Reviewing for Dummies: What Topics Would like to See Covered in a Review

[ChaosTheory]

I was not sure if I should post this in the lounge or not but since this section is the review section, i thought it would be most useful, viewed and commented in here, because we all come here to read reviews.

Obvious statements:
1) We all look at reviews
2) We want our questions/concerns/preferences to be answered and discussed.
3) Some reviews are helpful, some are not.
4) We want reviews to be accurate, unbiased, sincere and not shills or anti-shills.

I am trying to write helpful reviews. For Terbdom bros. I think everyone wants to.

I was wondering what Information you would like to see discussed/covered in a review to make it most helpful.
Perhaps this thread could act as a reference and standard for review writing for everyone.

The topics/categories I currently discuss are as follows:

1) Introduction - To the girl, how I came across them, etc.
2) Location - Discrete description, comment on neatness, accessibility etc.
3) Communication - Booking, voice, issues
4) Looks: - Compare to other SPs so people can get a more accurate representation, if possible

• a) Facial:
• b) Body:

5) Personality:
6) Experience: - PG details of the session, menu, I don`t go graphic, atmosphere etc.
7) Overall - Compare to other SP experiences
8) Previous Reviews: - include Terb links
9) Recommendation:
10) Repeat Recommendation:
11) Honorarium:

• a)Half Hour:
• b)Hour:

12) SP/MPA Link
13) Any additional info

Here are most of my past reviews from earliest to most recent to illustrate what the hell i`m doing (I am based in Hamilton):
The later ones are more categorized. Mine are crazy long...i have to work on that.

Sassy`s Sophie & Mia (TO) - https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?251447-Duo-Mia-amp-Sophie-Sassy-Angels&highlight=
TO/Miss/Ham Tessa: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?270739-Review-Tessa-(xxx-CL)-Ms.-SP-Olympia!&highlight=
Hamilton Gina - https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?275892-Review-Gina-Leigh-A-Passionate-Affair&highlight=
2nd Review of Tessa: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?276781-REVIEW-Tessa-The-Second-Coming&highlight=
Review of Hamilton CL XXXXX-22: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...l-22-Laura-etc-Makes-Hammer-A-Beautiful-Place

Any opinions on what you want to see in reviews?
I will add the categories to this initial post when I can to create a template as I can.

 

[shack]

I was not sure if I should post this in the lounge or not but since this section is the review section, i thought it would be most useful, viewed and commented in here, because we all come here to read reviews.

Obvious statements:
1) We all look at reviews
2) We want our questions/concerns/preferences to be answered and discussed.
3) Some reviews are helpful, some are not.
4) We want reviews to be accurate, unbiased, sincere and not shills or anti-shills.

I am trying to write helpful reviews. For Terbdom bros. I think everyone wants to.

I was wondering what Information you would like to see discussed/covered in a review to make it most helpful.
Perhaps this thread could act as a reference and standard for review writing for everyone.

The topics/categories I currently discuss are as follows:

1) Introduction - To the girl, how I came across them, etc.
2) Location - Discrete description, comment on neatness, accessibility etc.
3) Communication - Booking, voice, issues
4) Looks: - Compare to other SPs so people can get a more accurate representation, if possible

• a) Facial:
• b) Body:

5) Personality:
6) Experience: - PG details of the session, menu, I don`t go graphic, atmosphere etc.
7) Overall - Compare to other SP experiences
8) Previous Reviews: - include Terb links
9) Recommendation:
10) Repeat Recommendation:
11) Honorarium:

• a)Half Hour:
• b)Hour:

12) SP/MPA Link
13) Any additional info

Here are most of my past reviews from earliest to most recent to illustrate what the hell i`m doing (I am based in Hamilton):
The later ones are more categorized. Mine are crazy long...i have to work on that.

Sassy`s Sophie & Mia (TO) - https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?251447-Duo-Mia-amp-Sophie-Sassy-Angels&highlight=
TO/Miss/Ham Tessa: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?270739-Review-Tessa-(xxx-CL)-Ms.-SP-Olympia!&highlight=
Hamilton Gina - https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?275892-Review-Gina-Leigh-A-Passionate-Affair&highlight=
2nd Review of Tessa: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?276781-REVIEW-Tessa-The-Second-Coming&highlight=
Review of Hamilton CL XXXXX-22: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...l-22-Laura-etc-Makes-Hammer-A-Beautiful-Place

Any opinions on what you want to see in reviews?
I will add the categories to this initial post when I can to create a template as I can.

I must admit, that is a well thought out game plan for writing reviews, just about all helpful, but as I was reading the post, I said, these have to be long reviews. I see you have confirmed that.

Although all the details have merit, personally I want to know if the lady was a GFE (classic--DFK, DATY, BBBJ and of course FS) and if her age and physical description are as advertised.

Those are essential to me. After that, I`m not so picky. Always include those important points and then any other observations that maybe stand out as being out of the ordinary. Keep the reviews succinct and as objective as possible. Nothing over the top and nothing insulting will help to minimize the cries of shill. If guys want more info they can ask but don`t give us an essay every time to read.

 

[freestuff]

There's only 3 things that I look for in a review: 1. Are the pics accurate? 2. What does she look like facially? 3. What's the menu? I don't need a blow-by-blow account. But I also can't use a review that simply states that she's beautiful and they had a good time.

 

[elassowipo1]

Reviewers are a small minority relative to the number of lurkers so I think all reviews are of some value irrespective of style or level of detail (obvious shills and trolls excluded of course)

Speaking for myself, when writing reviews, I try provide information that I feel would of of value to other hobbyists.

Specifically I try to answer the following basic questions in my reviews:

• Are her pictures accurate? If not, how are they different than her actual appearance?
• How attractive is she facially? Average? GND? Pretty?
• Is the information in her profile accurate? (Age, height, weight, hair/eye color, etc.)
• What is her service level (Full GFE?, Safe GFE?) and what specific services were offered?
• What is her personality like? (Shy? Outgoing? Bubbly)
• Sexually, is she on the passive side or more on the aggressive side? (i.e. Do you have to take the lead? or will she guide the session?)
• What was her level of ethusiasm? Did she have a positive attitude?

 

[Bale]

I prefer the reviews that are short and to the point.

If everyone used the "LASER LC" approach I'd be content.

Looks x/10
Attitude x/10
Service x/10 , list menu received
Extras - things of note worth mentioning eg. she is leaving in 2 weeks, she only sees black guys ,etc
Repeatability Y or N

Link to Ad & Pics
Cost - per hh/h/multih whatever applies

I would also like to see reviews get locked after the original post. If anyone has issues or wants to say something, keep it in PM's.

 

[ChaosTheory]

Thanks Terb bros, I appreciate the help & contribution.

 

[Hangman]

I prefer the reviews that are short and to the point.

If everyone used the "LASER LC" approach I'd be content.

Looks x/10
Attitude x/10
Service x/10 , list menu received
Extras - things of note worth mentioning eg. she is leaving in 2 weeks, she only sees black guys ,etc
Repeatability Y or N

Link to Ad & Pics
Cost - per hh/h/multih whatever applies

I would also like to see reviews get locked after the original post. If anyone has issues or wants to say something, keep it in PM's.

My god...you even have a mnemonic for reviewing...

 

[hamermill]

Hair - would want to know if the lady is sporting or growing a Sherwood Forest If Asians SPs would just learn this

 

[ChaosTheory]

My god...you even have a mnemonic for reviewing...

Nice!
I gotta use that.

 

[ChaosTheory]

any help/suggestions from the lounge crowd?