Government to be held in contempt it fails to comply with Parliamentary order

By civilians or other people in the government that is true. But not Parliament. Parliamentary privilege overrides the securities act. You are missing the point about the supremacy of Parliament.

two things both actually related , read the post by Kingfisher with the legislation in it.

Second Parliment can not order an illegal act.

The govt has appointed a security cleared judge to review the documents , they have stated they will abide by his ruling on the status of the documents , what he says can be released will be released, if he says that something is classified it will not be released.
 
Sure, it sounds like a sensible thing to do. However it is not your choice to make nor is it the Prime Minister's choice to make. It is up to Parliament to decide whether that is how it will be done. The only way that process has legitimacy is if *Parliament* endorses it. Parliament could decide to dispense with that process and order the information outright released. That is a decision that your elected representatives in Parliament are entitled to make. Alternately Parliament could decide to set up a commission to review the documents, and, under the authority of Parliament, decide what to release. It is up to your elected representatives to decide which way is better.

You do have a say, though: If Parliament goes around making orders (or laws, or speeches, or anything else) that you think are inappropriate you have the option of voting for different representatives in the next Federal eleciton, people you think would make better decisions. Parliament is ultimately held accountable to the people--at the ballot box.

By that notethe opposition parties can simply table a non confidence motion and vote the govt out. They stand a chance of forming a govt , if not they can run on a platform of releasing the documents.

They might not actually like all the documents that get released.

http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2010/01/liberal-ministers-might-do-well-to.html
http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2009/12/torture-in-afghanistan-liberals-knew.html
 
By that notethe opposition parties can simply table a non confidence motion and vote the govt out.

Sure, they could, that is indeed one of the things they could do. They could also censure the government, or hold it in contempt, or use their majority to pass a variety of Parliamentary orders.

If Stephen Harper doesn't like what the elected Parliament can do he could ask the GG for a new election as well.

In the meantime, until someone decides to call for an election, the will of Parliament is supreme.
 
Last edited:
The govt has appointed a security cleared judge to review the documents , they have stated they will abide by his ruling on the status of the documents , what he says can be released will be released, if he says that something is classified it will not be released.

That appointee of the government has no authority to block the release of the documents. He is subservient to the Prime Minister, who in turn is subserviant to Parliament.

That could change obviously--if Parliament endorses his appointment--but until that happens any attempt to block the release of the documents as ordered by Parliament is insubordination verging on treason and grounds for a finding of contempt. People can be jailed until they comply, theoretically up to and including the Prime Minister.

There is no ambiguity here: It is not a request, it is an order.
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?

i would agree that he is a respected jurist but what would be the basis for such an appointment? If its really a question of Parliamentary authority then the supreme court should hear this not a retired judge.
 
i would agree that he is a respected jurist but what would be the basis for such an appointment? If its really a question of Parliamentary authority then the supreme court should hear this not a retired judge.
.
The issue is partly that the SCC does not involve itself with public inquiries , admittedly this is not a full blown inquiry the judge is being asked to review documents and determine the status of those documents and whether ther can be released into public. The reputation of the judge is beyond reproach and he has been security cleared for the documents involved, not all of the SCC justices have been.

The govt position is that the documents are a security issue and releasing them in part or in total would constitute a risk to Canadians and inteligence sources in Afghanistan. The oppositian parties are of the opinion the the documents are hiding something and have to eb released in the public for a full airing in the hope that political brownie points and a scandal will result, the damage to assets and Canadians in positions at risk is of no moment beyond the political . The Retired Justice was a Liberal appointee if I recall correctly and will provide an unbiased point of view to the procedings, something which is needed very badly in this case from all points of view.
 
.
The issue is partly that the SCC does not involve itself with public inquiries , admittedly this is not a full blown inquiry the judge is being asked to review documents and determine the status of those documents and whether ther can be released into public. The reputation of the judge is beyond reproach and he has been security cleared for the documents involved, not all of the SCC justices have been.

The govt position is that the documents are a security issue and releasing them in part or in total would constitute a risk to Canadians and inteligence sources in Afghanistan. The oppositian parties are of the opinion the the documents are hiding something and have to eb released in the public for a full airing in the hope that political brownie points and a scandal will result, the damage to assets and Canadians in positions at risk is of no moment beyond the political . The Retired Justice was a Liberal appointee if I recall correctly and will provide an unbiased point of view to the procedings, something which is needed very badly in this case from all points of view.

those are all good comments but the crux of this issue is Parliamentary authority. there is no need for the supreme court to review the documents or get involved in any other issue other than the limits of Parliamentary authority. this is really a constitutional issue which rightly should be referred to the supreme court.
 
So if Parliment ordered somebody to shoot you because you disagreed with their point of view that would then be a legal act?

Parliament does not have the authority to issue that order, as it would violate section 2 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which has constitutional force. The power of Parliament is constrained by the constitution, whereas it is not constrained by mere acts of Parliament such as you previously cited.

However your larger point is probably that Parliament could order all sorts of absurd things, and theoretically it could, but it doesn't: Parliament is comprised of people who are well respected, and trusted by all of us not to do things like that.

The real message here is that you should be very careful who you vote for, they are going to take important decisions on your behalf.
 
It is not a question of trusting those you vote for.

That is a truly idiotic thing to say. I try and abide by terb policy, and not insult people, but you make it oh so very hard--what kind of person says something that dumb?

You forget the power of the Supreme Court in Canada --- it has the authority and duty to act on any ole dumb thing Parliament might do --- has the power to toss out that piece of legislation by rendering it unenforceable in the Courts and order Parliment to devise a new piece of legislation. Ok I know your next dumb argument --- "The Not withstanding clause" well that won't work on legislation that doesn't pass the Supreme Court smell test.

No you fail at even the most basic comprehension of our legal system. The SCC is not going to throw out "any ole dumb thing Parliament might do", only those dumb things (or even smart things) that are unconstitutional. Period.

There are all sorts of perfectly constitutional things that Parliament could do that would be demented beyond belief, and all sorts of really smart things that it could do that are nevertheless completely unconstitutional. So long as we elect people we can trust to make good decisions, though, we don't have to worry about our government behaving in an intentionally stupid way.

As much as I dislike Harper and much of what he is doing, he is not just having a laugh: He believes his actions further the nation, and his supporters agree with him. He's there because there are enough people out there who support his polices to elect him.

While we may still wind up with bad government under a democracy we almost certainly wind up with a government that is well intentioned, however much it may sometimes be mistaken.

At any rate, bringing us back on topic:

Harper does not have the legal authority to resist a constitutionally valid order of Parliament. He and/or his Ministers have been ordered to produce the documents, and unless he can convince Parliament to rescind or modify its order, he MUST obey it. No argument has been advanced here that the order is unconstitutional, it has been called at odds with this and that legislation, but legislation is not constitution--an order of Parliament can override that. The ONLY thing an order of Parliament cannot override are the constitutional limits on government.
 
Parliament does not have the authority to issue that order, as it would violate section 2 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which has constitutional force. The power of Parliament is constrained by the constitution, whereas it is not constrained by mere acts of Parliament such as you previously cited.

However your larger point is probably that Parliament could order all sorts of absurd things, and theoretically it could, but it doesn't: Parliament is comprised of people who are well respected, and trusted by all of us not to do things like that.

The real message here is that you should be very careful who you vote for, they are going to take important decisions on your behalf.


Parliament is comprised of people who are well respected

Jack Layton, Svend Robinson, Rahim Jaffer,Helena Gurjis ?
 
You just posted that parliment can not order a murder , as it is unconstitutional, would the possibility of the same thing happening as a result of the public opening of these documents not have the same result ?

As well I just noticed that the motion to place the government in contempt of parliment is a private members bill, it still has a ways to go before it can even be considered for a vote,
 
You just posted that parliment can not order a murder , as it is unconstitutional, would the possibility of the same thing happening as a result of the public opening of these documents not have the same result ?

Nope. You could argue that the release of the information would be *stupid* but you cannot argue that it would be *unconstitutional*.

Presumably Parliament has given due consideration to the risks of releasing it and has decided, as is their right to decide, that it should be released. If you think it is a *stupid* decision then don't vote for those guys in the next election--Stephen Harper could always force one if you think it can't happen fast enough.

As well I just noticed that the motion to place the government in contempt of parliment is a private members bill, it still has a ways to go before it can even be considered for a vote,

Yes that's true, the opposition has limited control of the legislative agenda, a limited number of opposition days, etc., whatever they do will happen in slow motion. If they wanted to speed up the process they should have got more votes and formed the government.

Nevertheless they will eventually succeed in putting it to a vote.
 
Nope. You could argue that the release of the information would be *stupid* but you cannot argue that it would be *unconstitutional*.

Presumably Parliament has given due consideration to the risks of releasing it and has decided, as is their right to decide, that it should be released. If you think it is a *stupid* decision then don't vote for those guys in the next election--Stephen Harper could always force one if you think it can't happen fast enough.



Yes that's true, the opposition has limited control of the legislative agenda, a limited number of opposition days, etc., whatever they do will happen in slow motion. If they wanted to speed up the process they should have got more votes and formed the government.

Nevertheless they will eventually succeed in putting it to a vote.

Presumably Parliament has given due consideration to the risks of releasing it and has decided, as is their right to decide, that it should be released. If you think it is a *stupid* decision then don't vote for those guys in the next election--Stephen Harper could always force one if you think it can't happen fast enough.

I am sure that the " due consideration" that was given would be a great consolation to the families of anybody caught in the fallout . The fact that parliment and parlimentarians have 100% protection against action both civil and criminal for any actions taken while in Parliment has not been of any consideration to the people who want to declassify these documents.

Your assumptions that what you want to the correct way things should work have little or no basis in what actually happens. Reality sucks.
 
I am sure that the " due consideration" that was given would be a great consolation to the families of anybody caught in the fallout .

If there are any families caught in the fallout--all these years later, most of them probably no longer even in active service, certainly no longer on rotation--perhaps they should participate actively in the next election campaign.

I actually rather doubt that there are ANY affected families, other than perhaps Peter MacKay's family, and Stephen Harper's family, and a few other politicians who have been caught with their pants down over this issue--but that's pretty much irrelevant to the legality of it, though highly relevant to the politics of the decision.
 
The bottom line Fuji, is that the opposition in a minority Parliament can ask for information from the Government all it wants but under the Security Act, the Government has the legal right and obligation to follow the Act as their lawyers interrupt it. The Opposition can do only three things here:

1) petition the Supreme Court of Canada for a ruling which even the NDP won't do --- largely because the risk of failure at the SCC is to high of a political risk for the losers
2) amend the Security Act which I doubt the Liberals will want to do because they would be faced with problems in any future Government they form
3) appeal to public opinion --- which is exactly all they are doing

Under the Security Act, Harper is under no legal obligation to produce anything and a contempt of Parliament would be meaningless unless it is brought forward to the Supreme Court.

Get off your high horse, stop smoking crack and get some common sense.

You may want to take your own advice, since not a single thing you suggest in this post is correct.
 
As well I just noticed that the motion to place the government in contempt of parliment is a private members bill, it still has a ways to go before it can even be considered for a vote,

No, it is not a private member's bill. If and when the House is ready to pursue contempt, there will be a question of privilege raised. This takes precedence over all house business until the matter is resolved.
 
I say again it doesn't matter because if anything in parliament ever went against Harper he'd just close it, because he doesn't respect democracy or majority rule. And until the retards who vote for his party realize that the Conservative party doesn't beleive in government enough too even go to work then we're completely fucking screwed.

Now to say it in advance yes I realize Iggy and the Stooges are brainless poll watchers with no internal ideology and they will likely suck too, but at least we can trust them too go to work.