Tankless on demand DHW? pros & cons?

Gentle Ben

Senior Member
Jan 5, 2002
7,213
0
36
What are the pros and cons of on demand tankless domestic water heaters vs a traditional high efficeint tank ?
Will be upgrading the furnace , the gas water heater is getting older as well, the chimeny is in need of repair so the plan is to go to high efficiency water heater and get rid of the chimney, and re shingle the house in 3 years.. now is the time to replce the mechanicals under the Eco Energy grants, just curious on the water heater.
I've heard mixed reactions, anyone that can comment first hand is appreciated.

GB
 
My brother got a tanless WH a couple of years ago and noticed a difference on his bill. It's only heating the water when needed, not the rest of the day and evening when no one's home, or not in use.
 
It does work but the initial outlay is more than you first think. Aside from the unit you also 'must' install the powered exhaust to a cleared area outside in order to get full benefit and maximize safety standards. that plus all the connectors and pipes can cost another $1000. so if your staying around for at least 10 years then it a good deal. If not just look at it as a way to cut monthly costs and may be selling point. The trick is to get someone with experience with these units. often people from Europe have this background as they've been there for years.
 
I thought one of the downsides was that you had to run the taps longer before the hot water flowed, so some of your energy savings are reduced by increased water consumption. Tankless units are still fairly pricey, so I wouldn't count on a fast payback.
 
It does work but the initial outlay is more than you first think..

This. Expect to spend more than the brochure. When we put ours in there was a mountain of extra costs because we have a custom home. Not sure what you have but if its anything even remotely unique they may try and gouge you on the installation. There is definately a small but noticeable difference on your monthly bill. It is most economical if you don't use the hot water extremely often. (For example you won't see as much of a savings if you have three teenagers taking two showers a day.) It saves by having no "idle" cost, so it is best if you are low-volume user.

Also IMHO it is generally a bad idea to get rid of a chimney. Doesn't cost too much to keep it in functional condition (a sweep once a year is under $150) and it can save your life in case of a Quebec-Icestorm scenario or other disruption of electric/gas fired heating.
 
I thought one of the downsides was that you had to run the taps longer before the hot water flowed, so some of your energy savings are reduced by increased water consumption. Tankless units are still fairly pricey, so I wouldn't count on a fast payback.

This doesn't make sense to me because the only lag time might be in what it takes for the water that leave the unit at temperature until it reaches the faucet, That shouldn't be much different than in a traditional system. If your interior pipes are insulated there should be little difference at all.

Do you get instant hot water at this time, probably not?
 
Last edited:
This. Expect to spend more than the brochure. When we put ours in there was a mountain of extra costs because we have a custom home. Not sure what you have but if its anything even remotely unique they may try and gouge you on the installation. There is definately a small but noticeable difference on your monthly bill. It is most economical if you don't use the hot water extremely often. (For example you won't see as much of a savings if you have three teenagers taking two showers a day.) It saves by having no "idle" cost, so it is best if you are low-volume user.

Also IMHO it is generally a bad idea to get rid of a chimney. Doesn't cost too much to keep it in functional condition (a sweep once a year is under $150) and it can save your life in case of a Quebec-Icestorm scenario or other disruption of electric/gas fired heating.

I agree with Blackrock, if you're in a low usage scenario then the tankless makes would be more economical, you don't have to keep the thermal mass of the hot water tank at temperature all the time. In my experience, the high usage households often do not see the savings because the unit is running quite often. I have in instances, installed hot water holding tanks when there is a high demand for water with tankless hot water heaters.
 
In Toronto, you also have to be careful in calculating what size of unit. If you're a small volume user, don't buy one that just fits your needs as you'll probably want to sell some day. The size is dependent on use and maximum temperature difference between the indoors and outdoors.
 
This issue was discussed a few months ago in another thread. The high initial cost plus punching another hole in your wall is a drawback. I think one poster said in the older thread that he would breakeven 10 years (or something like that) after the tankless is already dead.
 
This issue was discussed a few months ago in another thread. The high initial cost plus punching another hole in your wall is a drawback. I think one poster said in the older thread that he would breakeven 10 years (or something like that) after the tankless is already dead.
That was the result of my economic analysis when my tank unit burst and had to be replaced. In addition, the incentives from the governments didn't help much, either.
 
I got one of those door to door rental outfits to install it and paid $18 per month. All service EVERYTHING included. Was cheaper in my timeframe than the $2k it likely woudl have cost otherwise.
Compare that with Direct Energy at $35 per month. Who is your renter?
 
Why is it always about payback? Why cant we just do what makes sense. Heat just the water you need, not the water you think you may need. Seems like a no-brainer to me.
In Europe, no one would dream of having a tank bigger than 20 litres, if they have one at all. I guess we are smarter keeping 187 litres of water hot...just in case?
 
Compare that with Direct Energy at $35 per month. Who is your renter?

I was curious as well. Too many horror stories concerning "door to door" folks. Maybe there is an escalator clause in the fine print that will shoot the monthly rental to $1,000 a month that kicks in at the 1/2 year mark.
 
I have found all that's been said on this forum issue true...the intial cost is high, make sure you're staying in your house for a while and not planning to sell soon, the water does take a bit longer to warm up as the burner does not turn on until a certain amount of flow is detected...MAKE SURE YOU GET A QUALIFIED INSTALLER...longer plumbing and extra holes in wall required...etc..

However, if you are renting a traditional water tank, there will be no more rental costs (in my case it was about $25.00 with Direct). Secondly, the rebates with the eco-audit figured my getting back some cash (although not nearly enough thatI'd like)...but at least this year we were getting something back from the govt.

I have just changed to a tankless heater (Sep 2009) and although there were issues at first (water temperature would fluctuate when someone flushed the toilet or turned on another tap), there was always a solution. Since then all issues have been fixed.

There are other things to think about when buying a tankless heater...some heaters cannot be installed on the outer wall. This needs to be considered because this will determine the length of your exhaust pipe. Remember the longer the exhaust pipe the more it's going to cost with the installation. Also if you have a tap that controls the temperature and volume, you will need an further installation to rectify the fluctuations in water temperature. If you've got kids you'll want to do this. In my 'venture' to get a tankless heater it's been frustrating at times but in the end I believe it was worth it.

Sorry it was a bit too long winded but I just wanted you to hear about my experiences.
 
Did someone mention the "European experience"? Euros live in tiny apartments and houses where there is no room for a tank water heater.
 
I thought one of the downsides was that you had to run the taps longer before the hot water flowed, so some of your energy savings are reduced by increased water consumption. Tankless units are still fairly pricey, so I wouldn't count on a fast payback.
No that's not it, if the new unit goes where the old unit was, then the hot water has the same distance to travel, and will sit hot and cooling in the same length of pipe until you next turn the tap on. None of that stuff changes. And when the first hot water arrives fronm the tankless it's as hot as you set it. The storage tank water cools off in layers between firings and tended to arrive hottish then get really hot as the burner kicked in. It takes a litre before the water in the kitchen's at max.

But if you were used to running just a trickle of that already paid-for hot water to take the frosty edge off, you'll find your consciousness is quickly raised by the thought that you just turned on a whole boiler and heated a whole pipeline to max just for that trickle. Still cheaper, and consciousness-raisings'a good thing.
 
I was curious as well. Too many horror stories concerning "door to door" folks. Maybe there is an escalator clause in the fine print that will shoot the monthly rental to $1,000 a month that kicks in at the 1/2 year mark.

Before I made the switch I was paying $12/month from Embridge for tank rental. Someone's getting hosed.
 
Why is it always about payback? Why cant we just do what makes sense.

Because the human race is stupid. Example: 1 million Americans go to a tanning salon every day. Example: 100 million Americans still smoke. I give the human race another 300 years, 500 years max.
 
Did someone mention the "European experience"? Euros live in tiny apartments and houses where there is no room for a tank water heater.
And, they tend to use less water than we North Americans. They are also as hygenic as us, or more so. We are known to be a wasteful society.
 
Before I made the switch I was paying $12/month from Embridge for tank rental. Someone's getting hosed.
I find that low rate hard to believe. I was paying about $21 and that was the government regulated rate for the water heater that I had. If there was a hosin', it was from the government. BTW, Enbridge hasn't rented hot water heaters for years. They relinquished the rental business to Direct Energy.