Tankless on demand DHW? pros & cons?

Why is it always about payback? Why cant we just do what makes sense. Heat just the water you need, not the water you think you may need. Seems like a no-brainer to me.
In Europe, no one would dream of having a tank bigger than 20 litres, if they have one at all. I guess we are smarter keeping 187 litres of water hot...just in case?
Does it make sense to pay too much for something? Unfortunately, it is difficult or impossible to find a hot water heater that size for a home. Also, a smaller hot water heater has a proportionally greater surface area than a larger one, and will lose more more heat. This is an engineering fact based on the 'two-thirds' law.

As for keeping 187 litres of water hot, a great deal of progress has been made in thermal insulation for hot water tanks. I know that the new tank I got as repalcement for the older 12 year old tank is much more thermally efficient. I have been able to turn down the thermostat significantly on the new tank and not lost any comfort or capacity. I have also heard that some of these tankless heaters require 100,000 BTU of gas supply versus about 33,00 BTU for the older ones. So, if you have a teen who loves to shower for hours, you have a much higher gas bill at the end of the day. With the old technology, they run out of hot waterr and get out of the shower very quickly, thereby saving you gas and water.

The bottom-line difference in performance between the new tankless heaters and the older technology is not that great, and not great enough in may cases to warrant the extra cost. However, each case needs to be analysed on its own. There really is no single solution for a hot water tank replacement, IMNSHO.
 
I find that low rate hard to believe. I was paying about $21 and that was the government regulated rate for the water heater that I had. If there was a hosin', it was from the government. BTW, Enbridge hasn't rented hot water heaters for years. They relinquished the rental business to Direct Energy.

You may be right about Enbridge directly not renting units, but it's on the three page Enbridge bill and it was $12.00 + tax. It may Direct Energy it may Bert & Ernie's, but it's on the Enbridge bill I get in the mail, up from $11.00. It went down when I got the new unit to replace the 14 year old unit I had before.
 
You may be right about Enbridge directly not renting units, but it's on the three page Enbridge bill and it was $12.00 + tax. It may Direct Energy it may Bert & Ernie's, but it's on the Enbridge bill I get in the mail, up from $11.00. It went down when I got the new unit to replace the 14 year old unit I had before.
The age explains part of your low rental fee. Maybe, location also has something to do with it. I live in Durham Region and they typically hose those outside of Toronto, I am told. Any one else care to verify or refute the hosing aspect?
 
Why rent a water heater, in a couple of years it's already paid for.

It is not so simple as you make it out to be. And, I doubt the couple of years time frame. How much does a hot water heater cost, installed? Divide it by the monthly rental fee and come back to me in a couple of years and tell me if it's been paid for. For a tankless heater, I think that the time interval is much more than a couple of years. Also, if the hot water heater breaks down , as mine did, the renters have to replace it for free, and within a few hours. Don't get nme wrong, I would love to tell my renter where to go and how to get there. But, the economics and logistics are somewhat against it.
 
How much does a hot water heater cost, installed? Divide it by the monthly rental fee and come back to me in a couple of years and tell me if it's been paid for.

I actually did the math on the back of an envelope and decided that renting is cheaper than buying. I think Direct Energy is able to buy the tank (wholesale price?) much cheaper than I can and their labour cost to install is cheaper than what my neighbour's son would charge me.
 
Thanks for all the input folks, I have a year to decide on what to do. bottom line, I'm getting rid of the chimney due to needing repair, so its either tankless or high efficient tank.
I'll keep trying to educate myself over the next 8 to 12 months to make a decision on which route to take.
 
What about installation costs and the cost of maintenance, which are often and largely assumed by the renter?

It's not going to cost the $1600 difference for installation, and I don't know of any maintenance on a water heater.
 
I pay $29 per month to Hydro for my gas powered tankless heater. The only drawback I see is that you need to keep a rate above 0.6 gal per minute or the heater won't kick on. This means using much more water than usual for shaving.

That and my tenants figured out that they can shower forever without running out of hot water
 
I almost forget. The other caveat I didn't remember is the warranty. A lot, if not most, have only a 1 years warranty. They're not that great on standing behind their product. Most good tanks have longer warranties; 6, 9, or 12 years. I could warranty my 90 year nana with 1 year and make money.
 
Until it breaks down, and then you are SOL if you can't get it fixed in a hurry for your family.

It's not going to cost the $1600 difference for installation, and I don't know of any maintenance on a water heater.

Learning how to flush/wash it out once in a while is good to keep the traditional tank at it's peak. The crud that builds up in the lower parts would amaze you. When was the last time you vacuumed or dusted the back of your fridge? It's the same reasoning.
 
$12+tax X 12 months $162.72 X 15 years = $2440.80

Similar to last time, I plan to exercise my "Buyout" option in year 8 for $100. Last time, I got 7 more year of "free" service before the tank died. Don't forget you could have invested the upfront cost of your purchased tank in BMO stock and have doubled your money by now.
 
Similar to last time, I plan to exercise my "Buyout" option in year 8 for $100. Last time, I got 7 more year of "free" service before the tank died. Don't forget you could have invested the upfront cost of your purchased tank in BMO stock and have doubled your money by now.

I like the way you think.