It is not a question of trusting those you vote for.
That is a truly idiotic thing to say. I try and abide by terb policy, and not insult people, but you make it oh so very hard--what kind of person says something that dumb?
You forget the power of the Supreme Court in Canada --- it has the authority and duty to act on any ole dumb thing Parliament might do --- has the power to toss out that piece of legislation by rendering it unenforceable in the Courts and order Parliment to devise a new piece of legislation. Ok I know your next dumb argument --- "The Not withstanding clause" well that won't work on legislation that doesn't pass the Supreme Court smell test.
No you fail at even the most basic comprehension of our legal system. The SCC is not going to throw out "any ole dumb thing Parliament might do", only those dumb things (or even smart things) that are unconstitutional. Period.
There are all sorts of perfectly constitutional things that Parliament could do that would be demented beyond belief, and all sorts of really smart things that it could do that are nevertheless completely unconstitutional. So long as we elect people we can trust to make good decisions, though, we don't have to worry about our government behaving in an intentionally stupid way.
As much as I dislike Harper and much of what he is doing, he is not just having a laugh: He believes his actions further the nation, and his supporters agree with him. He's there because there are enough people out there who support his polices to elect him.
While we may still wind up with bad government under a democracy we almost certainly wind up with a government that is well intentioned, however much it may sometimes be mistaken.
At any rate, bringing us back on topic:
Harper does not have the legal authority to resist a constitutionally valid order of Parliament. He and/or his Ministers have been ordered to produce the documents, and unless he can convince Parliament to rescind or modify its order, he MUST obey it. No argument has been advanced here that the order is unconstitutional, it has been called at odds with this and that legislation, but legislation is not constitution--an order of Parliament can override that. The ONLY thing an order of Parliament cannot override are the constitutional limits on government.