Wtf !! Solution to economic woes this simple !!

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
This thread is an extension of this thread

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?277870-Next-Great-Depression

Watch this video



Do you really think a couple of young film students in blue jeans got the economy figured out or are they pulling a Big Michael Moore lie ?

In essence, they say let the bank of Canada print interest free money to pay of the governments debts to the private banks and in the future the government should always borrow from themselves at zero interest, that they pay back through taxes the same way they pay back the banks

The money is pretend money anyways - the banks are not lending money they actually have - so why does not the government lend themselves pretend money at zero interest ???

If the solution is so so simple, then does that not mean the Chairman of the Fed and the Governor of the Bank of Canada and The World Bank and everyone with those PhDs and the politicians running the world are either stupid or are puppets of the banking system ????
 
Last edited:
I've only seen 37 seconds of a 10 minute movie, but they say that the banks are given money that is "backed" by NOTHING (at 18-21 seconds). Fact is it is backed by our initial deposits of cash into them from paycheques through to other money that we have. Banks can only "create" and lend-out so much credit based on how much deposits they have. Moreover, any mortgage is BACKED by the HOUSE someone owns. That's why people's houses are being taken away, so that the banks can get back their money.

By diluting the money supply like that, it makes the value of currency worthless. Think about it for a second. Say you have $100,000 in savings, and I don't. But now the government can go to itself and print any money it wants and give it out to whomever it wants? Great, I'll take my $100,000 and now both of us have $100,000. It makes yours worthless because I haven't had to work for it, but you have.

This is just what I've seen in the first 37 seconds, and based on your write-up. I'm sure there are other flaws.

You are incorrect .
The banks have only a small fraction of the money they lend out
It is imaginary ledger money

As to your second point the movie does not suggest the government give money away to themsleves but borrow it from themselves at zero interest then pay themselves back - in order to stop inflation - from taxes

If I want a personal loan I would still go to a private bank (and still open accounts there) it is just the government that would borrow from themselves ( they print the money anyways}

So the question is "Do you want our taxes to pay private bank government loans or government loans we have taken from ourselves at zero interest ???"
 
If you google "zimbabwe hyperinflation pictures” you will get some neat pictures of what your proposal leads to. If I knew how to post pictures, I would as some of them are pretty good.
Edit: Here are some neat ones http://images.google.ca/imgres?imgu...oft:en-ca:IE-SearchBox&rlz=1I7ADBR&tbs=isch:1


It is the huge world government debt to private banks at compounded interest that cause inflation as the governments print monies to pay back the interest on these loans

This idea will stop inflation
 
As to your second point they do give money away to themsleves but borrow it from themselves at zero interest then pay themselves back - in order to stop inflation - from taxes
If you took the time to at least learn the basics you would know that there is no difference between a central bank “printing money” and lending the government money. Central banks already do this by when they buy government bonds. To buy the government bonds (IOUs) they pay for them by “printing money” (technically in developed countries they usually make accounting entries to create the money but in under developed countries they use the printing presses.). As long as they don’t do too much of this, inflation does not get too bad. They do too much of this and you get hyperinflation.
The most basic rule of economics is that There is no such thing as a free lunch.
It is the huge world government debt to private banks at compounded interest that cause inflation

This idea will stop inflation
This is so completely wrong it is actually very funny!
 
If you took the time to at least learn the basics you would know that there is no difference between a central bank “printing money” and lending the government money. Central banks already do this by when they buy government bonds. To buy the government bonds (IOUs) they pay for them by “printing money” (technically in developed countries they usually make accounting entries to create the money but in under developed countries they use the printing presses.). As long as they don’t do too much of this, inflation does not get to bad. They do much of this and you get inflation.
The most basic rule of economics is that There is no such thing as a free lunch.

I do not see where you addressed the issue and I am not suggesting a free lunch

As you state the bank loans are simple accounting entries so why would not the government not create there own ledger then lend money to themselves instead of having a bank do it ???



If they borrow from themselves then raise taxes to pay it back they avoid the private bank interest which is exponentially more money than the original loan...

It is the compound interest that is the problem not the loan
 
This is so completely wrong it is actually very funny!


Then correct me

that our government owes billions - and the world trillions - to private banks is not a fundamental cause of inflation ???? as governments print money to pay just the interest on those loans ???


Do not insult me here I am trying to understand why this film is wrong and you seem knowledgeable ..........
 
I do not see where you addressed the issue
That is because you don’t understand the basics. I would suggest that you either pick up a first-year textbook, or check out the website one of the federal reserve banks or the another central bank. They have a lot of educational material.

As you state the bank loans are simple accounting entries so why would not the government not create there own ledger then lend money to themselves instead of having a bank do it ???
Because fiat money has no “real” value. You only accept fiat money in exchange for your labour services because you think others will accept it from you in exchange for goods and services you want. The more of it the government “prints” (whether they actually print it or just credit your bank account when you sell them a government of Canada bond, or credits the government’s bank account) the more prices increase. In the long run, there is almost of one-to-one relationship between growth of the money supply and the price level.

It is not the borrowing of the money that is of concern but the compounding interest they pay to the private banks
No
If they borrow from themselves then raise taxes to pay it back they avoid the interest which is wwwaaaayyyy more money more than the original loan...
Inflation is effectively a tax on people who hold money. It reduce the value of the money they hold. At the end of the day, you are still going to pay a “tax”, whether is in the form of traditional taxes or through inflation. There is no such thing as a free lunch. Indeed, governments only resort to what you're proposing when they have no other way of raising money. Hyperinflation is not a good thing.
Then correct me
I have not only corrected you but I have even suggested educational sources you can go to.

that our government owes billions - and the world trillions - to private banks is not a fundamental cause of inflation ???? as governments print money to pay just the interest on those loans ???
Not it is not. Money creation in excess of the growth of GDP is what causes inflation.


Do not insult me here I am trying to understand why this film is wrong and you seem knowledgeable ..........
The film was made my idiots who seem to have picked up an old social credit pamphlet.

Besides the sources I mentioned early, so a search for "quantity equation". It is also a good place to start.

Edit: This is not a bad place to start.: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantity_theory_of_money
 
Because fiat money has no value. You only accept fiat money in exchange for your labour services because you think others will accept it from you in exchange for goods and services you want. The more of it the government prints (whether they actually print it or just credit your bank account when you sell them a government of Canada bond, or credits the governments bank account) the more prices increase. In the long run, there is almost of one-to-one relationship between growth of the money supply and the price level.




Not it is not. Money creation in excess of the growth of GDP is what causes inflation.



The film was made my idiots who seem to have pick up on old social credit pamphlet.
L

OK

Actually Jack Layton agrees with them in the film (he must of read the same pamphlet)

However one question

Why do you say it is not OK for the government to create interest free fiat money, that they will repay through taxes, but the banks can create fiat monies (as the banks have only a tiny portion of the money they lend to the government - with compound interest !!! ) ????????

I agree it is money creation that causes hyperinflation ( deflation is actually worse ) but governments create this money to pay back the bank's fiat monies ( or just the interest on these monies !)
 
OK

Actually Jack Layton agrees with them in the film (he must of read the same pamphlet)
I already knew Jack Layton was an idiot.
However one question

Why do you say it is not OK for the government to create interest free fiat money, that they will repay through taxes, but the banks can create fiat monies (as the banks have only a tiny portion of the money they lend to the government - with compound interest !!! ) ????????
If you go to one of the sources I suggested you will get a good explanation of the money creation process. However, I will try to give you the basics (remember that when I am unlucky enough to teach first year courses, I usually spend a week or so on this, and I am not going to spend that much time here).
Suppose you buy a $ 1 000 Government of Canada bond (i.e. you lend the government money). If the Bank of Canada (B of C) then buys the bond from you (called an open market operation), they give you a cheque (actually, you would get your check from a middleman called a dealer, but let’s keep it simple). The loan you made to the Government of Canada (G of C) has now been transferred to B of C. You deposit that cheque into your bank account. It would make no real difference if the B of C bought the bond directly from the G of C as that would just eliminate you, the middleman and the money/ cheque would go directly to them. Either way, either you or the G of C deposits the cheque in a chartered bank. Say you deposit it in the CIBC. The CIBC takes that cheque to the B of C for payment (it would make no difference if it was the G of C that had deposited the cheque). The CIBC has an account with the B of C . The B of C can either give the CIBC currency or credit their account. Either way M1 has increased by $1000 (the amount of your deposit). However, this is not the end of the story. The CIBC does not pay you interest on your deposit because they are nice people. They pay you interest because they want to use your money to lend out to someone else. They will keep a small amount (in Canada often as little as 2%) in case people want to withdraw money and lend out the rest. To keep the numbers easy, suppose they keep $100 and lend $900 to OntheBottom. This has increase the money supply by another $900. OTB spends this $900 on is favourate SP by writing her a cheque for $900 which she deposits in her bank account, say the TD. Like the CIBC, the TD does not pay her interest because they are nice but rather because they want the money so they can lend it to someone else. Again, they keep some and lead out the rest, increasing the money supply again. And so on and on.
Although the money supply has increased, the real supply of goods and services in the economy has not. If you read the last link I gave you, you will know that the result is inflation.
As far as interest on the government debit is concerned, interest is the time cost of money (what you, the government, etc is willing to pay to consume now instead of in the future). If the Government chooses to pay the interest by printing money instead of raising taxes, it is as I described above, but they always have the choice of using tax revenues instead.

I agree it is money creation that causes hyperinflation ( deflation is actually worse ) but governments create this money to pay back the bank's fiat monies ( or just the interest on these monies !)
If you read the above, you should see why this need not be the cause. For further elaboration, please see the sources I have referred you to.
 
Thx for your time someone ? Want a loan ?? Only 10% compounded daily. I will send Egor and Rambo to collect next Friday



What I did not see in that film are economic PHDs agreeing (because there are none??)

They just find some turkey MPs who clearly are clueless (one was our old Prime Minister Martin !!!!!!!!)

Just like some biased Michael Moore film

But

in your scenario the BC ends up holding the GC bond so the government does not owe any money except to itself, therfore no interest payments. Correct ???? Thus increasing the money supply but not the real supply of goods and services in the economy thus creating inflation

So is your point that this is exactly what happens if the GC avoids selling me the bond by creating fiat money directly ??? ( as the movie suggests would be a better idea ) even though the GC would eventually take the excess fiat money out of the economy through taxes .

And this fiat money would not create real wealth in the meantime, even if I build a I build a subway with it instead of spending it on poon ???

There is no Bank conspiracy to keep us dumb ???
 
Well,

...does that not mean the Chairman of the Fed and the Governor of the Bank of Canada and The World Bank and everyone with those PhDs and the politicians running the world are either stupid or are puppets of the banking system ????

Probably a little of both. But the proposal put foreward is very reminicent of "The Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy" where they adopt leaves as currency ...:rolleyes:
 
But

in your scenario the BK ends up holding the GC bond so the government does not owe any money except to itself, therfore no interest payments. Correct ????
Technically, if it were not a discount bond, the G of C pays interest payments to the holder of the bond which in this case is the B of C but at the end of the year the profits of the B of C go to the government anyway so, yes it is basically correct. When the bond comes due, the principle would also be paid to the B of C but again, that would go back to the government. The basic point is that anytime the B of C buys anything, whether a government IOU or a pizza for an office party, it is creating money.
Thus increasing the money supply but not the real supply of goods and services in the economy thus creating inflation
Yes
So is your point that this is exactly what happens if the GC avoids selling me the bond by creating fiat money directly ( as the movie suggests would be a better idea ??) even though the GC would eventually take the excess fiat money out of the economy through taxes . And this fiat money would not create real wealth in the meantime, even if I build a I build a subway with it instead of spending it on poon ???

There is no Bank conspiracy to keep us dumb ???
If the government uses the resources to build a subway, it means that the resources cannot be otherwise used. Keynesian macroeconomists argue that it may be the case that there are unemployed resources during a recession due to labour and other markets not clearing. In this case, something would be created if those unused resources are used for the subway construction (there is a lot of debate on this point). If the government borrows money from the public, interest rates increase and provide sector activity is reduced (perhaps not by as much as public sector activity, you subway example, is increased). If they borrow it from the central bank, it may be the case that in the short run interest rates will stay low and do not crowd out private investment. However, in the long run you will get inflation. The question than becomes whether the short turn benefit is greater than the long term cost of inflation. Recently central banks have been creating money like this because they think the short term benefits are greater than the long term costs. However, they are not going crazy as they don’t want to end up like Zimbabwe.
It makes no difference if the G of C pays the principle off with taxes if the loan is from the B of C. Suppose they did. They B of C would take the tax dollars the government gave them and pay it back to the government at the end of the year.
 
Technically, if it were not a discount bond, the G of C pays interest payments to the holder of the bond which in this case is the B of C but at the end of the year the profits of the B of C go to the government anyway so, yes it is basically correct. When the bond comes due, the principle would also be paid to the B of C but again, that would go back to the government. The basic point is that anytime the B of C buys anything, whether a government IOU or a pizza for an office party, it is creating money.

Yes

If the government uses the resources to build a subway, it means that the resources cannot be otherwise used. Keynesian macroeconomists argue that it may be the case that there are unemployed resources during a recession due to labour and other markets not clearing. In this case, something would be created if those unused resources are used for the subway construction (there is a lot of debate on this point). If the government borrows money from the public, interest rates increase and provide sector activity is reduced (perhaps not by as much as public sector activity, you subway example, is increased). If they borrow it from the central bank, it may be the case that in the short run interest rates will stay low and do not crowd out private investment. However, in the long run you will get inflation. The question than becomes whether the short turn benefit is greater than the long term cost of inflation. Recently central banks have been creating money like this because they think the short term benefits are greater than the long term costs. However, they are not going crazy as they don’t want to end up like Zimbabwe.
It makes no difference if the G of C pays the principle off with taxes if the loan is from the B of C. Suppose they did. They B of C would take the tax dollars the government gave them and pay it back to the government at the end of the year.

Do I pass your course ??? Do you consider my observations to be worthy of a good student ?
 
please watch this

[video=google;-515319560256183936]http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-515319560256183936#[/video]

This informative documentary will help to explain what actually happens in the USA. The Federal Reserve is a PRIVATE BANK and NOT owned or operated by the US Federal Government.

The Fed loans money to the US Gov with interest not interest free as has been suggested.

I do not know if The Bank of Canada does have interest free loans.

Regardless, please watch the documentary it will totally blow u away how the US government is NOT in control of its own money. Maybe the same is true for Canada.

This is one of the most interesting documentaries I have ever watched.
 
It is the huge world government debt to private banks at compounded interest that cause inflation as the governments print monies to pay back the interest on these loans

This idea will stop inflation

Ordinarily the goverment does NOT print money to pay back the interest on loans, it generally repays loans from tax revenues.

The price level roughly equals the money supply divided by the quantity of goods available in the economy.

If you create money faster than you create new goods then you have inflation. End of story.

Thus there is a limit on how much money you can print before it's inflationary.. namely, the growth rate in the real economy. At the end of the day you're limited by how much the economy can produce no matter how you count it.
 
Do I pass your course ??? Do you consider my observations to be worthy of a good student ?
I am sorry if I came across as lecturing.
As far as the silly post about the federal reserve being privately own. The ownership structure is very strange. However, the American federal government appoints all the directors and gets all the profits. Technically it is owned my its member federal reserve banks but the member banks cannot trade, sell or otherwise do anything with its stock. For more information see: http://www.federalreserve.gov/generalinfo/faq/faqfrs.htm#5
In a recent thread on Canadian parliamentary democracy, Asterix stated:
And I thought the US system of government was convoluted.
In response, I refer him to the official ownership structure of the thread and the misunderstandings it creates for posters such as blueman and the so called documentary he cites.
 
I am sorry if I came across as lecturing.
As far as the silly post about the federal reserve being privately own. The ownership structure is very strange. However, the American federal government appoints all the directors and gets all the profits. Technically it is owned my its member federal reserve banks but the member banks cannot trade, sell or otherwise do anything with its stock. For more information see: http://www.federalreserve.gov/generalinfo/faq/faqfrs.htm#5
In a recent thread on Canadian parliamentary democracy, Asterix stated:

In response, I refer him to the official ownership structure of the thread and the misunderstandings it creates for posters such as blueman and the so called documentary he cites.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You don’t come across as lecturing . . . more like arrogant ass.
 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You don’t come across as lecturing . . . more like arrogant ass.
I have been called worse.
 
someone you sound like you know quite a bit about economics and how things "should" work but have you ever considered Canada , U.S. and countless other countries are in the control of private banks and not the government or its people. The doc I posted a link to may be exagerating slightly but if even half of it is true people world wide not just Canadians have a lot to worry about. The people in control don't want you to know how money or "credit" debt works so they distract us with entertainment and so called "news" and it has been working for a long time unfortunately.