shakenbake
Senior Turgid Member
Does it make sense to pay too much for something? Unfortunately, it is difficult or impossible to find a hot water heater that size for a home. Also, a smaller hot water heater has a proportionally greater surface area than a larger one, and will lose more more heat. This is an engineering fact based on the 'two-thirds' law.Why is it always about payback? Why cant we just do what makes sense. Heat just the water you need, not the water you think you may need. Seems like a no-brainer to me.
In Europe, no one would dream of having a tank bigger than 20 litres, if they have one at all. I guess we are smarter keeping 187 litres of water hot...just in case?
As for keeping 187 litres of water hot, a great deal of progress has been made in thermal insulation for hot water tanks. I know that the new tank I got as repalcement for the older 12 year old tank is much more thermally efficient. I have been able to turn down the thermostat significantly on the new tank and not lost any comfort or capacity. I have also heard that some of these tankless heaters require 100,000 BTU of gas supply versus about 33,00 BTU for the older ones. So, if you have a teen who loves to shower for hours, you have a much higher gas bill at the end of the day. With the old technology, they run out of hot waterr and get out of the shower very quickly, thereby saving you gas and water.
The bottom-line difference in performance between the new tankless heaters and the older technology is not that great, and not great enough in may cases to warrant the extra cost. However, each case needs to be analysed on its own. There really is no single solution for a hot water tank replacement, IMNSHO.

