Government to be held in contempt it fails to comply with Parliamentary order

The bottom line Fuji, is that the opposition in a minority Parliament can ask for information from the Government all it wants but under the Security Act, the Government has the legal right and obligation to follow the Act as their lawyers interrupt it.

False. An order of Parliament trumps the act, first of all. Secondly, the Minister can declassify the documents per the order at which point the act is irrelevant anyway. Thirdly, it isn't the opposition that is asking, formally, it is Parliament. Fourthly, they aren't asking, it's an order.

You are wrong on so many levels it's hard to keep track of how wrong you are.

1) petition the Supreme Court of Canada for a ruling which even the NDP won't do --- largely because the risk of failure at the SCC is to high of a political risk for the losers
2) amend the Security Act which I doubt the Liberals will want to do because they would be faced with problems in any future Government they form
3) appeal to public opinion --- which is exactly all they are doing

You missed this one:

4) Rule that the Minister is in contempt of Parliament and instruct the Sergeant at Arms to jail him until he complies with the order

It's fairly apparent that you do not understand the system of government we have here in Canada. You seem to think that a "Prime Minister" is really a "President" and that "Parliament" is merely an electoral college whose only power is to call for an election. You appear to be completely ignorant of the fact that in Canada Parliament has real power.
 
Last edited:
All the back and forth demonstrates one thing: bugger the law and precedents, Harper is determined to do whatever he wants and dare those who disagree to use whatever stick they can find to beat him for it. In his neo-con dog-eat-dog view of the world, you only stick to the rules when the cops are a)watching, and b) bigger than you.

fuji's been dead right on parliamentary supremacy since Post#1, and landscaper et al have been right about the constraints of the Security Act. But never before—even in wartime—has a PM and parliament gone to the mattresses over what is government business. Parliament is our government, the Ministers are just a committee within it, and they should get on with the job parliament describes. But how do you make them?

Sadly landscaper's also right in saying Harper needs a stick—defeat in the House—before he'll finally see reason. Unfortunately, being a slow learner, it seems he still imagines a new day where he can get a majority with the same old puffin poop, so he's smug and confident. Equally unfortunately, those who have the stick are also slow to learn that they're gonna have to use it. Which means either unite the majority they represent (in a better way than the Coalition Fiasco) or start campaigning long, long ago.

It's all a bit like realizing you shoulda used the 'tough love' on your adult kid and thrown him out back when he first started smoking at home. Now that he's dealing drugs from the basement you've got a really big bullet to bite.
 
Are you really this big of a moron --- what part of the will Parliament allows them to make a request, when the will of a past Parliament implemented a law.

The part where the will of Parliament is supreme, limited only by constitutional constraints such as the charter of rights and freedoms.

Look, you obviously don't have a clue what you are talking about, you just make stuff up as you go along, and you are belligerent.

Are you that daft --- it would be like Parliament putting aside, human rights laws and capital murder laws if it was the will of the Parliament to have you whacked, which by the way I'm seriously thinking of making request to my MP.

Parliament can't violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, a Parliamentary order to have you whacked would violate that six ways from Sunday.

This has already been explained to you...

I find it very interesting that in my post were I outline what the options of the opposition, you make absolutely no rebuttal to it.

I agree that they have the options you listed. You simply didn't list ALL of their options.
 
Are you certain about that?

He said a couple of correct things--he listed three valid options that the opposition does indeed have, his list simply wasn't complete--he left out several other things the opposition could do, one of them being holding the minister in contempt.

He's also right that Parliament holding a PM in contempt no doubt would wind up in the SC, but the PM would lose. In reality this is something that the PM knows, and his political grandstanding notwithstanding, he would seek a reasonable compromise with the opposition before allowing things to go that far--the PM is not as ignorant as kingfisher1 when it comes to Parliamentary procedures!!

The rest of what he wrote was pretty much nonsense sprinkled with insults.
 
As much as you and Fuji would love to make this a Parlimentry Privilege issue along with the Opposition Parties they are restricted by "existing laws".

Funny thing is that what you just quoted proves you wrong:

"The rule for when parliamentary privilege applies is that it cannot exceed the powers, privileges and immunities of the imperial parliament as it stood in 1867, when the first constitution was written."

Guess what law was passed after 1867?

That has been my point from the beginning. The high lighted part of the above quote says that Parliamentary Privilege cannot exceed the original Constitution which is in effect.

This is true. What you are too boneheaded to grok is that the Securty Act is not part of the original constitution, nor any constitution. It is a post-1867 Act of Parliament.

As to your "demand information would exceed the power of legislation under section7's authority" if that were actually true then the Security Act itself would be unconstitutional in the first place. Plainly the Security Act is not unconstitutional, and for the very same reason Parliamentary orders that overrule it are also not unconstitutional. You can't on the one hand say that Parliament had the power to enact laws regulating security, then turn around and say any attempt by Parliament to interfere in security issues is unconstitutional.

By the way I love that you quoted this Parliamentary privilege without realizing it: "Right to institute inquiries and to call witnesses and demand papers". Gee, I guess that means they have a right to demand papers? And if they don't get the papers, they have, and I quote you, "Power to discipline".
 
Kingfisher, you only prove me right by citing things out of context. Your highlighted portion does not say that parliamentary privilege is limited by the constitution, what it says is that they cannot exceed those privileges held by the British Commons in 1867. This is set out by section 18 of the Constitution. And yes, the British Commons had the power to send for persons, papers and records in 1867. In adopting the Security of Information Act, it was not specifically applied to Parliament, and therefore Parliament has not limited its powers in that regard.
 
Maybe not because you are still insisting that the PM can be arrested which is not an option.

Can be and will be are two different things. Parliament does in fact have the power to jail anyone, including the PM, or any other MP, who is found to be in contempt of Parliament, such as for refusing to obey an order of Parliament to produce documents relating to the treatment of Afghan prisoners. I personally doubt it will come to that: Long before things get that far the PM will make some sort of a deal that is acceptable to Parliament. Perhaps Parliament will endorse some more formal version of his ex-SCC judge scheme.

Failing a deal, if the opposition tabled an order to have the PM jailed it's likely the PM would use every procedural trick in the book to prevent that order from coming to a vote, up to and including dissolving Parliament and calling for an election.

If the order was allowed to come to a vote, though, and passed, the PM, or more likely the Minister of Defense, would in fact be lead away in handcuffs by the Sergeant at Arms.
 
This is even more boring, predictable and pointless than the daily oldjones rant. The important point is that the Liberals risk doing further damage to their popularity by being fixated on this issue instead of those that matter to average Canadians. All of this negative publicity gets wiped out in Joe Q's mind today with the job creation stats.
 
And I thought the US system of government was convoluted.
 
This is even more boring, predictable and pointless than the daily oldjones rant. The important point is that the Liberals risk doing further damage to their popularity by being fixated on this issue instead of those that matter to average Canadians. All of this negative publicity gets wiped out in Joe Q's mind today with the job creation stats.

So is it your view that the rule of law and the constitution are unimportant just so long as Joe Q gets his bread and circuses? This is how democracies fail.

Juvenal said:
Already long ago, from when we sold our vote to no man, the People have abdicated our duties; for the People who once upon a time handed out military command, high civil office, legions — everything, now restrains itself and anxiously hopes for just two things: bread and circuses.
 
I really have come to the conclusion that arguing with a moron is pointless --- but alas here I'm doing it again.

You need to tone down the insults and quit with the childish behavior. It makes you look infantile. If you can't debate politely please just go crawl back under the bridge you came out from under. If you can learn to be polite I'm more than happy to educate you further on this matter.

the section I gave you is from the Constitution on the legislative powers of Parliament

There's nothing wrong with the section you quoted. You simply haven't understood it.

This is the bit you don't seem to comprehend: "cannot exceed the powers, privileges and immunities of the imperial parliament as it stood in 1867"

You are somehow trying to twist that into saying that Parliament is subject to its own laws, but it does not say that. It simply says Parliament cannot expand its powers beyond those granted in the constitution.

Parliament's power to demand documents, and jail those who refuse to comply, existed in 1867. They are not new powers, they are as old as Parliament itself. The British Parliament had and has those powers, and the Canadian Parliament inherited them from Westminster when it was formed.

Guess what the Security Act is a piece of legislation that would require amendment prior to any claim of Parliamentary Privilege, that's not my opinion it is simple fact.

Nope. It's not fact. You are simply flat out wrong. The Securty Act is a mere act of Parliament and as such it in no way constrains the power of Parliament itself. It constrains those who are subject to Parliament, it constrains the government, it constrains the citizenry, but it does not constrain Parliament.

This has been pointed out to you several times, and in fact, follows from the text you yourself quoted.

Parliament is supreme, and limited ONLY by the constitution. Parliament is not limited by its own Acts unless the Acts explicitly say so, and even then, Parliament can override any such limitation simply by writing "notwithstanding" into an order. Parliament is limited by the constitution, by the charter, by the BNA act, and so on, but not by the Security Act or any other mere Act of Parliament.

You are simply refusing, despite all evidence to the contrary, to acknowledge that Parliament is in fact supreme.
 
the section I gave you is from the Constitution on the legislative powers of Parliament.

The section you cited deals with the division of powers between the federal and provincial legislatures. It does not limit parliamentary privilege in any way, shape or form.
 
A debate about who is or isn't supreme is really pointless unless each side has nominated a candidate. Thhose who deny that Parliament is supreme have so far not done so. All well and good to pick a supreme concept like the 'rule of law', but Parliament makes and can unmake any law, and even makes and can unmake the rules by which it does so, as well as establishing or diseastablishing the courts and judges that might rule on such laws or procedural matters. So the "Who or what is supreme if it isn't Parliament?" candidate is still MIA.

That we, unlike our Brit forebearers, now have a written Constitution—which Parliament alone cannot change—does complicate things a bit, and one could consider The Constitution as supreme and win a TKO. But it is a document, not a government. It can limit; it cannot act. In the Struggle of Supremes, it can only be a technical, not a real KO.

And that doesn't alter the fact that nothing in the Constitution preempts Parliament's supreme power to do what it wants, except where specific limits—the Charter, provincial jurisdictions etc.—are specified. In fact everything not so defined and limited is explicitly handed to Parliament to do. Witholding documents or requested testimony on grounds of security are nowhere mentioned, therefore Parliament is ultimately supreme in the matter. Denying that can only be a delaying tactic which must weaken our most democratic institution, to any extent it succeeds.

Which brings me back to where I began. If our most democratic body is not to be supreme in our government, who are you proposing should be?