy consumption.

If the supply is finite, and usage is potentially doubling, you do the math. We will face a global oil crisis, not in the distant future, but within the lives of many now alive. They may well see a world without significant oil.

Oh, I grow so impatient with those who prattle about our untapped resources in Alaska, yada yada yada. There seems to be only enough oil in Alaska to power the United States for a matter of months. The world’s great oil reserves have been discovered.

Saudi Arabia sits atop the largest oil reservoir ever found. For years, the Saudis have refused to disclose any figures at all about their reserves. If those reserves are vast and easy to tap by drilling straight down through the desert, then ask yourself this question: Why are the Saudis spending billions of dollars to develop offshore drilling platforms?

Ruppert is a man ordinary in appearance, on the downhill slope of middle age, a chain smoker with a mustache. He is not all worked up. He speaks reasonably and very clearly. “Collapse” involves what he has to say, illustrated with news footage and a few charts, the most striking of which is a bell-shaped curve. It takes a lot of effort to climb a bell-shaped curve, but the descent is steep and dangerous.

He recites facts I knew, vaguely. Many things are made from oil. Everything plastic. Paint. There are eight gallons of oil in every auto tire. Oil supplies the energy to convert itself into those byproducts. No oil, no plastic, no tires, no gas to run cars, no machines to build them. No coal mines, except those operated by men and horses.

Alternative energies and conservation? The problem is the cost of obtaining and using it. Ethanol requires more energy than it produces. Hybrid and battery cars need engines, tires and batteries. Nuclear power plants need to be built with oil. Electricity from wind power is most useful near its source. It is transmitted by grids built and maintained by oil. Wave power is expensive to collect. Solar power is cheap and limitless, but we need a whole hell of a lot more solar panels and other collecting devices.

Like I say, you do the math. Ruppert has done his math, and he concludes that our goose is cooked. He doesn’t have any answers. We’re passing the point of diminishing returns on the way to our rendezvous with the point of no return. It was nice while it lasted. People lived happily enough in the centuries before oil, electricity and steam, I guess. Of course, there were fewer than 6 billion of us. In this century, Ruppert says, there will be a lot fewer than 6 billion again. It won’t be a pretty sight.

I’m not going to mention his theories about global warming, because that’s a subject that inflames too many zealots. About peak oil, his reasoning is clear, simple and hard to refute.

So you can stop reading now. That’s the heart of Ruppert’s message, delivered by a calm guy who could be Wilford Brimley’s kid brother, lives alone with his dog and is behind on his rent.

I was fascinated by some of the directions peak oil takes him into. For him, he says, it was the key to understanding many seemingly unconnected geopolitical events. The facts he outlines are known to world leaders, who don’t talk a lot about them in alarmist terms, but they explain why Bush/Cheney were happy to have an excuse to invade Iraq. And why our embassy compound in Baghdad is the largest we’ve ever built, larger than Vatican City. And why we’re so much more worried by Iran than North Korea. They may also explain Obama’s perplexing decision to increase troops in Afghanistan. An undeclared world war for oil is already under way.

I don’t know when I’ve seen a thriller more frightening. I couldn’t tear my eyes from the screen. “Collapse” is even entertaining, in a macabre sense. I think you owe it to yourself to see it."

---------

http://transition-times.com/blog/2009/12/10/roger-ebert-reviews-collapse/
 
..............................................
Saudi Arabia sits atop the largest oil reservoir ever found. For years, the Saudis have refused to disclose any figures at all about their reserves. If those reserves are vast and easy to tap by drilling straight down through the desert, then ask yourself this question: Why are the Saudis spending billions of dollars to develop offshore drilling platforms?
......................................................................................................

If the offshore drilling platforms are being deployed to bring Manifa field
off the coast of Saudi Arabia to full scale production then the near-term outlook
for Saudi's oil industry must be a dire one.
Manifa the last untapped super-giant field of Saudi is heavily
loaded with Vanadium and hydrogen sulphide. Saudi Aramco must have been
desperate to (finally) turn to such a polluting source.
 
Saudi Aramco must have been desperate to (finally) turn to such a polluting source.

Surely (based on your handle) you agree that in this industry speculation is the driving force... To prove a reservoir and have that evaluation on paper is often the only reason for exploration. Production may or may not ever enter the equation, while proven assets are used as currency to fund production of other assets, and fund riskier exploration...
 
This article should be pertinent the thread although peak oil isn't really
the focus of it. Hope it isn't too long to be a distraction.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.buffalonews.com/2010/04/17/1022394/want-peace-solve-the-energy-crisis.html

Want peace? Solve the energy crisis!

By Walter Simpson
April 17, 2010

In 1979, the Russians invaded Afghanistan and fears were running high
that they were going after the Saudi Arabian oil fields. President Jimmy
Carter responded with the "Carter Doctrine," which designated those oil
fields as vital U.S. interests and stated that we would use "any means
necessary" to defend them — apparently including nuclear weapons.

Risking nuclear war for oil, when we were wasting it like crazy, seemed
absurd and dangerous to me. So I created the Energy Conservation Peace
Pledge, a petition that said let's conserve energy instead of risking
nuclear war. Pretty obvious stuff, but it was in direct opposition to
conventional wisdom and U.S. foreign policy at the time.

My conservation pledge did not change history but it was an epiphany
for me. I realized that if I wanted to be an effective peacemaker, I had
better address the energy issue. So I left my position as director of the
Western New York Peace Center and went back to school to study energy
policy. That decision led to a 26-year career as energy officer at the
University at Buffalo, where I planned and implemented energy conservation
measures while teaching about the need for sustainable energy policies.

My early understanding of the energy issue was influenced by Amory
Lovins' groundbreaking essay, "Energy Strategy: the Road Not Taken?" that
appeared in the October 1976 issue of Foreign Affairs. In that article,
Lovins established his credentials as an energy visionary by discussing
the "hard" and "soft" energy paths.

The hard energy path is the path we are on — with near-total reliance
on non-renewable fossil fuels and large central power stations mostly
fueled by coal or uranium. Lovins characterized the hard path as
polluting, risky, vulnerable, costly and capital intensive. He was also
prescient, observing more than 30 years ago that a long-term commitment
to coal-burning would cause substantial and potentially irreversible
changes in global climate. Moreover, he sounded the alarm about the
dangerous connection between nuclear power and nuclear weapons.

Lovins' soft energy path was easier on the environment, society and
pocketbook. Instead of the hard path's commitment to ever-increasing
conventional energy supplies, the soft path called for first reducing
demand through energy conservation and efficiency and then using soft
energy technologies like solar, wind and biomass to meet those reduced
energy needs in ways that were renewable, diverse, decentralized, easy
to understand and appropriate to the tasks at hand.

Observing that more than half the energy we produce is wasted, Lovins
turned energy thinking on its head by advocating meeting energy needs with
"negawatts" or energy savings — an approach he termed "least cost"
because it generally costs much less to save energy than it does to
make it.

Looking back, we see that the 1970s were watershed years in the energy
world. In 1973 and 1974 we experienced an energy crisis when Arab
oil-producing nations imposed an oil embargo on the United States and
its allies in response to U.S. support for Israel during and after the
Arab-Israeli War of 1973. Many will remember long gas station lines
that called into question our love affair with large, gas-guzzling cars.

That first energy crisis was followed in 1979 by a second energy
crisis when the U.S.-supported Shah of Iran (Mohammad Reza Pahlavi) was
overthrown and replaced by the Ayatollah Khomeini. In addition to seizing
American hostages, Iran's new government turned off the oil spigot,
reducing global oil supplies and causing gasoline prices to soar again.

These events and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan focused the Carter
administration on U.S. foreign oil dependence. At the time only 37
percent of U.S. oil was imported — compared to 57 percent now. While
Carter was an advocate of energy conservation, he also was willing
to use U.S. military might to keep foreign oil flowing into our gas
tanks. Before Carter left office he created the Rapid Deployment Force,
a new military command designed to quickly deploy to global hot-spots
like the Persian Gulf whenever U.S. interests were threatened.

Our first oil war occurred in 1991, when U.S. and allied forces carried
out Operation Desert Storm to repel Iraqi military forces that had invaded
Kuwait in 1990, seizing its oil fields. While President George H.W. Bush
took pains to wrap this war in the American flag, calling it a defense of
"freedom and democracy," the war was clearly all about oil. After all,
Kuwait was not a democracy but it did contain the world's fourth-largest
oil reserves.

While this war was relatively short, each day of fighting cost
taxpayers $1 billion, or three times the annual federal budget for
energy conservation. And 148 American soldiers died liberating Kuwaiti
oil. Iraqi deaths were considerably higher — 50,000 or more. Civilian
deaths were termed "collateral damage" with many killed during weeks
of U.S. aerial bombing of Baghdad.

Given the human and dollar costs of the Gulf War, the take-home lesson
should have been "let's do everything we can to avoid another oil
war." But that lesson was not learned. Our cars remained inefficient and
we drove them greater distances, causing U.S. foreign oil imports to grow
during the 1990s. Moreover, at the end of the Gulf War the seeds were
sown for the next oil war by establishing a permanent U.S. military base
in Saudi Arabia. This base was deeply resented by Saudi fundamentalists
like Osama bin Laden, and may have precipitated the al-Qaida terrorist
attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, which served as a catalyst to our second oil
war in 2003.

The ancient Greek dramatist Aeschylus is credited with saying, "In war,
truth is the first casualty." Nothing could illustrate that maxim better
than all the lies that were told by the George W. Bush administration
to mobilize our nation for "regime change" and war in Iraq.

We now know that Saddam Hussein and Iraq had nothing to do with the 9/11
attacks and that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction threatening the
United States. While the Bush White House was masterful in conjuring up
phony rationales for invading Iraq, it never admitted the real one —
oil. The role of Saudi Arabia in 9/11 was also obscured. Saudi money,
much of it recycled U.S. petro-dollars, was funding fundamentalist
Islamic schools throughout the region committed to jihad against the
United States.

Given the Bush administration's strong oil industry ties, it was not
surprising that it immediately focused on foreign oil through Vice
President Dick Cheney's energy task force, which met in secret with top
oil company executives. Its May 2001 report highlighted the dangers of
U.S. foreign oil dependency, predicting that by 2020 as much as two-thirds
of U.S. oil would be imported. Cheney's task force is believed to have
reviewed maps of Iraqi oil fields, noting which U.S. oil companies
wanted access to them. When the 9/11 terrorist attacks occurred, the
administration was ready to use this tragic event as an excuse to go after
the Iraqi oil reserves — the second- or third-largest in the world.

When the cause of war is obvious, it's remarkable that knowledgeable
political leaders remain silent and sustain the masquerade. It took Alan
Greenspan, former Federal Reserve chairman, to say in his 2007 memoir,
"I am saddened that it is politically inconvenient to acknowledge what
everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil." This statement's
truth was borne out by the Bush administration's ongoing attempts to
pressure the new Iraqi government to sign no-bid contracts with Western
oil companies like Exxon, Mobil, Shell, Total and BP, which previously
did not have access to Iraqi oil.


.......continued below.................................
 
part II

Our second oil war, which has yet to end, makes the first one look
like a piker: 4,000 Americans have been killed and more than 30,000
wounded. Iraqi deaths are estimated between 100,000 and 1 million. So far
the war has directly cost American taxpayers more than $700 billion and
the U.S. economy an estimated $3 trillion — $10,000 for every American.

These staggering sums may be more than would be needed to completely
redesign our transportation sector to run efficiently on domestic
biofuels or wind powered hydrogen, completely eliminating U.S. foreign
oil dependence.

In the absence of better energy policies, we can expect more oil wars in
the future, perhaps at an accelerating rate. After all, our dependence
on oil imports is still growing and most of the world's remaining
conventional oil is located in Middle East Islamic nations often not
well disposed to the United States.

Plus it appears that the world has or will soon experience "peak oil,"
a point in time when global oil production peaks and then declines as
the oil reserves that are easiest to discover and tap are depleted,
and when finding more oil becomes difficult and costly.

Peak oil, which is inevitable because global oil supplies are
finite, will usher in an era of much higher gasoline prices and
economic dislocation. Even worse, peak oil could propel us toward
"non-solutions" like reckless drilling for oil in fragile, irreplaceable
natural environments or tapping Canadian oil sands — which would be
catastrophic given the energy requirements and carbon footprint associated
with exploiting that resource.

The frightening prospect of peak oil should motivate us to quickly become
"energy independent" by developing public transit, bicycle-friendly
communities, smart-growth plans to minimize sprawl and highly efficient
alternatively fueled vehicles. Lack of action is setting us up to become
full participants in an intense international scramble for dwindling
oil supplies — a recipe for economic collapse, international conflict
and more oil wars.

Our addiction to fossil fuels also is causing global climate change
because when coal, oil and natural gas are burned they release vast
quantities of carbon dioxide, the principal greenhouse gas that traps
heat in the atmosphere. As the atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse
gases rise, so does global average temperature. Our unusual recent local
winter notwithstanding, NASA warns that a new global average temperature
record is likely to be set soon.

There is a natural tendency to deny the inconvenient truth about fossil
fuels, but it is based on overwhelming scientific evidence. We ignore this
problem at our own peril because as climate change gets worse, our species
will find itself living in a much less hospitable world with rising sea
levels and more intense storms, heat waves, droughts and floods.

Even now in parts of the world many people are just barely
surviving. Imagine the difficulties the world's poor will have as natural
environments fail. Changing climates will cause millions of "eco-refugees"
to illegally cross national boundaries, seeking land, food and water
resources to survive. Water wars may rival oil wars as deserts expand
and the glaciers and winter snowpack that feed rivers decline.

The U.S. military understands the science and takes the threat of climate
change seriously. As early as 2004, the Pentagon released a study that
found that climate change could lead to anarchy in many parts of the
world, making international conflict endemic. The report, which was
quickly suppressed by the Bush administration, described global warming
as a greater threat to national security than terrorism.

These findings were repeated in the recently released 2010 Pentagon
Quadrennial Defense Review, which described climate change as "an
accelerant of instability" that "may spark future conflicts." While we
spent $5 trillion on national defense and war during the last decade,
we have yet to address climate change and our addiction to fossil fuels
in any meaningful way.

Climatologist Jim Hansen said in 2006 that he believed we had just 10
years to make substantial progress reversing current carbon dioxide
emissions trends or we would be unable to avoid the worst consequences
of climate change. Hansen argues that we must curtail coal burning and
implement a carbon tax. To date, neither strategy has been seriously
considered. Nor has Congress passed even a flawed climate protection bill.

Any discussion of energy and conflicts has one more element — nuclear
power. Does it contribute to peace or war?

Consider the nuclear fuel cycle: Uranium is mined, enriched
and then "fissioned" in a reactor to produce heat, steam and then
electricity. Each step has risks. Nuclear plants also produce radioactive
waste that must be safely disposed of for tens of thousands of years
or reprocessed into more nuclear fuel.

The enrichment and reprocessing steps use technology that can produce
highly enriched uranium or plutonium — the stuff of radioactive
"dirty bombs" or city-flattening atomic bombs that we never want to see
in the hands of terrorists or governments hostile to us — like that of
Iran. Thus, nuclear power technology — what President Dwight Eisenhower
hailed as "atoms for peace" in the 1950s — inextricably is tied to
"atoms for war."

Climate change reopened the nuclear power debate because nuclear power
plants operate without emitting carbon dioxide. While unimpressed
by existing nuclear power plants, Hansen is among those calling
for accelerated R&D on "fourth generation" nuclear plants to provide
carbon-free, base-load electric-generating capacity. He believes these
"fast neutron" plants will be much more efficient than existing light
water reactors and able to "burn" the radioactive waste and plutonium
created by older reactors — easing both the radioactive waste and
proliferation problems.

On the other side is Lovins, who still doubts we need large coal or
nuclear power stations and observed years ago that nuclear power plants
make inviting targets for terrorists. Lovins maintains that advanced
reactor designs will not adequately safeguard against nuclear weapons
proliferation. In any event, he argues that a nuclear resurgence is
unlikely because — compared to the alternatives — nuclear power is
just too expensive and will inevitably die from "an incurable attack
of market forces."

Of the thousand things we need to do to create a more peaceful future,
surely one of them — a principal strategy — is finding less dangerous
ways to meet our energy needs.

Lovins was right in 1976 and he is right now in his continuing plea for
the soft energy path. We can have a cleaner, safer world and meet our
energy needs less expensively by making deep cuts in the amount of energy
we consume and then using diverse, renewable, carbon-free alternative
energy sources like solar, wind, biomass and geothermal to meet those
needs. It need not be the "road not taken."
 
But no problem with tailing ponds that dump carcinogens into the Alberta water supply?

What water supply?

It's true the oil sands are dumping carcinogens into Alberta's water supply, as well as Saskatchewan's and Manitoba's, but it is drying up. Alberta's water table is dependent on glacial runoff and they are receding. Dick Meat can talk about Alberta's global relevance and economic stature all he wants - you cant drink oil.

You can talk about peak oil all you want (we're myopic that way), fresh water is disappearing at a much more alarming rate. We in "lowly" Ontario have to do a better job of managing ours.
 
A further long term possibility is to convert nuclear power plants from being electric generation plans to generating some sort of fuel directly--say hydrogen--eliminating the inefficiency of carrying it as electricity.

What do you mean? Electricity is one of the most efficient forms of energy there is.. converting it to hydrogen, and then back to electricity the opposite is true.
 
What do you mean? Electricity is one of the most efficient forms of energy there is.. converting it to hydrogen, and then back to electricity the opposite is true.

Electricity transmission lines are very inefficient and account for much loss.
Homes and businesses equipped with stationary fuel cells would produce all your electricity on site with no need for any power lines.

Hydrogen IS the ticket!....
msn-wink.gif
 
What do you mean? Electricity is one of the most efficient forms of energy there is.. converting it to hydrogen, and then back to electricity the opposite is true.

Convertint it to electricity, and then from electricity to hydrogen, and then from hydrogen to forward motion in a vehicle would be less efficient than skipping the electrical step. If hydrogen turns out not to be the appropriate fuel, if it turns out to be something else, creating that directly would be more efficient. Nuclear power stations are essentially heat generation stations--what we turn the heat into depends on what we want to do with it. Turning the heat into electrical power is one option only. For most purposes it's a great option. If we want to replace combustion engines with something else, though, we should explore the possibility of directly generating the fuel cells.
 
As above hydrogen is an energy carrier not an energy source. Need some kind of energy to "release" the energy in hydrogen. What power in the standalone business or home will do so? Solar panels and wind generators are not quite renewable yet (can't build either with energy from one or both)

Nuclear plants in the US are running off fissionable material supplied by russian dismantled weapons. Contract due to expire 2013. Not likely to be a supply of new uranium to build a world based on nuclear energy. Last year at least 4 nuclear reactors in the US were shut down to drought. I believe about 10 reactors in France shut down for the same reason.

Other sources of electricty are coal - dirty and most of the good anthracite coal is long gone. Nat gas is available on each continent. North America is dependent upon the "hype" around shale to be self sufficient. Probably are for a while but not sure if its economically feasible given a shaky economy. Hydro is pretty much done, not much more expansion available. Solar has some potential but requires hydrocarbons to manufacture in large scale. Wind has some potential.

Oil has the highest energy density of current fuel sources. Likely we will see the industries and geographical areas which are high energy intensive begin to fall apart. American SW, car industry etc as both availabity and shrinking supply of oil affect tertiary industries including nat gas and coal.

Need oil, nat gas, electricity to keep the industrialized world ticking over to run public health services in the OECD like fresh water, plumbing, sewer systems, garbage disposal, cheap food. As this becomes less available over time its likely the OECD will start to resemble the Soviet Union after its collapse

Had a great run of close to 300 yrs with concentrated solar energy in the form of fossil fuels. Perhaps if we have Bill Shatner as GG in canada we can finally start to use dilithium crystals to power are way to a new future
 
Nuclear plants in the US are running off fissionable material supplied by russian dismantled weapons. Contract due to expire 2013. Not likely to be a supply of new uranium to build a world based on nuclear energy

Where do you get the idea that uranium is scarce? It's an incredibly common mineral. The reason why there's been a decline in mining is we dug up far more of the stuff than we need during the arms race--we can now run existing reactors for a good long time off material previously extracted for nuclear weapons, but once that's exhausted there's an ample supply of the stuff in the ground that can be dug up. It is a fairly commonplace metal.

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf75.html
 
Convertint it to electricity, and then from electricity to hydrogen, and then from hydrogen to forward motion in a vehicle would be less efficient than skipping the electrical step. If hydrogen turns out not to be the appropriate fuel, if it turns out to be something else, creating that directly would be more efficient. Nuclear power stations are essentially heat generation stations--what we turn the heat into depends on what we want to do with it. Turning the heat into electrical power is one option only. For most purposes it's a great option. If we want to replace combustion engines with something else, though, we should explore the possibility of directly generating the fuel cells.

Nice if it works, but how do we use that heat to create hydrogen?

Keep in mind that hydrogen cars are in fact electric cars. The odds of hydrogen being more efficient than batteries or super capacitors by the time hydrogen cars become a reality (if ever) are slim to none.. (I'm talking the better part of a decade away minimum).. Hydrogen is not a fuel, it's an energy storage medium.. and energy companies want a product to sell you.. I can't count how many times I've posted about this on this board, but hydrogen cars as a mainstream are pretty close to fantasy..
 
Where do you get the idea that uranium is scarce? It's an incredibly common mineral. The reason why there's been a decline in mining is we dug up far more of the stuff than we need during the arms race--we can now run existing reactors for a good long time off material previously extracted for nuclear weapons, but once that's exhausted there's an ample supply of the stuff in the ground that can be dug up. It is a fairly commonplace metal.

And aren't you the one whining about toxic tailings ponds and dirty mining? Uranium mining is tenfold more dangerous and polluting than bitumen production. Like I said, a lot of Alberta's oilsands deposits lie a meter or 2 from surface... Consider it the Earth's largest natural oil spill, if you wish. You should be thanking your fellow Albertan countrymen for dilligently cleaning it up...
 
Nice if it works, but how do we use that heat to create hydrogen?

By using it to separate oxygen from hydrogen???

Hydrogen is not a fuel, it's an energy storage medium

So is oil...

I don't disagree with your point that hydrogen cars may never be mainstream. What I think is that in the future SOME sort of efficient energy storage solution will exist, and when it does, it will be more efficient to convert nuclear energy directly to form rather than transforming it temporarily to electricity, if possible. Hydrogen is just an example.
 
And aren't you the one whining about toxic tailings ponds and dirty mining?

You've gone circular now. I brought up the tailing ponds in response to your claim that nuclear waste was some sort of liability against nuclear power, but tailing ponds are a similar problem with tar sands.

Uranium mining is tenfold more dangerous and polluting than bitumen production.

Only theoretically, because nuclear waste is a hell of a lot easier to contain than a tailing pond. A tailing pond is in theory less toxic, but practically speaking it's a bigger problem.

Like I said, a lot of Alberta's oilsands deposits lie a meter or 2 from surface... Consider it the Earth's largest natural oil spill, if you wish. You should be thanking your fellow Albertan countrymen for dilligently cleaning it up...

It's unclear whether the oil sands are a net gain in energy when the cost of cleaning up the tailing ponds is included in the energy calculation. It's unclear because nobody really knows how to do that, and therefore nobody knows how much energy it's going to cost.
 
Don't forget that at present, oil sands use lots of clean natural gas to produce oil. And lots of crap.

Hyrdogen is a problematic storage medium, sure it burns clean but its harder to put in a tank (smaller molecules) and pressurize.
Nuclear will have to be used, because we aren't going to want to go without power. And there are new methods in the work that might be less problematic.

Oil is a storage medium, but has stored up milleniums of years of solar/carbon. But to call it a storage medium assumes that we can make it efficiently, but we can't. See subisidies on biodiesel (not to mention that its a bad idea to turn our food into gas for cars).
 
Only theoretically, because nuclear waste is a hell of a lot easier to contain than a tailing pond. A tailing pond is in theory less toxic, but practically speaking it's a bigger problem.

Only theoretically, we are wasting enormous amounts of electrical energy keeping spent fuel rods cooled. They can remain reactive for over a millennium and can become unstable if they are not kept constantly cooled with flowing chilled water. This is the main stumbling block to nuclear energy. As for tailing pools you are correct the long term biological effect isn't known.