Peak Oil - imminent?

I fully agree. I don't know how Chinese and Indian demand changes this, but when oil prices spiked, I saw a news report that said that with existing reserves, we still have enough oil to 2050ish.

Reading this thread I don't think some people really understand what peak oil means. It does not mean run out of oil. It means we've peeked at production. It means we've used half the oil. Yes, we've got lots of oil.. but from this point on the amount available is continually decreasing. If demand decreased too it wouldn't be a big issue.. but demand isn't decreasing... it isn't even stagnant.. it's increasing.. more people want something that's becoming more scarce. So yeah, in 30 odd years, we'll have oil.. but how much will it cost? An amount that we can't even comprehend right now..
 
You need to give your head a shake. Put down the Toronto Star for a minute and think about what you are saying here. To discredit the oilsands as 'dirty', then suggest nulear power is laughable, and idiotic.

The oil sands dirty the atmosphere. Nuclear power does not. Nuclear waste is unsafe in a *local* area, while fossill fuel is unsafe *globally*.

Yes, nuclear power is far cleaner in the ways that count.
 
I would argue there is a enough oil to sustain the globe for centuries

Not likely. The problem is that demand is growing and supply is shrinking. Sure there will be oils around for centuries--but it will become super expensive. Peak oil is real, but I believe that we will successfully switch to alternate energy sources as we lose oil supply. It will probably be a painful process, and generate a series of recessions, but I don't believe the doom and gloom that characterizes the Peak Oil "community". I don't believe it's the end of civilization, just a bump on the road.

We do, however, have to get serious about reducing our dependency on oil and developing other energy sources. Nuclear power seems inevitable to me, but may be something else.
 
Yes, even the most negative prognosticator will not say that by 2020 or 2030 or a date like that, the world will have exhausted the entire oil supply, but that's not what 'peak oil' means, and unfortunately that's not what the world economy relies on. As soon as it becomes widely known, and not in classified government, or corporate documents, but in mainstream media, and general economic circles, that we, as a civilization have drilled, or will imminently extract, the majority of the Earth's supply of oil, and that oil supply will only decline in future years, then that will be the point that the industrialized economy will fundamentally change, either by choice, or more likely, by force. Not saying that it will be doomsday or the extinction of the human race, I have more faith in the ingenuousness of the human race than that, but it will be the end of the current economic model, and it will occur with much social and political upheaval. Only the extremely rich will be able to afford oil at that point, and since the vast majority of the Earth's population is not that rich, there will be incredible anger and social unrest, the likes of which haven't been seen in quite some time. Again, as I and others have pointed out, demand for oil will not be abating in the slightest anytime soon, and will only be increasing. I think alot of people are unaware of just how much the everyday person, and I'm referring to people in the industrialized world, rely on oil on an everyday basis without even starting a car. Toothpaste, plastic, even toothbrushes, all require oil in some capacity, and that reliance on oil will be the catalyst for all the shit that will happen in the next 10-20 years.
Again, at some point, with the scarcity of oil, governments and corporations will look at oil as a whether it is a net gain or loss in terms of whether the energy extracted is equal to the energy expended, and oil that may or may not exist below the ocean's surface, or in the Venezuelan tar sands, or even the Albertan tar sands, will most likely result in a net loss in terms of the energy expended in retrieving the oil

At a fundamental level, it has nothing to do with the price of oil, only the stark reality that there is not anywhere enough oil to sustain the current economic model of growth. Future technologies are great, and possibly a 'magic bullet' could occur along the lines of the Manhattan Project, such as cold fusion, or massive solar-panel technology that can easily power cities, and even countries, but in reality, the chance of a huge technological breakthough occuring in the next 10-20 years, or even the next 30-40 years, before the collapse of the oil-based economy is very small

Again, my 'facts' could easily be wrong by a few million or more barrels, and I fully admit that, but given the rate at which the world's economy is expanding in terms of oil consumption, and given the very-easily grasped fact (unless you're really ignorant/dumb) that there is a quantifiable amount of oil left, the conclusion is apparent, all that is open for debate, is the timeline.
 
Last edited:
One of the more believable theories I've heard for this latest recession is that the spike in oil prices ($140/barrel or whatever they were), exposed all the high leverages that almost brought down those banks that were too big to fail.

And that is just a taste of where oil prices are headed.
 
The oil sands dirty the atmosphere. Nuclear power does not. Nuclear waste is unsafe in a *local* area, while fossill fuel is unsafe *globally*.

Yes, nuclear power is far cleaner in the ways that count.

Nuclear power is somewhat of a false promise.
There's an excellent documentary on peak oil called Crude Awakening. One of the experts says the following:

To replace all the energy we use today (10 terrawatts) that is created from fossil fuels, we would have to build 10,000 large nuclear stations. Using U235 as your fuel source, we would be deplete that between 10 - 20 years.

Granted, that's worst case scenario and it wouldn't happen like that, but it shows that over the long term, nuclear is not a solution but just a band aid.

Contrast that with solar, which again according to the expert in the documentary which gives us daily 20,000 time more energy than we are currently using from fossil fuels. This is where the real answer lies. It's not going to be easy and it requires a great deal of resources to get it in place however..
 
Nuclear power is somewhat of a false promise.
There's an excellent documentary on peak oil called Crude Awakening. One of the experts says the following:

To replace all the energy we use today (10 terrawatts) that is created from fossil fuels, we would have to build 10,000 large nuclear stations. Using U235 as your fuel source, we would be deplete that between 10 - 20 years.

Granted, that's worst case scenario and it wouldn't happen like that, but it shows that over the long term, nuclear is not a solution but just a band aid.

Contrast that with solar, which again according to the expert in the documentary which gives us daily 20,000 time more energy than we are currently using from fossil fuels. This is where the real answer lies. It's not going to be easy and it requires a great deal of resources to get it in place however..

Yes, there is a supply problem with U235 and to a certain extent, it is a bandaid solution. There is also the the problem of outrageously high cost of construction with nuclear energy. We will be paying off debt here in Ontario for decades and already some of the nuclear plants are breaking down and going off line for years while they repair them.

It may be true that solar can provide 20,000 times more energy than we currently use with fossil fuels, but that energy needs to be converted, and that is no easy task. I believe solar is only part of the answer, in combination with conservation, biomass, geothermal, fuel cells, wind, tidal, and probably several others that don't immediately come to mind.

When you look at the way the GTA is designed, its obvious that suburbs will become unsustainable as gasoline prices rise. I wouldn't want to have too much money invested in housing there in 20 years. And I know Mayor Miller is not very popular around here, but I really think he has the right idea about Transit City. That the province has now gone back on its commitment to fund LRT lines along several avenues is very shortsighted. Rapid transit is a huge part of the solution to transportation/fossil fuel consumption.
 
The oil sands dirty the atmosphere. Nuclear power does not. Nuclear waste is unsafe in a *local* area, while fossill fuel is unsafe *globally*.
Yes, nuclear power is far cleaner in the ways that count.

Another example of ignorance coming from an Ontario simpleton. Alberta's oilsands projects are responsible for less than 5% of Canada's 'greenhouse gas' emmisions- which interestingly, contribute less than 1% to Global emmisions.

Nuclear waste is deadly toxic and, with a half life of 100,000 years, I would consider it the most deadly polluting threat to humans. I've read that one speck of spent nuclear fuel (the size of a dust particle) is considered enough to give cancer to 10,000 people if made it into the atmosphere. Presently there are over 2.5 billion lbs of spent nuclear fuel being stored globally, which will need to be shielded from us for millenium to come.

Anybody that believes oilsands production is a 'net loss' needs to do some research; specifically, from a source that is not so emotionally and politically biased from the East.
 
Another example of ignorance coming from an Ontario simpleton. Alberta's oilsands projects are responsible for less than 5% of Canada's 'greenhouse gas' emmisions- which interestingly, contribute less than 1% to Global emmisions.

Since you're throwing around the word "ignorant", what percent of Canada's greenhouse gas emissions are the result of nuclear power? If it's less than 5% or you don't know, then it may turn out that you're the ignorant one.

Here's another question: When you write 5% are you including the consumption of that oil in foreign countries and its upgrading in the United States? If not then you might again turn out to be the ignorant person here.

Nuclear waste is deadly toxic and, with a half life of 100,000 years

Not in dispute, but it's a local problem. Greenhouse gas is a global problem. Haven't you seen me write that already? You seem to be ignoring the key point. Funny, "ignoring" has the same root word as "ignorant" odd how it keeps coming up.
 
Comparing oil to nuclear is a moot point. Nuclear generators produces electricity, which is used to power light bulbs, air conditioners, computers, etc. The by-product, is nuclear waste, not CO2 emmisions.

Oil is mainly refined into fuel oils: gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, heating oils, propane, butane; and to a lesser extent, lubricating oils and petroleum based construction products such as asphalt, paint, and tar. All of which there are no alternatives available to us, by the way! Some of the by-products from the refining stage are used as essential ingredients in plastics, chemical and medicine components... take a look around you and try to point out a single thing in your home NOT derived from petroleum...

I live in Northern Alberta and I can guarantee you the air is cleaner than (here) in S Ontario on it's best day. I've been here for a week, the smell is disgusting and I can't stop coughing. I can feel a film of scum on my skin and see it on my car after just a few hours.

While I agree that greenhouse gas emissions are a Global and local problem, I am personally not as afraid of them as I would be of a nuclear generator in my backyard, or a thousand KG of spent fission sources being buried anywhere in my Province.

Like I said, Canada only contributes 1-2% to global greenhouse gas emisions, which by my standards, is plenty low enough for me to accept.
 
Comparing oil to nuclear is a moot point. Nuclear generators produces electricity, which is used to power light bulbs, air conditioners, computers, etc.

You're talking about the CURRENT situation. This is a thread about peak oil. Currently electricity is used as you say, while oil is used as you say. That's changing though and can change further: As conventional oil becomes scarce we will have to switch to alternatives. One alternative, in the mid term, is to switch to the tar sands. Another alternative in both the mid and long term is to switch to electrical sources.

In the mid term "switching to electrical sources" will mean greater use of hybrid vehicles, and in the long term it would mean switching to fully electric or hydrogen or some other cell-powered vehicle where the energy can be sourced electrically. A further long term possibility is to convert nuclear power plants from being electric generation plans to generating some sort of fuel directly--say hydrogen--eliminating the inefficiency of carrying it as electricity.

The long term is a long way off and unknown, a lot of technological advances will have to occur before we really know what it looks like. In the mid term a shift to hybrid vehicles transitions us from oil to electricity in a more gradual step.

While I agree that greenhouse gas emissions are a Global and local problem, I am personally not as afraid of them as I would be of a nuclear generator in my backyard, or a thousand KG of spent fission sources being buried anywhere in my Province.

Or a tailing pond? Seems to me that there have been more leaks into drinking water from tailing ponds than there have been from stores of nuclear waste.

Like I said, Canada only contributes 1-2% to global greenhouse gas emisions, which by my standards, is plenty low enough for me to accept.

The point isn't about Alberta, which would have the highest greenhouse gas emissions per capita of any country in the world if it was an independent country. The point is about a global shift from one energy source to another.

Shifting from conventional oil to nuclear power is demonstrably cleaner, globally, than shifting from conventional oil to tar sands oil.

Emissions go up a lot if we shift to tar sands oil, whereas they decline if we switch to nuclear power.

You can go quote the numbers if you like, I know you know them: An increase of 10 to 45 percent on a "wheels to well" basis resulting from the fact that a barrel of oil from tar sands results in three times more emissions than a barrel of conventional oil. All that while the rest of the world is proposing to cut emissions in half.
 
In the mean time, Canada will be patiently waiting for the nuclear powered car, and basement-sized reactor to heat our homes in the winter...
 
This is another lie that the powers that be have created, there is enough oil to make it cheaper than water. They choose not to produce more oil to keep the price at a certain level, supply and demand. Also bear in mind, they have discovered large oil fields in Haiti - which is being kept quite.
 
No thanks, my truck runs on diesel, my cars run on gasoline and my home is heated with Alberta natural gas. I have no use for an anemic 'hybrid' vehicle, nor interest in poinsoning the Earth with nuclear waste that wont decompose for 200 thousand years. Hydrogen cars won't work in Canada's climate and aren't suitable to the geography I live and work in, either.

The majority of Ontario's electricity comes from coal burning generators, clearly making Ontario the largest source of polluting emission in all of Canada. Alberta's oilsands development and production accounts for less than 5% of Canadas emissions, but will guarantee Alberta's Global relevence and economic stature for generations to come... I suggest Ontario start working on alternatives for themselves.
 
Hydrogen cars won't work in Canada's climate and aren't suitable to the geography I live and work in.

Hydrogen vehicles will work anywhere! NASA has even found Hydrogen vehicles even work pretty darn well in space!...
shiny.gif

Hydrogen put the US on the moon, not OIL.

If Hydrogen were developed on a scale the Apollo Moon project was, we would not be importing one drop of OIL today!
 
If Hydrogen were developed on a scale the Apollo Moon project was, we would not be importing one drop of OIL today!

I thought you just said it was??

So where are all these hydrogen powered vehicles? A rocket is clearly much different than an internal combustion engine that turns a shaft with wheels...
 
No thanks, my truck runs on diesel, my cars run on gasoline and my home is heated with Alberta natural gas. I have no use for an anemic 'hybrid' vehicle, nor interest in poinsoning the Earth with nuclear waste that wont decompose for 200 thousand years. Hydrogen cars won't work in Canada's climate and aren't suitable to the geography I live and work in, either.

The majority of Ontario's electricity comes from coal burning generators, clearly making Ontario the largest source of polluting emission in all of Canada. Alberta's oilsands developement accounts for less than 5% of Canadas emissions, but will guarantee Alberta's Global relevence and economic stature for generations to come... I suggest Ontario start working on alternatives for themselves.

Majority of ontario's power comes from nuclear, I am guessing 35% to 80% depending on the time of year and time of day.

Generally you always run nuclear plants at its rated output, regardless of price or even demand. If it costs $50 per megawatt to produce power from a nuke, and the spot market price for power is $20, you still run the nuke and make a loss. Nukes only have 2 modes of operation, rated output and chernobly, they can not manuver it's output without causing damage/stress to the nuke. Sometimes, during a nice spring/fall night where there is no cooling or heating load, you can go the IESO website and see that the Hourly ontario price is negative, yes that means they will pay you for using electricity. The reason is because they can not turn off the nukes or lower their output, the net injection of power into the power grid must be balanced with net withdrawls of power, so the IESO is willing to pay you to use electricty to make the power system balanced.

Water is next in line for supplying electricity. Cheaper than coal and cleaner.

Coal is next in line.

Gas, heating oil, natural gas, is last in line

Solar/wind/mokeys on treadmills, no one give a shit about because they produce dick all and cost a fortune.
 
nor interest in poinsoning the Earth with nuclear waste that wont decompose for 200 thousand years

But no problem with tailing ponds that dump carcinogens into the Alberta water supply?

Hydrogen cars won't work in Canada's climate and aren't suitable to the geography I live and work in, either.

Presently that's true. In 50 years?

The majority of Ontario's electricity comes from coal burning generators

Yup that's a problem. The coal burning plants in Alberta equally. They need to be replaced with nuclear plants. Ontario has taken steps to shut down Nanticoke, what is Alberta doing about it?